Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

BIL losing temper whilst staying for weekend

213 replies

Theeora · 03/06/2023 15:29

My sister has recently become engaged to a man I just don't like. I'll be honest.

I live with my parents as I am trying to get on the property ladder this summer. They live remotely in a nice but compact cottage.

This morning they were planning on going for a long walk but my sister asked to adjust plans for very warm weather which dog may not tolerate.

On the drive way I overheard them arguing, BIL said something to the effect of "well, I think the dog is underwalked". My sister told him "how dare you, say it again if you really believe that". BIL did. Ended up with him storming off to their bedroom and SLAMMING the door.

Just to note, our 7 yo is the best looked after dog in the UK. The lengths we go to to look after him are both ridiculous and indulgant. Sure, when BIL is here for the odd weekend the family dog gets walked at random times but never fails to get 2 walks (on top of everything else). BIL and sister often include the dog in walks so the rest of us just work the dog's schedule around that. Dog is also getting on in age so can't walk 10 miles consecutively. Needs to rest after strenuous activity. How dare he imply I'm basically abusing my beloved dog. We live in the Lake District.

Did he act inappropriately re door slamming. I was in kitchen making cookies for the pair and didn't know where to look. Reminds me of a traumatic childhood,lots of arguing between parents (mum and dad have mellowed with age).

Added to the list of red flags

OP posts:
GoodChat · 03/06/2023 17:57

Theeora · 03/06/2023 17:36

Oh wait forgot to mention something! Not sure if this changes things but I was on the upstairs landing (went to my room to hide pretty much) when BIL slammed the door.

Not like I was in living room, he saw me and still chose to be aggressive. Doesn't sit right at all.

Is it not a completely reasonable suggestion that he may have just used more force than anticipated on a lighter door than he's used to?

Prescottdanni123 · 03/06/2023 17:54

I live in Lake District too and the weather has been too hot to take dogs hiking. And how far a dog can walk/how many walks it can manage in a day depends a lot on breed and age.

Tbh, his comment about the dog being under walked would have pissed me off as well.

IhearyouClemFandango · 03/06/2023 17:52

Kitcaterpillar · 03/06/2023 16:34

What a banal argument. Everyone sounds very emotionally over-invested in the dog.

I also don't feel either way on the door slamming. It's quite easy to push a door shut irritatedly and the resulting slam be much greater than intended. Of course in an ideal world noone would irritatedly shut a door, but in that world noone is defending a dog's honour with the words like 'I dare you to say that again'

This!

willWillSmithsmith · 03/06/2023 17:47

porkpiesinthepark · 03/06/2023 17:36

Are you unusually triggered (for want of a better word) by male aggression? I only say because I am. I grew up in an all female household with one very mild mannered grandfather and one equally docile uncle. I find male irritation/ aggression absolutely intolerable. They are like big moody babies, slamming doors and shouting.
I find it absolutely mind blowing how many men out there are completely incapable of having a disagreement without shouting and acting aggressively. I would say his actions are aggressive. I don't know one abusive relationship which didn't start with slamming doors/ damaging property.
Hope your sister gets out

My dad and my uncle, the two main males in my childhood, were both non-aggressive, well mannered, docile people so, like you, I find any male aggression or tantrum/moody behaviour unacceptable. My ex was prone to tantrums and I found it a huge turn off (part of the reason we broke up - I grew to dislike him). I don’t like men who are bad tempered babies. I’m glad to say my own sons are not bad tempered (they take their temperaments after me not their dad thankfully).

Moveoverdarlin · 03/06/2023 17:42

I love how your sister demanded he say it again! I’ve only heard people say this when they have just heard someone say something truly shocking like ‘I wish we never had kids’ ‘I hate you’ or ‘I’m worried that I’m the reason she killed herself’. Not ‘I think your parents dog is under walked.’ Hilarious.

Theeora · 03/06/2023 17:40

how you got the honour of owning the best looked after dog in the UK ?

by having no life clearly!

OP posts:
Theeora · 03/06/2023 17:39

@porkpiesinthepark

Yes male aggression is intolerable to me.
Reminds me too much of my father who was not able to control his anger growing up. Partly why I have no idea why sister would subject herself to anything like this by choice.

OP posts:
OiFatArse · 03/06/2023 17:38

"Just to note, our 7 yo is the best looked after dog in the UK"

I just want to know more about this , and how you got the honour of owning the best looked after dog in the UK ?

ClareBlue · 03/06/2023 17:37

Theeora · 03/06/2023 16:56

He's had his every whim catered to (lovely meals made, cleaned up after etc). And he's STILL acted inappropriately, to me.

I just don't want to know how he'll act when life gets shit/hard.

Is this the dog or the sister's boyfriend. I'm getting a bit confused.
And a job that pays enough for a 600k house and alows time and head space for 3 hours baking and testing recipes for dogs and stressing about dog walking routines - sounds like a great job. Where do we sign up.

porkpiesinthepark · 03/06/2023 17:36

Are you unusually triggered (for want of a better word) by male aggression? I only say because I am. I grew up in an all female household with one very mild mannered grandfather and one equally docile uncle. I find male irritation/ aggression absolutely intolerable. They are like big moody babies, slamming doors and shouting.
I find it absolutely mind blowing how many men out there are completely incapable of having a disagreement without shouting and acting aggressively. I would say his actions are aggressive. I don't know one abusive relationship which didn't start with slamming doors/ damaging property.
Hope your sister gets out

Dunnoburt · 03/06/2023 17:36

It's a dog. Did you have windows open? Been a fair amount of door slamming in my house the last few days due to the draught of open windows/doors.......

Theeora · 03/06/2023 17:36

Oh wait forgot to mention something! Not sure if this changes things but I was on the upstairs landing (went to my room to hide pretty much) when BIL slammed the door.

Not like I was in living room, he saw me and still chose to be aggressive. Doesn't sit right at all.

OP posts:
Theeora · 03/06/2023 17:33

I agree, if he does this in public what is he, or will he be like, in time, in private?

This is what I should have typed. They have the easiest life right now. Well paid jobs, nice flat, plenty of socialising etc. Sister tells me she often has nothing to do at work (in between projects) but is still able to bill her hours.

A nice morning, home cooked beeakfast in a beautiful part of the world and there is still aggression. Life is going to get so much harder. What then?

OP posts:
Tellmeimcrazy · 03/06/2023 17:31

I don't think your family dog is any of his business. Of course if the dog was being abused or neglected is a different story, but that isn't the case here.

Dogs can also be over-walkes. Your BIL is a wanker

Regholdsworthswaterbed · 03/06/2023 17:31

You witnessed a minor tiff. Nothing more IMO

ProudToBeANorthener · 03/06/2023 17:28

sorry, your parents I mean, not your behaviour 🥴

ProudToBeANorthener · 03/06/2023 17:27

I grew up in a household where my parents argues, shouted and sulked all the time. It definitely coloured my view of what a “normal” relationship should look like. It took, my now, husband to ask me if I thought being aggressive (verbally) was acceptable for me to re-assess what is okay. If your sister is quite young and still living at home she may not realise that his behaviour is unacceptable because it mirrors that of her own parents (and yours). I agree, if he does this in public what is he, or will he be like, in time, in private?

Theeora · 03/06/2023 17:27

Okay but slamming doors for us is just not acceptable. I mean I saw MUCH worse growing up but its just not the done thing in our home these days.

OP posts:
Theeora · 03/06/2023 17:24

Wish I hadn't mentioned the pup! Totally derailed things. I won't dispute the fact that my life is ridiculous.

I literally have 3 friends up here and none are particularly social. Often on my own so hence the dog obsession.

OP posts:
LostFrog · 03/06/2023 17:23

I think your sister overreacted.

SchoolShenanigans · 03/06/2023 17:23

It sounds petty and both overreacted.

But overall, I really don't think a slammed door is a red flag. It's a common sign of anger which is a very normal human expression.

If he had sworn at or insulted her, hit her or hit something, then yes. But slamming a door, while not ideal, is hardly a red flag.

Would you sister tell you if her relationship wasn't good?

mainsfed · 03/06/2023 17:21

BIL said something to the effect of "well, I think the dog is underwalked". My sister told him "how dare you, say it again if you really believe that". BIL did. Ended up with him storming off to their bedroom and SLAMMING the door.

Your sis sounds controlling. The way she dared him to say the dog is under walked again is confrontational, I don’t blame BIL for storming off.

Theeora · 03/06/2023 17:19

7 is sadly getting on for my boy's breed. He's fit, vet said he had a lovely low heart rate but you can tell the long walks take it out of him and he needs a day of just walking around the village (still an hour mind you) to recover.

OP posts:
Irritateandunreasonable · 03/06/2023 17:19

LaGiaconda · 03/06/2023 17:15

Mumsnet is surreal.

🤣🤣🤣🤣

Theeora · 03/06/2023 17:17

Okay but BIL saying the dog doesn't get walked enough is objectively ridiculous.

I literally went for a 10 mile walk yesterday which is not uncommon and a bog standard weekend activity.

OP posts: