Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say I was genuinely happier before I have children

308 replies

Licinada · 03/06/2023 16:34

All I ever wanted in life was to be a Mum. I was so excited when I got pregnant.
I have one child and expecting another in September.
My Husband wanted children too. After the first I was hesitant to have another but thought it best they had a sibling for company. I will have no more after this one.

Now I am not a stressed out depressed Mum. My life is fine as it is. My Husband is amazing.

BUT I have to admit. I was happier before I had children. I am sure for most while they’d say parenting can be hard the benefits outweigh the negatives or hard times.
But for me if I’d actually known what was involved in parenting I’d have remained childfree and chosen a life partner who also didn’t want children. I quite admire people who know they don’t want children so don’t have them. I wonder how some people who have never had children know it’s not for them and others only find that out after the event.
I adore my Son and it’s odd as I’d never not want him now he’s here. I think I’m a good Mum and he is loved and well looked after. But had I known what parenting was all about it’s not a path I would have chosen.

For me I think it’s the peace of mind of only having to think of, be responsible for and look after yourself. It’s such an amazing freeing experience for me. To only have to worry about yourself. Obviously you have to consider adult loved ones but that’s different.
I greatly enjoyed (although I didn’t appreciate it at the time) how freeing and settling only having to think of myself was.
Bringing up another human being and being responsible for their physical and mental health is a HUGE responsibility.

One I was genuinely happier before I had.

So is this a terrible attitude for a Mother to have?

OP posts:
AllTheChaos · 04/06/2023 14:44

wobbledobbleflobble2 · 04/06/2023 13:58

"It's why childlessness is so catastrophic for most people who expereince it."

Please don't pull things straight out of your bottom and wave them around on threads as if they're facts.

Exactly. I have many child-free friends who are extremely happy with their lovely lives!

billy1966 · 04/06/2023 14:42

CBAironing · 04/06/2023 13:03

@Joystir59
I sometime think people lack imagination regarding what to do with their life, so opt for parenthood which kind of absolves one from wondering what to do.

@DonnaBanana There’s a good reason all your family will tell you having children is honey and roses and schools won’t even touch the subject. It’s to trick you into the conveyor belt of continuing humanity before you change your mind

These two comments are spot on. I’ve had many people tell me they had children because ‘well, it’s what you do isn’t it?’ or ‘well that’s the next step isn’t it?’ or ‘well that’s what life is about, what else would you do with your life?’

I disagree (for me personally) with the comment that said you cannot appreciate how carefree you are before you have children. I’m 30 and very much appreciate the peace and quiet when I sit and eat my breakfast in the garden and ponder what to do next, whilst next door all hell is breaking loose amongst 3 youngish children. It’s losing that sense of being able to be carefree and selfish that terrifies me.

OP your feelings are valid and heard.

Completely agree.

Definitely a conspiracy of silence.

A bit like the menopause!

Thankfully on both scores I have many close friends that have expressed themselves freely without shock or censure, but the quiet nodding of heads in understanding and sympathy.

These feelings can be very fluid and ebb and flow.

Definitely the expression of your happiness being reflective of your least happy child, rings very true.

wobbledobbleflobble2 · 04/06/2023 13:58

"It's why childlessness is so catastrophic for most people who expereince it."

Please don't pull things straight out of your bottom and wave them around on threads as if they're facts.

GeriKellmansUpdo · 04/06/2023 13:34

I’m 30 and very much appreciate the peace and quiet when I sit and eat my breakfast in the garden and ponder what to do next, whilst next door all hell is breaking loose amongst 3 youngish children.

Forgive me if I have commented too much on this thread; I am 51, which means a lot of thinking about how my life has turned out. I totally hear you on this, and when I was 30 with a toddler, felt like I had ruined my life of peace and quiet .

But I had a lovely long breakfast with DS today, while discussing Succession ( which we both love). I am now sitting in a park reading the paper peacefully, while he is off doing his own thing.

This is why the whole issue of having kids is so complicated. I feel I have made a connection for life, and on some days that's a beautiful thing and some days a bad thing! It's not black or white. Both choices are valid.

CBAironing · 04/06/2023 13:03

@Joystir59
I sometime think people lack imagination regarding what to do with their life, so opt for parenthood which kind of absolves one from wondering what to do.

@DonnaBanana There’s a good reason all your family will tell you having children is honey and roses and schools won’t even touch the subject. It’s to trick you into the conveyor belt of continuing humanity before you change your mind

These two comments are spot on. I’ve had many people tell me they had children because ‘well, it’s what you do isn’t it?’ or ‘well that’s the next step isn’t it?’ or ‘well that’s what life is about, what else would you do with your life?’

I disagree (for me personally) with the comment that said you cannot appreciate how carefree you are before you have children. I’m 30 and very much appreciate the peace and quiet when I sit and eat my breakfast in the garden and ponder what to do next, whilst next door all hell is breaking loose amongst 3 youngish children. It’s losing that sense of being able to be carefree and selfish that terrifies me.

OP your feelings are valid and heard.

billy1966 · 04/06/2023 11:42

Joystir59 · 04/06/2023 05:14

I sometime think people lack imagination regarding what to do with their life, so opt for parenthood which kind of absolves one from wondering what to do.

Very insightful and accurate comment that I have heard said by friends over the years.

I think we were a bit guilty of it a bit too.

After 15 years of travelling, living and working on several continents, lovely home fully renovated, settled in highly paid jobs, we decided to give it a go with the absolute minimal of thought, discussion or preparation. 🙄

I got pregnant first try and we were off.

I look back and cringe at my spectacular naivety, despite bring in my 30's.

The responsibility is absolutely enormous and if you are a competitive person, you put pressure on yourself to do the best you can, and berate yourself when you don't.

Like others, we love them deeply, but I absolutely understand the deep contentment of friends who are childless or those that stopped at one.

OP, that's a big age gap, going back to the beginning again will be very much like the first time.

Wishing you luck.

GeriKellmansUpdo · 04/06/2023 11:34

OP has already been tricked into the conveyor belt and is changing her mind as she is carried up it.😀

DonnaBanana · 04/06/2023 11:32

Well done. This is how it’s meant to work. If we were truly honest with children about the realities of having kids we’d have died out as a species centuries ago. There’s a good reason all your family will tell you having children is honey and roses and schools won’t even touch the subject. It’s to trick you into the conveyor belt of continuing humanity before you change your mind

coeurnoir · 04/06/2023 11:28

I don't really have much experience of adult life without children and sometimes I do wish that I'd had mine later so I could have experienced a few more years of childfree life. but saying that by the time I reached mid 40's they were mostly grown up and independent and I felt like I had my life back, at a time when lots of other women were deep in the early years hell.

I genuinely don't knkw if I'd have been happier without them. They've been here now for a long time - 25 and 21 years - so I guess I'm used to them. I do think that parenting has got much harder now since social media has become so widespread.

I have a childfree sister. She wanted kids but life didn't work out that way and she did struggle for a long time. Now she's content and in a lovely relationship. She isn't happier than me, I'm not happier than her. I get less judgement from society though, but that's a different argument.

I do think that there are a lot of people, men and women, who go into parenthood without really understanding the impact it will have on their lives. They just seem to see the cute babies, the snuggles and buy into the Instagram images and don't realise the truth. I think that my generation of parents were more aware that life was going to be a bit shit for a while.

GeriKellmansUpdo · 04/06/2023 11:21

I've spoken to my own parents about this and the overwhelming conclusion is, you're only as happy as your unhappiest child (if that makes sense!).

This is me. I have tried to overcome this, but been unsuccessful. One of my DC is happy but the other is unhappy at the moment, so I feel unsettled. I think your post hits the nail on the head.

Frustratedsupermodel · 04/06/2023 11:16

I don't think it's unreasonable, I think it's honest. And as you say, it doesn't in any way negate your love for your son. I don't have children through choice - I'm mid 40s and never felt that overwhelming maternal urge. I'm happy that I only have myself and other adults to take care of (I know having elderly parents can be a huge responsibility). I also know that by not having children, I'm missing out on some wonderful feelings and experiences that parents have. I've spoken to my own parents about this and the overwhelming conclusion is, you're only as happy as your unhappiest child (if that makes sense!). My mother will always worry about us, it's as ingrained as living with grief. It becomes part of you. And that's not something I would like to live with and I accept that with that, I miss out on all the wonderful parts of being a parent. So, I very much understand your pov and applaud your honesty and self awareness.

MyTruthIsOut · 04/06/2023 11:07

Teabab · 04/06/2023 08:44

I can't comprehend having another just so the other has company especially if you feel this way, but that's me being selfish I expect!

I often look back on the pre child years as being happier in many ways, it's a bit rose tinted though and for me I look back on being young, attractive, loads of spare money, the freedom to travel, and using weekends to party with friends; all of which would have changed a fair bit even I didn't have a child. I'd no longer be in my 20s and flitting between one house share and another with friends who were also all footloose and fancy free. I would have found stuff I enjoyed and adapted, but I miss something I wouldn't have now anyway as wouldn't be sure where my life would be at now.

I think people’s own childhood will have a big impact on whether they have more than one child or not…

If they came from a big group of siblings and loved it : likely to have more than one child.

If they came from a big group of siblings and hated it : more likely to only have one child.

Was an only child and loved it : wouldn’t see the need to provide a sibling for the first child in order for them to have company.

Was an only child and hated it : more likely to have another child to provide a sibling to the first.

I have a sister and I LOVED sharing my childhood with her and we can spend hours and hours reminiscing together and laughing about all the craziness we got up to…..all my favourite childhood memories are wrapped up in her. Because of this, it was important to me that my first child had a sibling to provide them with the opportunity to hopefully have the same special relationship.

My husband has a brother who he hated during their childhood and as adults they have no relationship at all. My husband really couldn’t see the need for a second baby as he has never experienced a positive sibling relationship so he didn’t understand why it would matter if our first born had a sibling or not.

PosseGalore · 04/06/2023 11:07

KimberleyClark · 03/06/2023 22:40

You say that you preferred only having to look after yourself in the past. But one of the most wonderful things about becoming a parent is how massively you grow as a person by learning to think of other, precious human beings, FIRST. Of course, it's not always easy, but it teaches you about love.

Of course us nom parents know fuck all about love.

Because we are all the children of parents, we all get the opportunity to care for someone else when our parents become elderly. Caring for someone who is near the end of their life is both rewarding and incredibly challenging. You grow through doing that too. In my experience the child free are often automatically expected to take on more of this care, so the idea that only parents have the opportunity to care for another human is just not true. Caring for an adult near the end of their life is not as attractive a proposition to most as caring for a beautiful young child with all their life ahead of them. And yet many child free people take on this role and just get on with it.

PosseGalore · 04/06/2023 10:57

Teabab · 04/06/2023 08:44

I can't comprehend having another just so the other has company especially if you feel this way, but that's me being selfish I expect!

I often look back on the pre child years as being happier in many ways, it's a bit rose tinted though and for me I look back on being young, attractive, loads of spare money, the freedom to travel, and using weekends to party with friends; all of which would have changed a fair bit even I didn't have a child. I'd no longer be in my 20s and flitting between one house share and another with friends who were also all footloose and fancy free. I would have found stuff I enjoyed and adapted, but I miss something I wouldn't have now anyway as wouldn't be sure where my life would be at now.

I don't think the pre-child freedom is just about being younger and more attractive, having more money etc. It seems to me that it is about a fundamental loss of self identity. I wish more mothers had the opportunity to keep up with their interests and friendships outside parenthood, but it seems to me that the child often becomes the mother's entire focus. A lot of men still do less than their fair share within the home and with childcare. Friends of mine will say that they and their partners share this 50/50 but when I pay visits the bloke is sitting with his feet up (sometimes making dinner) while the mother is on her feet rushing here there and everywhere keeping plates spinning.

I don't think the happiness has anything to do with having children, but everything to do with having partners who aren't pulling their weight absolutely 50/50, freeing up some of the women's time to be themselves.

PosseGalore · 04/06/2023 10:49

MightWriteNight · 04/06/2023 06:25

What an impressively dumb thing to say. Fine if you don’t want kids, but that doesn’t intrinsically make you better or more interesting. I can’t imagine anything more boring than my child free friends who carry on exactly the same as they did 10 years ago. I on the other hand have advanced in my career to a place of security and prestige, travel extensively, write, try new hobbies, all with my son whose wonder at experiencing things
for the first time makes me appreciate these things in a new way, and encourages me to continue trying new things. My life remains mine, just with an awesome sidekick.

Are you a single parent by any chance? From my observation many single parents are actually happier than those in couples. In most of the couples I know the women lose their identity because they have to take on most of the childcare as well as looking after their partners (this is a very subtle thing and they wouldn't necessarily think this is what they're doing), while single mothers seem to retain their identity. It seems illogical given that many single parents have to juggle so much on their own, but this is what I see.

WickedSerious · 04/06/2023 10:32

Theladyinluna · 03/06/2023 16:45

Yes, the people who assume if you feel like this then your kids must be infants are really annoying!

Mine are adults and I totally get where the OP is coming from.

GeriKellmansUpdo · 04/06/2023 10:25

Can imagine I’d feel differently if she was one of those brats out drinking and doing drugs and had no respect for me to the point she wouldn’t even speak to me though, but I’d also have failed her as a parent if that’s was the case.

No, you wouldn't have failed. Sometimes teens with the best parenting can do all that. A large part of it is luck.

ShimmeringShirts · 04/06/2023 10:22

@SaveMeFromForearms I'm not quite besotted (because the word makes me want to barf) but I love my teen DD a hell of a lot more now than I did as a toddler! She’s smart and funny and regularly has me in creases and wondering how the hell I ended up with such an amazing kid. Though I’m lucky in that even when she’s in the shittiest mood she still wants to talk to me and regularly wants to spend time doing stuff together. Can imagine I’d feel differently if she was one of those brats out drinking and doing drugs and had no respect for me to the point she wouldn’t even speak to me though, but I’d also have failed her as a parent if that’s was the case.

GeriKellmansUpdo · 04/06/2023 10:11

I have managed to travel with kids. I have managed to live abroad with kids. I have also gone on solo trips without the kids ( as has DH) from the time they were off the breast. I have kept most of my hobbies, including as I said earlier, write books. I have definitely made compromises, but not given up everything I loved.

I don't see that the only two options are have kids and never do anything exciting EVER again, or not have kids and be completely fulfilled.

SaveMeFromForearms · 04/06/2023 10:00

CornishGem1975 · 04/06/2023 08:26

Having a child has made me a billion times happier. I don't see it a lot on MN but I am totally besotted with my 15 mo and I haven't come close to loving anyone like her. Including my husband. It's just a different level. I was happy before I had her but my life without her now would be a dark, dark hole.

It might be a dark, dark hole if you lost her, but it wouldn't have been a dark, dark hole if you had never had her.

Also think the 'besotted' type comments are often from parents of squishable toddlers who are just starting to develop their lovely personalities and are so engaging.

Different story when you've got a 14 year old who doesn't want to swap sentences with you from one day to the next.

HavinKittens · 04/06/2023 09:43

I wonder how many people who could push the magic button and go back would actually stay child free.

miniegg3 · 04/06/2023 09:38

It's definitely hard having children, and I could never have imagined how hard the baby stage especially would be! Having 1 child I know I wouldn't cope well having another so I'm sticking with 1. What I never understand is why people continue to have more children when they don't enjoy it??

Having said that, even though its hard at times I wouldn't chose not to have him if I went back in time! I just don't want more 🤣

Marchintospring · 04/06/2023 09:31

I don’t feel raising children is a test. Just treat them like you do other people in your life with a bit more caring thrown in and the beginning.
If you’re halfway decent your kids will be ok. All of us have issues with our parents regardless of how much we love them.

KimberleyClark · 04/06/2023 09:21

drpet49 · 04/06/2023 08:10

@Joystir59 thick comment of the week there

I don't think it's a thick comment at all. Plenty of people think that way. Having kids means you automatically get a "I'm doing something special and my life has meaning and purpose" card, without having to do much else. Childfree people often seem to be expected to be doing something amazing because they don't have kids, like having a stellar career or climbing Mount Kilimanjaro for charity.

drpet49 · 04/06/2023 09:10

I can honestly say my life is 100 times more
happier when I had kids.