Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Universal basic income and what it may look like

534 replies

porkpiesinthepark · 04/06/2023 09:54

I've been thinking for a while about the criticism of UBI and I think it's due to people not being able to imagine the government trying to 'match' peoples wages. In my opinion, it never will but there will be alternatives to what we have now, which will be able to offer something better.

So say the UBI is £1000 a month for a single person.
We could change the housing market to allow much more public housing with rents set at an affordable level, much more stability, no private landlords and the option to customise/ change your home. Let's face it, home ownership is out of reach for the majority at present. I don't find people are dying to own their own homes but desperate to be out of the instability of the private rental market, out of parents houses, out of house shares etc. If you could offer the next best thing to owning your own house, I think people would go for it.
There would be much more community linked to people having extra time due to not working or not working as many hours. Now, not having enough to do in the day is bad but most people have these huge dreams for retirement and this would just allow them to do some of these things now instead. Also more volunteering, looking after elderly relatives etc.
I don't think that private car ownership would be a thing. There would be a big system like Uber who you could call rides on. There would be a cheaper option, say if ten people wanted to go to the city centre at the same time, they would have to walk to a hub and then the van would pick everyone up, like public transport but based on demand. It would be a status symbol to be able to call a car out just for you.
I think a lot more people would wfh getting the cost of transport and childcare down. Schools might even go remote, as there wouldn't be both parents working and so in theory they could help facilitate the lessons. Then teachers would have small classes of Sen kids like mine, key workers and vulnerable children. Kids would interact with others through volunteering groups with parents, or just playing out as there would be less cars and more parents around to keep an eye on them.
People will either hate this vision as it's so different to what we have now. Or they will like some parts. But what we have now can't continue.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
Throwncrumbs · 04/06/2023 15:19

Where’s this money coming from? Jesus, just another excuse for people NOT to work and bleat about how hard done by they are!

porkpiesinthepark · 04/06/2023 15:18

@dottiedodah well someone would still be making a profit, unless robot CEO's came to be. Therefore those profits (corporation tax) would have to pay for UBI

OP posts:
dottiedodah · 04/06/2023 15:16

I seem to be missing something here.Surely if low wage manual workers were replaced by AI ,then the companies employing them would not be paying the Robots as such ,so where would all this money to pay UBI come from? They would have plump profits and no workers to be taxed! Unless there is a grand scheme to tax the company owners! I dont feel worried about this as I dont see how it could work

titbumwillypoo · 04/06/2023 15:14

Room102 · Today 14:46

Government does not pay more for public sector staff in London. That's why in cheap areas they are very well off and in London and SE they are struggling.

London weighting is an allowance paid to certain civil servants, teachers, airline employees, PhD students, police and security officers in and around London, the capital of England. It is designed to help these workers with the cost of living in Greater London, which is higher than that of the rest of the UK.[1] Its purpose is to encourage key workers to stay in Greater London.

https://publicsectorpay.org.uk/nhs-london-weighting-pay-bands/#:~:text=The%20Inner%20London%20weighting%20for,a%20maximum%20of%20%C2%A37%2C746.

Yes they do.

porkpiesinthepark · 04/06/2023 15:13

@Room102 I agree, mass migration from climate change and AI will lead to a scarcity of jobs which most of us cannot imagine.

OP posts:
porkpiesinthepark · 04/06/2023 15:11

@DdraigGoch unfortunately you aren't in control. My friend worked for a big named bank who were all told 'the public won't be able to bank how they want to bank, they will bank how we want them to bank' and lo and behold it happened. Most high street branch's shut. There is no option to not use some form of computerised banking.
For retail, online shopping is easier for the retailer in most cases. If they can automate most things then they will for the convenience of the retailer, not the shopper.

OP posts:
Room102 · 04/06/2023 15:08

I don't understand how a conversation about UBI has become one about AI.

Because that is the only thing that will make it affordable.

Room102 · 04/06/2023 15:07

*Ok that’s interesting i

Can you describe what you think this is like?

You may have said already but I admit I’m not feeling this way, can you sum up what you’re most terrified about

Yes. Fresh water will become a very scarce resource in their lifetime. In the UK we are well-placed geographically to deal with this but haven't even built one new reservoir in decades.

We rely on food and energy imports. Our Government has no serious plans for energy or food security.

Climate change will result in mass migrations of populations on a scale never seen before by humanity: many of the largest cities in the world are coastal so will flood.

Many other areas will become too hot to be inhabitable for much of the year, many areas that grow much of the world's food will have reduced crop yields or be flooded.

At the same time due to hugely falling birthrates outside subsaharan Africa there is a massive population collapse underway. In their usual way Governments seem oblivious. There is a tipping point with it where it becomes hard to reverse and that isn't actually too far off now.

Technology will be our key to dealing with these issues - if we can - it is our only real hope to do so. Hence my previous comments on the AI part of the equation. Vast productivity gains mean more resources which means if social structures are changed to distribute these effectively then this can solve many problems BUT will these things be implemented? I highly doubt it. So dystopia beckons.

My fear is that my children are just starting an antiquated education system designed to prepare them with a mindset and "skills" for a world which will no longer exist, and that they will be growing up into a world of chaotic change from the impact of these multiple influences hitting at the same time. A level of change that humanity has never experienced in such a short period of time before (2-3 decades).

As children do, they are absorbing the life I provide for them now as the norm and expect as adults that their lives will be similar. They won't, that much is certain. But I'm unable to tell them what it WILL be like because nobody can, so they will live through huge turmoil. It could be much better than we have now, or much worse.

Medical advances will mean that - if those are available to people - they could live extremely long lives. But what will those lives be like?

Will the UK become even more isolationist? Its sea borders may benefit it once again. But without a plan for food or energy or water security this still will be useless. Will we engage with the world and try to solve these global problems globally, and create new systems? Without forward planning and serious people in Government who are aware of the risks and issues and how fast all of this will happen, it will likely be a time of great unrest and misery. Transitions always involve pain but this particular set of circumstances means not just minor adjustments - which for example the last industrial revolution was in comparison - but a total reimagining of social systems and the purpose of society, how we classify resources, even what we think of as "money" and how this represents "value" and is distributed.

Depending how it is handled it is hard to know what young children today will need. Very advanced IT skills? Or basic survival skills?

It could all be the dawning of a new age for humanity that is far better. Or not.

SybilWrites · 04/06/2023 15:02

I don't understand how a conversation about UBI has become one about AI.

AI will happen with or without UBI. It's already happening.

Re UBI - I think it sounds appealing. The basic issues in this country are that benefits and incomes aren't enough to have even a reasonable standard of living. UBI is one answer to that. So is raising benefits so that they reflect the actual cost of living today. So is increasing the minimum wage to £15 an hour.

Benefits are supposed to be a safety net for those who are struggling. They've become something needed by working people to supplement low incomes. The answer is to increase benefits and to increase incomes. (see PEF on increasing min wage and see JRF on increasing benefits.

Re housing, that's a separate issue and yes of course the Govt should be reforming the rental sector completely - owning your own property will become out of reach for most people, but as a result the Govt needs urgently to ensure that people living in rental properties can stay there long term.

The Case for a £15/hour Minimum Wage • The Progressive Economy Forum

New report makes the case for a £15/hour minimum wage by 2024 to compensate employees for a “lost decade” of wages 14 million people would see an increase in pay under proposals to increase the minimum wage to £15/hour, according to new research by Jam...

https://progressiveeconomyforum.com/publications/the-case-for-a-15-hour-minimum-wage/

Room102 · 04/06/2023 14:46

titbumwillypoo · 04/06/2023 14:34

So all those against UBI would you be ok if the Government did the following. Firstly, move ALL Government departments out of London. Most people could work remotely and they could have hubs in various main cities throughout the UK. Secondly have a flat rate of housing benefit that's the same for everywhere in the country. Thirdly get rid of London weighting for pay, there's no good reason a teacher or nurse should get paid more because of where they live. Fourth, stop subsidising transport. Make roads pay per mile (by vehicle weight) and let the market sort out buses, trams, trains and the tube. As some people think the market should be allowed to flourish the above government interference should be removed to allow it to do so.

Government does not pay more for public sector staff in London. That's why in cheap areas they are very well off and in London and SE they are struggling.

LlynTegid · 04/06/2023 14:46

UBI is not going to happen. Would make an interesting drama though.

I agree with those with concerns about AI and how it is used, which to me is a separate topic.

DdraigGoch · 04/06/2023 14:44

porkpiesinthepark · 04/06/2023 10:23

@Theunamedcat you would have to get your shopping delivered, there would be no option to go into an actual grocery shop.

Sod that. How dystopian.

titbumwillypoo · 04/06/2023 14:34

So all those against UBI would you be ok if the Government did the following. Firstly, move ALL Government departments out of London. Most people could work remotely and they could have hubs in various main cities throughout the UK. Secondly have a flat rate of housing benefit that's the same for everywhere in the country. Thirdly get rid of London weighting for pay, there's no good reason a teacher or nurse should get paid more because of where they live. Fourth, stop subsidising transport. Make roads pay per mile (by vehicle weight) and let the market sort out buses, trams, trains and the tube. As some people think the market should be allowed to flourish the above government interference should be removed to allow it to do so.

Anyotherdude · 04/06/2023 14:31

I’m pretty sure that if UBI were introduced, the privately-owned Utility Companies would just up their charges to swallow it up…

Beezknees · 04/06/2023 14:27

OutIander · 04/06/2023 14:21

Then you could work. Those who would be quite happy not working would balance that out. Or we encourage a two-day working week, and get a better work life balance. Those who love to work are welcome to work more. Those who want to spend more time with their young children are able to do that. Or with their along parents. Or their teens who need more parental interaction or help or whatever.
Or just to do art, or whatever they like.

And if you need to work because UBI isn't enough to live on but there aren't enough jobs available?

OutIander · 04/06/2023 14:21

wineschmine · 04/06/2023 13:28

I wouldn't say I particularly enjoy my job. It's ok, and it's fairly well paid, but I fell into it. It wasn't my childhood ambition or anything. Some mornings I wish I could just call in sick and go back to sleep.

BUT. I injured myself quite badly earlier this year and was off work for over two months (walking was difficult and I was on strong painkillers so a bit whoozy and couldn't work from home).

I have young kids but after getting them up and off to school (with a neighbours help) very quickly I was incredibly bored, lazy, demotivated and fed up.

I was delighted to finally go back to work. I find I couldn't enjoy my downtime with no balance.

I think humans need a purpose and to do meaningful work. I think the routine and the structure and the balance is good.

Sure, something like a 4 day working week as opposed to 5 would be fabulous. But the idea of a universal basic income for doing nothing? Nah, I don't buy it. It wouldn't work.

Then you could work. Those who would be quite happy not working would balance that out. Or we encourage a two-day working week, and get a better work life balance. Those who love to work are welcome to work more. Those who want to spend more time with their young children are able to do that. Or with their along parents. Or their teens who need more parental interaction or help or whatever.
Or just to do art, or whatever they like.

schnauzerbeard · 04/06/2023 14:18

porkpiesinthepark · 04/06/2023 13:10

The administration of benefits is most of its cost, if im not mistaken. UBI would do away with a lot of that.

I used to have this mindset when I was in my 20s. I would debate with my mother and make this very same point as you have in the above quote. Now, in my mid thirties, I cannot believe I ever aligned with any socialism/communism leaning.
I now have the same opinions that I was so passionately arguing against 15 years ago Blush.

SunnyEgg · 04/06/2023 14:15

Room102 · 04/06/2023 14:13

Yep. It applies to all of us. I am terrified about it. Especially given that I have young children and no idea how to prepare them for what is coming.

Ok that’s interesting

Can you describe what you think this is like?

You may have said already but I admit I’m not feeling this way, can you sum up what you’re most terrified about

OutIander · 04/06/2023 14:14

It could easily work if we change people's mindsets, but the powers that be have done a number on us, making the majority not capable of understanding or even be willing to really consider it.

I urge people to read The Ragged-Trousered Philanthropists to start with.

roinndosgrion · 04/06/2023 14:13

AI is bad for humanity and most people sleepwalking into it. We should be resisting it before it is too late.

Yes okay you (not you, but many people) have your nice middle or highish salary wfh job, bought house, not in poverty etc.. but what about all the people who have health problems which limit them working? what about all the people who aren't academic enough to find work after AI takes over the jobs they can do now? It's degrading, someone who works in a low-paid job now can at least have their autonomy.

People with limited choices are already screwed over by the benefits system. Those of you who are saying that £1000 a month UBI couldn't possibly be enough to live on... UC for a single person 'to live on' is not even £800 a month and rent has to be paid out of that too.

AI is just making the working class have much less power. Note the strikes - train workers etc had the power to go on strike and it affected the country. AI and robots don't go on strike.

AI is going to leave the super-rich wondering what they can do with a very large pool of now 'dependent' people who cannot make money for them, and somehow I don't think they are going to be too charitable.. I doubt UBI will be the solution.

Room102 · 04/06/2023 14:13

Yep. It applies to all of us. I am terrified about it. Especially given that I have young children and no idea how to prepare them for what is coming.

SunnyEgg · 04/06/2023 14:11

No. Because there is your personality, your experiences, your influences from family, friends and work. Culture even around the UK and what is considered "the norm" varies hugely.

This applies to you too does it not? Of course we’re all influenced to a certain extent

It’s not really selling in UBI though

Room102 · 04/06/2023 14:06

If it were just a socially engrained preference we’d all feel the same and we don’t.

No. Because there is your personality, your experiences, your influences from family, friends and work. Culture even around the UK and what is considered "the norm" varies hugely.

But someone from the UK will have more in common generally with someone else from the UK on cultural issues than someone from Japan, or Nigeria, or Pakistan, on average. Because the social and cultural environment is the biggest influence on what you think is the "norm" or acceptable. Many ideas are ingrained in early childhood hence change in human culture being slow, large scale events that cause a shift aside.

You'd also have way more in common with someone from modern Japan than with a British person from 12th Century. But that is many generations of gradual change.

The problem people will have here will be the huge scale of change happening very fast indeed, and whether mindsets and "values" and beliefs and social structures can adapt fast enough. That is the part where it will all fall down IMO.

We may well be coming upon the "great filter" which solves the Fermi paradox. It is part of the human condition sadly that people find it very difficult to step outside their frame of reference and imagine any other way of doing things.

sussexman · 04/06/2023 14:05

kitsuneghost · 04/06/2023 13:33

Perhaps some do but in general no. Why would you be outraged at someone else getting the same amount as you?

Because people do value equitable outcomes. Giving an extra £1000 a month to, say, Ed Sheeran is completely different to giving the same amount to an unemployed single parent of two kids with extra needs. Or think about it in reverse - consider taxing everyone at a flat rate of say £8k/year (right ballpark for income tax paid per taxpayer).

Room102 · 04/06/2023 13:56

Provided there are systems in place to make sure they are not hoarded by a very small number of people...

This is also why cooperation and global systems will become more necessary, not less. Many of the issues humanity faces including this one but also climate change etc cannot be resolved by isolationists, so if they win out all they will win for everyone including themselves is destitution and misery.