Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I a Mooncup minger?

234 replies

MooncupMinger · 03/06/2023 19:48

I use a Mooncup (actually a Boots copy one, but that’s beside the point). When I empty it, I pour the contents into the loo, then wash it out in the bathroom sink next to the toilet. Whenever I wash it out I think to myself that DP would probably find it gross that I’m washing it out where he washes his face/brushes his teeth etc. He could also walk in at any second, as we never lock the bathroom door, so there’s always the fear that I’m going to be outed as a Mooncup minger. Tbh he might think it’s a non-event.

I COULD turn the other way and wash it out in the bath, but that seems a bit overkill. Also… what do people do in their downstairs loos (which I don’t have)?!

So…

YABU - you’re a minger and should wash it out in the bath.

YANBU - it’s a normal bodily function (/fluid 😂) and it’s fine to wash it out in the sink.

OP posts:
Barleymilk · 04/06/2023 08:35

Those of you who find themselves in a loo and no sink,and wipe their cup with tissue.You are inserting the cup with dirty fingers surely?
A flush at least disperses any toilet germs so perhaps is cleaner if there is no other option!

NorthWestThree · 04/06/2023 07:10

DinoDaddy · 03/06/2023 20:02

I clean mine by boiling it in a saucepan. I also cook food in said saucepain. Obviously I wash it in-between uses.

At the end of my cycle mine goes in the dishwasher 😂

Snoopsnoggysnog · 04/06/2023 07:08

FusionChefGeoff · 04/06/2023 00:37

I sometimes do the flush clean and I've never had an infection or anything untoward. We have an immune system and all sorts of clever defences to protect us from bacteria and so far they're all working well for me and @Barleymilk

I think everyone is going a tad over the top in their reactions!

Cannot get over people washing them in the loo. Do you also just wash your hands in there as well? 🤮
OP I don’t think it’s you that’s the Mooncup Minger!

mathanxiety · 04/06/2023 05:37

penni00 · 03/06/2023 21:09

The wash basin needs to be washed out after! Especially if people are using the plug and filling the basin up to wash their faces.

It's no worse than crusty toothpaste and dried spit in a sink.

There's no need to fill a sink to wash your face. In fact, you'll end up rinsing your face with soapy water if you wash that way.

mathanxiety · 04/06/2023 05:30

Hairbrushhandle · 03/06/2023 20:28

I am definitely not coordinated enough to hold a full cup of blood in one hand, try to get out a bottle in another, in a tiny cubicle without ending up looking like I've stayed a night at the hotel in The Shining. And I flood so I'd need to do it every half an hour/hour on my heavy days at work. I love the reusable idea of cups and have tried 4 brands now but just cannot get on with them at all.

Get the bottle out first and then tackle the mooncup..

mathanxiety · 04/06/2023 05:26

I'm wondering if there's such a thing as a downstairs loo that doesnt have a sink?

Fwiw - sink is fine.

Also, why not lock the bathroom door?

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 04/06/2023 04:48

They say to use vinegar to "sterilize" it.

If you boil natural latex rubber, it will disintegrate pretty quickly, which may be the reason why they say to use vinegar. No one would selling a product would give instructions certain to quickly destroy it.

Anyway, the important thing (for me):

I apologise for mocking women who boil their menstrual cups and more importantly I retract where I said that menstrual cups do not require sterilisation because many models of cup do require it. Follow your cup's instructions because a random poster on Mumsnet can sometimes be wrong.

Tampons still aren't sterile though.

BadNomad · 04/06/2023 04:29

That Keeper website hasn't been updated since 2014, so their cleaning advice (which sounds like it's from the 80s) is very out of date. They say to use vinegar to "sterilize" it. Might as well rub it with lemon juice and say a prayer.

Things have definitely changed over the past 20 years. They did use to think TSS wasn't possible with cups. Until it happened. It takes a while for these things to become apparent. There are some research reports that say cups might actually be a greater risk than tampons (especially if not cleaned properly). It is still quite rare, but with more people switching to cups, there will be more reports if people don't clean them properly.

Definitely don't use toilet water to rinse it. And if it falls in a public toilet replace it. 😬

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 04/06/2023 04:00

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 04/06/2023 03:42

Mine's a Mooncup from around 2003-4. I think they've sold out of that vintage.

A serious answer to your question is that Keeper make cups in both latex and silicone and recommend against boiling or sterilising either.

The Mooncup leaflet shown online is not the same as the leaflet that came with mine, which is probably in a box in my attic. Back when I bought mine, even Mooncup were pushing the reduced TSS risk argument, that's why I bought the damned thing: I would have bought a Keeper long before Mooncup came out but I'm allergic to latex. Websites are annoyingly easy to rewrite to erase inconvenient past statements.

<a class="break-all" href="https://web.archive.org/web/20080409223826/www.mooncup.co.uk/menstrual_cup_why_is_it_better.html" rel="nofollow" target="_blank">https://web.archive.org/web/20080409223826/www.mooncup.co.uk/menstrual_cup_why_is_it_better.html

In 2008 they had got as far as telling you to boil it, but were still saying "The Mooncup menstrual cup contains no bleaches, deodorisers or absorbency gels. It does not interfere with your healthy vaginal environment, nor has it been associated with toxic shock syndrome."

@BadNomad Thank you for bringing the updated information to my attention. I was still working on the outdated belief that menstrual cups don't increase TSS risk.

Mooncup Menstrual Cup

The Mooncup Menstrual cup is a healthy and environmentally friendly alternative to tampons. Discover why it is better than tampons

https://web.archive.org/web/20080409223826/http://www.mooncup.co.uk/menstrual_cup_why_is_it_better.html

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 04/06/2023 03:42

BadNomad · 04/06/2023 02:57

Mooncup and TSS - Boil or use sterilising solution or tablets after period
Rubycup and TSS - Boil, microwave or oven after period
Lunette and TSS - Boil after period
Pixie Cup and TSS - Boil or steam before and after period
Diva Cup and TSS - Boil after period

That's just some of the big brands. But maybe yours is special and carries no risk of TSS or need to be sterilised after. Maybe you should share what brand it is so everyone else here can save themselves the bother of having these extra steps.

Mine's a Mooncup from around 2003-4. I think they've sold out of that vintage.

A serious answer to your question is that Keeper make cups in both latex and silicone and recommend against boiling or sterilising either.

The Mooncup leaflet shown online is not the same as the leaflet that came with mine, which is probably in a box in my attic. Back when I bought mine, even Mooncup were pushing the reduced TSS risk argument, that's why I bought the damned thing: I would have bought a Keeper long before Mooncup came out but I'm allergic to latex. Websites are annoyingly easy to rewrite to erase inconvenient past statements.

Cleaning Your Cups – The Keeper Inc./Moon Cup Co.

https://keeper.com/learn-more-about-menstrual-cups/cleaning-your-cups

BadNomad · 04/06/2023 02:57

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 04/06/2023 02:36

Why do you think these products tell you to sterilize them?

They do? The leaflet for mine said that sterilisation was optional and it just needed a good clean. If yours says to sterilise, then probably best to do what it says and I won't laugh any more at you for doing so.

You can get TSS from menstrual cups. It tells you that on the packaging.

Again, not on my leaflet. Perhaps new evidence has emerged in the last 20 years.

There is no need to stick bedpans in the steriliser between patients because they're inert

If you are sharing a mooncup, then absolutely do sterilise it between users, to prevent possible spread of HPV or HIV. Sharing an item is not the same as one person using it and has a different set of risks attached. You cannot give HIV to yourself.

Mooncup and TSS - Boil or use sterilising solution or tablets after period
Rubycup and TSS - Boil, microwave or oven after period
Lunette and TSS - Boil after period
Pixie Cup and TSS - Boil or steam before and after period
Diva Cup and TSS - Boil after period

That's just some of the big brands. But maybe yours is special and carries no risk of TSS or need to be sterilised after. Maybe you should share what brand it is so everyone else here can save themselves the bother of having these extra steps.

Let’s talk about Toxic Shock Syndrome - Mooncup

Find out all about Toxic Shock Syndrome (TSS). We explore its causes, symptoms, risks, and whether you can get it from using a menstrual cup.

https://www.mooncup.co.uk/blog/toxic-shock-syndrome/

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 04/06/2023 02:45

Twenty years ago when I bought mine, it not only came without a requirement to sterilise, it came with an absorbant, germ-harbouring, porous, lint-shedding cotton bag.

soap messes with your vagina's pH

Yet the leaflet says to use soap. When you rinse it off with water, it's gone and cannot mess up your vaginal pH any more. That's kind of the point of rinsing.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 04/06/2023 02:36

BadNomad · 04/06/2023 02:12

Inert doesn't mean it can't transmit infection. Tampons aren't sterile, but we don't wash tampons with soapy water and leave them sitting for a month before using them again do we?
You can get TSS from menstrual cups. It tells you that on the packaging. You can get TSS from anything that sits in your vagina for a long period of time. And soap messes with your vagina's pH, which also increases your risk of infection. If you introduce bacteria into your vagina, that cup will provide it a nice oxygenated environment to help it breed.
Why do you think these products tell you to sterilize them? Why do you think they tell you to change/empty it every few hours? Then there are people here fishing them out of toilet bowls or rinsing them in toilet water then popping them back in!

But maybe you're right. I'll tell my hospital on Monday to throw away the Clinell and get some Dove in instead. There is no need to stick bedpans in the steriliser between patients because they're inert so soap and water is enough to stop the spread of infection.

Why do you think these products tell you to sterilize them?

They do? The leaflet for mine said that sterilisation was optional and it just needed a good clean. If yours says to sterilise, then probably best to do what it says and I won't laugh any more at you for doing so.

You can get TSS from menstrual cups. It tells you that on the packaging.

Again, not on my leaflet. Perhaps new evidence has emerged in the last 20 years.

There is no need to stick bedpans in the steriliser between patients because they're inert

If you are sharing a mooncup, then absolutely do sterilise it between users, to prevent possible spread of HPV or HIV. Sharing an item is not the same as one person using it and has a different set of risks attached. You cannot give HIV to yourself.

BadNomad · 04/06/2023 02:12

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 04/06/2023 01:33

Once more for the people who didn't read this the first time I posted it:

Tampons are not sterile.

If you think about how non-applicator tampons are wrapped, that wrapper is not airtight, so the tampon cannot possibly be sterile. Applicator tampons are not sterile either. The clue with those is that there is no "use by" date on the box. If you look at a box of sterile plasters, there's a "use by" date on the box, after which the manufacturer does not guarantee the integrity of the wrapper.

Yet the majority of tampon users do so with no problems, indicating that objects inserted into the vagina, even for protracted periods, need not be sterile to be safe. Yes, I know about toxic shock syndrome. TSS comes from your bacteria growing like weeds in amongst the cotton fibres, which make a perfect breeding ground once they've got damp and bloody inside your body. Your mooncup has no fibres, it's solid impermeable silicone. "Biologically inert" does not mean clean, it means that it does not react with your body's tissues. A tampon is not biologically inert because it absorbs your menses, which is a bodily tissue. Your mooncup absorbs nothing, which is why it does not encourage bacteria to grow. It is biological inertness, not sterility, that makes your mooncup safe to use and safer than tampons.

Inert doesn't mean it can't transmit infection. Tampons aren't sterile, but we don't wash tampons with soapy water and leave them sitting for a month before using them again do we?
You can get TSS from menstrual cups. It tells you that on the packaging. You can get TSS from anything that sits in your vagina for a long period of time. And soap messes with your vagina's pH, which also increases your risk of infection. If you introduce bacteria into your vagina, that cup will provide it a nice oxygenated environment to help it breed.
Why do you think these products tell you to sterilize them? Why do you think they tell you to change/empty it every few hours? Then there are people here fishing them out of toilet bowls or rinsing them in toilet water then popping them back in!

But maybe you're right. I'll tell my hospital on Monday to throw away the Clinell and get some Dove in instead. There is no need to stick bedpans in the steriliser between patients because they're inert so soap and water is enough to stop the spread of infection.

Mamai90 · 04/06/2023 02:04

You've read my mind!

I've tried a soft cup a few times and I think it's totally gross cleaning it where people brush their teeth but I've done it and thought if DH saw that he'd be sick! It's one of the things that really puts me off using one.

LordSalem · 04/06/2023 02:01

I soak and wash the hamsters cage tubes in the kitchen sink then anti bac/bleach it thoroughly twice afterwards before dishes go in the following day. Bottle brush, sponge and tea towel all designated separately and washed or disposed of.
Period blood in a bathroom sink is no worse than washing your hands after a poo. You wash your hands afterwards? Soap or anti bac hand wash goes in the sink and down the same drain.
Think what goes into washing machines all the time. And pet bedding. But once things come out and dry we treat it all as clean.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 04/06/2023 01:37

"Biologically inert" does not mean clean

Nor does it mean sterile.

WiggyClawsThe2nd · 04/06/2023 01:36

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 04/06/2023 01:33

Once more for the people who didn't read this the first time I posted it:

Tampons are not sterile.

If you think about how non-applicator tampons are wrapped, that wrapper is not airtight, so the tampon cannot possibly be sterile. Applicator tampons are not sterile either. The clue with those is that there is no "use by" date on the box. If you look at a box of sterile plasters, there's a "use by" date on the box, after which the manufacturer does not guarantee the integrity of the wrapper.

Yet the majority of tampon users do so with no problems, indicating that objects inserted into the vagina, even for protracted periods, need not be sterile to be safe. Yes, I know about toxic shock syndrome. TSS comes from your bacteria growing like weeds in amongst the cotton fibres, which make a perfect breeding ground once they've got damp and bloody inside your body. Your mooncup has no fibres, it's solid impermeable silicone. "Biologically inert" does not mean clean, it means that it does not react with your body's tissues. A tampon is not biologically inert because it absorbs your menses, which is a bodily tissue. Your mooncup absorbs nothing, which is why it does not encourage bacteria to grow. It is biological inertness, not sterility, that makes your mooncup safe to use and safer than tampons.

Hear hear.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 04/06/2023 01:33

BadNomad · 04/06/2023 00:17

There is a difference between "clean" and "sterile". Clean just means free of dirt. Sterile means free of bacteria. You want anything you put in your vagina for a prolonged period of time to be free of bacteria.

Once more for the people who didn't read this the first time I posted it:

Tampons are not sterile.

If you think about how non-applicator tampons are wrapped, that wrapper is not airtight, so the tampon cannot possibly be sterile. Applicator tampons are not sterile either. The clue with those is that there is no "use by" date on the box. If you look at a box of sterile plasters, there's a "use by" date on the box, after which the manufacturer does not guarantee the integrity of the wrapper.

Yet the majority of tampon users do so with no problems, indicating that objects inserted into the vagina, even for protracted periods, need not be sterile to be safe. Yes, I know about toxic shock syndrome. TSS comes from your bacteria growing like weeds in amongst the cotton fibres, which make a perfect breeding ground once they've got damp and bloody inside your body. Your mooncup has no fibres, it's solid impermeable silicone. "Biologically inert" does not mean clean, it means that it does not react with your body's tissues. A tampon is not biologically inert because it absorbs your menses, which is a bodily tissue. Your mooncup absorbs nothing, which is why it does not encourage bacteria to grow. It is biological inertness, not sterility, that makes your mooncup safe to use and safer than tampons.

DiscoBeat · 04/06/2023 01:30

I've never used one but if I did I would use the sink then clean it afterwards.

Legoandloldolls · 04/06/2023 01:26

If its good enough for the MN loobrush.....

EBearhug · 04/06/2023 01:24

I don't have a dishwasher, so I always forget that option.

Legoandloldolls · 04/06/2023 01:23

EBearhug · 04/06/2023 01:17

How do you propose I sterilise my husband's penis?

Scrub it well with neat Dettol, then immerse in boiling water for at least 10 minutes.

Dishwasher on a hot cycle surely?

EBearhug · 04/06/2023 01:17

How do you propose I sterilise my husband's penis?

Scrub it well with neat Dettol, then immerse in boiling water for at least 10 minutes.

elm26 · 04/06/2023 01:03

Sink here too, with warm water.

If I'm in public I pour down the toilet then use some bottled tap water to rinse, if I forget the water I always carry a small pack of femfresh wipes in my handbag so can wipe with those.