Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Another person killed by one of these dogs

245 replies

Schooldinners1 · 03/06/2023 19:11

When will people stop getting these dogs?

There have been so many stories of it going horribly wrong. I don’t know what people are thinking! Especially with vulnerable people in the property like kids and elderly people.

There are hundreds of dogs out there! Why choose to get these dogs that have a history of being unstable.

Its awful!

ARTICLE

Savage dog mauls elderly woman to death: Cops arrest man and woman

The horror savaging happened while the woman in her 70s was lying on a sun lounger at home in Bedworth, Warwickshire, at 3.50pm on Friday.

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12155105/Woman-Pensioner-Mauled-Death-Control-Banned-Breed-Dog-Bedworth-Warwickshire.html

OP posts:
Thelnebriati · 05/06/2023 23:51

Some breeds shouldn't be owned by anyone that doesn't have a dog handlers licence, and all dog owners should have third party insurance.

OutIander · 05/06/2023 23:39

We ban all breeds that are capable of mauling a child. Mauling. Not biting. It really is that easy. No one's desire to own a dangerous breed should come above our rights to walk safely around town or in the park.

Conkersinautumn · 05/06/2023 22:24

It's obvious some people do not have the skills to care for a dog adequately as this one was kept in a too small space with very little exercise. I know the area well and there are plenty of places to really exercise and stimulate a dog moments from that road. A dog licence would only be useful if owners had to demonstrate competency in adequate care.

Wildflowersinthemeadow · 05/06/2023 21:51

But @WiddlinDiddlin , you haven’t put forward anything I can see that is actually going to stop people being killed by dogs. I really don’t want to appear argumentative here - I don’t think anyone is ‘wahey’ about it at all - but we do ban things that impede on public safety. We have to. I fully accept that this doesn’t make the public safe, but safer is a start.

I don’t see it as shutting the stable door after the horse has bolted, particularly. More that maybe we’ve lost a few horses, but we can stop the rest getting out.

WiddlinDiddlin · 05/06/2023 21:44

So we ban this breed and then wait until things get so bad, and there are multiple deaths attributed to another breed... and then ban that one... and never look forward or take action to stop that cycle?

Thats what I am saying - we need to prevent deaths, breed bans are shutting the stable door after the horse has bolted.

We do need to do something, ASAP, we needed to do it 20+ (I am refusing to admit how long ago 1991 actually was!) years ago.

But the answer is not (or not just) doing the same thing we've done before, and expecting a different result.

Public focus is on the breed, we ban the breed, public all cheer, wahey, got rid of the nasty dogs, great, problem solved.

And then public pressure is off government, the demand for 'something to be done' is over, something has now been done, so they can sit back and applaud themselves that they've done a useful thing, the public approve, how marvellous.

And people are still at risk, a risk that increases each year as breeds evolve, it's not been stopped at all its just put the brake on it a bit.

Breed bans are an illusion of safety and action. They're also fucking expensive for the taxpayer but we're shafted every which way anyway there.

They are not effective at actually removing dangerous breeds from the population.

They're not effective at actually preventing the real problem - dog attacks on people.

Wildflowersinthemeadow · 05/06/2023 20:48

No, we’re not seeing deaths from Labradors. When ten deaths in eighteen months are attributed to Labs, I’ll be the first to support further action. Fair?

Or honestly, are you arguing that because there are poorly bred Labs, no further action should be taken against the breeds that are killing people? I honestly don’t really understand the point you’re trying to make.

Wildflowersinthemeadow · 05/06/2023 20:46

@Elysiaxo (I realise you weren’t replying to me) but I do think there is a steadfast refusal to see things, there always is. People insist men are as much victims of domestic abuse as women (no, they are not) that white people are also victims of racism, and so on. It is almost like a weird extension of that, where to ‘demonise’ certain breeds is almost akin to a dog racism and we must pipe up with ‘but spaniels! / I know some nasty Yorkies / my neighbours chihuahua is awful!’

WiddlinDiddlin · 05/06/2023 20:42

Labradors due to their popularity, are increasingly suffering with poor temperament. Puppy farming breeders are producing bigger, heavier dogs with shockingly poor hips and elbows and of course pain also increases the chances of aggressive behaviour. Add in shit temperament to their generally over enthusiastic nature and poor social skills...

Labs are also bred to want to hold things in their mouths, grab stuff, hang on, keep hold of it.

Add to that labradors have a reputation for being easy going, good with the kids, excellent family dog (ooh does this sound familiar...) that barely need any training....

These factors mean that trainers like me are seeing more and more dodgy labradors who are very willing to bite people, very willing to approach strangers and their dogs and start fights.

We're not seeing deaths from labradors YET - but we could, easily, if they were the breed the 'I want a dangerous dog' brigade were pushed or encouraged to get. Breed them a bit bigger, select for the bitey guardy behaviour more and more... if you read what I actually said, again - we could be just a couple of generations away from dangerous Labradors (and other breeds, I don't want to pick on just labs!)

I've worked with a LOT of retrievers, mostly labs and goldens - believe me when I say, their temperament has been steadily worsening over the last twenty years and I have worked with MANY owners whose dogs have bitten them and others, including several sustained attacks (mostly rooted in resource guarding and fear, but poor genetics are the ultimate root cause).

AMonthOfSundaes · 05/06/2023 20:36

ItS nOt The brEEd iTs thE oWneR.

I think there might be something up with your caps lock. Maybe a reboot?

Chispazo · 05/06/2023 20:25

So stupid, labradors never turn on their owners

Elysiaxo · 05/06/2023 20:15

OutIander · 05/06/2023 20:06

Go watch some videos on fb groups abd pages such as Dog Bite Awareness. Many instances of dogs coming out of nowhere and attacking random people. The fact you don’t know this shows me how clueless you are. Embarrassed for you.

You think you know more than someone who works with dogs because you've watched a few fb videos? 😂 Embarrassed for you.

OutIander · 05/06/2023 20:06

WiddlinDiddlin · 05/06/2023 19:11

@OutIander "You really are the problem if these are your solutions. Pitbulls and their ilk attack our of nowhere. Watch the videos. They are out of control vile beasts and no amount of human training will save innocent people. They need to be totally wiped off the face of the earth. It really is simple. Them and rottweilers, huskies, Akitas, etc. No need for any of those breeds."

Ah. Yeah. And your experience in working with dogs and studying dog behaviour is what? Oh, garnered from the Daily Mail and similarly sensible, reliable sources.

On the other hand I have worked with plenty - no dog, literally no breed of dog just 'attacks out of nowhere', dogs are incredibly predictable on the whole though some are easier to read than others.

You keep peddling myths though, it appears to make you very happy.

Go watch some videos on fb groups abd pages such as Dog Bite Awareness. Many instances of dogs coming out of nowhere and attacking random people. The fact you don’t know this shows me how clueless you are. Embarrassed for you.

Wildflowersinthemeadow · 05/06/2023 19:48

@WiddlinDiddlin I don’t have a ‘desire to ban breeds’; I DO have a desire to reduce the number of deaths. I do think that’s a bit of a goady statement, to be honest, as if my ultimate aim is to rid the country of dogs I personally dislike.

In the wrong hands, with the wrong breeding, and active training to create a dangerous dog, any dog over around 25kg and with a average to slightly wider than average head could kill.

Right. Except they don’t. Funny, that.

In the last thirty years, we have had sixty three deaths.

Our of those sixty three, breeds involved (some cases involved more than one dog)

Five Alsatians
One Alsatian X Chow Chow
Fifty five bull breeds (including SBT, PBT, American bulldogs and XL Bullies.)
Eight Rottweilers
One Cane Corso (and one crossed with a bulldog included above)
Two JRTs
One Lakeland cross
One Doberman
One husky

So sure people will leap on the JRT attacks (one of which was with a SBT) and the Lakeland attack - but I’m not seeing much evidence of these fragile humans slaughtered by spaniels and Labs and so on. No matter how much people push this idea that all dogs are equally dangerous, the actual fatalities just don’t support that.

WiddlinDiddlin · 05/06/2023 19:11

@OutIander "You really are the problem if these are your solutions. Pitbulls and their ilk attack our of nowhere. Watch the videos. They are out of control vile beasts and no amount of human training will save innocent people. They need to be totally wiped off the face of the earth. It really is simple. Them and rottweilers, huskies, Akitas, etc. No need for any of those breeds."

Ah. Yeah. And your experience in working with dogs and studying dog behaviour is what? Oh, garnered from the Daily Mail and similarly sensible, reliable sources.

On the other hand I have worked with plenty - no dog, literally no breed of dog just 'attacks out of nowhere', dogs are incredibly predictable on the whole though some are easier to read than others.

You keep peddling myths though, it appears to make you very happy.

WiddlinDiddlin · 05/06/2023 19:06

But if you keep banning breeds and the death rate still goes up, apart from satisfying your desire to ban breeds, what have you achieved?

If the goal is to reduce or indeed halt, death by dog - then that fails (as it already has done).

In the wrong hands, with the wrong breeding, and active training to create a dangerous dog, any dog over around 25kg and with a average to slightly wider than average head could kill. Humans are really spectactularly fragile creatures and a dog that gets a grip around your neck can kill you even if its so small you could fight it off.

We could easily see killer Labradors, Golden retrievers, Border Collies within a few generations.

So then what, eradicate all dogs - never going to happen no matter how much some people would want it.

CrossBun · 05/06/2023 17:24

So after five, ten years the death rate goes up again and it’s a different breed this time - ban that breed. You won’t hear an argument from me.

It’s not even that different, they were created from Pit Bulls which are already banned.

Mollyplop999 · 05/06/2023 13:22

NOTANUM my thoughts exactly! I've got a good bruise and very swollen arm today.

Wildflowersinthemeadow · 05/06/2023 12:35

I think we know what WiddlinDiddlin is saying; we just don’t agree.

We don’t say ‘we need to stop people wanting to speed’ with no sanctions for speeding.

Trust me, I am all for improving peoples life chances and improving peoples lives in a more general sense, but this is something that is deeply rooted in a complex myriad of issues and can’t be resolved in the short or even quite long term, even if anyone had the will to take the bull by the horns.

So after five, ten years the death rate goes up again and it’s a different breed this time - ban that breed. You won’t hear an argument from me.

CrossBun · 05/06/2023 12:27

Oops sorry for all the typos was rushing.

RightWhereYouLeftMe · 05/06/2023 12:25

megletthesecond · 05/06/2023 12:08

I saw a horrible XL bully being 'walked' by a 6ft bloke who looked like he went to the gym too many muscles type idiot and even he couldn't control it when it lunged. The only time I've been scared by a dog and had something in my hand in case it came towards me.

I always wonder why people would think these dogs make them look tough. Being dragged along by your dog that you can't control makes you look anything but tough.

megletthesecond · 05/06/2023 12:08

I saw a horrible XL bully being 'walked' by a 6ft bloke who looked like he went to the gym too many muscles type idiot and even he couldn't control it when it lunged. The only time I've been scared by a dog and had something in my hand in case it came towards me.

CrossBun · 05/06/2023 12:04

I heard a woman on LBC radio this morning from a charity saying that they are getting a lot of calls from distressed people about Bully XLs something like 20 a week (or was it a day?). She was saying the typical call is from someone who has got their new XL home and it’s started growling at their children and they’re scared and don’t k or what to do.

So the charity has to arrange to collect the dog. Also vets who are being asked to put them down but scared to go bear them.

OutIander · 05/06/2023 11:47

Thelnebriati · 05/06/2023 11:12

What WiddlinDiddlin is saying is that the law not being enforced isn't the problem.
Its the desire to own any a dog for the purposes of intimidation that is the problem. If its not bull breeds it will be another type of dog. If chihuahuas were causing deaths, there's a group of people who would rush straight out and buy a chihuahua.
Breed bans can't fix this underlying problem. We need another approach altogether.

We just keep banning those breeds, keep on at it. Repeat offenders get jail time.

Thelnebriati · 05/06/2023 11:15

I can't find a link but a few decades ago Belgium passed a law to say that if you wanted to take your dog into a city centre, you had to train it to a certain certified standard.
One problem with this is you need to stop the inevitable rush of self styled dog trainers who will cash in on this kind of scheme.
But introducing behavioural/training certificates for specific situations and then widening their scope would be a start.

Swipe left for the next trending thread