Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say I was genuinely happier before I have children

308 replies

Licinada · 03/06/2023 16:34

All I ever wanted in life was to be a Mum. I was so excited when I got pregnant.
I have one child and expecting another in September.
My Husband wanted children too. After the first I was hesitant to have another but thought it best they had a sibling for company. I will have no more after this one.

Now I am not a stressed out depressed Mum. My life is fine as it is. My Husband is amazing.

BUT I have to admit. I was happier before I had children. I am sure for most while they’d say parenting can be hard the benefits outweigh the negatives or hard times.
But for me if I’d actually known what was involved in parenting I’d have remained childfree and chosen a life partner who also didn’t want children. I quite admire people who know they don’t want children so don’t have them. I wonder how some people who have never had children know it’s not for them and others only find that out after the event.
I adore my Son and it’s odd as I’d never not want him now he’s here. I think I’m a good Mum and he is loved and well looked after. But had I known what parenting was all about it’s not a path I would have chosen.

For me I think it’s the peace of mind of only having to think of, be responsible for and look after yourself. It’s such an amazing freeing experience for me. To only have to worry about yourself. Obviously you have to consider adult loved ones but that’s different.
I greatly enjoyed (although I didn’t appreciate it at the time) how freeing and settling only having to think of myself was.
Bringing up another human being and being responsible for their physical and mental health is a HUGE responsibility.

One I was genuinely happier before I had.

So is this a terrible attitude for a Mother to have?

OP posts:
MumblesParty · 03/06/2023 19:48

Licinada · 03/06/2023 19:37

Thank you. This sums up how I feel exactly.

But OP, what people are trying to tell you but you’re not understanding, is that maintaining the status quo was never an option.

I sometimes drive past my old student house and think how happy and easy life was then, and for a moment I can wish I hadn’t had kids, promotion, bigger house, bigger bills etc. But even if I hadn’t studied and moved and had kids and so on…..even if I’d stayed child free living in that exact same house….my life still wouldn’t be as it was then. Time passes, things change, we will never recapture our youth whether we have kids or not.

if you’d stayed child free you may have been happier than you are now, but you certainly wouldn’t be the way you were 15 years ago. That’s why it’s not a valid comparison.

holaholiday · 03/06/2023 19:47

I think it may be down to the fact that you felt “all I ever wanted in life was to be a mum”…it sounds like you had unrealistic expectations about being a mum that in reality haven’t been matched. I would also challenge the assumption that you should ever have kids to make you happy….rewarding,life enhancing ,life changing and expanding yes but happiness is a transitory state and I don’t think any parent always has continual happiness from having kids .isn’t parenthood about different things at different stages in life and perhaps you should be looking at other things outside from your relationship with your children to improve your contentment in life? If you hadn’t been able to have kids you might equally writing about the opposite scenario in not being able to appreciate the life you have. I hear you about the feeling of unending responsibility for another life but I think I kind of knew what aspects I would struggle with before I ever had kids as I’m not a natural “mother” but I still wouldn’t change the experience of having a family.

70sTomboy · 03/06/2023 19:47

YANU, you can still appreciate your kids and still mourn an older time when life was freely enjoyable.

I had no experience of small children or babies. I was in the youngest group of relatives. I had never picked up a child, babysat, etc. I had an idealistic view of what family life would be like. I was persuaded against my better judgement to have more as it would 'get easier ', 'its a phase,' etc. I HATED IT.
I honestly can't see what anyone can see as enjoyable.

I was told I had PND/PSTD from the births, but if so, 30 odd years later, I must still have it.
I would have financially been better off, my health better.
Whilst I do love my kids, I will admit life without drudge was easier.

IsGoodIsDon · 03/06/2023 19:44

I feel the same OP. And I can’t really see a time when it will get better my eldest is 12 and youngest is 6 and my life is so unrecognisable. By the time they are grown up my life as I knew it will be a distant memory.
parenting just takes so much from you and it gets harder not easier. I found the baby years easier as they didn’t really have any demands other than being fed, changed and loved. They went where I went, no school commitments or homework, no sports or clubs to go to. No troubles with friends or bullying to worry about. It just gets harder and more exhausting mentally and physically. And I’m pretty sure I would make different decisions if I had my time again.

Cakeandcardio · 03/06/2023 19:43

I have one whom I adore to pieces. And I still absolutely hear you. There's something brilliant about just looking after yourself and you don't ever get it back once you become a parent. It's just really really hard.

nhsometime · 03/06/2023 19:42

It's tough. Mine are 2 1/2 and 1 year old. During the week, they don't want to get up for nursery.

On the weekend, they wake up between 5 and 6 😱

I am still so happy I have them and I consider myself extremely blessed to have the opportunity to be a mother.

My life definitely improved after having children and I feel more complete now.

I realise this is not how everyone feels, but that's okay.

Your feelings are valid and totally understandable. But you might not feel like this in a few years time when they are a bit older.

BadNomad · 03/06/2023 19:42

Your reason for having a second child now doesn't really make sense. When new baby is the age your first child is now, your first child will be in their early 20s and likely away living their life. With an 11-year age gap they're both pretty much going to feel like only children.

Anyway, most people who knew they ddin't want children knew it because they didn't experience this "All I ever wanted in life was to be a Mum."

Licinada · 03/06/2023 19:37

Unicorn2022 · 03/06/2023 17:52

I tried for many years to have children and had a very stressful journey and many losses.

I now have several children and completely agree with you OP - I was happier before children. I wish I'd realised how good my life was before children, and how much better it is when your life is completely your own. It's one of those things where you don't know how good you had it until it's gone. I can't believe I used to complain about being tired and having no time before kids. It's not all bad of course, but the minuses certainly outweigh the plus points by some margin.

Thank you. This sums up how I feel exactly.

OP posts:
Unsure33 · 03/06/2023 19:34

Do you think some of the feeling is just because you were happier when you were younger ? Not just because of children ? Personally my happiest times were when the children were young . Now they have their own families I miss them a lot .

TiredyMcTired · 03/06/2023 19:34

I think in the very early days I probably was a bit depressed (was v stressed and worried about everything). But as my son got a bit older I have to say that I am way happier now than I was before. I really wanted to be a Mum, so I do think that this makes me content, that I’ve been able to have this experience when there were times I thought I couldn’t.

GeriKellmansUpdo · 03/06/2023 19:28

Riapia · 03/06/2023 19:27

You’re looking at things in the short term.
The first 35 years are bound to be difficult. Your DC’s will need help with the DGC’s and then of course the inevitable breakup of their marriage.

Things can sometimes improve later.
😉😁😁

😆😯

Riapia · 03/06/2023 19:27

You’re looking at things in the short term.
The first 35 years are bound to be difficult. Your DC’s will need help with the DGC’s and then of course the inevitable breakup of their marriage.

Things can sometimes improve later.
😉😁😁

firsttimemum1230 · 03/06/2023 19:22

I’m 28 had my child at 26 she is 18 months old and I had her with my partner who already had 3 others but only in contact with mine and his eldest.

i feel this. I adore my child and I remember being stood in my old job when I was pregnant thinking oh wow, this life will be over soon and a new one will be here. The only thing I don’t miss about my old life is my old job. 37.5 hours a week in a hca role. No thank you never again.

i however wish I just had more time for me. I wish I had more 1-1 time with my partner but it’s my family for support or nothing as his is non existent. I am fortunate in the fact I now work in a school and she is going childminders 4 days a week all
year round and will be until she goes to school. Without that and the holidays I think
my mental health/thought process would be where yours is. I know I may atill
feel
it when she’s older like yours are but I can’t wait till she’s talking to me wanting to
do things with me and just become
my best friend. I too also want another so she has a sibling from me but I’m not planning on it for 3/4 more years if at all.

what im trying to say is your feelings are validated and don’t listen to those who are bringing up infertility problems etc it’s not your life or your situation.

youe worrying will never end itll
jusf change! But your life will
come back!

HellfireClubSandwich · 03/06/2023 19:20

janeseymour78 · 03/06/2023 18:44

I found your post very interesting @StrawberryWasp. I'm in my early 30s and one of these people with a calling or 'talent'. After the end of my last relationship I stayed single and focused on writing my novel and guess what? My first novel will be published next year. Its been my dream since childhood.

Now I find myself at a crossroads. I get so much fulfillment from following this dream and I worry that having a child will mean I have to drop it. I think that would destroy me and my sense of self.

On the other hand, I think I'd be a good mother although I know things would never be the same. OP you've taken a bit of bashing, but I'm glad you posted this. It's an honest thing to express and I'm sure others have similar thoughts.

Just so you hear another perspective, I’m a writer, I did it around my full time job and did bits and bobs. I had my son and I have never had less time in my life - but I’ve been getting more successful with my writing (non-fiction) and I’m working on my first book. Yes it’s crazy hard but I love it and it’s my creative outlet as a mother. It’s absolutely possible, just recognise your expectations when you first have a child, don’t demand too much of yourself. I worked through the newborn days and wish I hadn’t.

You don’t have to lose yourself when you become a parent at all, you can do both, just maybe not in the same way you did before. Xxx

YetiTeri · 03/06/2023 19:19

YetiTeri · 03/06/2023 19:17

I completely agree.

There's real pain in wanting children and not being able to have them. But I do think the happiest people are children by choice or well off Dads that have a SAHM wife (and staff.)

There is just so much drudgery in being a parent. As soon as kids start being fun they ditch you to go vape in a field with kids you don't even know the last name of 🙄

Childless by choice obviously.

Wildflowersinthemeadow · 03/06/2023 19:19

But drudgery will exist regardless of children or not @SaveMeFromForearms . Cleaning and cooking, laundry, dull work meetings, smear tests, waiting for trains. It’s just a normal sort of life, I would say.

BCBird · 03/06/2023 19:18

You are probably saying what many people are thinking.

YetiTeri · 03/06/2023 19:17

I completely agree.

There's real pain in wanting children and not being able to have them. But I do think the happiest people are children by choice or well off Dads that have a SAHM wife (and staff.)

There is just so much drudgery in being a parent. As soon as kids start being fun they ditch you to go vape in a field with kids you don't even know the last name of 🙄

FarmGirl78 · 03/06/2023 19:17

continentallentil · 03/06/2023 18:36

Erm, I’m really sorry you didn’t get to be a mother when you wanted to be, but IME you cannot know how you will find being a parent until you are - I can think of people who were deeply ambivalent who love it, and people who really wanted it (I mean rounds of IVF wanted it) who find really tough and not something they’d have done had they known how they would respond. Also everything in between obviously.

There’s no reason to think the OP isn’t a good parent, but she feels how she feels. Being able to break the taboo and speak honestly about parenthood and specifically motherhood can only be a good thing.

Totally agree. But don't say she didn't choose it. She did.

HarlanPepper · 03/06/2023 19:16

Licinada · 03/06/2023 16:45

My eldest is almost 11.
I feel no different as my reasons for preferring being childfree don’t change with age.

I wasn't assuming your child was an infant. 10 is still very young and for my eldest, maybe 8 through 12 were some pretty emotionally challenging years all round. Mainly I posted to say that I don't think it's 'terrible' that you feel the way you do, sorry if I came across wrong. Of course you'll never stop being a prarent now, no matter what - you can never go back, and that personally was what I found hardest. I didn't mean changing nappies or lack of sleep or whatever. My life changed and I changed.

In terms of the happiness of pre-child life though - well, I'm naturally a melancholic sort of person and I can't remember ever feeling truly carefree in the way you describe it, maybe not since I was very small myself! So I don't relate to that aspect of your post.

Toloveandtowork · 03/06/2023 19:15

'This is what I can't see at the moment; do the hard moments and days mean I'll wake up at 60 going 'well the two decades of boredom mixed with moments of joy and terror were totallyworth it'.

Sometimes I don't thing this is necessarily true. I had mine late and will be old, poor and knackered by the time I'm done. I'll certainly never forget this terrible feeling of being trapped, yet I must hide that for the sake of others - my children and a mother-policing society.

To me it feels like it's a cultural 'silent martyr' role. And so many of us feel like this. It's good we can talk about it now though, at least on here.

Sheruns · 03/06/2023 19:13

I'm with you here op. I wouldn't be without my two now and I love them to bits but I think if I could go back knowing what I know now I would have chosen to remain childless.

Atethehalloweenchocs · 03/06/2023 19:10

I am pleasantly surprised to see the vote. I think that this is something that is not discussed enough. As women, being a mother as the highest thing you can aspire to is so ubiquitous as a message, a lot of people get into it without really thinking about whether it is the best choice for them. For some people, it totally will be and they may feel it is the most fulfilling thing they have done. But there are other stories to be told and women (and men) should have access to all of them.

TreeRose · 03/06/2023 19:10

39 and childfree, but ttc. Life now is like my 20s, but better. I have more money, I'm doing the work I longed for in my 20s, my relationships are easier because I'm calmer and wiser (sometimes), and I no longer feel the pressure to "prove myself". A lot of my friends have young children, and it looks HARD. And they're all having to compromise either the careers they worked so hard for, or the amount of time they actually get to spend with their kids, or both. And several have said they wish they'd at lest waited a bit. And yet I desperately want kids. Occasionally I ask myself why on earth I want to throw away our easy lifestyle, but the thought of never having kids literally reduces me to tears.

PointlessTrophy · 03/06/2023 19:10

I have never told my parents any of my worries as an adult. Not one. I don’t see this as a positive, more of a reflection of their shit parenting. My young adult kids confide in me, and whilst it can be stressful, I would not change that.