Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Universal basic income and what it may look like

534 replies

porkpiesinthepark · 04/06/2023 09:54

I've been thinking for a while about the criticism of UBI and I think it's due to people not being able to imagine the government trying to 'match' peoples wages. In my opinion, it never will but there will be alternatives to what we have now, which will be able to offer something better.

So say the UBI is £1000 a month for a single person.
We could change the housing market to allow much more public housing with rents set at an affordable level, much more stability, no private landlords and the option to customise/ change your home. Let's face it, home ownership is out of reach for the majority at present. I don't find people are dying to own their own homes but desperate to be out of the instability of the private rental market, out of parents houses, out of house shares etc. If you could offer the next best thing to owning your own house, I think people would go for it.
There would be much more community linked to people having extra time due to not working or not working as many hours. Now, not having enough to do in the day is bad but most people have these huge dreams for retirement and this would just allow them to do some of these things now instead. Also more volunteering, looking after elderly relatives etc.
I don't think that private car ownership would be a thing. There would be a big system like Uber who you could call rides on. There would be a cheaper option, say if ten people wanted to go to the city centre at the same time, they would have to walk to a hub and then the van would pick everyone up, like public transport but based on demand. It would be a status symbol to be able to call a car out just for you.
I think a lot more people would wfh getting the cost of transport and childcare down. Schools might even go remote, as there wouldn't be both parents working and so in theory they could help facilitate the lessons. Then teachers would have small classes of Sen kids like mine, key workers and vulnerable children. Kids would interact with others through volunteering groups with parents, or just playing out as there would be less cars and more parents around to keep an eye on them.
People will either hate this vision as it's so different to what we have now. Or they will like some parts. But what we have now can't continue.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
WiddlinDiddlin · 06/06/2023 13:12

Greensheeps · 06/06/2023 02:39

I can only see UBI creating more of a divide. 50% of the population are less intelligent than the other…a certain percentage cost more than they give to society.
someone needs to code the AI systems, run and manage. Do they get the same basic income as Stacey sat on her fat arse?

I don't think you (And a fair few others) understand the concept at all.

Very very basically:

Everyone gets a basic income that is enough to reasonably live on (not like out of work benefits now which are calculated to be barely enough to punish people into going to work).

Everyone is also free to earn extra money by going to work if they want to.

The models I have seen explained do offer an extra sum to those who cannot work due to disability/long term illness.

So AI Coder gets her UBI and she gets her wage for going to work each day.

Stacey sat on her fat arse at home just gets her UBI.

There would undoubtedly be people who sit on their arses at home, but currently those people who do not want to work, are insufficiently intelligent/motivated/educated to be employable... are actually costing the taxpayer more money on being chased into work, sanctioned for whatever, getting into debts they cannot pay, than it would cost to just give them enough to live on and leave them alone.

And for all the 'sitting on their arses' people, there will be a similar number of 'can work a bit but not enough to fulfill current benefits criteria/earning requirements' who WOULD do something if they had the freedom and security to do it.

If people had the freedom to work part time, volunteer, try out starting up a business or self employment without the threat of losing everything, the economy would be better off.

If people had enough to live on, spending is likely to go up - good for the economy.

If people are not scrabbling to survive, then zero hours contracts and shitty toxic work environments and attitudes will be a thing of the past. Employers will have to work hard to get employees, we won't have people doing meaningless jobs and mega layers of management, things will be streamlined because labour will not be cheap.

We might see a return to more manufacturing, more 'lifestyle' jobs (because people can take a break from it, its not so precarious with the back up of the UBI), industry the UK has lost over the last 100 years, that it now needs due to Brexit.

8state · 06/06/2023 12:35

If there are no jobs, the useful people will be the young, fit and fertile, and a few experts - no idea what areas but obviously people who understand AI could be handy. One can only hope that governments have a plan to support the rest of the population, it looks quite grim if not.

SunnyEgg · 06/06/2023 09:15

NotAllStaceys · 06/06/2023 04:02

Economics. As soon as it's cheaper for a machine to do your job that will be the case. For all of us.

As the computers become faster and more efficient a human simply will not be able to compete. The exponential growth again.

It's hard to imagine things outside your frame of reference, so it seems impossible a computer could do a complex job with analysis, human interaction, judgement, etc?

What we are talking about is - because of the exponential curve - the equivalent difference between now and 2040, of the disbelief someone in 12th century would have if you turned up there and landed in their village in a helicopter.

Of course it seems unbelievable. But that is because the change is accelerating and is exponential, so our brains which expect our lives to be relatively similar to our earlier life or our parents' lives cannot compute it. Ironic.

It's the acceleration part that I think people aren't appreciating: how fast this is going to happen.

I haven’t read much on it at all but I did hear someone talk about AI doing coding for 12p a day rather than the human labour cost and at that rate you do lose rafts of staff.

The public ownership that I think has come up in pp, it would be good for funding but not sure how it would happen. Setting up new things is risky and investment takes the risk. Do the government do this?

Or maybe we need to ensure tax on profit. How likely is that? Where are companies setting up, is it different to now ior will various countries do well as they do now from tech

Lastly on humans not needing to work. On the optimistic end we have the idea they’ll do art, create new things or they’ll be half asleep on tik tok or whatever (or even worse drugs)

Looking around I’m not sure we can rely on the nicer optimistic version, or we get ghettos of inactivity

NotAllStaceys · 06/06/2023 09:06

There are lots of people because the ageing population is masking the lack of children.

NotAllStaceys · 06/06/2023 09:05

Turn on the news this morning and hear about the nursing brain drain from Africa. There are 8 billion people on the planet and less than 10% of those live in Europe. No shortage of workers in the developing world.

Right now, yes. But in every country outside subsaharan Africa there are not enough children already: again population decline accelerates, once birthrate falls. It is baked in already.

www.birthgap.org/spaces/10215679/page

Swrigh1234 · 06/06/2023 08:38

NotAllStaceys · 06/06/2023 08:33

From where? A global population collapse is happening over the same period we're discussing everywhere outside subsaharan Africa, the seeds are sewn already. Where are you going to get immigrants from who are not also elderly?

Turn on the news this morning and hear about the nursing brain drain from Africa. There are 8 billion people on the planet and less than 10% of those live in Europe. No shortage of workers in the developing world.

And by the way, the AI soundbite is not the big reveal it’s made out to be. We have had Industrial revolutions before and the same is said every time. This is nothing new.

NotAllStaceys · 06/06/2023 08:33

From where? A global population collapse is happening over the same period we're discussing everywhere outside subsaharan Africa, the seeds are sewn already. Where are you going to get immigrants from who are not also elderly?

Swrigh1234 · 06/06/2023 08:24

NotAllStaceys · 06/06/2023 04:02

Economics. As soon as it's cheaper for a machine to do your job that will be the case. For all of us.

As the computers become faster and more efficient a human simply will not be able to compete. The exponential growth again.

It's hard to imagine things outside your frame of reference, so it seems impossible a computer could do a complex job with analysis, human interaction, judgement, etc?

What we are talking about is - because of the exponential curve - the equivalent difference between now and 2040, of the disbelief someone in 12th century would have if you turned up there and landed in their village in a helicopter.

Of course it seems unbelievable. But that is because the change is accelerating and is exponential, so our brains which expect our lives to be relatively similar to our earlier life or our parents' lives cannot compute it. Ironic.

It's the acceleration part that I think people aren't appreciating: how fast this is going to happen.

Wrong.

As soon as it’s cheaper for a machine to do your job, the government will bring in more immigrants. What do you think has been happening for the last 25 years. Exactly this.

Machines cost upfront investment. And as long as there are poorer countries out there, the supply of cheap labour is never ending.

Swrigh1234 · 06/06/2023 08:20

Marmalayde · 06/06/2023 01:38

Also many would use ubi to take the time to move into more rewarding and high paying careers. It would help social mobility. It's rude to assume everyone would just choose to live off it and drop out of work. Many want fulfillment they can't pursue on low paid long hours

If that was true why doesn’t that happen with the ‘safety net’ of benefits today. We have more unproductive out of work people today than ever before. Handing out free money never, ever helps social mobility. It creates an underclass.

Ellmau · 06/06/2023 08:07

Bananas wouldn't stay at £1.50 a bunch for very long if no one could afford it. The price would drop, as would everything else.

Well, no. They would stop importing them altogether, or they would be very rare and a luxury for the super rich.

Beezknees · 06/06/2023 07:41

HandBall · 06/06/2023 06:57

There are so many skills required in a start up, the most important skill is the ability to be a salesperson, if you have empathy it's difficult to be a salesperson.

I worked in sales for a year when DS was young as it fit in with school hours, I hated it. I wouldn't want to be self employed either and have to sort out my own tax and whatever else you have to do. I just want to be an employee and let someone else deal with all that 😂

HandBall · 06/06/2023 06:57

Beezknees · 06/06/2023 05:27

Not everyone is capable of that though. A lot of poor people are poor because they didn't do well at school. If you don't have the intelligence, you don't have it. Ditto starting a business, it's not something that everyone can (or wants) to do. I don't want to run my own business!

There are so many skills required in a start up, the most important skill is the ability to be a salesperson, if you have empathy it's difficult to be a salesperson.

Beezknees · 06/06/2023 05:27

Marmalayde · 06/06/2023 01:53

I disagree I think it could help because the poorer could afford to quit work to study, freelance or train their way into a better career or start a business.

Not everyone is capable of that though. A lot of poor people are poor because they didn't do well at school. If you don't have the intelligence, you don't have it. Ditto starting a business, it's not something that everyone can (or wants) to do. I don't want to run my own business!

NotAllStaceys · 06/06/2023 04:42

And yes, before anybody boring says this thread was about UBI, not AI, the point is that they are intrinsically linked. UBI is only being considered because of AI. Otherwise it would not work because labour is needed and even more people would decide to be Stacey. And when AI takes over you will have to have UBI of some form or there will be social meltdown. And because the only way UBI can possibly be funded is from the productivity gains from AI.

It's impossible to discuss one without the other in a meaningful way. However, I think it's unlikely this is how it'll all play out sadly, I can't see humans overcoming their tribalism and selfishness and concern about the size of Stacey's arse to make it work and not destroy each other instead. Bleak I know.

Time for me to sleep.

NotAllStaceys · 06/06/2023 04:32

It's been used to manipulate multiple "democratic" elections already...

I don't think people realise the extent to which AI is involved in their lives right now. Most people interact with some form of it every day without really consciously thinking about it. It will be more and more.

NotAllStaceys · 06/06/2023 04:16

And no, not like nuclear. Because all nuclear powers know if they initiate something it will be fired back at them instantly and game over. So it does work as a deterrent.

It's clear who has done what, and what the consequences are. With this, it could be so different. Deniable. Hard to trace. Shutting down internet or banking systems, power grids, designing biological warfare, all kinds of awful ways it could be used.

It could also be used to crack clean hydrogen power, ways to farm without degrading soil, ways to provide good living standards for everyone with the resources left on Earth IF used for that purpose. But that would require global co-operation and it seems the UK can't even co-operate with its closest neighbours for mutual benefit, who most closely share our cultural values. So good luck getting North Korea, the US, China, Russia and others to put aside their ridiculous nationalistic crap and act in the interests of the human race and use this tech the right way. They won't. So it will likely lead to hideous things. 😔

I rather envy Stacey sitting on her arse obliviously.

NotAllStaceys · 06/06/2023 04:05

Sorry just had to do it, with the username. 😆

Sorry Stacey!

NotAllStaceys · 06/06/2023 04:02

Greensheeps · 06/06/2023 03:52

@Nepmarthiturn i get where you’re coming from, but you’re take does seem a little worst case scenario. I work for one of the ftse 100…..why have they not replaced me already?
These huge companies with the money and manpower to change the way they operate….they’re tinkering, but not committed to AI.
power hungry nutters? Is that not the same as nuclear capability?

Economics. As soon as it's cheaper for a machine to do your job that will be the case. For all of us.

As the computers become faster and more efficient a human simply will not be able to compete. The exponential growth again.

It's hard to imagine things outside your frame of reference, so it seems impossible a computer could do a complex job with analysis, human interaction, judgement, etc?

What we are talking about is - because of the exponential curve - the equivalent difference between now and 2040, of the disbelief someone in 12th century would have if you turned up there and landed in their village in a helicopter.

Of course it seems unbelievable. But that is because the change is accelerating and is exponential, so our brains which expect our lives to be relatively similar to our earlier life or our parents' lives cannot compute it. Ironic.

It's the acceleration part that I think people aren't appreciating: how fast this is going to happen.

Greensheeps · 06/06/2023 03:52

@Nepmarthiturn i get where you’re coming from, but you’re take does seem a little worst case scenario. I work for one of the ftse 100…..why have they not replaced me already?
These huge companies with the money and manpower to change the way they operate….they’re tinkering, but not committed to AI.
power hungry nutters? Is that not the same as nuclear capability?

Phoebo · 06/06/2023 03:52

Beezknees · 04/06/2023 10:04

I think the thought process is AI taking over a lot of those jobs. According to many on mumsnet in 10 years AI will be doing most of the jobs. Don't know if I buy it honestly.

Why not, it's been happening for years look at call centres, more recently self service check outs etc. And now AI is becoming intelligent, the sky is the limit. Particularly so many people working from home has taken the human element out of many jobs. It will happen faster than we think

Nepmarthiturn · 06/06/2023 03:43

Greensheeps · 06/06/2023 03:29

#99%ofstaceys

🤔😬🤣

Nepmarthiturn · 06/06/2023 03:43

Greensheeps · 06/06/2023 03:27

@Nepmarthiturn I spoke with various far more intelligent colleagues years ago about AI being able to do a better job than myself. They all dismissed it. I’m in 2 minds, obviously AI will be powerful, but I think the current media hype is a bit over the top.
But then a lot of the basic AI being used has been around for years. Will these all powerful robots destroy us? I guess I can’t understand what is the supposed end of humanity?
I can’t see governments replacing all jobs with AI, at the end of the day humans need something to do

Well, that's the problem.

A few years ago people didn't think AI would be able to write essays and new articles did they?

Now it can. And make art and write music. And very soon will be waaaay better at designing architecture or giving legal advice or diagnosing medical conditions than a human. Could give tailored teaching to each child like having a 1:1 teacher. Nursing robots are being developed already. Robots are better at surgery than humans already... At the moment it's not great at lots of things, but this is what I mean about people not grasping the exponential growth part: in 2-5 years, it goes from laughable to "bye bye job".

So then what? Either you have this as a tool, and humans devote their time to leisure and family. But then this has to be treated as a public resource and shared. And also kept under control so that it serves purposes people want it to. And if you have 90% of the population with no work or income, what do you do to avoid total societal meltdown?

It will quickly become more intelligent than humans. Why would it want to serve humans or prioritise our needs? If it can rewrite its own code then... game over. This is happening already. Many who have designed the current (primitive) AI systems have no idea already how they are functioning or reaching their conclusions. So how can we control it?

Humanity continues with this competitive model, nation states, no global agreement even on stuff like climate so of course any attempt to control this or use it for good will not work, idiots will wreck it for everyone as always. Power hungry nutters. It will become an arms race and not used for the purpose of providing good living standards etc for everyone.

And on top of that you have the problem of inputs, at this stage where it still is determined by human input. E.g. one of the advanced ones was asked how to fix acidity in the oceans and its "solution" involved lowering the oxygen in the atmosphere to a level where all animals (including humans obviously) would suffocate, slowly and unpleasantly. It has no "frame of reference" of human values.

It is the scale and pace of the change that is coming that I don't think people want to acknowledge. Exponential, not linear. It could be harnessed to fix many of the problems we've created for ourselves and our planet and frankly I see no other way out of them now so without it we will be fucked. But if it is not used in the right way then we will be fucked.

So basically we are likely fucked. 😆

Greensheeps · 06/06/2023 03:29

#99%ofstaceys

Greensheeps · 06/06/2023 03:27

@Nepmarthiturn I spoke with various far more intelligent colleagues years ago about AI being able to do a better job than myself. They all dismissed it. I’m in 2 minds, obviously AI will be powerful, but I think the current media hype is a bit over the top.
But then a lot of the basic AI being used has been around for years. Will these all powerful robots destroy us? I guess I can’t understand what is the supposed end of humanity?
I can’t see governments replacing all jobs with AI, at the end of the day humans need something to do

Nepmarthiturn · 06/06/2023 03:27

saltinesandcoffeecups · 06/06/2023 03:25

I feel like I should add #notallstaceys in defense of the non layabout Staceys in the world! 🤣

🤣🤣🤣🤣

I should clarify as well, to avoid being banned.

#notallstaceys

Swipe left for the next trending thread