Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Universal basic income and what it may look like

534 replies

porkpiesinthepark · 04/06/2023 09:54

I've been thinking for a while about the criticism of UBI and I think it's due to people not being able to imagine the government trying to 'match' peoples wages. In my opinion, it never will but there will be alternatives to what we have now, which will be able to offer something better.

So say the UBI is £1000 a month for a single person.
We could change the housing market to allow much more public housing with rents set at an affordable level, much more stability, no private landlords and the option to customise/ change your home. Let's face it, home ownership is out of reach for the majority at present. I don't find people are dying to own their own homes but desperate to be out of the instability of the private rental market, out of parents houses, out of house shares etc. If you could offer the next best thing to owning your own house, I think people would go for it.
There would be much more community linked to people having extra time due to not working or not working as many hours. Now, not having enough to do in the day is bad but most people have these huge dreams for retirement and this would just allow them to do some of these things now instead. Also more volunteering, looking after elderly relatives etc.
I don't think that private car ownership would be a thing. There would be a big system like Uber who you could call rides on. There would be a cheaper option, say if ten people wanted to go to the city centre at the same time, they would have to walk to a hub and then the van would pick everyone up, like public transport but based on demand. It would be a status symbol to be able to call a car out just for you.
I think a lot more people would wfh getting the cost of transport and childcare down. Schools might even go remote, as there wouldn't be both parents working and so in theory they could help facilitate the lessons. Then teachers would have small classes of Sen kids like mine, key workers and vulnerable children. Kids would interact with others through volunteering groups with parents, or just playing out as there would be less cars and more parents around to keep an eye on them.
People will either hate this vision as it's so different to what we have now. Or they will like some parts. But what we have now can't continue.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
SunnyEgg · 04/06/2023 13:54

Room102 · 04/06/2023 13:49

All socially ingrained ideas. What you think is the norm or comfortable to you is entirely the case because that's the social system more or less you were raised with plus values you've developed from your family/ mix of friends and experiences. If you'd been raised in Finland or Saudi or Japan or the Congo you'd have a different set of values and references and comfort zone. Or the 18th or 12th century. There's nothing inherent about your particular cultural references that makes them the most beneficial structure for a society, particularly one that is about to be transformed where - if it is managed correctly - resources become much less scarce and therefore there is not such a need to try to make everybody so competitive with each other. Provided there are systems in place to make sure they are not hoarded by a very small number of people...

Not really. It’s clear some people raised in the U.K. feel differently to me and would love UBI etc

And I wasn’t raised here anyway but I have benefited from a range of systems. Some feel more right for me than others. The US wouldn’t be my choice but neither would say, East Germany during Berlin wall times

If it were just a socially engrained preference we’d all feel the same and we don’t.

I loathed the Covid reaction, others welcomed it.

Room102 · 04/06/2023 13:54

It will take a reimagining of what resources are, that they are the property of everyone to be used for everyone's benefit. To get rid of the mentality that our social systems have been designed to indoctrinate and instill into people from pre-schooler age, that work is virtuous and without it nothing is deserved. The competition mentality. If resource is no scarce that is no longer necessary. Sadly I think much of the human race is not capable of such a shift in mindset so it may end up with complete destruction, but that does not have to be the case.

Room102 · 04/06/2023 13:49

SunnyEgg · 04/06/2023 13:42

Any large scale society requires state "intervention" to organise, administer and enforce its systems.

Of course. I have no misunderstanding on it, it takes some intervention.

But I know that reactions to Covid approach were varied and how I feel about increase state intervention. Some might like heavy involvement but a lighter amount (not zero) is more my comfort zone.

All socially ingrained ideas. What you think is the norm or comfortable to you is entirely the case because that's the social system more or less you were raised with plus values you've developed from your family/ mix of friends and experiences. If you'd been raised in Finland or Saudi or Japan or the Congo you'd have a different set of values and references and comfort zone. Or the 18th or 12th century. There's nothing inherent about your particular cultural references that makes them the most beneficial structure for a society, particularly one that is about to be transformed where - if it is managed correctly - resources become much less scarce and therefore there is not such a need to try to make everybody so competitive with each other. Provided there are systems in place to make sure they are not hoarded by a very small number of people...

NeverDropYourMooncup · 04/06/2023 13:48

8state · 04/06/2023 13:27

@NeverDropYourMooncup I think renationalising utilities, rent caps and staple food price caps would be quite reasonable, and not a dictatorship. House and car prices probably can't be controlled, and childcare I'm not sure about. I see the issues with some of those items, but not all.

And when EDF switches off the supply because they're not getting enough money? Or it's impossible to buy gas/oil or source the materials to build home based energy generation? How would you police food prices when the majority comes from overseas? Could you force the supermarkets to pay a fair price to their UK suppliers? What if there's a drought or crop failure? How much could it be worth to a major multinational food manufacturer to 'encourage' their items to be exempted from the basics? And for the supermarkets to run out of the capped versions, creating an even higher demand for the non capped (and fuelling a black market in ripped off food because you can't get hold of cheap pasta or bread, but you can get stuff through that). What happens when the US, for example, decides that the price of maize, wheat or vegetable oil products is too low and refuses to supply any until this is rectified (taking into account that supplies from Ukraine/Russia/etc are already destroyed through Vlad's expansionary batshittery)?

Do you punish somebody charging over x amount for rent through tax that will be evaded, do you seize their property, their bank account? Try to locate their offshore funding? Do they charge x amount on paper, but in reality, you only get to stay there if y amount is handed under the table?

We aren't talking hundreds or thousands of pounds here, we're talking billions, of pissing off foreign governments, international politics, security.

The restrictions that would have to be in force in order to make UBI not cause hyperinflation are such that it would have international consequences.

I'd like it to work. The concept that it's cheaper to pay everybody rather than piss around trying to avoid paying benefits isn't new. Everybody having enough has been the dream for humans forever. But the appeal of the idea belies the absolutely fucking disaster it would be due to people's inherent desires, particularly those of the people at the top of the food chain.

Room102 · 04/06/2023 13:43

Do people not get outraged when high income levels get benefits?

I recall energy supplement and people complaining it wasn’t targeted, then some pensioner benefit (warm home?) gets same

That's the mindset that needs to change. Firstly because the fastest way to undermine public support for any benefit is to means test it. Then the thresholds for it will just be gradually lowered with fiscal drag etc until it is effectively phased out. Secondly, it costs more generally to means test it. Child benefit withdrawal is a perfect example: that money now goes on additional HMRC staff to administer the scheme rather than to families, and costs the taxpayer more than when everyone received it. Good outcome?

SunnyEgg · 04/06/2023 13:42

Any large scale society requires state "intervention" to organise, administer and enforce its systems.

Of course. I have no misunderstanding on it, it takes some intervention.

But I know that reactions to Covid approach were varied and how I feel about increase state intervention. Some might like heavy involvement but a lighter amount (not zero) is more my comfort zone.

Room102 · 04/06/2023 13:40

8state · 04/06/2023 13:23

@Room102 It is very intriguing, I shall try to read more. I can see that if AI is given decision making abilities it may use a very different logic to human systems.

That's the problem. It will solve what problems it is given. Humans can tend to assume some "common sense" or "human values" in that decision making. There will not be: it does literally what it is asked to do. So retaining human control over it is vital and really nobody has figure out how to do that yet, that is the fear that prompted senior people to raise public concerns recently.

For example: one of the newest systems was recently asked how to resolve the acidity issues in the oceans. Its solution would have lowered the oxygen level in the atmosphere to a level where all humans and other animals slowly suffocated...

You have to be very specific about what you ask it to do and the parameters and boundaries!!

wineschmine · 04/06/2023 13:38

DollyTrolly · 04/06/2023 10:35

It all sounds so sterile and boring.

Remote working, remote learning, shopping delivered .......

If people want to live like that then fine but for lots of people it's their idea of hell.

Yes, sterile and boring. My thoughts exactly.

Advances in tech are great if used properly.

Ppl need to not lose sight of the bigger picture. Things are moving very fast, but in a lot of ways I feel like maybe we should be moving backwards (but with the better tech).

For exaample - take some of the good aspects of lockdown - slower pace of life, less unnecessary travel and commuting, home baking, more acceptable of flexible / home working.

Combine it with the greater freedoms that AI can bring and hopefully have a slower pace of life with a focus on sustainability and climate action and possibly even a declining population which has been discussed a lot lately and which to be honest I think is no bad thing.

The Jetsonesque / Terminator futuristic view of AI does not appeal to me at all. I feel very much that a lot of the older ways of living were better and if AI can be used to make improvements whilst still affording people a lot of freedoms to live their lives, earn their money, travel etc without this sterile, futuristic communism type stuff, I think it would be great.

I want my kids to be able to travel and to go to school and play out in parks and in nature with their friends. I don't want them
to be schooled remotely and then sit at home getting paid UBI for doing nothing because robots are doing all the jobs.

8state · 04/06/2023 13:37

@kitsuneghost Yes, it sounds a lot. 1000 might be feasible, and if it's cheaper than administrating the current benefits system, makes sense.

Room102 · 04/06/2023 13:37

Some people value state intervention or control more and others value freedom

It’s similar to lockdown, many on here probably preferred it, or would prefer set up where they are subsidised more

We’re not all the same, one persons comfort is another’s lack of freedom

It feels like similar themes to Industrial Revolution and East Germany wrt people trying to leave

To you it sounds nice but I wouldn’t feel the same, but then the whole high state intervention doting Covid wasn’t for me either

I'm not generally a huge fan of state intervention as it happens, however it's a misunderstanding of capitalism to think it involves little. Any large scale society requires state "intervention" to organise, administer and enforce its systems. People who claim they don't like it usually mean they like certain types of it and not others.

So you may well very much like for example having a legal system founded in property rights and enforced. Social structures that provide infrastructure like roads and train tracks and fresh water to your taps and electricity and gas to your house. All of this is state intervention. Building sewage plants and reservoirs. Providing educational establishments so that people can learn the skills requires to build and manufacture and invent the products you use, procure the materials to build them. That part requires foreign trade, so state intervention is required to set up structures to trade with other states and physically import these things. Etc.

All of these things will to some extent impinge on your freedom, because any type of collaboration at a country level or international level requires agreement and all people making compromises. This was the fundamental stupidity of Brexit: if you rely on food and energy and materials imports from other countries then of course there is no such thing as pure "Sovereignty" if you mean agreeing no common rules with other human beings for mutual benefit, because then you will have nothing.

I find proponents of "state intervention is bad" on principle seem to forget that unless the built their house themselves, live off grid, grow their own food, have their own well and protect it all with an axe they made themselves out of flint, then they are actually only living the life they have as a direct result of state intervention: i.e. humans developing systems to cooperate together for the benefit of all of them by pooling resources.

For that to be functional there also needs to be some level of healthcare, education, and support for disabled people, etc.

The question as always is balance. It does not need to involve social control. And the greatest failing of humanity that will likely be its downfall is the inability to look at the wider picture and greater good because of intense selfishness and not overcoming the tribal need to "other" people, to get caught up in ideologies rather than pragmatism.

kitsuneghost · 04/06/2023 13:36

8state · 04/06/2023 12:40

@kitsuneghost It sounds quite good. I work, but an extra 1600 a month would mean we could have a holiday or dental work done, those extra luxuries that are beyond us at the moment.

Just can't believe they would give everyone £1600 if it is ever to be rolled out. Even Finland with it's high cost of living was 560 euro

SunnyEgg · 04/06/2023 13:35

kitsuneghost · 04/06/2023 13:33

Perhaps some do but in general no. Why would you be outraged at someone else getting the same amount as you?

I didn’t say I was I said there are many posts where people complained that the energy supplement was to everyone on here.

It didn’t bother me personally although I’m not for UBI

porkpiesinthepark · 04/06/2023 13:34

@DojaPhat amen!

OP posts:
porkpiesinthepark · 04/06/2023 13:33

@Changechangechanging don't give these people a moment of your time.
The uncomfortable truth for many people is that the only reason they are not on benefits is because they are in a relationship. It's not their great earning potential. It's not their financial prowess.
They happen to have a child who can attend mainstream school and wrap around care. They managed to marry/ live with someone who can support them financially.
And they have the cheek to look down on us? I said that to someone the other day, the only reason I am on UC benefits and you aren't is that you are putting up with a bad relationship and terrible sex for pay and I'm not. Because we earn the same amount... so if they got divorced then they would be eligible for UC too.

OP posts:
DojaPhat · 04/06/2023 13:33

Florenz · 04/06/2023 12:57

Nobody would benefit from UBI. You can't just say "well things would be just like they are today, but people would have more money". Because that wouldn't be the case at all.

The thing I find intriguing about views like this and my personal favourite upthread: "UBI would be the downfall of society" is that I would fully expect someone say in the position of Rishi Sunak, or Elon Musk or Alan Sugar to happily espouse these views and genuinely believe these views to be the truth. Most people, indeed many working people are only one or two pay cheques away from complete destitution yet so many of us hold these views as testament. I wonder if future generations will begin to think more critically about the way society works. I'd like to think each generation starts off thinking it will upend traditional structures and many previous generations have succeeded in this in various forms - but when it comes to this particular issue of wealth, money and capital - it seems so ingrained, weaved into the fabric of society to the extent that people castigate those who they deem have ideas above their station. In other words you should remain in the class you were born, any attempt to go beyond those confines is dismissed as social climbing.

kitsuneghost · 04/06/2023 13:33

SunnyEgg · 04/06/2023 12:38

Do people not get outraged when high income levels get benefits?

I recall energy supplement and people complaining it wasn’t targeted, then some pensioner benefit (warm home?) gets same

The main issue is many people don’t want to further subsidise and others will absolutely take it easier and just lower work

Perhaps some do but in general no. Why would you be outraged at someone else getting the same amount as you?

wineschmine · 04/06/2023 13:30

Swrigh1234 · 04/06/2023 10:32

That wall of text from the OP summarized in one word. Communism. No one owns anything, everyone gets a few scraps to live on.

Sometimes, AIBU is like stumbling into the sixth form common room. Now, back to the real world….

Yes, I'm glad someone said it!

I, for one, am not a fan of communism, so I not keen, OP, sorry.

wineschmine · 04/06/2023 13:28

porkpiesinthepark · 04/06/2023 10:27

@DollyTrolly I do too, and I work in a pretty AI proof industry. But lots of people just work to pay bills and would give it up tomorrow if they could.

I wouldn't say I particularly enjoy my job. It's ok, and it's fairly well paid, but I fell into it. It wasn't my childhood ambition or anything. Some mornings I wish I could just call in sick and go back to sleep.

BUT. I injured myself quite badly earlier this year and was off work for over two months (walking was difficult and I was on strong painkillers so a bit whoozy and couldn't work from home).

I have young kids but after getting them up and off to school (with a neighbours help) very quickly I was incredibly bored, lazy, demotivated and fed up.

I was delighted to finally go back to work. I find I couldn't enjoy my downtime with no balance.

I think humans need a purpose and to do meaningful work. I think the routine and the structure and the balance is good.

Sure, something like a 4 day working week as opposed to 5 would be fabulous. But the idea of a universal basic income for doing nothing? Nah, I don't buy it. It wouldn't work.

8state · 04/06/2023 13:27

@NeverDropYourMooncup I think renationalising utilities, rent caps and staple food price caps would be quite reasonable, and not a dictatorship. House and car prices probably can't be controlled, and childcare I'm not sure about. I see the issues with some of those items, but not all.

Changechangechanging · 04/06/2023 13:26

All benefits are money for nothing. They just called them tax credits to make people feel better about themselves

Sure. I agree. I get money for nothing. Except I’m a single parent with a disabled child who works full time as a teacher in a shortage subject area. And I’m entitled to a small amount of tax credits. If I hadn’t received tax credits when my children were younger, I couldn’t have afforded childcare. So one less teacher.

I don’t feel bad about myself for claiming benefits. Why should I? I am doing the best that I can. Maybe my ex and the Government should have a bit of a think, given his self employed status exempts him from supporting his children and the Government agency set up to help with this has done precisely fuck all. In 15 years.

SunnyEgg · 04/06/2023 13:24

There’s another thread going on declining population issues so maybe we just let it decline, and use AI

Just need to work out older people to younger ratio issue somehow

8state · 04/06/2023 13:23

@Room102 It is very intriguing, I shall try to read more. I can see that if AI is given decision making abilities it may use a very different logic to human systems.

Beezknees · 04/06/2023 13:23

Room102 · 04/06/2023 13:20

Well the difference here is the sheer volume of human-performed roles that will no longer be necessary for a human to be involved in at all. Across pretty much all industries, with a vanishingly few small exceptions.

Even software engineers aren't safe. 😆 AI can already write code, much faster than humans. De-bug it. Then refine it. So it basically is now capable of "evolving" itself: rewriting itself to make it better, which will make it more intelligent, and then that version can rewrite it again and so on.

I don't think many people appreciate the scale of the changes that are coming, or the pace at which this will take place. It will be a rough ride I think as not only the public but our leaders are so woefully underprepared. They haven't even understood it let alone thought through, scenario-tested and prepared plans.

One thing that does finally seem to be dawning on them are the risks, which are huge. If AI is harnessed to improve human lives then the benefits may be immense. However, it will quickly become far more intelligent than humans and therefore if it is not controlled then we may make ourselves obsolete. Why would it even "care" about human wellbeing? Not that it would "care" about anything as such, but anthropomorphising to express the point.

There are so many good books about it all. People really should read up, and look at the latest research (what little of it is made public, which tbh is just the tip of the iceberg, hence so many involved taking the drastic step of warning Governments...)

... so how will any of that benefit anyone?

NeverDropYourMooncup · 04/06/2023 13:22

8state · 04/06/2023 13:06

@NeverDropYourMooncup Can't a lot of those things be capped?

So, you'd renationalise the utilities, make house prices something set by central government, take over all childcare provision, dictate car prices, house prices, rents, food? Much as it would be nice to think that things would stay the same price because otherwise, what's the point of an UBI?, outside a dictatorship (and even then, there will still be those who have far, far more), they cannot be capped or controlled. Moreover, all those overseas interests - property, utilities, consumer items, manufacturing - would be pretty pissed off it a government started trying to keep prices down.

All dropping a wodge of money into people's laps would do is reset £zero to £zero+UBI.

It would be lovely if everything stayed the same and people did have more money/a better standard of living, but the cold reality of the world is that they wouldn't. They'd just be poor with a currency requiring calculations with more zeroes - like having to work with lira rather than sterling; things weren't a hundred times dearer when the £3.50 item's cost was 3,500l, it was the same cost with some more zeroes.

Room102 · 04/06/2023 13:20

Well the difference here is the sheer volume of human-performed roles that will no longer be necessary for a human to be involved in at all. Across pretty much all industries, with a vanishingly few small exceptions.

Even software engineers aren't safe. 😆 AI can already write code, much faster than humans. De-bug it. Then refine it. So it basically is now capable of "evolving" itself: rewriting itself to make it better, which will make it more intelligent, and then that version can rewrite it again and so on.

I don't think many people appreciate the scale of the changes that are coming, or the pace at which this will take place. It will be a rough ride I think as not only the public but our leaders are so woefully underprepared. They haven't even understood it let alone thought through, scenario-tested and prepared plans.

One thing that does finally seem to be dawning on them are the risks, which are huge. If AI is harnessed to improve human lives then the benefits may be immense. However, it will quickly become far more intelligent than humans and therefore if it is not controlled then we may make ourselves obsolete. Why would it even "care" about human wellbeing? Not that it would "care" about anything as such, but anthropomorphising to express the point.

There are so many good books about it all. People really should read up, and look at the latest research (what little of it is made public, which tbh is just the tip of the iceberg, hence so many involved taking the drastic step of warning Governments...)