Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Work asking me to see violent patient while pregnant

109 replies

Kitely · 03/06/2023 11:40

Since I got pregnant work haven’t been great. My two managers have never been pregnant as sadly both have infertility. I was warned that they’re not particularly supportive of pregnant colleagues but I hadn’t seen evidence of this.
I won’t be too identifying but my job involves direct work with patients and also holding a ‘caseload’.
I work three days a week and after going down to part time my caseload didn’t reduce. Infact it got bigger. It’s totally unmanageable at the level it is. Suggested safe caseloads are less than half I have.
I was off for a month with horrendous vomiting. When I returned I received no support checking I was okay.
A 5 minute pregnancy risk assessment was done. It’s so basic and doesn’t include anything on travel which is a basic aspect of the job.
It does state I’m not to work with violent patients.

So far this month I’ve been asked to do the following I’m not comfortable with:
Asked to assess someone out of area meaning I’d be on trains from 9am-9pm except for two hours during the assessment. I’d be utterly exhausted.

Asked to assess a patient who is violent. He spits at staff, throws items, punished walls. He has done this as recently as this morning.

Asked to assess a patient who has criminal convictions for beating up his pregnant girlfriend

Given an extra 5 cases all needing urgent reviews.

So: I immediately questioned the guy who beat up his girlfriend and they reluctantly had to remove him from my caseload as it went against my risk assessment.

I asked about the other violent patient but was told he has a learning disability so it’s not deliberate and also he doesn’t do ‘anything more than throw cups or his handheld cd player at people/ spit at people’. So therefore that’s okay!

The 9am-9pm travel I was told I would be able to rest on the train so not too stressful (not mentioning the walk to the bus, getting on a tram to the location, walking back to the train station etc). It’s an arduous day.

The 5 cases needing reviewing I just decided to push myself to do as I hadn’t had a positive response regarding other concerns. It was a long day but I managed it.

I know there’s a range of options available to me (simply refusing, taking the issue to higher management, getting union involved etc).

I have long before pregnancy had concerns regarding unreasonable caseloads and expected work level. I am thinking of not returning to work after maternity as this level of work won’t be feasible with a baby to look after.

I am struggling in pregnancy with exhaustion. Doctors say it’s totally normal which is true but makes working so much more challenging. I just wish they could understand that and give me work accordingly. My Doctor has offered to sign my off sick the entire pregnancy but I’d not do that as if I need to return I’m worried it would make my life harder when returning.

So before I get assertive and refuse some of these tasks. My AIBU is this, and be honest. I won’t be offended.

Am I being a bit unreasonable not wanting to do the above tasks expected of me? I’m talking specifically about the very long day of travelling and working with the violent patient? I’m worried I’m being precious. I don’t want to take this further if I’m being unreasonable. I just feel exhausted and anxious.
I am 26 weeks pregnant.

OP posts:
ODFODeary · 03/06/2023 13:58

You shouldn't be placed with anyone that has a known history of violence
Put everything in writing and ask for a written response
Extending your working day has to be agreed by both parties as far as I'm aware
Then refuse to do it
Can't believe this shit is still happening

pillsthrillsandbellyache · 03/06/2023 13:42

Unfortunately you have shit managers so are going to have to stand firm OP. Do you feel strong enough to? My place of work sounds similar and no way would a pregnant woman be allowed anywhere near a violent client. They are normally put on light duties due to the unpredictable nature of most clients. You also wouldn't be expected to travel so far. Honestly, i would look at getting signed off. Check to see if affects your maternity package.

Bingbong9009 · 03/06/2023 13:32

Not surprised by the risk assessment - I honestly believe it’s just a tick box exercise to say it’s been completed.

can your doctor not write a fit note (this could be the wrong name for it) staying reasonable adjustments need to be in place until you go off for maternity leave?

Kitely · 03/06/2023 13:31

Adorapan · 03/06/2023 13:22

This sounds absolutely awful even if you weren’t pregnant but the fact that it’s happening during pregnancy is appalling. Do you think you are being penalised because you are pregnant or would you have been given this workload anyway and they are not given appropriate alterations to your duties?
For comparison when I was pregnant and suffering from vomiting and exhaustion my work - who were brilliant - gave me a rest space on site and worked it so that whenever possible I could work from home, although most of our work is usually done in the building. That’s what a good workplace does.

I personally think they’re annoyed I’m pregnant and off on maternity so far piling on the work so that I ‘earn’ my time off.
Several other employees have experienced similar.
One had a doctors note saying she couldn’t do visits but they repeatedly asked her to.
So there’s form for this sort of behaviour at my workplace.
They don’t bother to recruit a maternity worker for maternity posts so they expect you to close all your cases before you go on leave too. Which is a worrying practice.
but obviously I can’t prove what I suspect.
I definitely think the long travel day was deliberately given to me.
They knew no one would want to do it so gave it to me. There’s some evidence these long travel days have been deliberately given to pregnant workers in the past few years.

OP posts:
billy1966 · 03/06/2023 13:29

Clearly they couldn't care less about you.

You need to do WHATEVER is necessary to keep yourself safe.

Start an email trail and look at getting signed off.

My close friend has worked in adult services for 20 years and has several injuries which she didn't deal with that are now causing her issues in her late 50's.

Do not put yourself in any danger.

Be ruthless in putting yourself first.

Note in the email your reduced hours and increased workload.

Don't accept this.

thecatsthecats · 03/06/2023 13:27

MolkosTeenageAngst · 03/06/2023 12:25

It seems very reasonable not to agree to work with the violent client, obviously you don’t want to risk a CD player hitting your stomach and if somebody shows violent/ aggressive behaviour there is always the risk it could escalate.

Not wanting to travel does seem a bit precious though. I wouldn’t expect train travel to feature on a pregnancy risk assessment or think a pregnant woman wouldn't be capable of travelling. If your shifts are usually 12 hours long it seems a reasonable request. That said, if you usually work shorter days and on this case are being asked to work longer hours outside what is the norm I think it is reasonable to say no based on that factor, rather than the fact you need to catch the train. If there is a lot of walking to/ from the train station, between the train and the tram etc it would be reasonable to request your work pay for a taxi for this.

All risk assessments are different, obviously, but my work have told me not to come in from 20 weeks. I'm only in the office two days a week - 90m from each one, overnight stay in between. Office work only.

And travel is a bugger. It messes with meal times, the type of food you get, digestion, and overall makes you tireder. Add in pregnancy on top and you can get knackered, and it would disturb my care routine for another day or two, meaning losing half a week to one trip.

Pregnancy isn't a disease, and pregnant women aren't feeble. But what they are is genuinely 110% productive. 100% of the time your body is making a baby, then you do most of your normal stuff on top.

It's fine to acknowledge that and adjust accordingly.

Kitely · 03/06/2023 13:27

BananaBum · 03/06/2023 13:05

this is what I think too. I would love to be paid to sit on the train for a chunk of the day!

Different people find different things stressful. For me It would be an awful, arduous day. Even when not pregnant I’d return home feeling completely exhausted. In total it’s 10 hours of travelling. I would find a round trip like this tiring.
if it was a direct train with a short walk to my location from the train station I’d maybe not mind.
but it involves further travel either side of the train station.
also my working day is 9-5 and I’m being asked to work over this by 4 hours.

OP posts:
Tiddlypomtiddlypom · 03/06/2023 13:23

Decaffe · 03/06/2023 12:18

Your managers may well be shit but let’s not go down the road of pinning their shitness on infertility, eh? Hmm

I understand you may be triggered by that, but I don’t think the OP was suggesting their infertility was directly linked to them being shit managers. Come on, now.

Adorapan · 03/06/2023 13:22

This sounds absolutely awful even if you weren’t pregnant but the fact that it’s happening during pregnancy is appalling. Do you think you are being penalised because you are pregnant or would you have been given this workload anyway and they are not given appropriate alterations to your duties?
For comparison when I was pregnant and suffering from vomiting and exhaustion my work - who were brilliant - gave me a rest space on site and worked it so that whenever possible I could work from home, although most of our work is usually done in the building. That’s what a good workplace does.

Kitely · 03/06/2023 13:21

WibblyWobblyLane · 03/06/2023 12:39

I'm guessing you work in adult social services? In which case I can completely believe the the crappy conditions you're working under. I would go with your gp and get signed off

You would be correct.
Im so shocked to hear of the risk assessments other places have. When not pregnant it is standard practice to enter the homes of violent patients alone with nothing more than a mobile phone.

OP posts:
PlanningTowns · 03/06/2023 13:14

Talk to your union (assuming you’re in one) immediately and then HR. The risk assessment seems inadequate and the manager’s interpretation of it poor.

im not sure about the travel issue, if you work 9-5 the 9-9 would be unusual but unless unwell in pregnancy I’m not sure how getting a train would be a problem.

your casework sound like the whole of the public sector at the moment. But having more than a full time caseload when going part time is poor management. But I imagine staffing levels have been cut due to budgets. The reality is you can only do what you can do in the time available.

if you pay into a union this is absolutely what they are there to help you with.

AcclimDD · 03/06/2023 13:13

LakieLady · 03/06/2023 12:36

Bloody hell, their risk assessment and mitigation plans are shite.

I used to work in the community and any client with any history of violence had 2 staff at every visit, and appointments were generally held in a community setting rather than in their homes.

The 12-hour day is ridiculous, even for someone who's not pregnant. You should be allowed to stay overnight. Would it be less time consuming/exhausting to travel by car, and would they pay mileage?

I think you would be entirely reasonable to refuse, and that it's unreasonable to expect you to do such a long journey when pregnant.

I fully agree with this.
Very sensible advice.

BananaBum · 03/06/2023 13:05

HiCandles · 03/06/2023 13:01

I think you're completely right to be worried about the violent patients and would push back about that.
However I'm so surprised to hear you and others saying a 12 hour day most of which is travel is unreasonable. Many many women, myself included, continued to work 12 hour physically exhausting shifts in pregnancy with travel time before and after to get to work. To be honest actually working for just a 2 hour assessment sounds cushty, you can read/watch/listen away whilst travelling. I'd drop this part of your complaint tbh, it just sounds like you don't want to do any work and will undermine your chances of being taken seriously for the other issues.

this is what I think too. I would love to be paid to sit on the train for a chunk of the day!

BananaBum · 03/06/2023 13:03

Fedupofdiets · 03/06/2023 12:53

I agree with this tbh. I worked as a nurse right up until 37 weeks pregnant and whilst I was given patients to see that required no manual handling I still had to do all the other tasks, I remember doing bilateral compression bandages on a mans legs hunched over my bump. Pregnancy is exhausting at the best of times but they do need to minimise the risk from violent / potentially violent clients.

I had to take myself off the ward as soon as the lunch trolley came round!! 🤢

Justchooseone · 03/06/2023 13:02

I think you could probably do the travel one - if as you said you will be sitting on a train most of the day! You could take a nice packed lunch and a book it could even be quite restful. Ask for a taxi to and from the station though.
As to the violent patient throwing things - absolutely not. I don’t know what they are thinking!!

ChristmasFluff · 03/06/2023 13:01

Given what you are describing, you will have a professional body. Consult with them, they are really good.

HiCandles · 03/06/2023 13:01

I think you're completely right to be worried about the violent patients and would push back about that.
However I'm so surprised to hear you and others saying a 12 hour day most of which is travel is unreasonable. Many many women, myself included, continued to work 12 hour physically exhausting shifts in pregnancy with travel time before and after to get to work. To be honest actually working for just a 2 hour assessment sounds cushty, you can read/watch/listen away whilst travelling. I'd drop this part of your complaint tbh, it just sounds like you don't want to do any work and will undermine your chances of being taken seriously for the other issues.

itsmylife7 · 03/06/2023 13:00

Kitely · 03/06/2023 12:06

Yes a very vague one which took them 5 mins and missed out essential elements of the role

The onus is on you to get them to complete it correctly.

Stand up for yourself and refuse the client with learning issues and violence.

Freefall212 · 03/06/2023 12:57

You should have had a clear plan in place for your return. However pregnancy on its own isn't a disability. If you take all the easy close to home cases, it makes your coworkers case loads exceptionally heavy as now thye have to do your share of the travel and take on your share of the violent clients.

I think you need to pick your battles. Safety is the priority. How can they create a safer environment for you to work in? If the reality is that many of the clients are violent then how can that risk be mitigated? I am not sure what environments you are going into where people are being violent but many of those already have safer rooms with dividers or barriers or ways to keep yourself safer in the environment.

However you can't just avoid all travel or anything that would be tiring or difficult unless you have a specific pregnancy related need that requires accommodation.

You need to talk to your health care team and occ healthy or HR and create a safe working plan based on your specific needs. I worked inpatient psych at one point and many women worked right up until their due date. Pregnany on its own isn't a disability that is accommodated but it can necessitate changes to make the work environment safer (you move slower, can't do restraints, need more frequent breaks etc).

Heartsnrainbows · 03/06/2023 12:54

I'd go the route of asking your GP for a fit note stating you are well enough to work but not well enough for excessive travel and would outright refuse the violent patient. Pregnant women are not allowed to clean up bodily fluids in the workplace due to the health risks and being spat at carries the same hazards.

Ask them to state in writing that you are required to assess a patient who is regularly violent and throws things at people and who will likely spit in your face, while you are pregnant. They will either refuse and back down or give you some excellent evidence for a grievance.

Fedupofdiets · 03/06/2023 12:53

BananaBum · 03/06/2023 12:32

Agree that no way should you be near any violent patients

however unfortunately feeling exhausted is a part of being pregnant for many people and making a fuss over the travel does make you sound quite precious. Many of us have been through terrible tiredness/vomiting etc and had to carry on working

I agree with this tbh. I worked as a nurse right up until 37 weeks pregnant and whilst I was given patients to see that required no manual handling I still had to do all the other tasks, I remember doing bilateral compression bandages on a mans legs hunched over my bump. Pregnancy is exhausting at the best of times but they do need to minimise the risk from violent / potentially violent clients.

mumofblu · 03/06/2023 12:53

I was pregnant working with clients who posed risk , children and adults and learning disabilities . Also I had to travel .
I was removed into light duties , admin support / report writing / phone calls / advice line . Office based
Speak to HR then union
And the argument of harm not being intended due to lack of capacity is rubbish . Whether intentional or not the outcome of being attacked is the same . Risk to you and your unborn child .

SpareHeirOverThere · 03/06/2023 12:51

It sounds like your overall workload/caseload needs re-assessing, irregardless of pregnancy. I would contact the union about that.

No to the violent case. Of course you should not be around that.

A 12-hour day of travelling is also unreasonable if you do not feel up to it. That's always the medical advice in pregnancy - don't overstretch yourself.

Put all this in writing. YANBU.

amylou8 · 03/06/2023 12:51

I'm guessing you're in probation/social services/housing or that sort of public sector roll, in which case they'll be a well defined grievance procedure to follow. What they are asking you to do regarding clients with a history of violence is unacceptable, learning difficulties or not. I was a police officer when I was pg, and I was literally allowed to do nothing that involved public contact. They even sent me with a chaperone to court appearances in case anything kicked off, and this was 25 years ago.

musicalold · 03/06/2023 12:46

YANBU at all OP. Are occupational health involved?