Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it isn't normal to be this critical?

361 replies

FrustratedCitizen44846 · 03/06/2023 11:44

This morning me and DH were having a lazy morning in bed (no kids yet) when we realised we don't have any milk. I said "I'll nip to the shop and get some now then". He asked if I wanted him to come with me and I said no, don't worry, I can finish my audiobook on the way (it's a 2 minute walk). Before I left he asked me to grab him some vanilla yoghurt and some blueberries, too. Of course! No problemo.

Anyway as I'm milling round the shop I'll admit I was in my own world a bit, so I forgot to buy the blueberries. I also bought the wrong yoghurt; he asked for vanilla this time but I bought strawberry. The shop was packed and so in my haste I grabbed strawberry, which is his usual choice.

When I got home and emptied the bag of he looked a bit confused (and I will note didn't say thank you once). At that point I said shit, sorry, I forgot the blueberries, but there's a fresh punnet of strawberries in the fridge and bananas on the side of you want some fruit. And said my bad about the yoghurt.

I honestly thought nothing of it, didn't think it was a big deal (he could walk the 2 mins to the shop if he really wanted) but as I was eating my breakfast I could tell he was being a bit sulky. I asked him what's wrong and he said if I wasn't going to get him what he wanted he would've just gone to the shop with me, and it's not fair that I pretty much told him he couldn't come with me. I said that's not fair, all I said was "don't worry about coming with me, I have something I want to listen to anyway". It's not like it was a strict directive or anything, of course he could come with me if he really wanted to. And in any case the shop is literally two minutes from where we live. It's not a big deal.

Anyway he then goes off on this sulk about how I'm not very thoughtful and how it's impossible to say no to me (i.e. he couldn't push the point about coming with me to the shop).

I think he's being overly critical over what is an incredibly minor mistake and turning into some big character flaw. It's not like this sort of thing happens often, if at all.

Tbh there have been a few cases like this where I feel he's a bit too.... unforgiving? Critical?

It kinda puts me on eggshells at times, to the point I've considered breaking up with him. Taking today as an example, we're supposrd to be going out to meet some friends but now I feel really on edge and a bit sad. Feels like the day is ruined for no good reason.

But it seems like such a minor thing and I'm not sure if it's just me being unreasonable/overdramatic and that it's normal for him to be a bit miffed over things like this from time to time (we're all human after all).

AIBU?

OP posts:
christmascalypso · 06/06/2023 14:01

YANBU - his reaction was OTT. Neither my DH or I would even think of being annoyed if either one of us had forgotten something we were asked to buy. I'd just laugh if my DH forgot something and say next time I'll give you a list! But I wouldn't be cross or feel upset, that's ridiculous.
I really couldn't cope with someone who sulked over small things like that!!

DustyMaiden · 06/06/2023 13:29

I would say he feels rejected, you didn’t want his company preferring a book. You didn’t get what he wanted as he’s not important to you.

JusthereforXmas · 06/06/2023 13:22

Jennieflo · 06/06/2023 13:03

if he continually harps on about all the things you do wrong, and doesn’t just let it drop when you apologise or rectify your mistake, then this could be part of controlling and coercive behaviour. It sounds like you are already feeling that you are being punished for little mistakes, which is also a sign that things aren’t right.

Yes there are things you could do to overcome scattiness, like write a list before going to the shop, but ultimately we’re all human and if you are scatty, he should accept that is part of who you are. You didn’t ask if he wanted anything, he made a request, and if he knows you are scatty he should make adjustments for that, like text you what he wanted as well, or say, no I’ll come with you as there are things I need. But instead he makes you feel like you’ve done something awful, whilst your rational brain is wondering why it’s such a big deal. That’s manipulative behaviour.

I think its actually more that he is frustrated with OPs lack of regard for others.

He isn't going on 3 years later about the one isolated time she forgot blueberries but is rather hurt that she repetitively lets him down and dismisses it as 'his problem'.

She admits shes 'go with the flow', 'in her own world' and her whole post highlights how she doesn't listen and didn't care. Every time she does an action that effects others they are allowed to have a new reaction to that disappointment its NOT 'harping on' that effect comes from several unrelated grievances from a pattern from OP.

Him highlighting a pattern of thoughtlessness is not 'critical'. OP seems to think she gets to decide how important any of this should be and tell him how to feel/react. Worse shutting it down (with talks of divorce) shows that not only does she not listen to instructions (irratating but livable) but she refuses to communicate about issues either or see anything from anyone else's perspective (something that will effect all her relationships as its a major social flaw).

Jennieflo · 06/06/2023 13:03

if he continually harps on about all the things you do wrong, and doesn’t just let it drop when you apologise or rectify your mistake, then this could be part of controlling and coercive behaviour. It sounds like you are already feeling that you are being punished for little mistakes, which is also a sign that things aren’t right.

Yes there are things you could do to overcome scattiness, like write a list before going to the shop, but ultimately we’re all human and if you are scatty, he should accept that is part of who you are. You didn’t ask if he wanted anything, he made a request, and if he knows you are scatty he should make adjustments for that, like text you what he wanted as well, or say, no I’ll come with you as there are things I need. But instead he makes you feel like you’ve done something awful, whilst your rational brain is wondering why it’s such a big deal. That’s manipulative behaviour.

ItsNotRocketSalad · 06/06/2023 10:14

CleverLilViper · 05/06/2023 16:58

It’s fucking blueberries and vanilla yoghurt. Calm the fuck down.

she didn’t forget to pick up his lifesaving medication. The shop is two minutes walk away. If he wanted them that badly he can get off his arse and get them.

The self-awareness is weak with this one. Calm the fuck down, love.

Butterflybutterflies · 06/06/2023 09:44

Years ago I asked DO to buy me a slice of cheesecake, he brought home London cheesecake- I still remember the disappointment so I think YABU!

JusthereforXmas · 06/06/2023 09:41

CleverLilViper · 05/06/2023 17:30

OP, you've received a lot of unduly and unnecessary batshit responses here.

Was it a little thoughtless? Yes, maybe. Did he have a right to be a little disappointed? Yes.

However, to be sulky about it, and overly-critical of what is a simple mistake which anyone can make, is OTT.

Everyone posting on here is acting like they've never made a mistake or forgotten anything that their partner has asked for. It's not the end of the world. He's not going to die if he doesn't get his blueberries. It's also worth noting that the shop is 2 minutes away. He can walk to there and get them himself if they are so important to him.

It's not normal for an adult, of either sex, to sulk over a minor mistake. They're not a toddler. They're not a child. It's fine to express disappointment and to make it clear that you're unhappy that someone got something wrong, but to sulk? No.

We all make mistakes. We all forget things. People need to get off their high horses, quit pretending that they're perfect and get everything right all the time and give it a rest. It's not normal for adults to be so critical over what amounts to a tiny mistake.

If the worst thing to happen to him in recent times is forgotten blueberries, he's living a pretty good life.

Literally EVERYONE has said mistakes happen, most have said we have done it or our partner has and it was easily fixed by them popping back to the shop.

Everyone has also seen the bigger picture that its NOT about blueberries & yogurt but the OP in her own side of the story showing huge red flags about her abusive (not allowing her partner to express emotion, refusing to take responsibility and gaslighting him) and emotionally manipulating (threatening divorce in an attempt to control the situation) attitude to her husband.

If you can't see past the blueberries then your not very observant to the far bigger picture here.

JusthereforXmas · 06/06/2023 09:32

CleverLilViper · 05/06/2023 16:58

It’s fucking blueberries and vanilla yoghurt. Calm the fuck down.

she didn’t forget to pick up his lifesaving medication. The shop is two minutes walk away. If he wanted them that badly he can get off his arse and get them.

PP response was perfectly calm and raised the issue perfectly you countered randomly with swearing and aggression... it suggests you might actually be the irate one not the person you quoted.

CrazyArmadilloLady · 05/06/2023 23:45

It’s like the OP expects him to be some sort of emotionless robot, and when he does express some sort of opinion or disappointment - caused by the OP (no judgment - we all do things that annoy and/or upset our partners from time-to-time) - he’s being completely unreasonable.

Well, he’s not. He’s a bit annoyed - because you were annoying, OP. He’s allowed to be.

If you find that untenable, break up with him.

But good luck in you next relationship - I don’t think you’re going to find it any easier.

paulthepython · 05/06/2023 22:24

Yeah...I'm totally scatty brained too and would 100% do this...but I'd also be pretty hurt if my partner told me not to bother coming then didn't get either of the only 2 things I asked for. But...my partner and I (whoever respectively forgot the items) would have simply apologised and gone back to the shop to get it. You repeat that its 2 minutes and seem like you think he doest have a right to be upset but at no point do you even seem to consider popping back out yourself to sort your own mistake. That seems kind of thoughtless and selfish to me. I suspect that had you headed back out positively and without any mind games this would have been immediately resolved. He wanted you to show some thought and care about his feelings...you didn't and now you're talking about breaking up with him. That seems incredibly drastic and honestly if that's your gut reaction when he expresses any negative emotions then I really do think you should break up because it seems kind of cruel and emotional manipulation. He shouldn't not be allowed to be disappointed in case you break up with him...that's really odd.

Drosselmeyer · 05/06/2023 21:26

If this were the other way round, people would be telling OP that his forgetfulness was a symptom of a wider problem, that he doesn’t care about her, and that she should crack on and LTB. Which of course would be completely mad but gives a bit of context.

I think what might have been particularly annoying is the fact that he offered to go to the shop as well and was told not to- I have some sympathy here as my DH has form for this sort of thing (eg I’m about to make a cup of tea, he says that he’ll make it for me, so I go and sit down but time passes and no tea appears and I realise he’s forgotten and is off doing something else instead- not a big deal but annoying when I was quite happy to make it myself and indeed was about to do so). Plus OP telling him to have strawberries instead sounds annoying.

Having said all that, none of its a big deal so if he’s making it into one, that’s unreasonable.

PlantingMarigolds · 05/06/2023 20:54

Why not just text and ask him in the shop?

CrazyArmadilloLady · 05/06/2023 20:24

CleverLilViper · 05/06/2023 17:18

The first word in your name is right.

The last word in your name is right.

Calm down, it’s just a thread on the internet. No need to take it all so weirdly personally.

Coyoacan · 05/06/2023 19:59

If the worst thing to happen to him in recent times is forgotten blueberries, he's living a pretty good life

Well it looks like he is now going to be divorced by someone who doesn't care a fig for him.

CleverLilViper · 05/06/2023 17:30

OP, you've received a lot of unduly and unnecessary batshit responses here.

Was it a little thoughtless? Yes, maybe. Did he have a right to be a little disappointed? Yes.

However, to be sulky about it, and overly-critical of what is a simple mistake which anyone can make, is OTT.

Everyone posting on here is acting like they've never made a mistake or forgotten anything that their partner has asked for. It's not the end of the world. He's not going to die if he doesn't get his blueberries. It's also worth noting that the shop is 2 minutes away. He can walk to there and get them himself if they are so important to him.

It's not normal for an adult, of either sex, to sulk over a minor mistake. They're not a toddler. They're not a child. It's fine to express disappointment and to make it clear that you're unhappy that someone got something wrong, but to sulk? No.

We all make mistakes. We all forget things. People need to get off their high horses, quit pretending that they're perfect and get everything right all the time and give it a rest. It's not normal for adults to be so critical over what amounts to a tiny mistake.

If the worst thing to happen to him in recent times is forgotten blueberries, he's living a pretty good life.

CleverLilViper · 05/06/2023 17:18

CrazyArmadilloLady · 05/06/2023 08:58

He ASKED to go to the shops with her.

She told him NO.

He then asked if she could then bring some things back for him.

She didn’t bring them back.

Of course he’s annoyed. He tried to make it easy for her - she rejected that, and then didn’t even do what he asked.

I’d be pissed off.

The first word in your name is right.

CleverLilViper · 05/06/2023 17:10

PineappleLatte · 03/06/2023 12:32

Or she’s changed her story because things weren’t going her way….

Possibly because most of MN is batshit.

Cherrycola44 · 05/06/2023 17:06

He sounds petty and over-critical. You shouldn’t have to feel like you are ‘walking on egg-shells’ around someone, that’s how controlling behaviour can start.

CleverLilViper · 05/06/2023 16:58

ToK1 · 03/06/2023 12:06

@FrustratedCitizen44846

I dont see how you could have forgotten 2 things out of 2

You say it doesn't happen often but the fact you are minimising it so much would suggest otherwise

It's OK to be pissed off about stuff that is annoying

It’s fucking blueberries and vanilla yoghurt. Calm the fuck down.

she didn’t forget to pick up his lifesaving medication. The shop is two minutes walk away. If he wanted them that badly he can get off his arse and get them.

AuntMarch · 05/06/2023 15:55

"Didn't say thank you"... for what?! while I'd get over it and just go to the shop myself, I'd also be aware you'd said you'd rather listen to something than go together but then still ignored what I'd asked you to get. I'd be irritated.

LifeIsPainHighness · 05/06/2023 15:44

Freeballing · 05/06/2023 13:51

He could have responded. Aw thanks for going to the shops. Wow it must have been busy in there for you to struggle to remember the two items. I will nip back because I really wanted those items. Would you like anything getting.
Done.

I would feel incredibly patronised if my dh spoke to me like this. I'm a grown adult who takes responsibility for my own actions not some halfwit that needs pandering too. Would you not feel it was insincere for someone to thank you for nothing? It's not like she was doing him some massive favour he offered to go and she said no then didn't actually get him anything he wanted. I'd be like wtf are you thanking for me for?!

Same!!

Imagine expecting thanks for going to the shop and getting stuff only yourself wanted 🤣

Freeballing · 05/06/2023 13:51

He could have responded. Aw thanks for going to the shops. Wow it must have been busy in there for you to struggle to remember the two items. I will nip back because I really wanted those items. Would you like anything getting.
Done.

I would feel incredibly patronised if my dh spoke to me like this. I'm a grown adult who takes responsibility for my own actions not some halfwit that needs pandering too. Would you not feel it was insincere for someone to thank you for nothing? It's not like she was doing him some massive favour he offered to go and she said no then didn't actually get him anything he wanted. I'd be like wtf are you thanking for me for?!

pollymere · 05/06/2023 12:50

FrustratedCitizen44846 · 03/06/2023 12:13

Alright I sort of fibbed about the yoghurt thing because I couldn't be bothered typing out the whole scenario. But I feel I should add some much needed context!

So he asked for vanilla yoghurt and said it they don't have any of that, buy strawberry. I asked if he'd prefer a Muller corner or a big tub of yoghurt and he said the big tub.

The shop didn't have any big tubs of vanilla, they only had big tubs of strawberry. They did have vanilla Muller corners.

I bought a big tub of strawberry, thinking that would be his preference.

Turns out he would have actually preferred the vanilla corner. It was honestly just a miscommunication.

No... What you actually communicated went like this:

If no Vanilla get Strawberry.
Vanilla corner or Vanilla big tub?
Big tub.

So the logic goes: Vanilla big tub, Vanilla corner, strawberry big tub, strawberry corner...

And you still forgot the blueberries. Make a ranking list or make a phone call or text if you're not sure. This is why communication is important in a marriage...

rhow · 05/06/2023 12:44

I would be sending you back to the shop....

pollymere · 05/06/2023 12:42

If you've offered to do the shop run but A: not suggested you go together and B: not actually bought the items requested then you probably are in the "wrong" here. My DH asks if I want to come along and then makes a list on his phone of what's been requested. He'll often ask what the backups are 😂. He's so "well-trained" that he'll ring me if he's not sure or if they don't have requested items.

I don't make a list but I'd definitely invite him along. I'd also offer to go back to the shop if I forgot items. He asked you for vanilla yoghurt and blueberries, neither of which you bought. I'd be offering to go back and get both items and leave him to say no, it's fine. I'd not be suggesting they can make do. He's probably feeling a bit narked/unloved by your apparent lack of care. Think of all those Mumsnetters discussing a DH who didn't get the one item they wanted for their birthday - it's a mini-version of that.