Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there’s no good option for first time buyers

205 replies

ton29 · 04/06/2023 09:49

Prepared to be told it’s always been like this but I’m not quite sure it has.

On our combined income as it is now (both earn the average UK salary) in 2018 we would have been able to buy a 3 bed semi, possibly 3 bed detached in a really lovely area. We couldn’t buy then as we were still students.

Fast forward to this year and prices have rocketed so much so the same houses are 60-80k more making them unaffordable.

Buying a flat isn’t always the answer if you’re going to outgrow it immediately because if you move fairly quickly after buying, there’s the risk of negative equity and costs associated like legal fees and stamp duty on the new property.

Buying a house in need of renovation isn’t suitable for everyone. It’s ok if you have family help or are quite creatively minded, but if you work very busy 9-5s it’s soon going to get expensive and untenable to rip up flooring and knock through walls.

Moving 30-40 miles away to a cheaper area makes life inconvenient for commuting to work and seeing family.

I’m not sure why you can no longer buy the average sized house when you are on average sized salaries. Buying wouldn’t be an issue either if it was more secure to rent, but as everyone knows renting in this country is huge instability.

OP posts:
wotsitsorhoops · 05/06/2023 10:13

Lockheart · 05/06/2023 10:04

Don't be so bloody daft. It's not about "this generation not wanting to start at the bottom" its about this generation not being able to afford to start at the bottom so by the time they get a decade or two into full adult life the bottom is no longer suitable for their needs.

Oh right daft, so I guess there are no families living in these houses then or couples?

Get a grip, I have lots of friends with 2 adults and children living in rough areas with 2 bed terraced houses and Flats. Stop avoiding the fact this is a want not a need.

Nordicrain · 05/06/2023 10:10

Oliotya · 05/06/2023 10:07

Reading. A flat is a more affordable of course.

Reading isn't rough? Is it? It has loads of jobs and is close to London, of course it's going to be expensive.

Oliotya · 05/06/2023 10:07

wotsitsorhoops · 05/06/2023 10:01

Go on tell me the rough area not for an outing and let us all see then, so we can all check right move.

Reading. A flat is a more affordable of course.

Lockheart · 05/06/2023 10:04

wotsitsorhoops · 05/06/2023 09:53

"I totally understand why a 30 something couple would be looking to buy more than a 1 bed 'starter home' in a crap area

OP I totally get it!"

See this is exactly the issue, this generation don't want to start at the bottom. These property's and areas are bellow you? Why may I ask, are the people in these areas below you?

I bought my first, 1 bed terraced house in a deprived area 22 years ago, because I needed a home and needed to get on the property ladder.

I also had a good job but it was a start, If people like you and the OP feel these properties are below you quite honestly you deserve all you get.

Don't be so bloody daft. It's not about "this generation not wanting to start at the bottom" its about this generation not being able to afford to start at the bottom so by the time they get a decade or two into full adult life the bottom is no longer suitable for their needs.

Twiglets1 · 05/06/2023 10:02

kljpl · 05/06/2023 09:56

@ThankmelaterOkay the interest rate is irrelevant if you're planning to overpay anyway, it has the same end result but with the bonus of wiggle room should personal circumstances change mid term.

You seem unrealistic. Most FTBs stretch themselves to buy the best place they can, even if they is only a 1 bed flat. The overpayments come at a later stage in life when salaries rise and the mortgage starts to feel more manageable.

Nordicrain · 05/06/2023 10:02

ton29 · 04/06/2023 14:28

Thank you! Feel so seriously fed up that we can’t afford that now yet we could have had that EXACT thing if we were of age and stage to buy in 2018. Even a 2 up 2 down is a huge stretch for us now and means moving to a rubbish area. Looking at shared ownership for a nice 3 bed with the hope that it will gain in value anyway over the 5-10 years we stay there, meaning we will take away some equity to use against a bigger house on the open market. Sorry you were stung last year! I hope your next fix is cheaper in a a couple of years

Yes, but that's like saying if I had been at the age and stage to buy out current house when it was built 14 years ago I would have got it for about £300k less. But I wasn't. So it's a moot point. House prices have risen. So have wages (although not to the same extent). Interest rates are rising, but as I said, they are lower how than they were when we bought out first (small, in need of imporvement) starter house in 2008. Right before the market crashed as well OP, so we bought it at the peak and essentially lost about a third of its value in the next year.

It's challenging now. absolutely. But this whole "all these posts aren't relevant as noone knows what it's like" is a very insular way to view your circumstances. Current home buyers don't have a monopoly on challenges.

wotsitsorhoops · 05/06/2023 10:01

Oliotya · 05/06/2023 09:55

1 bed terrace round me is ~£250k. Could you afford that now on what a 22 year old in your job is making these days?

Go on tell me the rough area not for an outing and let us all see then, so we can all check right move.

wotsitsorhoops · 05/06/2023 10:00

ThankmelaterOkay · 05/06/2023 09:55

Were you 30-35 then?

31 actually.

ThankmelaterOkay · 05/06/2023 09:59

kljpl · 05/06/2023 09:56

@ThankmelaterOkay the interest rate is irrelevant if you're planning to overpay anyway, it has the same end result but with the bonus of wiggle room should personal circumstances change mid term.

So do you overpay each month, or at the end of the year?

kljpl · 05/06/2023 09:56

@ThankmelaterOkay the interest rate is irrelevant if you're planning to overpay anyway, it has the same end result but with the bonus of wiggle room should personal circumstances change mid term.

Oliotya · 05/06/2023 09:55

wotsitsorhoops · 05/06/2023 09:53

"I totally understand why a 30 something couple would be looking to buy more than a 1 bed 'starter home' in a crap area

OP I totally get it!"

See this is exactly the issue, this generation don't want to start at the bottom. These property's and areas are bellow you? Why may I ask, are the people in these areas below you?

I bought my first, 1 bed terraced house in a deprived area 22 years ago, because I needed a home and needed to get on the property ladder.

I also had a good job but it was a start, If people like you and the OP feel these properties are below you quite honestly you deserve all you get.

1 bed terrace round me is ~£250k. Could you afford that now on what a 22 year old in your job is making these days?

ThankmelaterOkay · 05/06/2023 09:55

wotsitsorhoops · 05/06/2023 09:53

"I totally understand why a 30 something couple would be looking to buy more than a 1 bed 'starter home' in a crap area

OP I totally get it!"

See this is exactly the issue, this generation don't want to start at the bottom. These property's and areas are bellow you? Why may I ask, are the people in these areas below you?

I bought my first, 1 bed terraced house in a deprived area 22 years ago, because I needed a home and needed to get on the property ladder.

I also had a good job but it was a start, If people like you and the OP feel these properties are below you quite honestly you deserve all you get.

Were you 30-35 then?

ThankmelaterOkay · 05/06/2023 09:54

kljpl · 05/06/2023 09:47

But like everything, if collectively FTBs decided, “right guys, no one take a mortgage over 25 year term”, the market would correct itself sharpish.

Well that just simply isn't realistic is it? I've always preferred to have a longer term mortgage and overpay, gives me more control. I'm not doing anything "collectively" I'm doing what's right for my situation.

Regardless of the interest rate?

Or did you do this when rates were 1%?

wotsitsorhoops · 05/06/2023 09:53

TurquoiseDress · 05/06/2023 06:23

You're absolutely spot on with the ever changing goalpost scenario!

Also now with even more insane prices, I can see why people balk at paying a fortune for that eg 1 bed flat in a dodgy area

People banging on about the 'property ladder' I'm really not sure it exists in a form that it once was a decade or so ago

Now I would think that buyers want to get their moving done in as few moves as possible- factor in stamp duty (this is just an exponential cost which will increase as price goes up) and moving costs/solicitor's fees.

I totally understand why a 30 something couple would be looking to buy more than a 1 bed 'starter home' in a crap area

OP I totally get it!

"I totally understand why a 30 something couple would be looking to buy more than a 1 bed 'starter home' in a crap area

OP I totally get it!"

See this is exactly the issue, this generation don't want to start at the bottom. These property's and areas are bellow you? Why may I ask, are the people in these areas below you?

I bought my first, 1 bed terraced house in a deprived area 22 years ago, because I needed a home and needed to get on the property ladder.

I also had a good job but it was a start, If people like you and the OP feel these properties are below you quite honestly you deserve all you get.

kljpl · 05/06/2023 09:47

But like everything, if collectively FTBs decided, “right guys, no one take a mortgage over 25 year term”, the market would correct itself sharpish.

Well that just simply isn't realistic is it? I've always preferred to have a longer term mortgage and overpay, gives me more control. I'm not doing anything "collectively" I'm doing what's right for my situation.

Oliotya · 05/06/2023 09:45

ThankmelaterOkay · 05/06/2023 09:42

Of course.

But like everything, if collectively FTBs decided, “right guys, no one take a mortgage over 25 year term”, the market would correct itself sharpish.

That's the responsibility of the banks and government though surely. Individuals buying homes can't be expected to control the market. It's not like people have enormous mortgages over huge terms for fun.

ThankmelaterOkay · 05/06/2023 09:42

kljpl · 05/06/2023 09:28

@ThankmelaterOkay people are extending mortgage terms to try to make their repayments more affordable month by month, not because they think it's a smart long term move, nobody wants to pay their mortgage off over a longer period of time.

Of course.

But like everything, if collectively FTBs decided, “right guys, no one take a mortgage over 25 year term”, the market would correct itself sharpish.

kljpl · 05/06/2023 09:28

@ThankmelaterOkay people are extending mortgage terms to try to make their repayments more affordable month by month, not because they think it's a smart long term move, nobody wants to pay their mortgage off over a longer period of time.

CabbageKale · 05/06/2023 09:27

Yes that’s very true. I should have written “ideally” rather than “make sure”.
Paying down the equity is the important thing.
Also keeping a close eye on total interest to be paid is something that I feel most people don’t do.

ThankmelaterOkay · 05/06/2023 09:21

The problem people aren’t navigating, or I guess can’t, is that when interest rates go up, you should be decreasing the length of the term, not increasing it.

Youcancallmeirrelevant · 05/06/2023 09:09

berksandbeyond · 04/06/2023 09:54

A 3 bedroom house as your first buy is not ‘average’
Its called a housing ladder for a reason, you climb it, you don’t expect to be magically half way up.
Buy a 2 bed flat, why would you magically immediately outgrow it? Unless you’re expecting quadruplets?

This

We did 1 bed flat thrn 2 bed terraced house then finally 3 bed detached house as family home. We would not havr been able to afford any of the future homes without equity and mortgage payments from previous one.

And i was still a student in 2018 so not too different in age i would guess

kljpl · 05/06/2023 09:05

Whatever you buy now just make sure that it is cheaper than renting and that you are building equity.

This is less likely to happen now interest rates are over 5%, my mortgage used to be comfortably under the going rental rate, but when it goes up when I refix it very likely won't be, unless you have a lot of equity already. Not that it matters, so long as I am paying back capital I will be building equity which is all that matters to me, not what I'd be paying in rent.

Bunbuns3 · 05/06/2023 08:33

That's why a lot of families opt for new builds, slightly out of town. They are easier to secure, usually a deposit of £500 is enough and banks seem to look more favourable on new builds when securing a loan. Yes some are not the best, but it seems an easier solution for a lot of people.

Twiglets1 · 05/06/2023 08:28

billthefrog · 04/06/2023 22:22

And as for ‘a starter home only needs one bedroom’ well yes when you could move out at 21 with your husband and buy a house

times have changed, people are at home til 30, then they want to move out for a family home. So the ‘starter home’ which so may posters think should be Op’s first thought - how does that work for people that can’t afford to buy h til they are 35/40/45….?

so short sighted and lacking any insight or intelligence. Blame the people that can’t afford the houses. Sure.

My daughter has just bought her first place in London and yes, it's a starter home with one bedroom. It's a flat and it cost 450k because that is London prices. She's 31 not 21.
People living in cheap areas should count themselves very lucky and not think they are entitled to have 3 bed semis as their first home. Fine if they can afford it, but if they can't they will just have to buy what they can afford and affording a 2 bed flat or house would still be a luxury for most young people.

It's what people have done forever. My first home was also a 1 bed flat with no garden, I was 25, my partner was 29.

CabbageKale · 05/06/2023 08:20

tealsofas · 04/06/2023 10:25

These huge price increases simply aren’t going to happen any more. If someone buys a house for 400k this year it’s not going to be 450k two years later. And even if it is, all the other house prices have gone up too; meanwhile wages are stagnating/falling in real terms. Climbing the ladder ‘like in the old days’ simply isn’t an option any more. Those days are gone.

Unfortunately this is very true. Whatever you buy now just make sure that it is cheaper than renting and that you are building equity. Don’t assume that your property will increase in value. A lot of doer uppers ( obv not all ) assume they made money by doing something up when in fact they just rose on the rising tide.
In your situation I’d try to buy a small but desirable flat in a good location.
Good luck!