Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Universal basic income and what it may look like

534 replies

porkpiesinthepark · 04/06/2023 09:54

I've been thinking for a while about the criticism of UBI and I think it's due to people not being able to imagine the government trying to 'match' peoples wages. In my opinion, it never will but there will be alternatives to what we have now, which will be able to offer something better.

So say the UBI is £1000 a month for a single person.
We could change the housing market to allow much more public housing with rents set at an affordable level, much more stability, no private landlords and the option to customise/ change your home. Let's face it, home ownership is out of reach for the majority at present. I don't find people are dying to own their own homes but desperate to be out of the instability of the private rental market, out of parents houses, out of house shares etc. If you could offer the next best thing to owning your own house, I think people would go for it.
There would be much more community linked to people having extra time due to not working or not working as many hours. Now, not having enough to do in the day is bad but most people have these huge dreams for retirement and this would just allow them to do some of these things now instead. Also more volunteering, looking after elderly relatives etc.
I don't think that private car ownership would be a thing. There would be a big system like Uber who you could call rides on. There would be a cheaper option, say if ten people wanted to go to the city centre at the same time, they would have to walk to a hub and then the van would pick everyone up, like public transport but based on demand. It would be a status symbol to be able to call a car out just for you.
I think a lot more people would wfh getting the cost of transport and childcare down. Schools might even go remote, as there wouldn't be both parents working and so in theory they could help facilitate the lessons. Then teachers would have small classes of Sen kids like mine, key workers and vulnerable children. Kids would interact with others through volunteering groups with parents, or just playing out as there would be less cars and more parents around to keep an eye on them.
People will either hate this vision as it's so different to what we have now. Or they will like some parts. But what we have now can't continue.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
Beezknees · 04/06/2023 12:17

Honeychickpea · 04/06/2023 12:13

It depends. What is your job and how many hours a week do you devote to it?

Why does that matter? Any full time job should be enough to live on without needing UC. I work full time 38 hours a week.

schnauzerbeard · 04/06/2023 12:15

Businesses and capital are already taxed though and wouldn't generate enough to make up the shortfall from employees working less hours. Unless the poster who replied to me is suggesting tripling business rate tax?

C152 · 04/06/2023 12:14

I think UBI is a good idea, but not necessarily the way you propose. Providing people with a financial safety net improves mental and physical well-being, but doesn't necessarily improve one's ability to find work. I think if it were introduced, it would need to be with open eyes about what the benefits are. As I can see it, one of the benefits saves the Gov money in other areas ie. improved health means preventing health issues which wind up costing the Government money in terms of those accessing NHS services.

Some early info on an experiment in Finland is here:

https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2019/02/the-results-finlands-universal-basic-income-experiment-are-in-is-it-working/

It is worth considering, on the basis of what other UBI experiments have shown. But the reality is, mass social wellbeing intiatives like this will never be introduced in the UK, because as a whole, the country doesn't want it.

The results of Finland’s basic income experiment are in. Did it work?

The results are in from Finland’s big political experiment, and they offer something for everyone.

https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2019/02/the-results-finlands-universal-basic-income-experiment-are-in-is-it-working

Honeychickpea · 04/06/2023 12:13

Beezknees · 04/06/2023 10:34

Don't you think someone working full time shouldn't have to claim UC?

I don't see it as money for nothing, I see it as just what I'm owed and what I should actually be paid for doing my job.

It depends. What is your job and how many hours a week do you devote to it?

DollyTrolly · 04/06/2023 12:10

Why is it sterile? The idea is people have much more free time so they can spend that doing whatever they choose.

The OPs idea involved remote learning and work. No physical shops with everything being delivered.

That sounds sterile and boring to me. Where is the social interaction, the small talk the little interactions that actually make a difference.

Highandlows · 04/06/2023 12:04

Tbh your problem OP has been happening in many other countries. People leave to make a better life for themselves. In some of those countries the politicians found a way to deceived with handouts and promises of a better life. Let Venezuela be a cautionary tale for you.

There is not free lunch I am afraid.

Room102 · 04/06/2023 12:03

schnauzerbeard · 04/06/2023 10:45

There will be less money paid in taxation though as people can work 50-100 hours less each month if they get guaranteed £1000 UBI. How will Public services survive with less public funding? Will people bother going for promotions at work? Will people go on to further education? Will people bother turning up to work if they know they can rely on UBi. Landlords would increase rents by £1000 pcm.

UBI / socialism just does not work. Economic growth needs capitalism.

The taxes will be on businesses and capital instead.

Room102 · 04/06/2023 12:01

DollyTrolly · 04/06/2023 10:35

It all sounds so sterile and boring.

Remote working, remote learning, shopping delivered .......

If people want to live like that then fine but for lots of people it's their idea of hell.

Why is it sterile? The idea is people have much more free time so they can spend that doing whatever they choose.

Room102 · 04/06/2023 11:55

Some huge change in how the financing of society is structured is going to be necessary because otherwise a large proportion of the population will be destitute. And businesses in their current form cannot function if there are vanishingly few people who can buy their products.

A very large proportion of the population cannot live on £1000 per month or whatever, in many areas this won't even cover half of their mortgage. It makes no sense either to build lots of social accommodation and force people to move to that leaving their current homes abandoned as nobody has money to buy them. In practice large scale debt forgiveness will be required as part of restructuring (many precedents for this in history but not on this scale of course as societies were smaller and less interconnected).

There is also the issue that while AI will hugely reduce the work required by humans some roles will still require humans and you need to be able to get people to do them. There will also be new roles that don't exist now and require lots of new skills.

The problems are not insurmountable but it will be a time of enormous change that's difficult to predict in terms of how it will play out. Particularly given the interactions with climate change (flooding, energy and food shortages, huge mass migrations) and also population collapse due to low birthrates everywhere outside subsaharan Africa. All of this requires a lot of long-term scenario planning, investment, infrastructure change. I suspect it will end up being chaos unfortunately because this won't be done, just like there was no proper planning even for a pandemic which was entirely predictable and predicted.

Rasputina · 04/06/2023 11:53

I’ve never been more relieved I chose not to have kids TBH. People just aren’t getting how completely everything is going to change so what sounds stupid and unworkable now doesn’t matter much because life will be wholly different in so many way. I’m the first to admit I’m most smart enough to come up with any solutions.

IncomingTraffic · 04/06/2023 11:52

Bloody hell. Because it would be so easy to completely redesign society. And, of course, everyone will want to live in exactly the same way that the OP is imagining will work for her.

That scenario even has some of the worst aspects of covid lock down baked in - school remote (and women bearing the brunt of the labour!) unless you’re considered needy enough to be allowed inside the building. Urgh.

Peacepudding · 04/06/2023 11:51

Rasputina · 04/06/2023 11:30

I think a lot of people don’t realise just how revolutionary AI is and just how much it’s going to change everything. UBI in some form will absolutely be needed.

Agree. My DD is only 12 and I'm already starting to think about what career paths she should avoid. So many people are going to be without income in the coming years

8state · 04/06/2023 11:51

If unemployment due to AI rises, which seems likely, something will need to be done. I imagine poverty will get quite extreme before a government does anything, as it sounds complicated and controversial to enact. When and if it does come in I think it would be linked to doing a certain amount of work or hours that serves the country. I don't know if it would be good or not. If we do start to see massive hunger and poverty we may welcome it, and there are already people struggling to eat and pay rent. On the other hand, I would be concerned it may be linked to a social credit system run by AI.

Swrigh1234 · 04/06/2023 11:50

AutumnCrow · 04/06/2023 11:49

I'm still trying to get past the banana economics

I think OP took the idea of banana republic too literally when coming up with this revolutionary idea.

Swrigh1234 · 04/06/2023 11:49

We have UBI. It’s called universal credit and 6 million are currently getting it. Some may say it’s not truly universal, yet this country borrowed £26bn last month alone to pay it to those 6 million people. Any ideas on how it will be funded for 70 million people? More borrowing? Money printing? Well we all know how that turned out during Covid. More taxes? Who is paying these taxes if everyone is on UBI?

Serious answers only please. No sixth form student type brainwaves.

AutumnCrow · 04/06/2023 11:49

I'm still trying to get past the banana economics

SunnyEgg · 04/06/2023 11:47

Phineyj · 04/06/2023 11:17

I read the OP and thought, she's reinvented East Germany!

When you read memoirs of people who lived under that regime, there were good aspects.

But also massive downsides. To the extent a wall was built to stem the population drain.

You need a huge amount of government intervention in everyday life to control prices and rents. It can go really wrong. Look at Venuezuela. Or just look at our politicians. Do you really want them having more power?

And no there wouldn't be any bananas.

Yes some on mn would like it but countries that have done similar have had to build walls to stop people fleeing

Peacepudding · 04/06/2023 11:46

orangegato · 04/06/2023 10:06

A robot doctor dentist or care assistant, fireman, customer service (no one accepts an automated response), decorating, plumbing, building?

Computers can do tech, finance, analysis jobs but fuck all practical really

Customer service - you won't know it's an automated response. It'll sound like speaking to a human and it'll be knowledgeable and helpful every time. No more being passed around departments because agents don't want to deal with you or don't know how. AI is going to take A LOT of jobs.

Rasputina · 04/06/2023 11:46

BarelyLiterate · 04/06/2023 11:45

Sounds like an illiberal, authoritarian socialist nightmare to me. I will continue to earn my own money, thanks. And continue to vote for governments which don’t seek to deprive me of it and hand it over to the stupid, the feckless and the idle who don’t want to support themselves and already receive ridiculously inflated levels of benefits & entitlements. Which I am forced to pay for.

What I would support is a much higher minimum wage, combined with substantially increased tax allowances and massive benefit cuts creating much stronger incentives to work.

You can still work to earn your own money the idea is we are all given a baseline amount as a starting point. You wouldn’t be prevented from working more to buy nice things.

BarelyLiterate · 04/06/2023 11:45

Sounds like an illiberal, authoritarian socialist nightmare to me. I will continue to earn my own money, thanks. And continue to vote for governments which don’t seek to deprive me of it and hand it over to the stupid, the feckless and the idle who don’t want to support themselves and already receive ridiculously inflated levels of benefits & entitlements. Which I am forced to pay for.

What I would support is a much higher minimum wage, combined with substantially increased tax allowances and massive benefit cuts creating much stronger incentives to work.

Beezknees · 04/06/2023 11:44

gogohmm · 04/06/2023 11:42

Have you ever lived anywhere with a every 2 hour bus service? In fact we have "on demand" buses now, but I've yet to be able to use one for work because you can't prebook a time except "within an hour" useless for anything but leisure.

I don't want allocated social housing either. I own my house. My 22 year old dd has just put in an offer for a house by saving up, house buying is very much in reach for those outside of the expensive areas.

You still have to earn enough to be accepted for a mortgage. A single person on minumum wage couldn't buy a house.

Rasputina · 04/06/2023 11:43

Well I was talking more about businesses than individuals.

kitsuneghost · 04/06/2023 11:42

It would never be £1000 a month and even if it was there would be outrage as many on benefits get more than this AND rent paid.
There is a lot of support for at the moment cause the benefits people think they will get it on top of benefits.

Basilthymerosemary · 04/06/2023 11:42

porkpiesinthepark · 04/06/2023 10:35

Just to say I don't think this idea is a good one or feasible, but I don't think what we have now is a utopia either.
Two adults working full time jobs, two children in childcare 8-6, all to pay for a house we're in 6.30- bedtime and briefly in the morning. Flying out the house again on weekends, too busy for hobbies, seeing friends, elderly relatives. Too busy for our own health or wellbeing to be a priority.
Just so we can keep paying and paying and paying... for a house.

Then don't have children and you'll have more free time and money.

You have a choice.

gogohmm · 04/06/2023 11:42

Have you ever lived anywhere with a every 2 hour bus service? In fact we have "on demand" buses now, but I've yet to be able to use one for work because you can't prebook a time except "within an hour" useless for anything but leisure.

I don't want allocated social housing either. I own my house. My 22 year old dd has just put in an offer for a house by saving up, house buying is very much in reach for those outside of the expensive areas.