Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

We need to start talking about population decline

792 replies

user4567890754 · 02/06/2023 22:15

The first signs of it are starting to show in the UK, with primary school closures. Secondary school closures will follow.

https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/11158f12-0133-11ee-a364-04e704863f75?shareToken=5ef47b2b4776be376153089146c8bacf

Italy is a few years ahead of us.

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2023/may/01/plunging-birthrate-threatens-italian-schools

Japan shows where every country is headed - towards a crisis where they are on the brink of being unable to maintain social functions.

https://edition.cnn.com/2023/04/13/asia/japan-population-decline-record-drop-intl-hnk/index.html

And yet there are still people who think that we have a problem with overpopulation. It’s the opposite.

The school with one pupil: how falling birthrates are killing village primaries

Four generations of Ruby Booker’s family have been educated at Skelton Newby Hall, an idyllic village primary school in North Yorkshire.It was the autumn of 194

https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/11158f12-0133-11ee-a364-04e704863f75?shareToken=5ef47b2b4776be376153089146c8bacf

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
hyggeb · 05/06/2023 16:59

Fewer babies equals fewer elderly people in 70 years time.

I know I’ve said this ten times on this thread but people mustn’t have read it.

They've ignored it as it's not particularly relevant to now...

Famzonhol · 05/06/2023 16:54

inamarina · 05/06/2023 16:08

That’s what I’d love to know too. Several people on this thread just keep repeating “fewer humans is a good thing” like some sort of mantra, but it’s not quite clear how we could deal with an aging population.
And no, immigration can’t be the only answer. Immigrants aren’t just there to provide services while young and healthy and than go back to their own country - they might want to settle, have kids, they too will get older one day.
Who is going to look after them?

Fewer babies equals fewer elderly people in 70 years time.

I know I’ve said this ten times on this thread but people mustn’t have read it.

Newnamenewname109870 · 05/06/2023 16:30

SideBob · 05/06/2023 15:14

but then humans will suffer. You think the planet is more important than humans? You only care about the planet because you are a human.

Yes, actually, the environment is so important for all of us.

Having fewer children doesn't equate to 'suffering'. Nobody is suggesting a cull except maybe the people complaining about old people being alive and having to look after them

But you have no logical understanding about how human life works and the fact we would not survive with only an elderly population. Do you have any idea what’s happening in the care system right now? It’s disgusting. Yes we need a lot of young people to support them and keep life going. If you don’t care about life on earth continuing, kill us all now instead of a long and painful death.

hyggeb · 05/06/2023 16:29

There would be time to support the frail, time to care properly for our children and less need for expensive childcare. The biggest benefactors would be children followed by the elderly. There would be less children removed into care, less people with mental health problems and we would be a healthier nation. It would encourage family life and would be a form of utopia for many. A balanced and equal society

There wouldn't be enough numbers in the workforce though.

illiterato · 05/06/2023 16:09

GCalltheway · 05/06/2023 15:32

So what if we do this. We return to a time when one salary is enough to comfortably and enjoyably as it used to be in the 70s. Quality of life was prioritised across the country. This could be achieved; if there was the political will to do so. One parent of either sex can remain at home if they want to or each parent works part time thus allowing home to become central again.

This would automatically increase community engagement, investment and time with neighbours Inc the elderly and takes the rush and sting out of everyone’s lives. There would be time to support the frail, time to care properly for our children and less need for expensive childcare. The biggest benefactors would be children followed by the elderly. There would be less children removed into care, less people with mental health problems and we would be a healthier nation. It would encourage family life and would be a form of utopia for many. A balanced and equal society.

Because you’ve just decreased the workforce by roughly 30% ( by taking out one worker per family) thus exacerbating the problem that is already being caused by depopulation.

inamarina · 05/06/2023 16:08

Oliotya · 05/06/2023 15:42

But seriously, who is going to look after the old people? We're already struggling to fund pensions and staff care healthcare.

That’s what I’d love to know too. Several people on this thread just keep repeating “fewer humans is a good thing” like some sort of mantra, but it’s not quite clear how we could deal with an aging population.
And no, immigration can’t be the only answer. Immigrants aren’t just there to provide services while young and healthy and than go back to their own country - they might want to settle, have kids, they too will get older one day.
Who is going to look after them?

Tenacioustattle · 05/06/2023 15:49

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Oliotya · 05/06/2023 15:42

SideBob · 05/06/2023 15:14

but then humans will suffer. You think the planet is more important than humans? You only care about the planet because you are a human.

Yes, actually, the environment is so important for all of us.

Having fewer children doesn't equate to 'suffering'. Nobody is suggesting a cull except maybe the people complaining about old people being alive and having to look after them

But seriously, who is going to look after the old people? We're already struggling to fund pensions and staff care healthcare.

GCalltheway · 05/06/2023 15:32

So what if we do this. We return to a time when one salary is enough to comfortably and enjoyably as it used to be in the 70s. Quality of life was prioritised across the country. This could be achieved; if there was the political will to do so. One parent of either sex can remain at home if they want to or each parent works part time thus allowing home to become central again.

This would automatically increase community engagement, investment and time with neighbours Inc the elderly and takes the rush and sting out of everyone’s lives. There would be time to support the frail, time to care properly for our children and less need for expensive childcare. The biggest benefactors would be children followed by the elderly. There would be less children removed into care, less people with mental health problems and we would be a healthier nation. It would encourage family life and would be a form of utopia for many. A balanced and equal society.

SideBob · 05/06/2023 15:14

but then humans will suffer. You think the planet is more important than humans? You only care about the planet because you are a human.

Yes, actually, the environment is so important for all of us.

Having fewer children doesn't equate to 'suffering'. Nobody is suggesting a cull except maybe the people complaining about old people being alive and having to look after them

Nothingisblackandwhite · 05/06/2023 14:44

illiterato · 05/06/2023 12:24

Housing and childcare are the big disincentives atm

If this is true, why is Sweden at 1.7?

The thing is there will nearly always be a tangible financial benefit to a (UK) family of having fewer children. Only the Uber rich are not financially affected by one more child. For nearly everyone else, 2 children vs 3 children is likely to lead to higher discretionary income, which is something most people want- holidays, days out, nicer house etc.

Because just as anywhere else in the modern world women want to enjoy their youth , list of Swedish mums are in their 40 or late 30s meaning having multiple children without intervention is harder .

Newnamenewname109870 · 05/06/2023 13:55

SideBob · 05/06/2023 09:36

Correct. Less people will save the planet. More people solves precisely nothing.

but then humans will suffer. You think the planet is more important than humans? You only care about the planet because you are a human.

Newnamenewname109870 · 05/06/2023 13:52

SunnyEgg · 05/06/2023 08:21

Would you prefer to keep growing the population, how does it look over time?

My dream? We can keep it static and improve global warming by other means and you know world inequality. With the latter, the population would start decreasing anyway. Pretending that we should all stop having children to solve the problem is silly.

Thesharkradar · 05/06/2023 13:46

Men would have to want to do this. I see no indication at scale that they do so I remain dubious
Then we need to structure incentives such that being good and decent is their best option for getting on in life.

OutsideLookingOut · 05/06/2023 13:44

Thesharkradar · 05/06/2023 13:40

For the avoidance of doubt absolutely women SHOULD be educated and free to have children or not have children according to their own preferences.
I think you're doing men a disservice, they are capable of being good partners and fathers, the sticking point is that boys and young men need older men to provide much better role models for them. So the older men need to pull themselves up by their (chauvinistic) bootstraps- which is a big ask I Grant you!

Haha yes - I do not advocate for taking away women’s freedom but I also think the population must decrease - we have to find a better way to support the old than a Ponzi scheme.

Men would have to want to do this. I see no indication at scale that they do so I remain dubious.

And again because having a child means giving birth there will be many women with options who are not fussed about doing that.

TripleDaisySummer · 05/06/2023 13:42

https://www.arup.com/perspectives/what-does-an-age-inclusive-city-look-like

We should look a building for an older population now - many things like fewer trip hazards, more benches., think about urban heat with climate change and perhaps better separation of pedestrian and traffic would be positive for wider population.

https://www.theguardian.com/cities/2016/apr/25/improving-with-age-how-city-design-is-adapting-to-older-populations

What does an age inclusive city look like?

https://www.arup.com/perspectives/what-does-an-age-inclusive-city-look-like

Thesharkradar · 05/06/2023 13:40

OutsideLookingOut · 05/06/2023 13:33

I sadly don’t see that ever happening. It would help for the women who want kids for sure but there are women who just don’t want kids. With education and freedom these women get to remain child free.

For the avoidance of doubt absolutely women SHOULD be educated and free to have children or not have children according to their own preferences.
I think you're doing men a disservice, they are capable of being good partners and fathers, the sticking point is that boys and young men need older men to provide much better role models for them. So the older men need to pull themselves up by their (chauvinistic) bootstraps- which is a big ask I Grant you!

inamarina · 05/06/2023 13:39

DarkForces · 05/06/2023 13:12

It's completely ageist to write people aged 65+ as elderly. Their contribution in terms of caring for relatives, volunteering and through employment is enormous. Living longer, healthier lives should be celebrated. I for one am very glad to have my parents around in their 70s. They're amazing and not a burden in the least.

Again, nobody’s disputing their contributions. But as they get older they will most likely need more and help. That’s not a criticism either, just reality.
And if there aren’t enough working age people around to look after them it will become a problem.
If you google elderly + what age you get different results, including people who are 65+. Personally I know people in their 70s who are fit and active and who I wouldn’t regard as ‘elderly’. But that’s not the point here.
Fwiw, I definitely don’t regard older/ elderly people as a burden.

GCalltheway · 05/06/2023 13:37

DarkForces · 05/06/2023 11:51

That's a huge number of people to generalise about and very ageist. Most 65 year olds will have many healthy years ahead of them and do a lot of the care for family and friends.

I disagree. Retirement age is the beginning of old age! It’s not ageist, is fact, you can see the uptick of health problems set in at this age and upwards. You may not like it, and you may be very active but it doesn’t change biology

OutsideLookingOut · 05/06/2023 13:33

Thesharkradar · 05/06/2023 12:55

Alternatively, educate men so that they can be decent good fathers and partners.
If we had men who stepped up and did their fair share rather than always prioritising their own interests and their own earning potential women might be more willing to have children with them☝️😁

I sadly don’t see that ever happening. It would help for the women who want kids for sure but there are women who just don’t want kids. With education and freedom these women get to remain child free.

DarkForces · 05/06/2023 13:12

It's completely ageist to write people aged 65+ as elderly. Their contribution in terms of caring for relatives, volunteering and through employment is enormous. Living longer, healthier lives should be celebrated. I for one am very glad to have my parents around in their 70s. They're amazing and not a burden in the least.

Thesharkradar · 05/06/2023 12:55

OutsideLookingOut · 05/06/2023 12:26

Educated women. Remove education for women and you’d get a higher population.

Alternatively, educate men so that they can be decent good fathers and partners.
If we had men who stepped up and did their fair share rather than always prioritising their own interests and their own earning potential women might be more willing to have children with them☝️😁

inamarina · 05/06/2023 12:52

DarkForces · 05/06/2023 11:51

That's a huge number of people to generalise about and very ageist. Most 65 year olds will have many healthy years ahead of them and do a lot of the care for family and friends.

I think PPs point is not that a large percentage of 65-68 year olds within a population is a bad thing as such (whether it is or it isn’t is a different topic), but that an aging population is a problem.
You might not define 65-68 year olds as “elderly”, but the point is they’re getting older and if there aren’t enough younger/ working age people to look after them as they age, then that’s a problem. Nothing ageist about it.

OutsideLookingOut · 05/06/2023 12:26

illiterato · 05/06/2023 12:24

Housing and childcare are the big disincentives atm

If this is true, why is Sweden at 1.7?

The thing is there will nearly always be a tangible financial benefit to a (UK) family of having fewer children. Only the Uber rich are not financially affected by one more child. For nearly everyone else, 2 children vs 3 children is likely to lead to higher discretionary income, which is something most people want- holidays, days out, nicer house etc.

Educated women. Remove education for women and you’d get a higher population.

illiterato · 05/06/2023 12:24

heartofglass23 · 05/06/2023 10:02

To get a uk replacement rate of 2.1 we need half of women to have 3 DCs and 30% to have 2DCs. This is because it's been consistent historically (pre contraception etc) for 20% of women to never have DCs.

The jump from 2 to 3 is so big we need to make that step easier to not have the chaos of a bulge of elderly people and a shrinking working population.

It's not about never ending growth but about going back to c 50 million in the uk and keeping that steady.

Housing and childcare are the big disincentives atm.

Those are fixable by better social policies.

Push our elected representatives for the changes we need!

Housing and childcare are the big disincentives atm

If this is true, why is Sweden at 1.7?

The thing is there will nearly always be a tangible financial benefit to a (UK) family of having fewer children. Only the Uber rich are not financially affected by one more child. For nearly everyone else, 2 children vs 3 children is likely to lead to higher discretionary income, which is something most people want- holidays, days out, nicer house etc.