Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Universal basic income and what it may look like

534 replies

porkpiesinthepark · 04/06/2023 09:54

I've been thinking for a while about the criticism of UBI and I think it's due to people not being able to imagine the government trying to 'match' peoples wages. In my opinion, it never will but there will be alternatives to what we have now, which will be able to offer something better.

So say the UBI is £1000 a month for a single person.
We could change the housing market to allow much more public housing with rents set at an affordable level, much more stability, no private landlords and the option to customise/ change your home. Let's face it, home ownership is out of reach for the majority at present. I don't find people are dying to own their own homes but desperate to be out of the instability of the private rental market, out of parents houses, out of house shares etc. If you could offer the next best thing to owning your own house, I think people would go for it.
There would be much more community linked to people having extra time due to not working or not working as many hours. Now, not having enough to do in the day is bad but most people have these huge dreams for retirement and this would just allow them to do some of these things now instead. Also more volunteering, looking after elderly relatives etc.
I don't think that private car ownership would be a thing. There would be a big system like Uber who you could call rides on. There would be a cheaper option, say if ten people wanted to go to the city centre at the same time, they would have to walk to a hub and then the van would pick everyone up, like public transport but based on demand. It would be a status symbol to be able to call a car out just for you.
I think a lot more people would wfh getting the cost of transport and childcare down. Schools might even go remote, as there wouldn't be both parents working and so in theory they could help facilitate the lessons. Then teachers would have small classes of Sen kids like mine, key workers and vulnerable children. Kids would interact with others through volunteering groups with parents, or just playing out as there would be less cars and more parents around to keep an eye on them.
People will either hate this vision as it's so different to what we have now. Or they will like some parts. But what we have now can't continue.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
Swrigh1234 · 04/06/2023 10:58

porkpiesinthepark · 04/06/2023 10:43

@Swrigh1234 I don't think communism is the big take down that you think it is. Obviously it was incomprehensible to people growing up in the 70-80s when house ownership was affordable, job progression was realistic, jobs were for life, loyalty was rewarded.
For my generation, we saw our parents shafted. We have been laughed at in banks when we want to get a mortgage, both on 30k jobs, we have been made redundant, furloughed, paid stagnant wages. We have been forced to live with parents until our mid thirties, if we could, or risk renting where we could be evicted at any time. We have been priced out of the areas we grew up in. We have been told that it's our faults that we can't save up 20k for a deposit.

A house which was secure, although not ours on paper, seems like a good alternative.

What has not being able to buy a house got to with getting rid of the market economy? That is student politics. Not a serious suggestion.

The reason we have a skewed situation with wages and housing is that the free market was destroyed by Labour 25 years ago. Tax credits did untold damage to this country. Is there any surprise that the gap between wages and house prices started to widen at the same time as tax credits were introduced. Effectively the government put a cap on wages by subsidizing employers. If employers don’t have to pay the going rate, they won’t invest in automation and productivity, meaning median income stagnates.

That government and every single one since relied on mass migration to massage the economic growth figure because more people means more GDP while GDP per capita drops and everyone gets poorer. While further corruption and money printing since 2008 caused money to flow into assets, inflating house prices.

Tax credits and universal credit since then is basically a form of corruption to take from the taxpayer to give to lobbying businesses so they don’t need to pay the going rate or invest in automation. It is socialism by the back door.

So the root of our problems lies with destruction of the free market, which if allowed to set wages have meant higher incomes and higher productivity and less asset price inflation.

WakeMeUpWhenGoodOmensIsBack · 04/06/2023 10:50

porkpiesinthepark · 04/06/2023 10:26

Surely the market would adapt if the majority of people were unemployed.
Bananas wouldn't stay at £1.50 a bunch for very long if no one could afford it. The price would drop, as would everything else.

You're confusing different sorts of pricing.

Houses in most of the UK are a scarcity good. They cost half a million quid or whatever because that's what people can afford to pay. If we had less money they'd cost less.

Bananas OTOH are produced to demand in a highly competitive market. The price charged in UK mass market supermarkets is pretty much what it costs to grow them, ship them across the world, sell them, and for everyone in the chain take a smallish chunk of profit. You could squeeze the profit margins and you could automate the sales process which would make them a bit cheaper but the price is fundamentally not linked to what people can afford to pay. If we could only afford to pay half the current price then the producers would shut up shop or sell to other countries.

You're right about one thing though. UBI could only ever work with massive state intervention in the housing market.

anniegun · 04/06/2023 10:49

UBI is a great idea but needs testing properly. Richard Nixon (of all people) came close to introducing it in the US. It provides a basic safety net that allows people to work flexibly , take more risks and start businesses. It should ensure that businesses reward their staff fairly. Its nonsense that "people will not work" as if that the case why doesn't everyone just work until they have earned enough to survive?

PhoenixArisen · 04/06/2023 10:47

schnauzerbeard · 04/06/2023 10:45

There will be less money paid in taxation though as people can work 50-100 hours less each month if they get guaranteed £1000 UBI. How will Public services survive with less public funding? Will people bother going for promotions at work? Will people go on to further education? Will people bother turning up to work if they know they can rely on UBi. Landlords would increase rents by £1000 pcm.

UBI / socialism just does not work. Economic growth needs capitalism.

I think this whole concept requires us all to be dumbed down and uneducated

Beezknees · 04/06/2023 10:46

Secure housing exists in theory, in the form of social housing. I have a housing association flat, I've got a home for life here. There's just not enough of it.

schnauzerbeard · 04/06/2023 10:45

There will be less money paid in taxation though as people can work 50-100 hours less each month if they get guaranteed £1000 UBI. How will Public services survive with less public funding? Will people bother going for promotions at work? Will people go on to further education? Will people bother turning up to work if they know they can rely on UBi. Landlords would increase rents by £1000 pcm.

UBI / socialism just does not work. Economic growth needs capitalism.

porkpiesinthepark · 04/06/2023 10:43

@Swrigh1234 I don't think communism is the big take down that you think it is. Obviously it was incomprehensible to people growing up in the 70-80s when house ownership was affordable, job progression was realistic, jobs were for life, loyalty was rewarded.
For my generation, we saw our parents shafted. We have been laughed at in banks when we want to get a mortgage, both on 30k jobs, we have been made redundant, furloughed, paid stagnant wages. We have been forced to live with parents until our mid thirties, if we could, or risk renting where we could be evicted at any time. We have been priced out of the areas we grew up in. We have been told that it's our faults that we can't save up 20k for a deposit.

A house which was secure, although not ours on paper, seems like a good alternative.

OP posts:
PhoenixArisen · 04/06/2023 10:42

We just need fair wages and those who can't work need fair benefits.

We are social animals, we need communities, relationships and good social interactions.

We need to have roles in society and be productive.

We need space and the freedom to roam and travel

We need independence and freedom to make choices

What you describe sounds horribly restrictive and terrible for our wellbeing.

DollyTrolly · 04/06/2023 10:40

porkpiesinthepark · 04/06/2023 10:35

Just to say I don't think this idea is a good one or feasible, but I don't think what we have now is a utopia either.
Two adults working full time jobs, two children in childcare 8-6, all to pay for a house we're in 6.30- bedtime and briefly in the morning. Flying out the house again on weekends, too busy for hobbies, seeing friends, elderly relatives. Too busy for our own health or wellbeing to be a priority.
Just so we can keep paying and paying and paying... for a house.

Sounds like you need to make changes to your own life..... rather than suggesting society changes because your work/life balance isn't working.

Swrigh1234 · 04/06/2023 10:37

porkpiesinthepark · 04/06/2023 10:26

Surely the market would adapt if the majority of people were unemployed.
Bananas wouldn't stay at £1.50 a bunch for very long if no one could afford it. The price would drop, as would everything else.

I’m not sure you know how economies, markets and supply chains work. In this utopian scenario that you paint, there would be no bananas to buy. Because they would be exported only to countries where there is a market and where people can afford to pay for them. You know, the market? It works wonders for making things available to the masses.

You haven’t invented a novel, new idea here to solve every problem. It was tried in 70 years and came crashing down in 1989.

porkpiesinthepark · 04/06/2023 10:35

Just to say I don't think this idea is a good one or feasible, but I don't think what we have now is a utopia either.
Two adults working full time jobs, two children in childcare 8-6, all to pay for a house we're in 6.30- bedtime and briefly in the morning. Flying out the house again on weekends, too busy for hobbies, seeing friends, elderly relatives. Too busy for our own health or wellbeing to be a priority.
Just so we can keep paying and paying and paying... for a house.

OP posts:
Wnikat · 04/06/2023 10:35

*without

morcoccansunset · 04/06/2023 10:35

orangegato · 04/06/2023 10:01

Who does the jobs then lol? Answers phones, works in shops, doctors dentist nurses care etc? What the fuck are you on about 😂

I think the point OP is trying to make is the money will be enough to live on and that's it. If people wanted luxury and treats then they'd have to work for it

DollyTrolly · 04/06/2023 10:35

It all sounds so sterile and boring.

Remote working, remote learning, shopping delivered .......

If people want to live like that then fine but for lots of people it's their idea of hell.

Wnikat · 04/06/2023 10:34

Once you factor in extra payments for disability etc it would look almost exactly like the current welfare state, which for all it’s flaws does aim to provide a basic standard of living for everyone with disincentivising work.

Beezknees · 04/06/2023 10:34

Madamecastafiore · 04/06/2023 10:31

Beezknees yes it is essentially money for nothing. You don't work for it? You haven't earnt it. Your employer pays you for working not the government.

Don't you think someone working full time shouldn't have to claim UC?

I don't see it as money for nothing, I see it as just what I'm owed and what I should actually be paid for doing my job.

Swrigh1234 · 04/06/2023 10:32

That wall of text from the OP summarized in one word. Communism. No one owns anything, everyone gets a few scraps to live on.

Sometimes, AIBU is like stumbling into the sixth form common room. Now, back to the real world….

Madamecastafiore · 04/06/2023 10:31

Beezknees yes it is essentially money for nothing. You don't work for it? You haven't earnt it. Your employer pays you for working not the government.

BCCoach · 04/06/2023 10:30

Didtheythough · 04/06/2023 10:08

I'm really interested in UBI and the places that have trialled it, but as far as I can see the major flaw is who will do the low paid, unpopular jobs, can't all be fine by AI, who's going to work in care homes? Also I don't understand your housing plan, how is it funded etc?

If the jobs market was a functional free market the “low paid unpopular jobs” would become very well paid.

DollyTrolly · 04/06/2023 10:29

I meant this is not the reality of many people lives

Tots678 · 04/06/2023 10:29

I think people would work a few hours on the side - so most painters, gardeners, plumbers, drivers woud go out of business and also this money wouldn't be declared so no tax from it. Unless you found a way to police this - which they don't now so can't see it happening then.

Spendonsend · 04/06/2023 10:29

I find it difficult to envisage as its a real change from now.

I dont get where the money comes from or what impact it would have on inflation.

I think the more likely way we are headed is a modern twist on the workhouse with food, accommodation and a small allowance for fun, in exchange for doing crap busy work that makes those not in the workhouse feel like the inhabitants arent getting a free ride.

DollyTrolly · 04/06/2023 10:29

Why do we think kids have to work side by side when we work remotely and don't see a human outside of our immediate family for days?

You're making so many sweeping generalisations and assumptions.

This is the reality of many peoples lives. There's are lots of people who work and socialise with people, in person regularly.

Beezknees · 04/06/2023 10:27

porkpiesinthepark · 04/06/2023 10:25

@Beezknees in a way though, what are we preparing children for if the majority of them will not work in a similar environment? Why do we think kids have to work side by side when we work remotely and don't see a human outside of our immediate family for days?

I certainly don't plan to live like that. Remember Covid? Humans crave human interaction. When we were all forced to stay at home, it didn't work.

porkpiesinthepark · 04/06/2023 10:27

@DollyTrolly I do too, and I work in a pretty AI proof industry. But lots of people just work to pay bills and would give it up tomorrow if they could.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread