Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

We need to start talking about population decline

792 replies

user4567890754 · 02/06/2023 22:15

The first signs of it are starting to show in the UK, with primary school closures. Secondary school closures will follow.

https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/11158f12-0133-11ee-a364-04e704863f75?shareToken=5ef47b2b4776be376153089146c8bacf

Italy is a few years ahead of us.

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2023/may/01/plunging-birthrate-threatens-italian-schools

Japan shows where every country is headed - towards a crisis where they are on the brink of being unable to maintain social functions.

https://edition.cnn.com/2023/04/13/asia/japan-population-decline-record-drop-intl-hnk/index.html

And yet there are still people who think that we have a problem with overpopulation. It’s the opposite.

The school with one pupil: how falling birthrates are killing village primaries

Four generations of Ruby Booker’s family have been educated at Skelton Newby Hall, an idyllic village primary school in North Yorkshire.It was the autumn of 194

https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/11158f12-0133-11ee-a364-04e704863f75?shareToken=5ef47b2b4776be376153089146c8bacf

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
Phoebo · 02/06/2023 22:55

evuscha · 02/06/2023 22:41

Well, if people live into their 90’s, but with many health issues, needing care, then that has to be funded somehow, from, I don’t know…taxes?

Yes but it defies logic doesn't it, because then those people get old and need funding and so on. It's exponential. And it also means quality of life declines. It's actually very stupid model.

HowNowBrownElephant · 02/06/2023 22:54

inky1991 · 02/06/2023 22:42

I don't think Mumsnet is the place you're going to get much support on this OP. Although personally, I completely agree with you and have watched that documentary.

All you're going to get is the automated responses about climate change and immigration. It's quite funny that people don't realise immigration doesn't solve low birth rates or population decline.

I'm sure people will start to realise the gravity of the situation in 2/3 decades when there'll be no retirement age, or pensions or any sort of adult social care as there won't be a good enough working population to support it.

This, 100%

user4567890754 · 02/06/2023 22:53

PriamFarrl · 02/06/2023 22:39

I understand you concern. As the population gets older we need more young people to pay into pensions and care for the elderly. But what do you propose to do about it op? Force people to have more children?

It was pointed out on Radio 4 the other day then when labour came to power the birth rate was falling, so they put in financial incentives and things like surestart. The current government took them away and birth rate started to fall again.

As for the school you linked to, I wonder how many houses in the village are holiday homes…?

The “what do we do about it” is very difficult and worrying. Financial incentives don’t seem to be very effective over the longer term. Some countries have been trying that already - eg Poland. if I think about myself, there is no reasonable financial incentive that would persuade me to have another child.

The concern is that, especially in non-democratic countries, if women can’t be persuaded to have more children, then the government will attack the problem in other ways. China is already restricting abortion rights ina desperate attempt to increase birth rates (even after so many years they spent trying to reduce them!).

The documentary I linked to above suggests that tackling unplanned childlessness might be the answer - women who wanted to have children but ran out of time fertility-wise because of lack of a suitable or willing partner, pressures of education and career, or whatever. But restructuring society to tackle those underlying issues is not simple either!

OP posts:
JustanothermagicMonday1 · 02/06/2023 22:51

We just have to hope that artificial intelligence aka robots will
look after the elderly and decarbonise the atmosphere. Gene tech is coming to make us all live even longer.

The Gilead point is a valid one though. We have to keep normalising breeding as a social norm.

Does anyone want to kill off the elderly? Say you get to 90 and that is it? For all or just those who can’t afford it? Those countries that force women to give birth…be careful. Forced birth and forced death, not so different as a concept.

nosyupnorth · 02/06/2023 22:50

Populations have been expanding rapidly since the industrial revolution and a minor dip now needs to be taken in perspective. Population contraction will likely cause short term issues related to an aging population, such as the current situation in Japan, but over a few generations will lead to a more stable population, rather than one which is constantly growing beyond what is sustainable for the resources on the planet.

You will always see companies and goverments pushing for more more more but that is because people are just sources of income to them, in reality most people would benefit more from a stable society where resources were abundant.

Catchasingmewithspiders · 02/06/2023 22:50

It's quite funny that people don't realise immigration doesn't solve low birth rates or population decline.

Muslim families in the UK and Europe have on average one child per family more than non Muslim families.

Therefore a greater immigration of Mulism people into the UK would boost the birth rate.

Im not sure how the Government would manage to do such turn on their stance on immigration though.

WrigglyDonCat · 02/06/2023 22:49

user4567890754 · 02/06/2023 22:33

https://www.birthgap.org/spaces/10215679/page

I recommend this documentary for further information. Demographic change is not as far away as you think. It’s going to impact the lives of people alive today. The birth rate is below replacement rate across the whole developed world already. We are currently able to attract enough migrants to the UK to keep things running, but that may change.

In around 2050 the global fertility rate may fall below replacement level. It’s already at 2.3. Replacement rate is 2.1.

The purely logical standpoint would be to head out tomorrow and 'remove' 75% of the human population. I reckon about 2 billion is a sensible and sustainable world population.

Obviously morals and ethics get in the way of logic from time to time. For anyone with a brain, the obvious thing to do about an ageing population and/or a declining population is to figure out how to work with the demographic change. The incredibly dangerous and naive thing (hence it's what governments of all colours have done for decades) to do is to try and inflate the population to deal with a perceived shortfall of workers.

Spoiler alert, immigration on average is a net economic drain on society in the short and medium term and only reaches equilibrium economically after decades. Bringing in workers to deal with a shortfall is treating symptoms not cause and simply pushes the problem down the road to be an even bigger issue down the line.

Why does nothing work in the UK - let's have a think - oh yes, population has increased by around 14%, >8 million people, in 20 years - I wonder if that might not be a considerable influencing factor? The previous 14% growth took around 45 years (which includes the post-war rush for workers...)

HeadNorth · 02/06/2023 22:47

Immigration is the answer. Japan has low immigration. Immigration is our friend to bring in workers to support our aging population. But it seems we don’t want non Brits, we have to breed our own pure stock. Madness.

Mumto32022 · 02/06/2023 22:46

Try telling any midwife in the UK that there’s a population decline… I’m pretty sure this isn’t UK wide. Eg major cities / towns

Catchasingmewithspiders · 02/06/2023 22:45

Village schools have been closing for years, most of them in small villages where families used to have 5 or 6 children to send to school and now only have 1 or 2.

I'm not sure as a country we can simultaneously moan about the birth rate dropping and claim we are too over populated to allow for immigration

If they actually want to increase the birth rate bring back child benefits for more than 2 children. Taking that away made the abortion rate spike and has also forced families into poverty.

But again people moaned (and still do) about families being paid child benefit

DemonicCaveMaggot · 02/06/2023 22:44

There was a net population increase in the UK last year of over 600,000 people. Given that sea levels are rising and people near coasts, low lying island nations, and living close to an increasingly hotter equator are going to need to move it is likely that our population will continue to grow - to the detriment of all the native animals and plants.

The last thing we need is people having huge numbers of children.

If you are bothered, go sponsor a Duggar. That family's descendants will number about 67 million in 250 years.

Rowthe · 02/06/2023 22:43

Phoebo · 02/06/2023 22:20

Unfortunately governments just want taxpayers, so keep encouraging people to breed, breed, breed!

I dont think they are encouraging people to 'breed'.

Child benefit isnt much and nursery fees are crippling.

Hopingforagreatescape · 02/06/2023 22:43

I think it can only be a good thing. If Japan needs more workers then it should consider importing from abroad. The world has plenty of people, it's just that movement has become so difficult.

inky1991 · 02/06/2023 22:42

I don't think Mumsnet is the place you're going to get much support on this OP. Although personally, I completely agree with you and have watched that documentary.

All you're going to get is the automated responses about climate change and immigration. It's quite funny that people don't realise immigration doesn't solve low birth rates or population decline.

I'm sure people will start to realise the gravity of the situation in 2/3 decades when there'll be no retirement age, or pensions or any sort of adult social care as there won't be a good enough working population to support it.

rinseandrepeat1 · 02/06/2023 22:41

The world population grew by 2.5 BILLION in the last 50 years...... I think that's enough people.

evuscha · 02/06/2023 22:41

Phoebo · 02/06/2023 22:20

Unfortunately governments just want taxpayers, so keep encouraging people to breed, breed, breed!

Well, if people live into their 90’s, but with many health issues, needing care, then that has to be funded somehow, from, I don’t know…taxes?

Hohofortherobbers · 02/06/2023 22:41

Don't be bloody ridiculous, there's loads of us. We should just spread out a bit.

Phoebo · 02/06/2023 22:40

Phoebo · 02/06/2023 22:20

Unfortunately governments just want taxpayers, so keep encouraging people to breed, breed, breed!

Completely misunderstood the title! Population decline is a good thing, where I live has changed so much now, everything is busting at the seams. Bring on population decline I say.

mauveiscurious · 02/06/2023 22:39

RudsyFarmer · 02/06/2023 22:25

People can’t afford to have children. I guess this is why some countries are starting to make abortion illegal.

America has been looking at what their population will look like in a 100 years

Gilead here we come

PriamFarrl · 02/06/2023 22:39

I understand you concern. As the population gets older we need more young people to pay into pensions and care for the elderly. But what do you propose to do about it op? Force people to have more children?

It was pointed out on Radio 4 the other day then when labour came to power the birth rate was falling, so they put in financial incentives and things like surestart. The current government took them away and birth rate started to fall again.

As for the school you linked to, I wonder how many houses in the village are holiday homes…?

user4567890754 · 02/06/2023 22:37

PrrrplePineapple · 02/06/2023 22:28

"On the brink of being unable to maintain social functions"? Come on, now. We have more people then ever before on this planet, and we've been maintaining social functions for centuries with much smaller populations thean we have now. Get a grip.

Also, if you cannot understand that the planet has limited and finite resources and the impending threat to significant swathes of humanity is that we're running out of food production capabilities and clean water, and that the effects of that are going to be nothing short of devastating, a quick Google will give you tons of reading materials to give you a new perspective. Start with a book called Ten Billion, then come back and let us know if you still think population decrease is the thing to be worried about right now.

If you read the article you will see that "On the brink of being unable to maintain social functions” is the way the Prime Minister of Japan is describing the crisis his country is facing right now.

OP posts:
cyncope · 02/06/2023 22:37

Plenty of people want to come and live here though?

Ylvamoon · 02/06/2023 22:36

Less humans would be better!

The uk is an island, maybe once all the farmland and current greenbelt is turned into housing/ warehouses / wasteland/ landfill you'll understand that we need a decline in the population.

I know declining population is a scary thought. Our model of retirement and care is based on support from the working population. Governments will have to act ... raise retirement age (✔), encourage families to care for their elderly relatives, offering good financial packages for retirement and all the staff we haven't thought of yet.

RedRiverSun · 02/06/2023 22:35

This is a GOOD thing. There is no more destructive species on the planet. We need a sustainable population.

Alphabet1spaghetti2 · 02/06/2023 22:35

They’ve been closing primary schools for decades, it’s just on occasion it hits the news. It’s nothing new. Several local primary schools closed in the 1970s. They didn’t build a new school to replace them all, or even build/rent extra classrooms for those primary schools left open. All rural. The nearest secondary school closed one of its sites (years split across two sites) later on in the 1990s - again no new school/extra development on existing site.

Swipe left for the next trending thread