Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there’s no good option for first time buyers

205 replies

ton29 · 04/06/2023 09:49

Prepared to be told it’s always been like this but I’m not quite sure it has.

On our combined income as it is now (both earn the average UK salary) in 2018 we would have been able to buy a 3 bed semi, possibly 3 bed detached in a really lovely area. We couldn’t buy then as we were still students.

Fast forward to this year and prices have rocketed so much so the same houses are 60-80k more making them unaffordable.

Buying a flat isn’t always the answer if you’re going to outgrow it immediately because if you move fairly quickly after buying, there’s the risk of negative equity and costs associated like legal fees and stamp duty on the new property.

Buying a house in need of renovation isn’t suitable for everyone. It’s ok if you have family help or are quite creatively minded, but if you work very busy 9-5s it’s soon going to get expensive and untenable to rip up flooring and knock through walls.

Moving 30-40 miles away to a cheaper area makes life inconvenient for commuting to work and seeing family.

I’m not sure why you can no longer buy the average sized house when you are on average sized salaries. Buying wouldn’t be an issue either if it was more secure to rent, but as everyone knows renting in this country is huge instability.

OP posts:
BashfulClam · 05/06/2023 08:12

We did what you don’t want to do. A one bedroom flat in the arse end of nowhere. Part exchanged for a 2 bedroom new build flat (brilliant flat) in a counter town, now a three bedroom townhouse…we moved up but didn’t start at the top.

Oliotya · 05/06/2023 08:11

Hardbackwriter · 05/06/2023 08:00

You keep talking about 2018 as some golden age of house buying - maybe it's just annoying me because it makes me feel old but I promise you no one felt those five years ago that it was cheap and easy for a FTB. We bought our first house in 2015 and it was similarly depressing but pointless to think of what we could have bought if we'd been buying 5 years earlier. I also remember lying awake with anxiety the night before we exchanged because I'd read an article saying that 2016 would see a huge crash in housing prices so buying now was foolish. Any year you buy you find that there were better years to buy and that there's someone who will tell you it's a terrible year to buy.

It's not a competition, but house prices have increased a huge amount in the last few years. Average house price has gone up by like £80k since 2018. Wages aren't close to keeping up.
It's never been easy, but it's harder than ever at the moment.

kljpl · 05/06/2023 08:05

I remember buying in 2017/2018 as being quite stressful as the market had stagnated post referendum and nobody knew what Brexit was going to do to the market, very little came up onto our local market until the Covid boom.

Hardbackwriter · 05/06/2023 08:00

You keep talking about 2018 as some golden age of house buying - maybe it's just annoying me because it makes me feel old but I promise you no one felt those five years ago that it was cheap and easy for a FTB. We bought our first house in 2015 and it was similarly depressing but pointless to think of what we could have bought if we'd been buying 5 years earlier. I also remember lying awake with anxiety the night before we exchanged because I'd read an article saying that 2016 would see a huge crash in housing prices so buying now was foolish. Any year you buy you find that there were better years to buy and that there's someone who will tell you it's a terrible year to buy.

Justdontask · 05/06/2023 07:33

I wish all the people who are discussing their first buys mentioned how old they were when they bought them. The average age for a FTB in the UK is now 34. This definitely wasn''t the case 5, 10 and 20 years ago. People are buying at an increasingly older age, so of course that comes with the need for different sized "starter" properties. I've been happy renting a room in a terraced house or living in a studio and one bed flats, but at 37 I've outgrown these spaces, just as those who were able to buy these kind of properties did at similar ages. Governments really need to get serious about what housing stock needs to be built like they did in the 1930s and 1950s, but also build the social housing that is needed that could free up properties on the private rental market for first time buyers.

TurquoiseDress · 05/06/2023 06:23

billthefrog · 04/06/2023 22:15

Jesus some people on this thread.

yes, buying a house has always required sacrifices. The goal was in sight making the sacrifices worthwhile.

if you are sacrificing your quality of life for an ever changing goalpost scenario knowing that you might never get what you want, as house prices go up and your relative salary goes down, it is really hard to stay positive. Great to live in a shithole working to get out of it - the family home is in sight - much harder to pay a fortune for a shithole knowing it might be forever, while previous generations tell you you just need to ‘work a bit harder’.

with you OP. Anyone who cannot sympathise has a screw loose.

You're absolutely spot on with the ever changing goalpost scenario!

Also now with even more insane prices, I can see why people balk at paying a fortune for that eg 1 bed flat in a dodgy area

People banging on about the 'property ladder' I'm really not sure it exists in a form that it once was a decade or so ago

Now I would think that buyers want to get their moving done in as few moves as possible- factor in stamp duty (this is just an exponential cost which will increase as price goes up) and moving costs/solicitor's fees.

I totally understand why a 30 something couple would be looking to buy more than a 1 bed 'starter home' in a crap area

OP I totally get it!

tealsofas · 05/06/2023 01:02

Let’s not forget increasing levels of WFH these days too. Some people don’t even have an office any more or can only go in once or twice a week.

1offnamechange · 04/06/2023 23:03

ton29 · 04/06/2023 09:49

Prepared to be told it’s always been like this but I’m not quite sure it has.

On our combined income as it is now (both earn the average UK salary) in 2018 we would have been able to buy a 3 bed semi, possibly 3 bed detached in a really lovely area. We couldn’t buy then as we were still students.

Fast forward to this year and prices have rocketed so much so the same houses are 60-80k more making them unaffordable.

Buying a flat isn’t always the answer if you’re going to outgrow it immediately because if you move fairly quickly after buying, there’s the risk of negative equity and costs associated like legal fees and stamp duty on the new property.

Buying a house in need of renovation isn’t suitable for everyone. It’s ok if you have family help or are quite creatively minded, but if you work very busy 9-5s it’s soon going to get expensive and untenable to rip up flooring and knock through walls.

Moving 30-40 miles away to a cheaper area makes life inconvenient for commuting to work and seeing family.

I’m not sure why you can no longer buy the average sized house when you are on average sized salaries. Buying wouldn’t be an issue either if it was more secure to rent, but as everyone knows renting in this country is huge instability.

not the average 'size' but if you're going by average price then yes it has always been the case that you can't skip the first few steps and go straight to the middle of the ladder.

Most people on the middle/average of the ladder have a combination of equity from their first properties and wages not just average wages.

Plus it's all location. 2xaverage wage in Sheffield/Newcastle/Swansea might be enough to get you a nice-ish house straightaway. 2xaverage wage in London, Oxford, Edinburgh might not.

Also if you were students 5 years ago then I assume you're still quite young.
Fairly normal not to jump straight into the middle of the housing ladder aged 26ish - that's why it's called a 'ladder' - there's an expectation your first house is either a do-er upper or a flat or in a dodgy area or a bit far out etc. B

It's never been the norm that just because you've got a steady wage you ca jump straight to a 3 bed (semi/)detached as your first home.

ThankmelaterOkay · 04/06/2023 22:44

Andanotherone01 · 04/06/2023 22:36

House prices are high, yes. But it’s called the property ladder for a reason - most people will start off with something less than desirable and trade up. We bought our first flat (1 bed) in a crap area. Moved to a 2 bed semi in a slightly better area and are just about to close on a 4 bed in a really nice area - all of that has taken almost 20 years!

Did you stretch yourself at any point? Because, in hindsight, that was the play.

ton29 · 04/06/2023 22:37

Andanotherone01 · 04/06/2023 22:36

House prices are high, yes. But it’s called the property ladder for a reason - most people will start off with something less than desirable and trade up. We bought our first flat (1 bed) in a crap area. Moved to a 2 bed semi in a slightly better area and are just about to close on a 4 bed in a really nice area - all of that has taken almost 20 years!

I’m really pleased that’s worked for you, it just won’t be as viable anymore though. House prices are stagnating but very high. If they’re not gaining in value it’s going to be impossible to build equity and level up as you describe unless salaries for people drastically change, and not everyone’s fortunate enough that they will

OP posts:
ton29 · 04/06/2023 22:37

Bringabrolly · 04/06/2023 22:36

Getting rid of stamp duty would really help here. It’s a terrible tax that punishes people for moving house. Sin taxes are supposed to apply to things we want to discourage whereas people frequently moving makes the most of the housing stock we have in this country and is in everyone’s interest.

Definitely! It’s stamp duty that is stinging people and making it difficult to ‘climb the ladder’

OP posts:
Andanotherone01 · 04/06/2023 22:36

House prices are high, yes. But it’s called the property ladder for a reason - most people will start off with something less than desirable and trade up. We bought our first flat (1 bed) in a crap area. Moved to a 2 bed semi in a slightly better area and are just about to close on a 4 bed in a really nice area - all of that has taken almost 20 years!

Bringabrolly · 04/06/2023 22:36

Getting rid of stamp duty would really help here. It’s a terrible tax that punishes people for moving house. Sin taxes are supposed to apply to things we want to discourage whereas people frequently moving makes the most of the housing stock we have in this country and is in everyone’s interest.

Bringabrolly · 04/06/2023 22:33

Lenovolaptop · 04/06/2023 19:56

Just to add I agree it's ridiculous that people earning average (or above average in my immediate households case) can't buy a home. A 3 bed semi in my area is £550k min - they will be beyond reach for most ftb (me included)

This is where the British equivalent of the American dream ends. If two people in reasonable jobs (teacher / police / nurse etc) cannot afford to buy an average house there isn’t enough housing in this country. It’s the main reason why the Tories have no chance getting the votes of anyone other than pensioners.

ton29 · 04/06/2023 22:29

billthefrog · 04/06/2023 22:15

Jesus some people on this thread.

yes, buying a house has always required sacrifices. The goal was in sight making the sacrifices worthwhile.

if you are sacrificing your quality of life for an ever changing goalpost scenario knowing that you might never get what you want, as house prices go up and your relative salary goes down, it is really hard to stay positive. Great to live in a shithole working to get out of it - the family home is in sight - much harder to pay a fortune for a shithole knowing it might be forever, while previous generations tell you you just need to ‘work a bit harder’.

with you OP. Anyone who cannot sympathise has a screw loose.

I agree with you wholeheartedly, and another poster who said it’s not 2018 anymore and it’s not easy to buy a starter home

all the starter homes have been bought and now people can’t afford to move out, or they’re bought very fast by landlords

OP posts:
billthefrog · 04/06/2023 22:22

And as for ‘a starter home only needs one bedroom’ well yes when you could move out at 21 with your husband and buy a house

times have changed, people are at home til 30, then they want to move out for a family home. So the ‘starter home’ which so may posters think should be Op’s first thought - how does that work for people that can’t afford to buy h til they are 35/40/45….?

so short sighted and lacking any insight or intelligence. Blame the people that can’t afford the houses. Sure.

billthefrog · 04/06/2023 22:15

Jesus some people on this thread.

yes, buying a house has always required sacrifices. The goal was in sight making the sacrifices worthwhile.

if you are sacrificing your quality of life for an ever changing goalpost scenario knowing that you might never get what you want, as house prices go up and your relative salary goes down, it is really hard to stay positive. Great to live in a shithole working to get out of it - the family home is in sight - much harder to pay a fortune for a shithole knowing it might be forever, while previous generations tell you you just need to ‘work a bit harder’.

with you OP. Anyone who cannot sympathise has a screw loose.

fomnt · 04/06/2023 20:39

Has OP said where they are based? Yes a 3bed house might be a tall ask in the SE, but it's a normal starter home where I am from and other parts of the country including where we bought, our first house was a 3 bed semi with parking and garden for £180k 2017, could have been cheaper too if we went for an older property.

Meggie2008 · 04/06/2023 20:36

I bought my 2 bed flat in 2020 as a first time buyer, I was 28 years old.
My partner and I are getting married in 2025 and I'm hoping that after the wedding, I'll be able to sell this flat and for us to get a 3 bed together. Housing market is a riot at the moment though so I don't envy anyone looking.

Usernamenotavailab · 04/06/2023 20:24

Lenovolaptop · 04/06/2023 19:56

Just to add I agree it's ridiculous that people earning average (or above average in my immediate households case) can't buy a home. A 3 bed semi in my area is £550k min - they will be beyond reach for most ftb (me included)

So why not start with a 2 bed flat?

3 bed family homes are a big leap for most FTB.

Lenovolaptop · 04/06/2023 19:56

Just to add I agree it's ridiculous that people earning average (or above average in my immediate households case) can't buy a home. A 3 bed semi in my area is £550k min - they will be beyond reach for most ftb (me included)

Lenovolaptop · 04/06/2023 19:53

FluffyDiplodocus · 04/06/2023 19:21

A lot of people are saying the OP should get a flat or two bedrooms house (and if that’s all they can stretch to, fair enough). But it’s not always easy to move to the step on the ladder when you outgrow it (assuming children are on the cards if that’s a concern) because nursery fees affect what the mortgage companies will lend and if you’ve gone part time as some people want to there’s a salary drop too.

We bought a three bed fixer upper back in 2014 and we wouldn’t be able to afford it on our salaries now due to the house price increase. It’s crap for FTB!

So they have to move away to get the 3 bed or buy a fixer upper - maybe both. Few people get to buy an Instagramable house as first time buyers unless they've had family help somewhere along the line or live in a cheap area and earn very well.

Twiglets1 · 04/06/2023 19:31

ton29 · 04/06/2023 09:49

Prepared to be told it’s always been like this but I’m not quite sure it has.

On our combined income as it is now (both earn the average UK salary) in 2018 we would have been able to buy a 3 bed semi, possibly 3 bed detached in a really lovely area. We couldn’t buy then as we were still students.

Fast forward to this year and prices have rocketed so much so the same houses are 60-80k more making them unaffordable.

Buying a flat isn’t always the answer if you’re going to outgrow it immediately because if you move fairly quickly after buying, there’s the risk of negative equity and costs associated like legal fees and stamp duty on the new property.

Buying a house in need of renovation isn’t suitable for everyone. It’s ok if you have family help or are quite creatively minded, but if you work very busy 9-5s it’s soon going to get expensive and untenable to rip up flooring and knock through walls.

Moving 30-40 miles away to a cheaper area makes life inconvenient for commuting to work and seeing family.

I’m not sure why you can no longer buy the average sized house when you are on average sized salaries. Buying wouldn’t be an issue either if it was more secure to rent, but as everyone knows renting in this country is huge instability.

I think YABU for thinking you should be able to get a 3 bed semi as your first home. We started with a 1 bed flat then a 2 bed terraced house, then a 3 bed semi then a 4 bed detached. Climbed the property ladder over time.

Also, it's nothing to move 30 miles from family to a cheaper area if that helps you get closer to the sort of property you want. I've commuted that distance in the past just to get to work each day.

LolaSmiles · 04/06/2023 19:26

I agree going for the area you love/feel most comfortable living in and buying what you can afford there.

To me, cheaper property in a worse/less convenient or less desirable area is a false economy- you may get the bigger house I'd whatever, but you're still living in the area you don't really want to be in
I would agree, or find somewhere that's an acceptable balancing act of location and property.
Being a FTB usually means some form of compromise in terms of location, property size, amount of renovation required.
Very few people as FTB get to have their 3 bed family home in the nice area they want that's also close to friends, family and social life.

FluffyDiplodocus · 04/06/2023 19:21

A lot of people are saying the OP should get a flat or two bedrooms house (and if that’s all they can stretch to, fair enough). But it’s not always easy to move to the step on the ladder when you outgrow it (assuming children are on the cards if that’s a concern) because nursery fees affect what the mortgage companies will lend and if you’ve gone part time as some people want to there’s a salary drop too.

We bought a three bed fixer upper back in 2014 and we wouldn’t be able to afford it on our salaries now due to the house price increase. It’s crap for FTB!