Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it isn't normal to be this critical?

361 replies

FrustratedCitizen44846 · 03/06/2023 11:44

This morning me and DH were having a lazy morning in bed (no kids yet) when we realised we don't have any milk. I said "I'll nip to the shop and get some now then". He asked if I wanted him to come with me and I said no, don't worry, I can finish my audiobook on the way (it's a 2 minute walk). Before I left he asked me to grab him some vanilla yoghurt and some blueberries, too. Of course! No problemo.

Anyway as I'm milling round the shop I'll admit I was in my own world a bit, so I forgot to buy the blueberries. I also bought the wrong yoghurt; he asked for vanilla this time but I bought strawberry. The shop was packed and so in my haste I grabbed strawberry, which is his usual choice.

When I got home and emptied the bag of he looked a bit confused (and I will note didn't say thank you once). At that point I said shit, sorry, I forgot the blueberries, but there's a fresh punnet of strawberries in the fridge and bananas on the side of you want some fruit. And said my bad about the yoghurt.

I honestly thought nothing of it, didn't think it was a big deal (he could walk the 2 mins to the shop if he really wanted) but as I was eating my breakfast I could tell he was being a bit sulky. I asked him what's wrong and he said if I wasn't going to get him what he wanted he would've just gone to the shop with me, and it's not fair that I pretty much told him he couldn't come with me. I said that's not fair, all I said was "don't worry about coming with me, I have something I want to listen to anyway". It's not like it was a strict directive or anything, of course he could come with me if he really wanted to. And in any case the shop is literally two minutes from where we live. It's not a big deal.

Anyway he then goes off on this sulk about how I'm not very thoughtful and how it's impossible to say no to me (i.e. he couldn't push the point about coming with me to the shop).

I think he's being overly critical over what is an incredibly minor mistake and turning into some big character flaw. It's not like this sort of thing happens often, if at all.

Tbh there have been a few cases like this where I feel he's a bit too.... unforgiving? Critical?

It kinda puts me on eggshells at times, to the point I've considered breaking up with him. Taking today as an example, we're supposrd to be going out to meet some friends but now I feel really on edge and a bit sad. Feels like the day is ruined for no good reason.

But it seems like such a minor thing and I'm not sure if it's just me being unreasonable/overdramatic and that it's normal for him to be a bit miffed over things like this from time to time (we're all human after all).

AIBU?

OP posts:
ToK1 · 03/06/2023 13:42

@Tryagainplease

Maybe not

But she clearly didn't care enough to try not to upset him

Nordicrain · 03/06/2023 13:41

ToK1 · 03/06/2023 11:52

I'd be pissed if if I asked you to get me2 things and you didn't get either of them.

You're making out it's entirely understandable and reasonable you forgot/didn't bother to get 2 things out of 2 things you were asked to get

It's not.

I agree with this too.

Can't believe you expected him to be grateful for buying him two things he didn't want and not getting him what he wanted.

YABU.

emmylousings · 03/06/2023 13:38

Its petty, unkind and controlling. I had an ex who did this, it got gradually worse. But like a lobster in a pot...you don't realise quite how bad it is until your whole life is miserable. Expect others to treat you how you would treat them. How would you have reacted in the same situation?
Do not get pregnant with him. He'll be a super critical co-parent = nightmare.

Theladyinluna · 03/06/2023 13:38

ToK1 · 03/06/2023 11:52

I'd be pissed if if I asked you to get me2 things and you didn't get either of them.

You're making out it's entirely understandable and reasonable you forgot/didn't bother to get 2 things out of 2 things you were asked to get

It's not.

Me too.

Mummysaf · 03/06/2023 13:38

I would be irritated too but would move on quickly.
that being said if DH had annoyed me all week then it may be a straw that breaks the camels back.
Is there anything else going on?

bonzaitree · 03/06/2023 13:37

I wouldn’t personally care about the bf buying the wrong thing / forgetting something as a one off.

But that’s because he consistently shows me he cares for me and loves me.

If you’re in a relationship where you don’t feel consistently loved and cared for, forgetting little things would serve to verify that partner so does not love and care for you.

So how is the relationship going generally?

OCarumba · 03/06/2023 13:36

Newbie198 · 03/06/2023 13:31

@HeckyPeck
@Tryagainplease
see your stories are lovely and seem to reflect couples who get on well and understand each other.
My dh forgets something, he immediately offers to go back and I’d probably refuse and make do. No biggie.

If you’re happy, these things hardly matter. If you’re unhappy, then they become major problems.

Yep I think it depends a lot on the underlying relationship. When you’re happy small things are more likely to be no sweat

And sometimes when there’s a big underlying issue, these little quibbles are actually that big issue ‘leaking out’

ValentineGreen · 03/06/2023 13:35

I think it really might be worth taking a deeper look at how often things like this happen, where you forget a 'small' thing and think your dh is 'making a big deal' of it. I'd hazard a wild guess that you didn't forget / mess up your own breakfast preference when you got the to shop. You didn't remember to get the yoghurt and blueberries and forget to get the milk for instance?

My dh has a recent ADHD diagnosis and 'small' things like this have mired our relationship for so many years and it sort of snowballs. Each single one is inconsequential but the all add up over time.

My dh would have had your attitude too, oh stop being sulky - you have yoghurt and fruit, what's the big deal? Meanwhile he's tucking into exactly what he fancies and bought for his meal etc

I started thinking and saying to him that he only forgot things that were of no consequence to HIM. We had so many petty fights about this over the years that I really became bored and saddened by it all. I felt it was an absolute sign that he just didn't really give a shit.

We could park outside a shop and he'd ask what would you like, I would tell him, he'd go in and come out and hand me the entirely wrong thing and when I'd say WTF he'd say 'but you love xxx, you aways get it' and he would not have even registered that I'd answered yyy when he asked.

It all came to a terrible head last year for him (unrelated to me) and now he has a diagnosis. And in many ways this has alleviated the frustration I have felt.

I'm not saying you have ADHD but if your dh is telling you that he finds you thoughtless and hard to communicate with, I think you might do well to actually listen to it.

Newbie198 · 03/06/2023 13:31

@HeckyPeck
@Tryagainplease
see your stories are lovely and seem to reflect couples who get on well and understand each other.
My dh forgets something, he immediately offers to go back and I’d probably refuse and make do. No biggie.

If you’re happy, these things hardly matter. If you’re unhappy, then they become major problems.

Tryagainplease · 03/06/2023 13:28

ToK1 · 03/06/2023 12:02

If ots OK for the op to be that scatty because no human is perfect then it's OK for him to be pissed off about ot because no one is perfect

They are two different things
Sulking is childish and cruel and intentional
The OP didn’t set out to deliberately upset him!

DarkDayforMN · 03/06/2023 13:25

OnSusansFloor · 03/06/2023 12:16

It's difficult to comment on the wider context of your relationship as a whole but this particular issue reminds me of something I read about "bids for connection" in a relationship. I'm wondering if his asking about coming along was a bid to connect with you - maybe he was thinking "So lovely to have this lazy morning with Citizen. Might be nice to mosey over to the shop together and pick out some things for breakfast, then hang out together over a nice relaxed breakfast", but you heard "Do you need help going to the shop?" and answered that question honestly, but he felt rebuffed and his response later had more to do with that than with the specifics of breakfast.
Or he could just be a childish brat, difficult to say without knowing him 🤷🏼‍♀️

I thought this was a really smart comment and overlooked.

I know I sometimes get frustrated with DP and feel rejected if I want to just be together and chat and he’s listening to audiobooks. I’ve learned that I have more need to spend quality time together than he does, and usually I’m very rational about that but if I’m not on good form it can feel quite shitty to feel like he doesn’t want my company.

TheKobayashiMaru · 03/06/2023 13:25

I'd be annoyed with you OP. His request was simple.

CheshireCat1 · 03/06/2023 13:24

Just let him sulk and enjoy the rest of your day, he’s being a bit of a drama llama.

Tryagainplease · 03/06/2023 13:24

I agree with the love languages post as well. People give and like to receive affection in different ways. You can’t always expect the other person to show thought the way you normally would. We don’t know how and if the OP shows thoughtfulness in other ways…

Also for context, I went to the shop with my partner once and waiting in the car because I was feeling a bit run down. He went in to get ingredients for dinner and I ask for painkillers too. He had forgotten them when he got back to the car but I couldn’t bring myself to point it out because he looked so pleased with himself for getting all the dinner stuff and I thought he was being really thoughtful just going in and being ok with me waiting in the car.
He remembered about an hour later when we were back home and insisted on going back despite me telling him I didn’t need him to

ItsNotRocketSalad · 03/06/2023 13:24

Naunet · 03/06/2023 13:02

Dear god, I can’t believe all the people who think it’s reasonable for a grown adult man to sulk over something so minor. If it was a regular pattern, sure, but a one off? I’d be a bit irritated, but hardly worth a big drama.

He hasn't made a big drama. All he said was she was thoughtless, which nearly everyone here agrees with.

Whatisityoucantface · 03/06/2023 13:23

I would FaceTime my DH in the shop to avoid exactly this scenario. Been there, done that and got the t shirt!
I think what you’re describing sounds like a very typical tiff in a relationship.
You should probably have let him go with you/ checked when you got there. He should chill out and not care about the yoghurt and make it a big deal. Both of you are just cracking on living in your own heads and need to communicate better is all. Clear the air, agree to communicate better and try. Enjoy your day please!

HeckyPeck · 03/06/2023 13:16

CharlotteCollinsneeLucas · 03/06/2023 12:53

I've lived with someone overly critical and with whom I felt like you do, that a shadow had been cast over the day, that I felt on edge and walking on eggshells. I also couldn't express what was going on clearly because each thing on its own was petty and insignificant.

Maybe that's your situation, maybe not. What I would say is: you don't need a reason to break up with someone. You don't need a reason that someone else will agree with. "This just isn't working for me any more" is all you need - and the bonus is, there's no argument can be made against it. He can promise to change but you just shrug and say, "Sorry, my mind's made up."

I agree with this as well.

billy1966 · 03/06/2023 13:15

CharlotteCollinsneeLucas · 03/06/2023 12:53

I've lived with someone overly critical and with whom I felt like you do, that a shadow had been cast over the day, that I felt on edge and walking on eggshells. I also couldn't express what was going on clearly because each thing on its own was petty and insignificant.

Maybe that's your situation, maybe not. What I would say is: you don't need a reason to break up with someone. You don't need a reason that someone else will agree with. "This just isn't working for me any more" is all you need - and the bonus is, there's no argument can be made against it. He can promise to change but you just shrug and say, "Sorry, my mind's made up."

Excellent post.

Critical, petty people grind you down.

Think very carefully about the future you want OP.

burnoutbabe · 03/06/2023 13:14

i would probably have lied to him that they didn't have the vanilla at all, rather than telling him what he could have had and then him sulking.

the main thing is the milk. Getting milk was the reason for the trip, i'd have gone on my own to if we were in bed and remembered it, other person puts on the coffee, gets up/shower whatever.

HeckyPeck · 03/06/2023 13:13

Puckthemagicdragon · 03/06/2023 12:59

I think it's a red flag in terms of compatibility. It's hard to be with someone who holds grudges when you forgive easily

Agreed.

I remember when I was meant to order the food shopping, but had forgotten the vital step of actually clicking pay. Then when it didn't turn up we had to go to Tesco at 9pm do to a whole shop because we had people coming over the next day 🤦‍♀️ DH didn't get annoyed because he knew it wasn't on purpose. In contrast, my ex would have kicked off and sulked through the whole of the next day and party.

It's so nice being with someone who sees the best in you and forgives mistakes. I'll never go back to walking on eggshells.

For balance, DH forgot to check his passport expiration date until right before our holiday once and then led to a last minute dash up to London to get an emergency one. I wasn't annoyed at him & we ended up making the most of it and had a funny day. I knew it was an accident and I know he's a good man so I wasn't annoyed at him.

2 laid back people together is the best combo in my experience. Or maybe 2 uptighters because they'd know where each other are coming from 🤔

billy1966 · 03/06/2023 13:12

OP, listen to your gut.

You walk on eggshells because he's critical and highly strung?

Is this really the future you want.

He's a PITA and no, sulking over such stuff is not normal.

However, if you want a stressful future, stay with him.

But please don't inflict him on a child.

My advice would be listen carefully to your gut and dump him.

Life is too short.

TeenLifeMum · 03/06/2023 13:11

You had to get 3 things and messed up on two? Yes I’d be annoyed if dh did this.

Ponoka7 · 03/06/2023 13:10

In your scenario, I'd phone from the shop.

""Which probably isn't a great combination with me as I'm very "go with the flow"/what will be will be.""

What's your/his love language, how to you show him that you care? That's something that you've got to work out when you are a couple.

Nanny0gg · 03/06/2023 13:10

FrustratedCitizen44846 · 03/06/2023 12:05

Just to clarify: this is not a pattern at all. I can't think of any other time I've ever been forgotten something like this. I get it was my mistake, I just don't feel there's any need to be so critical of what is just human error.

He is on the highly strung/critical/unforgiving end of things in general, IMO.

Which probably isn't a great combination with me as I'm very "go with the flow"/what will be will be.

I just don't see the need to get so irate over minor things. But I may very well BU.

Maybe if you'd offered to go back to get what you should have got in the first place?

Tryagainplease · 03/06/2023 13:08

Baystar · 03/06/2023 12:46

Seriously so many uptight responses over a bit of yoghurt and blueberries, did people get out of the wrong side of bed today or not get what you wanted for your own brekky 🙄

I agree with this!
I feel quite sorry for their partners.

Context surrounding the whole relationship would be more useful here IMO. My ex was overly critical about everything I did. I’m pretty easy going in relationships too but I show a huge amount of love and respect to the one I am with. He would pick at everything and it didn’t matter what I did to improve, it would never be enough. And he would never address his faults, either. I gave up trying to please him in the end because he was impossible and I left.