Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Universal basic income and what it may look like

534 replies

porkpiesinthepark · 04/06/2023 09:54

I've been thinking for a while about the criticism of UBI and I think it's due to people not being able to imagine the government trying to 'match' peoples wages. In my opinion, it never will but there will be alternatives to what we have now, which will be able to offer something better.

So say the UBI is £1000 a month for a single person.
We could change the housing market to allow much more public housing with rents set at an affordable level, much more stability, no private landlords and the option to customise/ change your home. Let's face it, home ownership is out of reach for the majority at present. I don't find people are dying to own their own homes but desperate to be out of the instability of the private rental market, out of parents houses, out of house shares etc. If you could offer the next best thing to owning your own house, I think people would go for it.
There would be much more community linked to people having extra time due to not working or not working as many hours. Now, not having enough to do in the day is bad but most people have these huge dreams for retirement and this would just allow them to do some of these things now instead. Also more volunteering, looking after elderly relatives etc.
I don't think that private car ownership would be a thing. There would be a big system like Uber who you could call rides on. There would be a cheaper option, say if ten people wanted to go to the city centre at the same time, they would have to walk to a hub and then the van would pick everyone up, like public transport but based on demand. It would be a status symbol to be able to call a car out just for you.
I think a lot more people would wfh getting the cost of transport and childcare down. Schools might even go remote, as there wouldn't be both parents working and so in theory they could help facilitate the lessons. Then teachers would have small classes of Sen kids like mine, key workers and vulnerable children. Kids would interact with others through volunteering groups with parents, or just playing out as there would be less cars and more parents around to keep an eye on them.
People will either hate this vision as it's so different to what we have now. Or they will like some parts. But what we have now can't continue.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
DrHousecuredme · 04/06/2023 13:20

Doesn't sound like a very good future to me. People already resent those who get UC, do away with all the low paid jobs and that will mean a whole lot more people out of work, workers will resent paying for them even more.

Isn't the idea that AI will do more so productivity will remain the same so the "norm" will be for people to work less rather than some people working harder and some people not working at all?
That's the way I always envisaged it.
As with everything, there'll be people who can't work or choose not to but then that will always be the case no matter how things are organised.

SunnyEgg · 04/06/2023 13:18

Room102 · 04/06/2023 13:11

It is very weird isn't it? The idea of less work and more leisure time leaves people horrified. My impression is that this strange cultural attitude is primarily driven by people having a serious dose of the green eyed monster and huge resentment at anybody getting anything they don't feel they "deserve" and absolute hatred of anybody who has any more than they do. Even if a change might leave them personally better off, if it benefits anybody else as well their reaction is a flat "NO".

Sad indeed.

Some people value state intervention or control more and others value freedom

It’s similar to lockdown, many on here probably preferred it, or would prefer set up where they are subsidised more

We’re not all the same, one persons comfort is another’s lack of freedom

It feels like similar themes to Industrial Revolution and East Germany wrt people trying to leave

To you it sounds nice but I wouldn’t feel the same, but then the whole high state intervention doting Covid wasn’t for me either

Beezknees · 04/06/2023 13:15

Room102 · 04/06/2023 13:11

It is very weird isn't it? The idea of less work and more leisure time leaves people horrified. My impression is that this strange cultural attitude is primarily driven by people having a serious dose of the green eyed monster and huge resentment at anybody getting anything they don't feel they "deserve" and absolute hatred of anybody who has any more than they do. Even if a change might leave them personally better off, if it benefits anybody else as well their reaction is a flat "NO".

Sad indeed.

I have no issue with less work and more leisure time personally, but I don't want to have enough money just to "survive" and nothing else. If the only jobs available are highly skilled ones, that means all the people who aren't clever enough to do them are just sacked off basically. At the moment people on UC can get more money by working, but if work is only available to those who are highly educated there's even less opportunities for those who aren't.

Swrigh1234 · 04/06/2023 13:12

Room102 · 04/06/2023 13:04

Increase in productivity doesn’t mean less with for people. It means different work. This has been happening since automation began, which is the beginning of time itself. AI is just another chapter in this story.

This is not the same as previous times. Work will be necessary because some roles can't be automated, and because new roles will be created but those will be more skilled and far fewer of them.

That’s the same argument made at the dawn of every Industrial Revolution. Nothing new.

Beezknees · 04/06/2023 13:12

DrHousecuredme · 04/06/2023 13:09

I actually love this vision of the future and I image the technology will be created to do an awful lot of the low paid jobs eventually...see Pepper the Finnish care robot 🤷🏽‍♀️
The problem is on here, if you dare to mention a future that is not 💯 dreadful then Mumsnetters get very cross with you.
Try again with your futuristic vision but introduce a bit of doom-mongering and you'll be away 🥴😝

Doesn't sound like a very good future to me. People already resent those who get UC, do away with all the low paid jobs and that will mean a whole lot more people out of work, workers will resent paying for them even more.

RedRosette2023 · 04/06/2023 13:11

I don’t understand the link between all the things you’ve listed? Why would £1k p/m make people want to Ubers, homeschool and volunteer?

Room102 · 04/06/2023 13:11

DojaPhat · 04/06/2023 12:52

One thing about the UK which I will always find fascinating is its sheer, unwavering dedication to suffering and subjugation. Any hint of a mere idea which could improve society as a whole will always be laughed out of the room.
Working from home?? Forget it! Why should you be able to have a life balance. You should spend 2 hours every morning commuting to your office just because!! UBI?? Forget it! Won't it affect inflation and why should people get money for doing nothing! Young people can't afford to buy houses?? So the fuck what! Maybe if they stopped eating avocados and cancelled their Netflix subscription they'd manage. Pay rises?? Absolutely NOT!! Everyone is struggling so let's all struggle instead of collectively fight for better pay and conditions for all.

It's quite funny but also very sad too. I'm used to this attitude now but it still gets me every time. Because even those who would benefit from some of these ideas are some of the loudest shouting it down. Grin

It is very weird isn't it? The idea of less work and more leisure time leaves people horrified. My impression is that this strange cultural attitude is primarily driven by people having a serious dose of the green eyed monster and huge resentment at anybody getting anything they don't feel they "deserve" and absolute hatred of anybody who has any more than they do. Even if a change might leave them personally better off, if it benefits anybody else as well their reaction is a flat "NO".

Sad indeed.

porkpiesinthepark · 04/06/2023 13:10

The administration of benefits is most of its cost, if im not mistaken. UBI would do away with a lot of that.

OP posts:
DrHousecuredme · 04/06/2023 13:09

I actually love this vision of the future and I image the technology will be created to do an awful lot of the low paid jobs eventually...see Pepper the Finnish care robot 🤷🏽‍♀️
The problem is on here, if you dare to mention a future that is not 💯 dreadful then Mumsnetters get very cross with you.
Try again with your futuristic vision but introduce a bit of doom-mongering and you'll be away 🥴😝

Room102 · 04/06/2023 13:08

DollyTrolly · 04/06/2023 12:48

These would be in social situations. Pubs, restaurants, parks, family events, just as they are now. Who needs work to be able to socialise?! Surely you'd rather spend that time doing things you want to with people you choose to see?

Well I love my job and the social side of it so I wouldn't want that to disappear completely. Plus there are some aspects of my job that just work better in person.

I appreciate that remote/online has it's benefits but moving everything online is not optimal ... remember the OP mentioned remote learning as a benefit. We learned during Covid that it wasn't optimal at all. Young people hated it and they missed out on learning key skills that only develop when you are in a classroom with other people.

I wasn't the one saying everything will be remote: clearly it won't be. My response was to the poster who said that, pointing out that even if someone works remotely and orders all their shopping online etc, they still have interaction with other humans. I have worked remotely for years, since well before Covid and haven't been to a supermarket in over a decade. I like it. My life is not sterile, I see friends and family when and where I want to.

8state · 04/06/2023 13:06

@NeverDropYourMooncup Can't a lot of those things be capped?

Room102 · 04/06/2023 13:04

Increase in productivity doesn’t mean less with for people. It means different work. This has been happening since automation began, which is the beginning of time itself. AI is just another chapter in this story.

This is not the same as previous times. Work will be necessary because some roles can't be automated, and because new roles will be created but those will be more skilled and far fewer of them.

Rasputina · 04/06/2023 13:01

NeverDropYourMooncup · 04/06/2023 13:00

In short, how it would work in practise is;

  1. Everybody gets a guaranteed income of £2000, say, a month.
  2. House prices go up another £150 - £300k ish because people can afford to pay an extra £2000 a month each.
  3. Rent prices go up an extra £6000 a month
  4. Childcare goes up £2001 a month
  5. Cars go up another £8000 - people can afford it, after all
  6. Food prices go up
  7. Fuel prices go up
  8. Utility prices go up

It would be no different to when Tax Credits started and childcare providers whacked the equivalent maximum amount claimable onto their fees, or when LHA came into force - cool, you'll pay up to £1100 a month? Great, I was only charging £680. Oh, I don't want those people, I'll have to charge £1600.

It sounds attractive if you don't look too closely, but it'll be just another inflationary pressure because of all the people and companies clamouring to take advantage of that extra money floating around. But they'll be able to say 'The country is richer now - look at how much everybody's houses are worth'

That’s really not how it would work because the job market is going to be significantly reduced amongst other things.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 04/06/2023 13:00

In short, how it would work in practise is;

  1. Everybody gets a guaranteed income of £2000, say, a month.
  2. House prices go up another £150 - £300k ish because people can afford to pay an extra £2000 a month each.
  3. Rent prices go up an extra £6000 a month
  4. Childcare goes up £2001 a month
  5. Cars go up another £8000 - people can afford it, after all
  6. Food prices go up
  7. Fuel prices go up
  8. Utility prices go up

It would be no different to when Tax Credits started and childcare providers whacked the equivalent maximum amount claimable onto their fees, or when LHA came into force - cool, you'll pay up to £1100 a month? Great, I was only charging £680. Oh, I don't want those people, I'll have to charge £1600.

It sounds attractive if you don't look too closely, but it'll be just another inflationary pressure because of all the people and companies clamouring to take advantage of that extra money floating around. But they'll be able to say 'The country is richer now - look at how much everybody's houses are worth'

SunnyEgg · 04/06/2023 12:57

DojaPhat · 04/06/2023 12:52

One thing about the UK which I will always find fascinating is its sheer, unwavering dedication to suffering and subjugation. Any hint of a mere idea which could improve society as a whole will always be laughed out of the room.
Working from home?? Forget it! Why should you be able to have a life balance. You should spend 2 hours every morning commuting to your office just because!! UBI?? Forget it! Won't it affect inflation and why should people get money for doing nothing! Young people can't afford to buy houses?? So the fuck what! Maybe if they stopped eating avocados and cancelled their Netflix subscription they'd manage. Pay rises?? Absolutely NOT!! Everyone is struggling so let's all struggle instead of collectively fight for better pay and conditions for all.

It's quite funny but also very sad too. I'm used to this attitude now but it still gets me every time. Because even those who would benefit from some of these ideas are some of the loudest shouting it down. Grin

Not everyone likes fully wfh but yes it’s good if it’s more flexible

I’m more amazed at the never ending ask for others to subsidise

Florenz · 04/06/2023 12:57

Nobody would benefit from UBI. You can't just say "well things would be just like they are today, but people would have more money". Because that wouldn't be the case at all.

8state · 04/06/2023 12:55

@DojaPhat I know. I'm very fond of my country, but we do make putting up with crap an art form!

DojaPhat · 04/06/2023 12:52

One thing about the UK which I will always find fascinating is its sheer, unwavering dedication to suffering and subjugation. Any hint of a mere idea which could improve society as a whole will always be laughed out of the room.
Working from home?? Forget it! Why should you be able to have a life balance. You should spend 2 hours every morning commuting to your office just because!! UBI?? Forget it! Won't it affect inflation and why should people get money for doing nothing! Young people can't afford to buy houses?? So the fuck what! Maybe if they stopped eating avocados and cancelled their Netflix subscription they'd manage. Pay rises?? Absolutely NOT!! Everyone is struggling so let's all struggle instead of collectively fight for better pay and conditions for all.

It's quite funny but also very sad too. I'm used to this attitude now but it still gets me every time. Because even those who would benefit from some of these ideas are some of the loudest shouting it down. Grin

8state · 04/06/2023 12:51

I wasn't sure, but now I'm leaning to it being a good idea. It won't be enough to live on, for many, but it would make an enormous to those in minimum wage jobs. A one bedroom flat in my area is around £800 pcm, so it wouldn't mean someone wouldn't need to work. It would give them more disposable income, however.

DollyTrolly · 04/06/2023 12:48

These would be in social situations. Pubs, restaurants, parks, family events, just as they are now. Who needs work to be able to socialise?! Surely you'd rather spend that time doing things you want to with people you choose to see?

Well I love my job and the social side of it so I wouldn't want that to disappear completely. Plus there are some aspects of my job that just work better in person.

I appreciate that remote/online has it's benefits but moving everything online is not optimal ... remember the OP mentioned remote learning as a benefit. We learned during Covid that it wasn't optimal at all. Young people hated it and they missed out on learning key skills that only develop when you are in a classroom with other people.

Swrigh1234 · 04/06/2023 12:46

Florenz · 04/06/2023 12:45

UBI would be the downfall of society as we know it. You can't have a society where a tiny number of people work to support the masses who don't work. Sooner or later the people paying for it all would revolt and refuse to pay and you'd be left with tens of millions of people who have no way to exist. It would be genocide.

It’s been tried so many times before and it always fails. Venezuela is the most recent example.

Beezknees · 04/06/2023 12:46

Room102 · 04/06/2023 12:42

These would be in social situations. Pubs, restaurants, parks, family events, just as they are now. Who needs work to be able to socialise?! Surely you'd rather spend that time doing things you want to with people you choose to see?

Depends how you work. I dislike working from home, I only do it 2 days a week so I can be a bit more present for my teenager. I like my work colleagues and I actually like going to the office, I feel I'm more productive there. If I had to work from home permanently 5 days a week I'd look for something else!

Swrigh1234 · 04/06/2023 12:46

It feels like people have swallowed the hysteria about AI hook, line and sinker. It has been the same throughout history. Tech advancement creates this frenzy that all jobs will disappear, when really they just get replaced by different ones. Of course part of the AI hysteria narrative is ‘nudge politics’ to get people to accept things they wouldn’t otherwise accept. Some may call it manipulation. If people didn’t learn about how nudge policy works during Covid, they never will.

Florenz · 04/06/2023 12:45

UBI would be the downfall of society as we know it. You can't have a society where a tiny number of people work to support the masses who don't work. Sooner or later the people paying for it all would revolt and refuse to pay and you'd be left with tens of millions of people who have no way to exist. It would be genocide.

DoYiu · 04/06/2023 12:45

I don't think anyone on benefits get upnto £1000 a month on basic or standard benefits. Those who get up to or more than that have other add ons like children, carers, disability benefits, etc.

UBI should be the equivalent of basic/standard benefit per person. The add ons should still be separate because they're based on different personal circumstances and not everyone gets the same.

Swipe left for the next trending thread