Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say I was genuinely happier before I have children

308 replies

Licinada · 03/06/2023 16:34

All I ever wanted in life was to be a Mum. I was so excited when I got pregnant.
I have one child and expecting another in September.
My Husband wanted children too. After the first I was hesitant to have another but thought it best they had a sibling for company. I will have no more after this one.

Now I am not a stressed out depressed Mum. My life is fine as it is. My Husband is amazing.

BUT I have to admit. I was happier before I had children. I am sure for most while they’d say parenting can be hard the benefits outweigh the negatives or hard times.
But for me if I’d actually known what was involved in parenting I’d have remained childfree and chosen a life partner who also didn’t want children. I quite admire people who know they don’t want children so don’t have them. I wonder how some people who have never had children know it’s not for them and others only find that out after the event.
I adore my Son and it’s odd as I’d never not want him now he’s here. I think I’m a good Mum and he is loved and well looked after. But had I known what parenting was all about it’s not a path I would have chosen.

For me I think it’s the peace of mind of only having to think of, be responsible for and look after yourself. It’s such an amazing freeing experience for me. To only have to worry about yourself. Obviously you have to consider adult loved ones but that’s different.
I greatly enjoyed (although I didn’t appreciate it at the time) how freeing and settling only having to think of myself was.
Bringing up another human being and being responsible for their physical and mental health is a HUGE responsibility.

One I was genuinely happier before I had.

So is this a terrible attitude for a Mother to have?

OP posts:
Newbie198 · 03/06/2023 19:09

@AndIKnewYouMeantIt
Yes, I would agree that at 38 you can, and should in my opinion, not share certain things with parents as far as possible. My mum at 80 does not know about a minor op I’m having next week for example.

The OPs point still stands, about younger children especially. You can’t possibly hide some things from parents if you’re 13 for example. So the mental load and responsibility is unavoidable. Neither can you hide something like terminal cancer from a parent even in you’re 40s. Someone in my family cannot possibly hide the fact they’re having chemo from their mum.

That’s the OPs point I think, it must be lovely to not worry, but sadly these things are often unavoidable and the risks are always there if you’re a parent.

ContinuousProcrastination · 03/06/2023 19:08

I think the idea that you are totally free of responsibilities towards others purely by being childfree is depressing and not really the whole point of being human Confused

We are social creatures who have evolved and survived by living in groups where we depend on and support others. We care for the elderly, we pass on skills to the young, we support friends and neighbours.

I would not consider myself free of social and community responsibilities and obligations whether i had children or not.

GeriKellmansUpdo · 03/06/2023 19:02

Fair enough. I hear you on the drudgery. I hate cooking. Now DC cook their own meals and it is GREAT. Often not v healthy ones, but I don't care.

BHRK · 03/06/2023 19:02

I hear you 100%. I wouldn’t change it but I hear you!

SaveMeFromForearms · 03/06/2023 19:01

Yeah you're right @GeriKellmansUpdo it's not all boring. But the drudgery part never ends. If I didn't have kids I would never cook tea; I would do one or two loads of washing a week; I'd never have to sit through a bloody pantomime or ballet or nativity ever again where my kids were barely visible from my seat.

That's the kind of boredom I'm talking about.

GeriKellmansUpdo · 03/06/2023 18:59

@SaveMeFromForearms I didn't find it two decades of boredom honestly. Maybe about 5 to 6 years of boredom with each child? When they started to read and talk and go to school, I found it quite interesting.

AndIKnewYouMeantIt · 03/06/2023 18:58

HamBone · 03/06/2023 17:56

OP, every one says it don’t they ‘You are only as happy as your saddest child’ or something like that.

@Newbie198 Genuine question, I’m not being goady, but how do you and your Mum know how happy/unhappy your children are?

My Dad (85) has no knowledge of my problems, because I don’t share them with him, haven’t for decades. I speak to him every day, but I don’t burden him with anything, because I don’t want to worry him. My IL’s don’t know about DH’s problems either.

Do older adult children really share their problems with their parents or are we the anomaly? I can understand young adults under 30 doing it perhaps.

Nope. Didn't tell any of our parents when we were struggling to conceive. Didn't tell my parents when I was under threat of redundancy and certainly did not tell them about a particular tough patch in our marriage that was depression-related.

My parents don't worry about me either. I'm 38 with a house, husband, son, no debt etc. I'd think they were batty if they told me they were worrying constantly about things like car crashes and cancer.

SaveMeFromForearms · 03/06/2023 18:57

VinoVeritas1 · 03/06/2023 18:26

It’s hard to begin with but as they get older you get happier seeing them develop & reaping the benefits of family life. You’ve also got to think of them in terms of the long game. Would you be happy reaching, say 60 and regretting not having them? I know quite a few women who chose not to have children because they didn’t want to go through the grind of the little years but now they’re older and are seeing the richness having a family can bring they’re deeply regretting their decision

This is what I can't see at the moment; do the hard moments and days mean I'll wake up at 60 going 'well the two decades of boredom mixed with moments of joy and terror were totally worth it'.

ReachForTheMars · 03/06/2023 18:56

Licinada · 03/06/2023 16:54

Thank you. This is how I feel.
I am certainly not unhappy being a Mother. I don’t find Motherhood particularly stressful either.
I was just happier before I had children.

I don't really understand why you had two with such a big age gap if we are having an open conversation.

I found having a child harder than I thought I would, I'm not as patient or fun as I thought I would be, so I'm sticking with 1 one. If I'm brutally honest, and this is bot a dog at you, it's because I think my child deserves the best and I'm already struggling and I dont want to do that to number 2 or stretch myself thinner for 1.

Mine is currently 8. I have time for 2 if I change my mind. Why did you change yours at age 11?

AAAAABBBBBCCCCC · 03/06/2023 18:49

Mum of 5,with no family around,all kids home ed/no nurseries and 2 are disabled and can not understand you at all

And? This isn't about you understanding the OP. This is about the OP, and about her being happier, pre-kids.

GeriKellmansUpdo · 03/06/2023 18:48

Hey @janeseymour78 I have written 3 non-fiction books since I was 40 and am writing my fourth. They are niche books, but they are traditionally published. I have two DC. You don't have to give up on writing and your sense of self if you have DC, though you may have to pause ( depending on circs).

GeriKellmansUpdo · 03/06/2023 18:45

I don't think there is a magic bullet for a regret-free life. Human nature being what it is, it is natural to wonder "What if?"

My DD has just sent me a funny meme and a thank you for cooking for her during her very stressful uni exams, and honestly, I suddenly feel on top of the world!

janeseymour78 · 03/06/2023 18:44

I found your post very interesting @StrawberryWasp. I'm in my early 30s and one of these people with a calling or 'talent'. After the end of my last relationship I stayed single and focused on writing my novel and guess what? My first novel will be published next year. Its been my dream since childhood.

Now I find myself at a crossroads. I get so much fulfillment from following this dream and I worry that having a child will mean I have to drop it. I think that would destroy me and my sense of self.

On the other hand, I think I'd be a good mother although I know things would never be the same. OP you've taken a bit of bashing, but I'm glad you posted this. It's an honest thing to express and I'm sure others have similar thoughts.

Crikeyalmighty · 03/06/2023 18:44

Funnily enough I disagree with the first 5 years being hard work but then our son is an only one- teenage years were in our case way more challenging

MumblesParty · 03/06/2023 18:41

Wildflowersinthemeadow · 03/06/2023 18:40

@PinkRiceKrispies that’s great but it isn’t what I was saying.

When people look back and lament the life they had before children, they often don’t seem to realise the life they had before children would not have looked the same, children or otherwise, five, ten, twenty years later. A forty three year old me without children would not have the same life twenty eight year old me had, that’s true of everybody.

Everyone should ideally make a choice they are content with, but looking back to what life was will never really give you a true picture because whether you have children or not that life will naturally move on from what it was.

This is exactly what I was trying to say. It’s comparing apples with oranges.

Wildflowersinthemeadow · 03/06/2023 18:40

@PinkRiceKrispies that’s great but it isn’t what I was saying.

When people look back and lament the life they had before children, they often don’t seem to realise the life they had before children would not have looked the same, children or otherwise, five, ten, twenty years later. A forty three year old me without children would not have the same life twenty eight year old me had, that’s true of everybody.

Everyone should ideally make a choice they are content with, but looking back to what life was will never really give you a true picture because whether you have children or not that life will naturally move on from what it was.

MysteryBelle · 03/06/2023 18:38

🙄

theculture · 03/06/2023 18:38

I don't feel like you but I had my children late, after many fun years of socialising and then slowly watching all my friends leave me behind while settling down and having kids so I was quite ready for a new stage in my life

Being an older parent has downsides too though so I don't think there is any magic bullet that can make being responsible for creating new humans an easy task!

MumblesParty · 03/06/2023 18:37

KimberleyClark · 03/06/2023 18:13

I can assure you that most people who haven't had children, for whatever reason, don't feel their lives are boring and pointless.

Argh I knew someone would misinterpret that. The point I’m making is that no one knows how they’d feel if their life hadn’t gone the way it did. I could think I was happier living in a city like I did when I was younger, compared to how I feel now, living in the countryside. But all I’ve got to compare it with is how I felt then. I don’t know how I’d feel now if I lived in a city.

continentallentil · 03/06/2023 18:36

FarmGirl78 · 03/06/2023 17:20

That’s a HUGE task. One I would never have chosen to take on.

But you did choose to take that on.

I was desperate to be a Mother but never got to be. I'd fully realised that was the world's biggest responsibility which I'd have to step up to massively, and I was ready to take on that responsibility even though it would mean me coming second in my own life and generally being under the cosh for the next however many years with the drudge of making packed lunches while worrying about that girl in the playground being ever so slightly mean to my imaginary 8 year old. And you appear to have just willy nilly ACTIVELY chosen to be a parent without thinking of the actual reality. I know you're probably a very nice decent person, and I know I'm definitely being very unreasonable, but your choice of words here has made me absolutely seething. Unless your child is severely disabled or terminally ill etc you DID chose the life you have. I wanted your responsible parent life but COULDN'T choose it. You COULD AND DID.

Erm, I’m really sorry you didn’t get to be a mother when you wanted to be, but IME you cannot know how you will find being a parent until you are - I can think of people who were deeply ambivalent who love it, and people who really wanted it (I mean rounds of IVF wanted it) who find really tough and not something they’d have done had they known how they would respond. Also everything in between obviously.

There’s no reason to think the OP isn’t a good parent, but she feels how she feels. Being able to break the taboo and speak honestly about parenthood and specifically motherhood can only be a good thing.

GeriKellmansUpdo · 03/06/2023 18:35

For the introverts on this thread who struggle with not having solitude or time for quiet contemplation, mine are now young adults and I have tons of solitude!
It comes around quicker than you can imagine. This weekend for instance, all 4 of us are doing different things with different friends( though we are reuniting for dinner).

filingmonotype · 03/06/2023 18:35

This is a very interesting thread to follow. We are in our mid-30s and decided a while ago not to have children. I was always ambivalent about it - there are times when I feel I would love to be a parent. But my wife is quite firmly against it, and has even had to deal with family calling her selfish for not wanting to have children, which I think is unreasonable.

I think it's very brave of the OP to admit that she feels less happy since becoming a parent. It's a perspective that we seldom hear because societally, women are expected to be maternal and to enjoy being mothers. Once you have children, you can't undo that decision and to even have thoughts about it seems to be taboo in our society, which I don't feel it should be.

I've accepted my wife's decision to not have children as it frees her from any regret that she may have chosen a path that wasn't entirely right for her, as OP has phrased it. I think it's important to respect every individual's feelings about parenthood regardless of whether or not they decide to have children.

Moveoverdarlin · 03/06/2023 18:34

I agree. Struggled for years to conceive. Eventually had 2 and I was by far and away happier before. I love them but I feel I have completely lost my life. Since becoming a mother I am this new person who never has fun, I dedicate my whole life to them. It’s relentless …People saying it gets better as they get older are encouraging but I think by then I’ll too old to do the things I used to do.

PinkRiceKrispies · 03/06/2023 18:33

@Wildflowersinthemeadow I am late thirties and single. No different to when I was in my early twenties and single. Never wanted kids but you dont need a partner to complete you. 🙄
I never have wanted kids. Pregnancy, labour, the worry, the lack of sleep and freedom as well as the way the world is right now. I remain very strong in my decision and glad I didn't just have kids for the sake of it being something I felt I had to do.

LakieLady · 03/06/2023 18:32

thecatsmeows · 03/06/2023 17:58

I'm nearly 55, don't have children, and never wanted children. I've been asked many times how did I always know (from age 9) that I didn't want children and it's a hard one to answer...I just KNEW. I imagine it's probably pretty much like being gay...for some people (like my best friend) it's just something they've always known, they never even considered they may not be. I also knew from my own personal experience (my father never wanted children and my mother made it pretty clear she regretted having them) that if I did do it, to make someone else happy or because it was 'expected' I'd be being very selfish and unfair on the child.

I consider myself very lucky, because I think having a child and realising you regret it/were happier before you did - and that feeling never going away - must be very difficult to live with.

I was the same, @thecatsmeows , although (according to DM) I announced this when I was 5 or 6. I wanted dogs instead, apparently, and that's what I had.

I actually find babies and small children dull, although I find them progressively more interesting as they get older and actually like teenagers. I would gladly have adopted my DNiece when she was a teen, and there were times when I think her mother would gladly have let me!