Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there’s no good option for first time buyers

205 replies

ton29 · 04/06/2023 09:49

Prepared to be told it’s always been like this but I’m not quite sure it has.

On our combined income as it is now (both earn the average UK salary) in 2018 we would have been able to buy a 3 bed semi, possibly 3 bed detached in a really lovely area. We couldn’t buy then as we were still students.

Fast forward to this year and prices have rocketed so much so the same houses are 60-80k more making them unaffordable.

Buying a flat isn’t always the answer if you’re going to outgrow it immediately because if you move fairly quickly after buying, there’s the risk of negative equity and costs associated like legal fees and stamp duty on the new property.

Buying a house in need of renovation isn’t suitable for everyone. It’s ok if you have family help or are quite creatively minded, but if you work very busy 9-5s it’s soon going to get expensive and untenable to rip up flooring and knock through walls.

Moving 30-40 miles away to a cheaper area makes life inconvenient for commuting to work and seeing family.

I’m not sure why you can no longer buy the average sized house when you are on average sized salaries. Buying wouldn’t be an issue either if it was more secure to rent, but as everyone knows renting in this country is huge instability.

OP posts:
AndIKnewYouMeantIt · 04/06/2023 12:59

The point still stands that if you are 32 and want to buy a 3 bed detached, then the equivalent requirement to go straight into a family home (instead of being on the property ladder) is to have spent 10 years saving a deposit, plus the equity you would have paid down over 10 years on a smaller property, plus the equity you've gained if prices have gone up. While renting.

It's one reason Shared Ownership is getting so popular, and I get it. 3 bed semi in Oxfordshire, £330k full market value, but you can get one with a £110k mortgage.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 04/06/2023 12:59

Looking back is often painful with the UK property market. I bought 20 years ago, but if I had bought 22 years ago I could have paid half the price or got twice as much for my money..but as time passed what I paid looks good to those who bought later.

If you were students 5 years ago you are probably young and building towards higher salaries. The market is flat so there is no rush to buy, and time is on your side to earn more, save more and be in a position to buy what you want (or, like most of us, the best you can afford) in a few years time.

ton29 · 04/06/2023 12:57

Ambi · 04/06/2023 12:52

We were FTBers a long time ago when house prices were fairly cheap, however as we didn't earn much and are cautious purchasers, we went for space over location. Bought a 3 bed semi in a rough area. Moved a few years later and doubled our mortgage to get to a better area with good schools and have kids.

Unfortunately in house buying there is always a compromise and I appreciate that the prices are ridiculous now for FTB, I fear for my kids getting on the ladder.

I’m glad things worked for you. I think less and less people will own homes in years to come, for sure

OP posts:
Ambi · 04/06/2023 12:52

We were FTBers a long time ago when house prices were fairly cheap, however as we didn't earn much and are cautious purchasers, we went for space over location. Bought a 3 bed semi in a rough area. Moved a few years later and doubled our mortgage to get to a better area with good schools and have kids.

Unfortunately in house buying there is always a compromise and I appreciate that the prices are ridiculous now for FTB, I fear for my kids getting on the ladder.

ton29 · 04/06/2023 12:45

Fretfulmum · 04/06/2023 11:01

Most of these posts are not relevant to 2023. There is no longer the concept of moving up the ladder. Flats are very poor investments and no longer allow one to build up equity as they don’t increase in price relative to houses which means upsizing from them is very very hard unless you have accumulated big cash savings. Flats are at a lower price today than 2016 so definitely shouldn’t be an option for you.
FTBs are also much older now than in the past decade so it’s very easy to quickly outgrow a small house. If you buy a first home at 32, have 2 DC within the next 3 years, then a 2 bed will be outgrown within 3 years. With house prices as they are, you need to buy a property you’re happy to stay in for minimum 5 but preferably longer so you don’t go into negative equity, chance to build up equity etc, so a 2 bed won’t work in this case for a FTB.
People need to get real and stop offering advice which was appropriate in 2018 and not today

I wish I could pin your response to the top of this thread. You’re so spot on. Many people don’t see it.

OP posts:
ton29 · 04/06/2023 12:43

Skethylita · 04/06/2023 12:39

Priced are increasing massively in the very undesirable area I live in. It's not necessarily a case of buying somewhere cheaply even in those areas now. I bought a 3 bed ex council terraced house as it was all I could afford on a single parent, but reasonably high (for the area) salary. 1 year later and properties around me recently have sold for 15k more than I have bought my house and some are now asking for 30-40k more.

That's an insane increase.

Similar round here. It is crazy

OP posts:
Skethylita · 04/06/2023 12:39

Priced are increasing massively in the very undesirable area I live in. It's not necessarily a case of buying somewhere cheaply even in those areas now. I bought a 3 bed ex council terraced house as it was all I could afford on a single parent, but reasonably high (for the area) salary. 1 year later and properties around me recently have sold for 15k more than I have bought my house and some are now asking for 30-40k more.

That's an insane increase.

ton29 · 04/06/2023 12:24

CityKity · 04/06/2023 12:13

@Fretfulmum I didn’t see your post when I posted, but you’ve said it much better than me!
DH are mid/late 30’s and the advice from PP to buy a starter flat really grinds my gears as we tried to and are no better off and still don’t have a family home. We’re currently in a 1 bed rental expected a baby getting increasing depressed by the housing market. There is very little stock coming up and a lot of competition despite high interest rates

Completely agree with you - and your comment before. So tricky. Also a smaller property might lose value and then you’re trapped.

OP posts:
CityKity · 04/06/2023 12:13

@Fretfulmum I didn’t see your post when I posted, but you’ve said it much better than me!
DH are mid/late 30’s and the advice from PP to buy a starter flat really grinds my gears as we tried to and are no better off and still don’t have a family home. We’re currently in a 1 bed rental expected a baby getting increasing depressed by the housing market. There is very little stock coming up and a lot of competition despite high interest rates

Pinkdelight3 · 04/06/2023 12:12

The housing market is nuts coupled with the CoL crisis, that's undeniable. However 3-bed semi has never been a trad first time buyer property. If you're looking back in time to make your point, it's pretty much always been the case that FTBs get on the ladder with smaller properties and only get to that level of family home by the 3rd purchase e.g. flat then terrace then semi.

Again, it's harder than ever now, but equally you are looking to jump to a family home from a standing start and that's not the same as FTBs having no options.

CityKity · 04/06/2023 12:08

Solidarity OP. I think other posters are being slightly unfair in telling you you’re expectations are too high.
Me and DH have tried to do everything right (without parental help) and are none the better.
We did buy the small starter flat that we could afford at the time in 2016. We finally sold it last year (to try and upsize) after being on the market for 8 months, and just broke even with no additionally equity gains. The same flat this year has dropped an additional 70k, so I’m relieved we managed to sell when we did!
Friends that bought the 3 bed house at the same time (with parental help) have seen their investment increase 40% in the same time.
We’ve been looking for a family home since selling as I’m expecting, and have been looking at doer uppers and ready to go homes, but even doer uppers are priced to account for value when finished which doesn’t take into account the cost of renovating these days.
We can’t move area as we rely on our London salary’s and have parents and siblings close by which we will need when baby is here.
My advice is that a starter flat isn’t the first rung on the ladder that it used to be. I know another couple in exactly the same situation trying to sell their flat this year and are struggling to even get what they paid. I wish we’d had the money for a small house in the first place!

CatsOnTheChair · 04/06/2023 11:50

I guess it depends where you live.
I'm estimating both of you on 30k.
3xjoint salary is 180K. Add in a 20k deposit, and you'd be looking at a 4 bed semi or 3 bed detached where we've just sold. But the other side to that is we sold for almost exactly what we bought it for 15 years earlier....

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 04/06/2023 11:31

OP, I broadly agree with you- things are really really difficult as a first time buyer now.

I think what some people on this thread aren't acknowledging is that a lot of first time buyers are a lot older now. So yes, it makes sense that your first buy is a 2 bed flat, or a small terrace etc BUT if you are in your 30s, then as OP says, this may not be a suitable house for very long.

Because most people can't/aren't buying in their early 20s, they need a larger house to get started with, and it does become a bit of a vicious cycle- because the type of house that meets your needs is always more than you can afford.

I don't have the answer- I've moved towns and jobs in part to be able to afford to buy. I think compromise has to come in somewhere- but it's definitely not right that we've ended up in this situation.

FedUpWithEverything123 · 04/06/2023 11:02

It's always been difficult to get a first property. Prices are higher now, so it's even more challenging - but it always involves compromise and sacrifice - eg small size, far from work/family etc. For our first property we sacrificed space, it was a studio flat. Took us years to save for the deposit and years to be able to move on to a flat with a bedroom.

Fretfulmum · 04/06/2023 11:01

Most of these posts are not relevant to 2023. There is no longer the concept of moving up the ladder. Flats are very poor investments and no longer allow one to build up equity as they don’t increase in price relative to houses which means upsizing from them is very very hard unless you have accumulated big cash savings. Flats are at a lower price today than 2016 so definitely shouldn’t be an option for you.
FTBs are also much older now than in the past decade so it’s very easy to quickly outgrow a small house. If you buy a first home at 32, have 2 DC within the next 3 years, then a 2 bed will be outgrown within 3 years. With house prices as they are, you need to buy a property you’re happy to stay in for minimum 5 but preferably longer so you don’t go into negative equity, chance to build up equity etc, so a 2 bed won’t work in this case for a FTB.
People need to get real and stop offering advice which was appropriate in 2018 and not today

Oliotya · 04/06/2023 10:45

Let's not forget stamp duty is a real barrier to "climing the ladder" these days too.

jackstini · 04/06/2023 10:44

Have you been using your LISA allowances to maximise savings into deposit?

That's probably the main benefit I can see for FTB now, that wasn't around when I bought

I was 21 and bought a 3 bed end townhouse in an ok area with then DP for £41k; interest rates were about 7% and it was worth about 3 x our joint salary - this was 1993

SnapBang · 04/06/2023 10:43

@tealsofas i know what you’re saying but we are just two very ordinary people who have made it work. A mix of doing things slowly, prioritising carefully, buying in up and coming areas, doing lots of things ourselves, saving and shopping around. If you want to move in and get tradesmen round to immediately transform then expect to pay a fortune.

Lots of people have said to us recently that they would love a house like our new one… but I honestly don’t think they would. They would love it if you gave it to them right now but they haven’t prioritised that dream above other spending dreams and that’s what it takes for those of us on average / above average but not mega salaries.

nahwhale · 04/06/2023 10:41

AndIKnewYouMeantIt · 04/06/2023 10:31

You know what I think it (partly) is? My gen (1980s) grew up, in my area anyway, in either pleasant detached homes (approx 90k) or solid Victorian terraces with big gardens (50k). We only saw what we were born into and see the mid range homes as normal.

It goes the other way too. My mum and dad assumed we'd move into a detached from our current townhouse because thay's what you did in your 30s, if you were 30 in 1990! But we're not going anywhere.

I know as fact I was born in a crappy 2 bed bungalow in Bradford which was my parents' First Time Buy but I don't remember it. They dormered it and quadrupled their £10k investment.

Yeah I think you're right. I guess also a lot of the "starter home" stock has been snapped up and improved rather than left so it's now too expensive

tealsofas · 04/06/2023 10:34

My brother and his GF bought a tiny two bed house in the best area in 2016. You could barely swing a cat in the living room or kitchen but it was literally the cheapest house in the best area.

In 2019 they were able to remortgage and took £20k equity out to build a two floor extension (no way are two floor extensions £20k now!).

So it’s now a three bed house, albeit still a small one.

They would like to move to a more spacious three bed, or even a four bed, not far, still in the same area because they’ve had kids who are now at the local school. But to get that, the houses are an extra £70k more than the value of their house. They’re both public sector earning at the top of their bands and promotion isn’t a possibility. They’re trapped. They can’t move.

ThisGirlCab · 04/06/2023 10:32

The prices have slowed down a lot. When we bought in 2016 the small 3 beds we were looking at went up from 200- 210k when we started looking to 230-240k when we were ready to buy 4 months later. It was depressing having to adjust our criteria for Rightmove alerts so frequently. We jumped on it and then it slowed down. Our house is now worth 280k. For what it's worth, it wouldn't have been possible if my DH didn't have a flat that was also increasing at the same speed.

AndIKnewYouMeantIt · 04/06/2023 10:31

nahwhale · 04/06/2023 10:24

Why are you trying to buy a 3 bed house? We had to coz we have 3 kids now but why would you start with that? Do you have kids?

You know what I think it (partly) is? My gen (1980s) grew up, in my area anyway, in either pleasant detached homes (approx 90k) or solid Victorian terraces with big gardens (50k). We only saw what we were born into and see the mid range homes as normal.

It goes the other way too. My mum and dad assumed we'd move into a detached from our current townhouse because thay's what you did in your 30s, if you were 30 in 1990! But we're not going anywhere.

I know as fact I was born in a crappy 2 bed bungalow in Bradford which was my parents' First Time Buy but I don't remember it. They dormered it and quadrupled their £10k investment.

Playgrind · 04/06/2023 10:31

Asking prices are very high at the moment but actual sold prices are starting to come down in many areas. Depending on where you want to buy you might be best holding off for a year or so, watching your area in the meantime.

LuckyStone · 04/06/2023 10:31

It is shit.
But the older generation here will tell you how hard they had it +massive eyeroll+ they just cant fess up to having ruined it for their children.

tealsofas · 04/06/2023 10:28

SnapBang · 04/06/2023 10:21

I think you are forgetting about building equity to use as a deposit. Plus your salaries may grow over a bit of time too.

We both had above average salaries when we bought our first house six years ago. Paid £200k and I loathed it 😂 but we did it up, sold it fairly quickly for a big profit, bought a nicer house to do up again.

Now age 34, we’ve recently moved a short distance and bought our final home which is a gorrrgeous detached period property with six bedrooms. We still need to do it up though! Despite it not being convenient to work around our jobs, it’s worth it.

Buy something you can stick with short term and make money on.

I also forgot to mention the sheer cost of trades and labourers now. Not just the raw materials have shot up in price but the hourly and daily rates of plumbers, plasterers, electricians, roofers, joiners… and where do you get the money to flip a house if you have spent every penny on the house itself?

@ton29 has the problem spot on.

Swipe left for the next trending thread