Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Universal basic income and what it may look like

534 replies

porkpiesinthepark · 04/06/2023 09:54

I've been thinking for a while about the criticism of UBI and I think it's due to people not being able to imagine the government trying to 'match' peoples wages. In my opinion, it never will but there will be alternatives to what we have now, which will be able to offer something better.

So say the UBI is £1000 a month for a single person.
We could change the housing market to allow much more public housing with rents set at an affordable level, much more stability, no private landlords and the option to customise/ change your home. Let's face it, home ownership is out of reach for the majority at present. I don't find people are dying to own their own homes but desperate to be out of the instability of the private rental market, out of parents houses, out of house shares etc. If you could offer the next best thing to owning your own house, I think people would go for it.
There would be much more community linked to people having extra time due to not working or not working as many hours. Now, not having enough to do in the day is bad but most people have these huge dreams for retirement and this would just allow them to do some of these things now instead. Also more volunteering, looking after elderly relatives etc.
I don't think that private car ownership would be a thing. There would be a big system like Uber who you could call rides on. There would be a cheaper option, say if ten people wanted to go to the city centre at the same time, they would have to walk to a hub and then the van would pick everyone up, like public transport but based on demand. It would be a status symbol to be able to call a car out just for you.
I think a lot more people would wfh getting the cost of transport and childcare down. Schools might even go remote, as there wouldn't be both parents working and so in theory they could help facilitate the lessons. Then teachers would have small classes of Sen kids like mine, key workers and vulnerable children. Kids would interact with others through volunteering groups with parents, or just playing out as there would be less cars and more parents around to keep an eye on them.
People will either hate this vision as it's so different to what we have now. Or they will like some parts. But what we have now can't continue.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
JuliaHines2023 · 14/06/2023 09:34

Highandlows · 14/06/2023 09:08

How are the pans to prevent inflation when this payments start? And when inflation hits very high who is going keep paying for this shortfall as it would be unsustainable?

I am not going to pretend to be an economist. I'm not. I am a community volunteer, highlighting the problems with the current system. However, Basic Income Conversation have modelled different scenarios, one of which is fiscally neutral in static terms, so no extra call on public finances, and no net increase in taxation. That shows that a modest basic of £63 pw for adults, £41 pw per child, and £190 pw for over 65s, would cut child and pensioner poverty rates in half (a big issue for women who may not have a full NI payment record). The Mayor of London has similar modelling. And, as I said before, there is no evidence that people stop working and therefore stop paying tax. In fact, the opposite. You can read more here https://autonomy.work/wp-content/uploads/2023/05/Full_Paper_Lansley_Tackling_Poverty.pdf

https://autonomy.work/wp-content/uploads/2023/05/Full_Paper_Lansley_Tackling_Poverty.pdf

Highandlows · 14/06/2023 09:08

How are the pans to prevent inflation when this payments start? And when inflation hits very high who is going keep paying for this shortfall as it would be unsustainable?

ThroughThickAndThin01 · 14/06/2023 06:14

Thank you JuliaHines’ good to have a post from someone directly involved.

AutumnCrow · 13/06/2023 20:46

JuliaHines2023 · 13/06/2023 19:42

@AutumnCrow I am so sorry to hear that.

Thanks. But I doubt it's uncommon.

JuliaHines2023 · 13/06/2023 19:42

@AutumnCrow I am so sorry to hear that.

AutumnCrow · 13/06/2023 18:49

Thank you very much for your post and the discussion & information, @JuliaHines2023.

This bit is crucial:

Thresholds are a huge problem, particularly because UC is a passporting benefit for housing benefit, and rents are sky high. People are trapped in low paid work, because they cannot afford to lose HB when they do better.

It's affecting a couple I know. They both work (one F/T, one P/T), rent, and have young children. They are also stymied by sky-high childcare costs and labyrinthine bureaucracy if they work more hours.

They are utterly miserable and on the point of splitting. The social costs of that will be huge, to no-one's benefit, and to everyone's detriment.

JuliaHines2023 · 13/06/2023 18:14

I am one of the people who has been part of developing the pilot proposal. We are a small community group in East Finchley and, talking to people, we found the system at the moment isn't working.

  1. It isn't enough for people to manage. We have people reliant on foodbanks, and, trust me, that is not because they need someone to shop for them. They know how to shop, they just don't have enough money.
  2. Sanctions cause massive stress, and real financial problems. They are often applied wrongly.
  3. Thresholds are a huge problem, particularly because UC is a passporting benefit for housing benefit, and rents are sky high. People are trapped in low paid work, because they cannot afford to lose HB when they do better.
  4. Conditions often make no sense. People are now being asked to work an extra two hours a week minimum. If their current job can't offer them that, they have to find another one, which may be lower paid on an hourly rate, so saves the Govt nothing, or they hit the thresholds issue.
  5. Disabled people are terrified of showing they are capable of any kind of activity, even if they have good and bad periods, in case they are accused of faking. But activity is important for our physical and mental health. Of course disabled people, with extra needs, need more money.
  6. People working in the gig economy can have very uncertain incomes, and that's a problem.
  7. Calculating on household instead of individual incomes traps people in situations of domestic abuse.

So, we wanted to imagine something different. Basic income addresses all of these problems. Raising the level of benefits just raises the threshold, but it is still a problem when you meet it.

Basic income is money that is always there if your life changes (if you lose your job, or become sick or disabled), or if you want to change your life (take a low paid internship, train, start your own business - things that middle and upper class kids already have through the Bank of Mum and Dad). It is both a safety net and a springboard.

We chose the amount of £1600 a month because we already know that poverty and health inequalities are correlated. We wanted to know what the impact of sanctions, thresholds and conditions is (or what happens when you remove them), especially on health and wellbeing. It is also the sum that is being used in the Welsh Government UBI trial for care leavers, so comparisons can be made.

We know it will go further in Jarrow than in East Finchley; it won't be right for everyone in N2, but we will make sure they understand the impact on them.

We are not suggesting that this should be the level of a basic income going forward. I agree it would be wrong to start at a level like this nationally. We have to do the research in the system we live in. And yes, the interaction between a basic income, tax, and minimum wage levels, would be crucial.

For all the people who say that you lose control of your life or that this is communism, I would disagree. The current benefit system exerts massive control over people, but the point about UBI is that it is unconditional. Having money gives people choice and control over their lives. Communism, unlike UBI, provided universal services, where there was no choice or control over the quality or way those services were delivered. And of course, we need some of those too, like schools and the NHS.

There is no evidence that people stop working with a basic income - in fact in Finland, where the trial was on unemployed people, they worked more than the control group. The pandemic showed us that sitting in your room watching telly, with little money and no other options, is pretty miserable. I don't think you can bully people into work; I do think you can support them into it. Do I think that some people will swing the lead? A few, but they are probably working the system anyway.

And is it fair? I think so. Everyone gets it, so if your neighbour wants to waste her life away, why do you care? She isn't getting a penny more than you. But basic income gives everyone a stake in the level of benefits. At the moment, everyone knows what they are paying for energy and food and rent, but unless you receive them yourself, who knows what benefit levels are?

And for those of you who said the pilot is too small, we know it won't produce masses of statistical data, but it will produce some, and it will give us qualitative data. We had to balance the size of the trial, with what we needed to pay if the Government won't support the trial, and still make it achievable from a fundraising perspective.

I hope that helps.

You can find our proposal here (along with other pieces on basic income and the future of work) https://autonomy.work/portfolio/basic-income-big-local/

A BIG LOCAL BASIC INCOME: PROPOSAL FOR A LOCALLY-LED BASIC INCOME PILOT

Read Autonomy's new report on a basic income pilot consultation with local residents in Jarrow and Grange.

https://autonomy.work/portfolio/basic-income-big-local

PhoenixArisen · 07/06/2023 09:44

NotAllStaceys · 06/06/2023 19:01

It's a very narrow view of the purpose of learning to think it is only for work/ earning money. I find that sad.

I have been saying that I think it is possible to restructure things so people can live a life of mostly leisure and freedom and how that could be done. Do I think this will happen? No. Very low chance, for the reasons I stated last night. I think it will be widespread destruction and misery instead, sadly.

Most of our work is to create a future for ourselves and future generations. Whether it's health, educational, financial or material.
We are not programmed to just survive.
People talk about freedom but what would we use that freedom for if we don't have the money or driving force to learn new skills or travel?
We're intelligent beings who thrive when we're mentally stimulated, have a role within society, have money and freedom to make choices.
Even in sci fi where there's more of a utopian society in a technologically advanced civilisation, people are exploring space and having lots of human interaction and everyone has a role in that society.
If we're going to be happy in a society where we're limited, we'll have to be drugged/medicated or dare I say, neuralinked.

Beezknees · 07/06/2023 08:13

Florissante · 07/06/2023 07:17

Typical MN hyperbole. AI will take over the job market! People will starve! Save, us, government, by giving us money for doing nothing!

I don't actually think it will happen. It's hypothetical.

Florissante · 07/06/2023 07:17

Beezknees · 07/06/2023 06:38

There will literally be no choice if AI takes over the job market. You can't let people starve. To fight back against it we'd need to fight against the development of AI.

Typical MN hyperbole. AI will take over the job market! People will starve! Save, us, government, by giving us money for doing nothing!

Beezknees · 07/06/2023 06:38

Florenz · 06/06/2023 17:45

What would be the point of getting an education if there were no jobs and everyone got UBI anyway?

It would be absolute living nightmare and I can't believe people can't see this. You'd end up with a massive underclass with no genetic memory of ever working, providing for themselves or being able to do anything, just being utterly reliant on the state, and a small elite which would basically evolve into a different species. And on a long enough timeline, the elite would ask themselves what the point of the underclass was if they didn't serve any purpose but to consume. And that would be it. UBI must never be allowed to happen, we need to fight against it with every fibre of our being.

There will literally be no choice if AI takes over the job market. You can't let people starve. To fight back against it we'd need to fight against the development of AI.

BCCoach · 06/06/2023 20:57

jenandberrys · 06/06/2023 13:56

So take teachers for example. A profession in which there is already a shortage, why would a teacher work FT when they could simply work half the week and not have a pay cut? In fact why would they not leave altogether and top up their 1600 with a low stress job elsewhere? Why would a carer work full time for a low wage if they didn't need to. You seem to be drastically overestimating how much people want to or enjoy work. I am pretty well paid but I would quite happily drop my hours if the state was going to sub my pay. The problem is, I work in a role where there is already a shortage of workers so that's not really going to have a positive impact on society.

UBI only works (and is indeed only required) in a society with a very high degree of automation. Only jobs that cannot be automated, or where it is still cheaper to employ a human, still exist, and those are paid well enough to attract candidates who are willing to do them. Many jobs will no longer exist, or only in very small numbers: the motorcar did not get rid of farriers, but there are a lot fewer than they used to be. Ditto typists, boilermakers, and supermarket cashiers. New jobs will come into being as they always have when there are big upheavals in society. In the past, the new jobs have been "better" and more numerous than the old jobs that were rendered redundant. The concern with pervasive automation, AI, and robotics, is that the new jobs will not be as numerous as the ones they replace, nor will they be accessible to people who do not have highly specialised skillsets.

KisstheTeapot14 · 06/06/2023 19:30

Could be positive I feel. Guess that is why w are having trials - to look at how people behave.

Lots of retired people with a guaranteed income don't loaf about, they volunteer. They find something meaningful to do.

Not enough carers even now, due to very low pay and poor conditions/regard by society.

I have no idea about the taxation side though. How would the money be raised to pay for UI and NHS etc? Hoping someone cleverer than me at economics can explain.

Florissante · 06/06/2023 19:21

jenandberrys · 04/06/2023 10:08

All benefits are money for nothing. They just called them tax credits to make people feel better about themselves.

Well put. And then there's the term "entitlement". A popular comment on MN is "find out what you're entitled to, OP".

SunnyEgg · 06/06/2023 19:04

NotAllStaceys · 06/06/2023 19:01

It's a very narrow view of the purpose of learning to think it is only for work/ earning money. I find that sad.

I have been saying that I think it is possible to restructure things so people can live a life of mostly leisure and freedom and how that could be done. Do I think this will happen? No. Very low chance, for the reasons I stated last night. I think it will be widespread destruction and misery instead, sadly.

Oh I know learning is for more than work that’s why it going fills me with dread.

If schools and learning can remain that will help with the part of the issue.

The other is human behaviour and how optimistic I am people will do nice things with their time

NotAllStaceys · 06/06/2023 19:01

It's a very narrow view of the purpose of learning to think it is only for work/ earning money. I find that sad.

I have been saying that I think it is possible to restructure things so people can live a life of mostly leisure and freedom and how that could be done. Do I think this will happen? No. Very low chance, for the reasons I stated last night. I think it will be widespread destruction and misery instead, sadly.

SunnyEgg · 06/06/2023 18:49

NotAllStaceys · 06/06/2023 18:34

The puritan mindset of virtuous work has taken hold on a deeper level than I imagined.

Do people really believe this stuff? Like actually believe that work = value?

The entire point of technology is to reduce the need for human input: to achieve the same or more output with less work.

People really have been done a number on by those who don't work at all if they genuinely believe that hours in should equal money out as some kind of moral value, when those with serious money would never entertain doing anything of the sort.

I’m not sure the lovely picture painted is accurate, I find talk of online learning depressing and that’s even better than the point raised on why bother with education at all

I’m glad people see the good, maybe they’re right, the bad end of it isn’t looking nice.

And all the talk doesn’t really convince me we’ll have access to the public funds from tax from the few without some way of ensuring it

NotAllStaceys · 06/06/2023 18:34

The puritan mindset of virtuous work has taken hold on a deeper level than I imagined.

Do people really believe this stuff? Like actually believe that work = value?

The entire point of technology is to reduce the need for human input: to achieve the same or more output with less work.

People really have been done a number on by those who don't work at all if they genuinely believe that hours in should equal money out as some kind of moral value, when those with serious money would never entertain doing anything of the sort.

Garusmulp · 06/06/2023 18:15

Reading people’s posts in favourite of UBI - too good to be true in my opinion! All fantasies! There is never going to money for nothing, we will have to pay a price one way or another.

jenandberrys · 06/06/2023 18:02

HandBall · 06/06/2023 17:17

Robot bins, self driving bin lorry, one supervisor human, no need for many bin men.

Hoists in out of bed, bath, helping with dressing, robot hoover, AI robot meals on wheeels let themselves into the home with digital locks, AI oversee supervisors, no need for many care workers, instead of several a day, one a day to tidy dishes into the dishwasher, sort out broken dishwasher etc.

I don't think I have ever seen someone so totally miss the point of care work.

NotAllStaceys · 06/06/2023 18:01

Oh dear. Technological growth is exponential. Comparing this to the industrial revolution makes no more sense than comparing that to when humans figured out how to make an axe from flint. I don't know about "hype". If anything I find it quite interesting that people are only just starting to discuss this recently when it has been publicised in newspapers erc when the change that is coming has been well documented by well-respected experts in the field in published books on the topic for at least 30 years now. Perhaps you were oblivious all this time and that's why you now perceive it as "hype". 🙄

Swrigh1234 · 06/06/2023 17:57

NotAllStaceys · 06/06/2023 17:50

I think they mean no personal tax allowance or steps to the 50% PAYE tax.

The whole point is that before long there will be very little work for humans to do, and therefore the tax burden cannot fall on employment income anymore.

Very little work for humans to do? When have we heard that before. At the start of every Industrial Revolution. Nothing new and overhyped.

NotAllStaceys · 06/06/2023 17:50

I think they mean no personal tax allowance or steps to the 50% PAYE tax.

The whole point is that before long there will be very little work for humans to do, and therefore the tax burden cannot fall on employment income anymore.

NotAllStaceys · 06/06/2023 17:49

Only 40% tax/nic/student loan on next £22.5k or so.

Also wrong. 40% income tax + 2% NI + 9% student loan = 51%. Add in child benefit withdrawal and the marginal tax rate can be over 85%.

At £100k+ it is often well over 100%, hence many people cutting hours because they are actually charged and end up with less net pay for working more.

NotAllStaceys · 06/06/2023 17:46

No one is paying 50% or more tax/nic/SL unless their wages are currently over £50k!

And?

Swipe left for the next trending thread