Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there’s no good option for first time buyers

205 replies

ton29 · 04/06/2023 09:49

Prepared to be told it’s always been like this but I’m not quite sure it has.

On our combined income as it is now (both earn the average UK salary) in 2018 we would have been able to buy a 3 bed semi, possibly 3 bed detached in a really lovely area. We couldn’t buy then as we were still students.

Fast forward to this year and prices have rocketed so much so the same houses are 60-80k more making them unaffordable.

Buying a flat isn’t always the answer if you’re going to outgrow it immediately because if you move fairly quickly after buying, there’s the risk of negative equity and costs associated like legal fees and stamp duty on the new property.

Buying a house in need of renovation isn’t suitable for everyone. It’s ok if you have family help or are quite creatively minded, but if you work very busy 9-5s it’s soon going to get expensive and untenable to rip up flooring and knock through walls.

Moving 30-40 miles away to a cheaper area makes life inconvenient for commuting to work and seeing family.

I’m not sure why you can no longer buy the average sized house when you are on average sized salaries. Buying wouldn’t be an issue either if it was more secure to rent, but as everyone knows renting in this country is huge instability.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Twiglets1 · 08/06/2023 07:05

@Linning You really went above & beyond to buy your first home! Not many people would go as far as that, but I agree that big compromises sometimes have to be made. And that was also true in the late 80s when I bought my first property, a 1 bed in a grotty part of London (estate agent talk: "up & coming").

I don't consider that moving 30-40 miles away to a cheaper area (the option OP considers unreasonable) is a big sacrifice. Neither is buying a 2 bed when you would ideally like a 3 bed @ton29

ThankmelaterOkay · 08/06/2023 05:57

@Linning

Fair enough. Sounds like you worked hard for it.

Did you rent whilst you saved?

What you describe could maybe be done in the U.K. but over a slightly longer period, and you’d almost certainly need to live with parents rent free, which really is just being indirectly given money.

Linning · 07/06/2023 21:15

ThankmelaterOkay · 07/06/2023 10:42

@Linning

Wow! What’s your salary and what was the property price? You started from £0? That’s some amazing saving.

Sorry, @ThankmelaterOkay I have been working all day so didn’t get back on Mumsnet until now. It would be extremely outing if I gave the exact figures, but the property was under 100K (in a fairly popular coastal city of a European country with good weather).

My salary is considered high, if you do look at the monthly figure, but as I have said, I work 24 hours shifts so my hourly rate is actually extremely close to minimum wage when divided by the amount of hours I do work and so I have essentially been sacrificing having a life (at all) for the (seemingly) higher salary.

The only benefit of working that much is not having the time to spend much of what I earn, so while I did start from zero, I have been able to save relatively quickly as a combination of continuously overworking myself and not spending almost anything due to lack of time & my choice to buy in a country where real estate is still affordable.

But see, personally, despite being a technical “high earner” and coming with a high deposit banks didn’t want to loan me because I was borrowing alone (despite the repayments being ridiculously low and not even amounting 5% of my monthly income). So unfortunately my only way to buying was buying cash & without help so it was a choice between overworking, saving hard & buying at my level or not buying at all (as there was no way I was ready to bring in someone else on a mortgage.)

But it was fine because it fitted my plans and I personally think the only way to emulate the “luck” people have had in the past real estate wise, is to invest in places that are still cheap but are likely to increase drastically in the next few years/decade(s), rather than in the already popular and overpriced places and that saving us a good exercise when planning to own anyway.

Now not everyone would feel comfortable buying abroad for example, and that’s alright, but I think if you can buy 3/4/5 properties abroad (or in a cheaper place in your own country) for the price of a 3 bedroom flat in London, and manage to get a revenue out of each, that can technically pay your rent in your dream apartment in London (and then some). Why not do that?

if I had to save up for a place in my home country/hometown to buy outright like I did abroad, I would need probably a few more years and that would be to buy a studio or a one bedroom. For a three bedroom I would need probably a decade+ and by the time that decade came around housing would have probably increased exponentially still, meaning I would probably still be behind, on gathering the amount I need. Yet now if I was to rent out my flat, I could likely afford most if not the totality of the rent of a similar sized apartment in my hometown (one I still wouldn’t be able to buy) with the revenue from my own place. It’s not my plan at all, as I actually quite love where I have bought and do want to live there. But essentially buying in city/country A could give me the opportunity to live/rent in in my dream place in city/country B if I wanted to, for almost free (depending on rent prices in B) so it seems crazy to me that some people who dismiss buying based on small things such as distance don’t see the potential of buying even if further afield or of overworking yourself a bit/ accepting a flat with a bit of work (that will no doubt automatically increase value once done etc…) as those sacrifices might mean potentially being able to own a place + still live in your preferred area.

ThankmelaterOkay · 07/06/2023 18:10

@Linning

Seriously? I’m still doing the mental gymnastics on your finances. Put me out of my misery.

ThankmelaterOkay · 07/06/2023 10:42

@Linning

Wow! What’s your salary and what was the property price? You started from £0? That’s some amazing saving.

LT1982 · 07/06/2023 10:15

The OP was talking about living a driveable distance from their preferred area, not a drastic move up north or to Wales. And nlt all areas north of Birmingham are deprived 🙄🙄🙄

Linning · 06/06/2023 23:23

ton29 · 05/06/2023 17:19

Also. Presuming most people plan to buy before kids, if they can. Is it really smart to strap yourself in for 30-40 years of paying such ridiculously high debt off? Nobody is going to come and help you pay a mortgage that you’ve stretched yourself on throughout times of reduced income, maternity leave etc. Okay it’s a means to an end and you’ll own the house eventually but ultimately the bank still owns your house for most or all of your working life, when you’re actually supposed to enjoy life. Wages have stagnated for too long and house prices have climbed which means the current situation is untenable, with people forced to pay more than a thousand pounds each month for a tiny flat or house in possibly a poor condition that they’re going to outgrow soon. Supposing you can’t move because you’ve fallen into negative equity so not only now have you lost your deposit that you saved so hard for, but also have to find the legal fees to move on. Nobody advocates for the risks of buying property especially when you’re junior in the workforce and on low income. We are HA at the moment and although we would love to own our home it would reduce our fun and enjoyment of life. This is backwards.

I think YABU on the basis that you seem to have high expectations (being able to buy pretty much the dream house aka a big house with 3 bedrooms and nothing to fix) but not willing to sacrifice anything in the process?

I have talked about real estate with my family (multi generations of people) at length and even my grandparents who clearly paid their house a lot cheaper than we do today, still started off with a small flat with no bathroom before eventually getting to owning the 4-bedroom home they built. My own parents went from renting a flat in the middle of the city to owning a home in the countryside (as cheaper and could have never afford a house in the city) and it was a 3-bedroom fixer-upper that required a lot of work and is now a 4 bedroom house that looks nothing like it used to after years of renovations (made by them). They could have never afforded to buy the house they have if they had bought it in its current state vs its original state.

I am in my late 20’s & I have now just bought a 3-bedroom flat, by the beach in a fairly big/touristy city (mortgage-free). But it’s in a completely different country to my family. I absolutely couldn’t have afforded a 3-bedrooms place, especially by the beach, close to my family. The place I have bought didn’t require any major work, just decorative, and to make it look a bit more modern and so I have spent my free time doing some adjustments that didn’t require that much time but yes a bit of effort and moderate financial investment and in doing so, the value of my property is now at least 25k above what I have paid for it much less than a year ago.

But to be mortgage free and get something this big I had to work 24 shifts for months on end and had to accept I wouldn’t be buying close to family.

Personally for me those were easy choices to make because I think buying a home is the best way to invest in one’s future and I knew that if I made the sacrifices now they would pay off and provide me with a better future and there is literally no incentive to rent, renting a flat like mine would be so expensive, renting near my family would also be extremely expensive, and every rent would be money lost, and rent will continue to increase I fear meaning you will still be spending the best of your working years paying for housing, except you’ll be paying off someone else’s mortgage. So it seems crazy to me that one would see renting as less of a prison when each paycheck you make a landlord is money away from your pocket into theirs, and off their mortgage (not yours) whilst any mortgage repayment is money invested into your own pocket and own equity.

Personally the flat I bought still isn’t my dream flat but it’s a strategic investment as it’s in a (beautiful) city that still offers lower real estate prices than my home country (meaning I can get more for my money than I would elsewhere) but with great resale value and a great quality of life (one I could not afford back home). If I had tried to invest back home, I could have probably afforded a one bedroom apartment with a mortgage in my city and it would have probably taken me years and years to be able to upgrade to something bigger in a nicer area. But now I own a property mortgage free, I can save what I would pay on rent, for a deposit for a second place and use the flat I own to get better offers from banks regarding mortgages on a bigger or better situated flat, and if I wanted to move back to my city (I don’t) I probably now could do it, and afford a much bigger place than I would if I didn’t invest in the first place and with a better mortgage/easier time paying for it, as I could just rent out one of the properties (essentially paying of the new mortgage with the rents).

Yes, I could have used all the money I have spent on the flat on fun stuff but it was more important to me to be on the property ladder because I understood that the money I am investing would get back to me in some ways if I bought while it never would if I spent it on frivolous things or rent. Now because I own I ironically have more financial options and more financial freedom as owning gives me access to properties I wouldn’t have accessed to before as the gap between not owning and such places was just too big for me to make up for with just my income (or it would have taken many many years).

So my advice to you, if you do want to buy (which I recommend) accept it comes with sacrifices of some sort. Which ones, you can almost pick for yourself as it’s going to be based on the property you select as to what you will have to sacrifice for it, but I see a lot of my friends of a similar age “wanting it all” without being willing to make the temporary sacrifices to get where they want to be. You wouldn’t run a marathon without training and even trained you likely wouldn’t expect to finish first. I think real estate is a bit like that. Training (sacrificing) sucks, but getting there is worth it. In a marathon most people accept that they will likely need years of sacrifices & training before they get a good timing, let alone a chance to end up first, and they still partake because every time they partake they probably get at least as much back from doing the race as they have invested and they get better & more prepared for the next one, well it’s the same with housing and the housing ladder. If you aren’t willing to do the long race you will likely think it’s unfair you can’t get to the finish line without giving up so much of you in the process but if you see the race for what it is, an investment in yourself rather than in a finish score then you will start understanding why it’s important not to jump step and why it can be quite smart actually to start with a small race but well prepared rather than with the hardest marathon but unprepared and how you’ll probably get more out of it from the first scenario than the last.

Good luck OP, and reconsider what it is that you want from buying and if those things are worth a little distance with family and friends/ a little more important commuting costs etc… only you can know that and decide for yourself, but I do think there are options for FTB to buy, that are likely good investments still, but just that a lot of FTB simply don’t want to start small or invest in something that’s not already to their taste and just like they have pictures meaning most people feel like they can’t afford anything when really they just can’t afford exactly what they want.

ThisGirlCab · 06/06/2023 19:58

Okay it’s a means to an end and you’ll own the house eventually but ultimately the bank still owns your house for most or all of your working life, when you’re actually supposed to enjoy life.

The bank owns your house to the value of your mortgage. You still own the equity you wouldn't have while renting. Our house has increased by just under 40k since we've been here. We've spent about 15k on maintenance like replacing the porch, getting concrete fence posts and panels, fixing the boiler. That's still 25k of profit compared to 0k if we'd rented. On top of that, the interest rates when we bought in 2017 means our mortgage on a small 3 bed house was £550 which is less than rent for a 1 bed flat around here. We're on a tracker and because we're moving, we didn't want to lock in to an interest rate so our mortgage has soared to £900 but it's still less than renting a 2 bed flat. We could have locked it earlier in if we weren't planning to move.

Feelinadequate23 · 05/06/2023 21:09

@ton29 i think YABU I’m your refusal to make compromises I’m afraid. I bought my first property age 27 on a single wage (2 bed flat with garden). I had to buy a doer upper in a horrible area not near family in order to do so. I also worked long hours but paid workmen to do the hardest bits of the renovation (kitchen and bathroom) and then did the painting etc late at night and on weekends. Took 6 months as only a small property.

now DH and I have bought a 3.5 bed semi with decent garden. To do this we have moved 30 miles away, so didn’t know a single person in our town and have a v long commute. But I think that’s to be expected unless you have rich parents or a v high paying job! We could also have moved less far but to more dodgy areas so we chose the longer commute to feel safer.

basically nobody can get a decent size property in a nice area requiring no work unless they are rich. That has always been the case unless you are lucky to be a high earner relative to the area you live in. Otherwise compromises are necessary.

ton29 · 05/06/2023 21:00

Ndhdiwntbsivnwg · 05/06/2023 20:58

It is what it is.
Though I just bought a house so I’ll shut up 😂

Congratulations x

OP posts:
ton29 · 05/06/2023 21:00

Twiglets1 · 05/06/2023 19:12

I think I win on distance from family - my Dad lives in Australia!

I think now OP has added the detail that they live in a HA property, maybe the best thing for them is to stay put? I believe those places are gold dust.

We do, we rent with a small discount on market value prices but in two years it’ll be full whack rent like any other place. So it might be a secure tenancy but it’s still set to get more expensive. We’re looking at shared ownership

OP posts:
Ndhdiwntbsivnwg · 05/06/2023 20:58

It is what it is.
Though I just bought a house so I’ll shut up 😂

Twiglets1 · 05/06/2023 19:12

Usernamen · 05/06/2023 18:16

The unwillingness to compromise on anything is silly (30 miles is nothing… I live 200 miles from my family!)

I think I win on distance from family - my Dad lives in Australia!

I think now OP has added the detail that they live in a HA property, maybe the best thing for them is to stay put? I believe those places are gold dust.

Usernamen · 05/06/2023 18:16

Twiglets1 · 05/06/2023 17:45

I think they are referring to the fact I said I moved from a flat to a 2 bed terraced house in 2 years. Though as I explained that wasn’t the initial plan & we had to move from London to Norfolk to achieve it. A much cheaper area but it wouldn’t suit OP as they think 30 miles is a long distance move.

The unwillingness to compromise on anything is silly (30 miles is nothing… I live 200 miles from my family!)

UsingChangeofName · 05/06/2023 17:50

ThankmelaterOkay · 05/06/2023 17:38

@UsingChangeofName

Spot on. If you are really smart:
•Take in a lodger. They pay rent and do 10x loads of outsourced ironing. Plus they cook a chicken and create 5x meals for the week for the household.

Not sure what you are hoping to achieve by mocking ?

A poster asked how people make the move from buying their first property, to the next (bigger, or in a better area) property. So some of us are pointing out how they did it.

why does that bother you?

Twiglets1 · 05/06/2023 17:45

Usernamen · 05/06/2023 17:42

Who’s trying to go from a flat to a house in 2 years? That’s a ridiculous expectation - as much in 2018 as it is now.

I bought a flat in 2020, aged 31, and expect to be there for 5-10 years. Luckily it’s a 2-bed so a future DC will have their own room.

You either comprise or you stay renting, I don’t think there’s an alternative 🤷‍♀️

I think they are referring to the fact I said I moved from a flat to a 2 bed terraced house in 2 years. Though as I explained that wasn’t the initial plan & we had to move from London to Norfolk to achieve it. A much cheaper area but it wouldn’t suit OP as they think 30 miles is a long distance move.

Usernamen · 05/06/2023 17:42

Fretfulmum · 05/06/2023 15:21

@Twiglets1 did you also have to pay stamp duty for all these moves? And were these properties 8 times your salary? How much deposit did you put down? You do realise that you can’t go from a 1 bed flat to a 2 bed terrace in 2 years anymore. Flat prices are not increasing, they are decreasing and have been since 2016. So how can anyone make a jump from a flat?

Who’s trying to go from a flat to a house in 2 years? That’s a ridiculous expectation - as much in 2018 as it is now.

I bought a flat in 2020, aged 31, and expect to be there for 5-10 years. Luckily it’s a 2-bed so a future DC will have their own room.

You either comprise or you stay renting, I don’t think there’s an alternative 🤷‍♀️

Twiglets1 · 05/06/2023 17:40

ton29 · 05/06/2023 17:14

We would then live near nobody we know and it would make costs ridiculous for getting to work

You would live fairly near people you know as 30-40 miles isn’t that far. Plus you can make new friends. And loads of people commute longer distances than that.

Obviously there are things more important to you than owning a 3 bed semi so why not just buy the 2 bed you can afford and count yourself lucky?

ThankmelaterOkay · 05/06/2023 17:38

@UsingChangeofName

Spot on. If you are really smart:
•Take in a lodger. They pay rent and do 10x loads of outsourced ironing. Plus they cook a chicken and create 5x meals for the week for the household.

Twiglets1 · 05/06/2023 17:37

tealsofas · 05/06/2023 17:15

Which lender will lend 8 times salary, never heard of a ratio that high?

None of them, that’s the point…

What is your point exactly?
Why when mention 8 times your joint salary?

UsingChangeofName · 05/06/2023 17:31

Flat prices are not increasing, they are decreasing and have been since 2016. So how can anyone make a jump from a flat?

The same as people have always done.

  • Promotion or a new job, means your salary improves
  • you get a lodger, who effectively covers your mortgage, or a large chunk of it, and you save
  • You continue to work at your 2nd job, and save
  • You meet someone and then have 2 incomes rather than one
  • some people will be in the position of coming into a chunk of money - maybe through inheritance, maybe through winnings
  • you do work on the property that improves it's value
  • you save what you can, when you can in the same way people try to save a deposit whilst renting
Often a combination of these.

We are HA at the moment and although we would love to own our home it would reduce our fun and enjoyment of life.

Well, if that is the way you feel, I am not sure why you have started the thread, tbh.
If you feel the reasons not to buy, outweigh the reasons to buy, then no-one is forcing you to try to buy your own home. It is a matter of personal preference (for those in a position to choose). Lots of people would choose the home owning route, others wouldn't.

ton29 · 05/06/2023 17:19

Also. Presuming most people plan to buy before kids, if they can. Is it really smart to strap yourself in for 30-40 years of paying such ridiculously high debt off? Nobody is going to come and help you pay a mortgage that you’ve stretched yourself on throughout times of reduced income, maternity leave etc. Okay it’s a means to an end and you’ll own the house eventually but ultimately the bank still owns your house for most or all of your working life, when you’re actually supposed to enjoy life. Wages have stagnated for too long and house prices have climbed which means the current situation is untenable, with people forced to pay more than a thousand pounds each month for a tiny flat or house in possibly a poor condition that they’re going to outgrow soon. Supposing you can’t move because you’ve fallen into negative equity so not only now have you lost your deposit that you saved so hard for, but also have to find the legal fees to move on. Nobody advocates for the risks of buying property especially when you’re junior in the workforce and on low income. We are HA at the moment and although we would love to own our home it would reduce our fun and enjoyment of life. This is backwards.

OP posts:
tealsofas · 05/06/2023 17:15

Which lender will lend 8 times salary, never heard of a ratio that high?

None of them, that’s the point…

ton29 · 05/06/2023 17:14

Twiglets1 · 05/06/2023 17:06

Just move the 30-40 miles away to a cheaper area if you're that desperate for a 3 bed semi @ton29

We would then live near nobody we know and it would make costs ridiculous for getting to work

OP posts:
Twiglets1 · 05/06/2023 17:06

ton29 · 05/06/2023 16:06

Say it louder for the people at the back!

Just move the 30-40 miles away to a cheaper area if you're that desperate for a 3 bed semi @ton29

Swipe left for the next trending thread