Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

We need to start talking about population decline

792 replies

user4567890754 · 02/06/2023 22:15

The first signs of it are starting to show in the UK, with primary school closures. Secondary school closures will follow.

https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/11158f12-0133-11ee-a364-04e704863f75?shareToken=5ef47b2b4776be376153089146c8bacf

Italy is a few years ahead of us.

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2023/may/01/plunging-birthrate-threatens-italian-schools

Japan shows where every country is headed - towards a crisis where they are on the brink of being unable to maintain social functions.

https://edition.cnn.com/2023/04/13/asia/japan-population-decline-record-drop-intl-hnk/index.html

And yet there are still people who think that we have a problem with overpopulation. It’s the opposite.

The school with one pupil: how falling birthrates are killing village primaries

Four generations of Ruby Booker’s family have been educated at Skelton Newby Hall, an idyllic village primary school in North Yorkshire.It was the autumn of 194

https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/11158f12-0133-11ee-a364-04e704863f75?shareToken=5ef47b2b4776be376153089146c8bacf

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
Famzonhol · 03/06/2023 08:06

hyggeb · 03/06/2023 05:10

I'm sure people will start to realise the gravity of the situation in 2/3 decades when there'll be no retirement age, or pensions or any sort of adult social care as there won't be a good enough working population to support it.

It's bizarre people can't join the dots.

Fewer people means fewer elderly people going forward.

BadLad · 03/06/2023 08:06

hyggeb · 03/06/2023 07:58

@BadLad That is what Japan has done, I haven't made a comment on whether those policies were correct or not. For a while though they were considered by some to have a good model of dealing with the demographic shift. However there has definitely been a shift in how they see older people.

Fair enough. I consider that pretty much fuck all in terms of practical solutions. I’ve never read any commentary praising them for their efforts but I’ve seen plenty criticizing the LDP for its cluelessness. Obviously you and I read different sources. I wonder what will happen in 2026, which is a fire horse year.

hyggeb · 03/06/2023 08:06

It wouldn't surprise me if I never see my state pension. The age I can claim it has risen three times since I started working.

It probably a reality as healthy life expectancy has stagnated.

User135644 · 03/06/2023 08:05

Jk987 · 02/06/2023 22:25

My first thoughts are that there are less people choosing to live in rural Britain. Many schools in towns and cities are over subscribed. Net migration is high and that can counteract a low birth rate. I don't think there's an issue but maybe the government should encourage more people to move to the countryside?

Rural areas are generally full of older people. Class sizes in cities are huge.

hyggeb · 03/06/2023 08:05

Hasn't there recently been an increase in the number of people of working age who are not working? That might be fuelling the problem

There has been an unexpected "silver exodus" but many of those people have just retired early because they can afford it or due to ill health. Not sure how we can incentivise those back.

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 03/06/2023 08:04

WrigglyDonCat · 02/06/2023 22:49

The purely logical standpoint would be to head out tomorrow and 'remove' 75% of the human population. I reckon about 2 billion is a sensible and sustainable world population.

Obviously morals and ethics get in the way of logic from time to time. For anyone with a brain, the obvious thing to do about an ageing population and/or a declining population is to figure out how to work with the demographic change. The incredibly dangerous and naive thing (hence it's what governments of all colours have done for decades) to do is to try and inflate the population to deal with a perceived shortfall of workers.

Spoiler alert, immigration on average is a net economic drain on society in the short and medium term and only reaches equilibrium economically after decades. Bringing in workers to deal with a shortfall is treating symptoms not cause and simply pushes the problem down the road to be an even bigger issue down the line.

Why does nothing work in the UK - let's have a think - oh yes, population has increased by around 14%, >8 million people, in 20 years - I wonder if that might not be a considerable influencing factor? The previous 14% growth took around 45 years (which includes the post-war rush for workers...)

Yes.

musixa · 03/06/2023 08:03

orangegato · 03/06/2023 08:00

I think peoples main concern is too many old people compared to children. We have way too many people, just not enough young ones.

Maybe you should be able to choose to retire earlier at a reduced state pension, meaning the age does not go up for everyone, it’s a choice.

It wouldn't surprise me if I never see my state pension. The age I can claim it has risen three times since I started working.

hyggeb · 03/06/2023 08:02

You're just being obtuse about the first point, purposefully so I expect.

What's your excuse? Ignorance?

Again I'm not sure what you're going on about with who wants what- I was saying humans will be gone one day and it'll be good for everything else. It's not a bad thing.

Amazing! I'm sure we will look forward to more of your insightful contributions 😆

QuintanaRoo · 03/06/2023 08:01

Mumto32022 · 02/06/2023 22:46

Try telling any midwife in the UK that there’s a population decline… I’m pretty sure this isn’t UK wide. Eg major cities / towns

I’m a midwife and there is definitely a birth rate decline. All the birth rate stats from local hospitals demonstrate this. Hospitals which a few years ago were having a bit over 4000 births a year are now around 3700-3600 and dropping every year. Maternity depts are struggling to be allowed to recruit to a vacancy when someone leaves as the board say not as many midwives are needed/income is dropping as not as many women coming through.

AmazonAmazibe · 03/06/2023 08:00

All these people saying ‘it’s villages’, it’s North East London too. I work with schools and I’d say a third of those I work with have reduced their PAN or have enough vacancies to have funding issues. Some have closed.

29 out of 32 London boroughs are reporting a fall in numbers. Over the last ten years the city’s birth rate fell 17%.

It’s creating a funding crisis near me, as schools are funded per pupil. One is 48% empty, overall it’s about 12%- a 12% funding loss. Many groups who are filling extra spaces are transient groups, such as clusters of Ukrainians or workers, who stay short -term

orangegato · 03/06/2023 08:00

I think peoples main concern is too many old people compared to children. We have way too many people, just not enough young ones.

Maybe you should be able to choose to retire earlier at a reduced state pension, meaning the age does not go up for everyone, it’s a choice.

hyggeb · 03/06/2023 07:59

I don’t think the JP government has the slightest clue about how to plan for its low birth rate.

I agree with that. Tbh I think once the mindset has shifted you can't undo it. Obviously high living costs are a huge issue.

China now has the three child policy but I can't see that working.

Froffycoffee · 03/06/2023 07:58

hyggeb · 03/06/2023 07:54

@Froffycoffee

Ridiculous, we won't always have the gov er have now and if there are huge huge issues I'm sure someone will say ah okay let's look at how we fund this. The issue now is that schools aren't paid enough per child, not that they pay per child.

No, falling rolls do impact school budgets because it's done by headcount's. That's the current model. A school still needs SEN etc regardless of the numbers & there's a huge crisis there currently. And yes a different gov could change it but the current gov aren't.

Not sure what the second part even means

I thought it was pretty clear so I don't really know what else to say...

You're just being obtuse about the first point, purposefully so I expect.

Again I'm not sure what you're going on about with who wants what- I was saying humans will be gone one day and it'll be good for everything else. It's not a bad thing.

Famzonhol · 03/06/2023 07:58

user4567890754 · 03/06/2023 00:03

Immigration won’t solve the problem forever. Eventually every country is going to be putting in measures to hold on to their own citizens. There’s also an ethical question about accelerating depopulation in other countries by “stealing” their citizens.

And this does not solve the problem of overall global decline. unless we’re going to “close down” some countries and redistribute all the people. Even if we did that, Once the world population starts to fall, how are we ever going to get it back to replacement rate? In the longer term humanity will shrink and disappear, with increasingly hard and isolated lives for the survivors. I happen to think that the human race is a valuable and interesting part if planet Earth and we need to think about how we will protect it!

In the shorter term, Our entire economic and social structure is based on a growing population. It is going to have to adapt.

Just take housing, as one example. In Japan, there are right now many empty houses, indeed whole abandoned villages. This means house prices go down. In Italy they are selling houses for 1 euro. Great if you want to get on the property ladder, but what happens to those communities? What happens to the shops and cinemas and services now that there’s no one to staff them? And now we’re no longer building new houses. What happens to the construction industry? And how much of your pension is invested in housing or construction? What happens to people who bought their houses before prices collapsed? And that’s just one industry. Imagine this repeated across all industries and the kind of economic and social devastation that will result.

A falling population is the future. This is going to happen and we probably can’t stop it. We need to be planning now for how we’re going to adapt.

So we should keep breeding just to support the housing and construction industry?

hyggeb · 03/06/2023 07:58

@BadLad That is what Japan has done, I haven't made a comment on whether those policies were correct or not. For a while though they were considered by some to have a good model of dealing with the demographic shift. However there has definitely been a shift in how they see older people.

BadLad · 03/06/2023 07:57

And whatever they are trying to do to improve birth rates is having fuck all effect. It is historically low and getting no better whatsoever. They do nothing to address the cramped conditions many families live in and companies just ignore the laws about overtime limits. I don’t think the JP government has the slightest clue about how to plan for its low birth rate.

hyggeb · 03/06/2023 07:54

@Froffycoffee

Ridiculous, we won't always have the gov er have now and if there are huge huge issues I'm sure someone will say ah okay let's look at how we fund this. The issue now is that schools aren't paid enough per child, not that they pay per child.

No, falling rolls do impact school budgets because it's done by headcount's. That's the current model. A school still needs SEN etc regardless of the numbers & there's a huge crisis there currently. And yes a different gov could change it but the current gov aren't.

Not sure what the second part even means

I thought it was pretty clear so I don't really know what else to say...

BadLad · 03/06/2023 07:52

The staying healthy is making things worse, seeing as people live longer and therefore the ratio of old to young is getting worse.

I haven’t seen much of this changing infrastructure as a government policy to improve the birth rate. I thought it was getting worse. More and more people cramming into the mega cities while small villages in the countryside have fewer and fewer young people and end up with just old people, hence the large number of deserted houses.

The robots aren’t going to address the real issue, which is that there is going to be a horrendous tax burden on future generations when young people are such a minority compared to the elderly.

Froffycoffee · 03/06/2023 07:52

hyggeb · 03/06/2023 07:45

@BadLad about 20 yrs ago they implemented a care insurance plan for people (they didn't used to have one). They have invested in emerging tech eg robots. They have tried to make the country more "age ready" eg changing infrastructure & making more things physically accessible. They have also tried to boost birth rates eg higher benefits, cheaper childcare etc.
And of course there is a strong message within the culture to be personally responsible which includes staying healthy particularly as you age.

Having said that it's not been enough and the PM recently said “Japan is standing on the verge of whether we can continue to function as a society,” & wants to heavily boost investment in children.

Meanwhile the UK hasn't done anything except increase state pension age. I actually thought the blanket h&s levy was a good policy but they scrapped that. We don't even have enough suitable housing.

The best thing we could do here is have some grown up discussions about whether keeping people alive as long as possible despite the quality of life, amount of medication and whatever else.

musixa · 03/06/2023 07:51

Hasn't there recently been an increase in the number of people of working age who are not working? That might be fuelling the problem. The government needs to incentivise people into the workplace, which they could do by increasing minimum wage and placing caps on the salaries/bonuses paid to executives (to cover this cost).

hyggeb · 03/06/2023 07:50

www.ft.com/content/342d059e-7252-4212-8bfc-1f508b063f17

this is a good article on global population trends. The UN already thinks u15s peaked in 2021. And the growth to 9bn that's forecast is largely due to a surge in older people.

That's why the "just grab some migrants" becomes an interesting conversation as lots of countries in the West will be competing for them as well as some of their own countries which will become far more prosperous.

Froffycoffee · 03/06/2023 07:49

hyggeb · 03/06/2023 05:44

Finding metrics can change if the current models aren't working ie paying per pupil

Yeah the point is we aren't great aren't changing models. It's not like there is problems in education now re school budgets...

The planet will be immeasurably better off without us so good news if we are on our way out.

Are you volunteering to go first? I think it's an interesting debate does the right of a living person to live as long as they want trump the right of another who wants a child? Economically younger people are more valuable. Societies don't tend to progress without new blood.

Ridiculous, we won't always have the gov er have now and if there are huge huge issues I'm sure someone will say ah okay let's look at how we fund this. The issue now is that schools aren't paid enough per child, not that they pay per child.

Not sure what the second part even means, I'm saying if humans are no longer sustainable the planet and every other creature on earth will be much better off, so happy days when that happens (just not for us).

hyggeb · 03/06/2023 07:45

@BadLad about 20 yrs ago they implemented a care insurance plan for people (they didn't used to have one). They have invested in emerging tech eg robots. They have tried to make the country more "age ready" eg changing infrastructure & making more things physically accessible. They have also tried to boost birth rates eg higher benefits, cheaper childcare etc.
And of course there is a strong message within the culture to be personally responsible which includes staying healthy particularly as you age.

Having said that it's not been enough and the PM recently said “Japan is standing on the verge of whether we can continue to function as a society,” & wants to heavily boost investment in children.

Meanwhile the UK hasn't done anything except increase state pension age. I actually thought the blanket h&s levy was a good policy but they scrapped that. We don't even have enough suitable housing.

ferneytorro · 03/06/2023 07:36

user4567890754 · 02/06/2023 22:33

https://www.birthgap.org/spaces/10215679/page

I recommend this documentary for further information. Demographic change is not as far away as you think. It’s going to impact the lives of people alive today. The birth rate is below replacement rate across the whole developed world already. We are currently able to attract enough migrants to the UK to keep things running, but that may change.

In around 2050 the global fertility rate may fall below replacement level. It’s already at 2.3. Replacement rate is 2.1.

Agree op but as another posted out (very amusing post) upthread, the bandwagon is climate change currently so all focus has to be on that from celebs politicians and companies.

it’s all a bit of a moot point though. In the end this planet will do what it has to do. We are delusional if we think we are more powerful than the planet is.

Goldbar · 03/06/2023 07:30

hyggeb · 03/06/2023 07:23

I feel the mess is more to do with poor planning tbh

The gov could do more but you're right people don't want to hear. Look at how many people on this thread think the UKs issue it's down to too many babies...

Or you get comments like people have paid all their lives for their care later on. Or a&e is full because of drunks on the weekend or sprained ankles. And of course everyone thinks someone else should pay.

Exactly. If they've paid all their life, where is their money now?

It doesn't matter what people have paid, there's no magic pot of money sat waiting for them. Their entitlement to anything at all from the government in their retirement depends on the policies in place at the time, and whether the government can fund these by extracting sufficient taxes from working age people.

If the workers can't pay because there are not enough of them, then you can whistle for your entitlement. And it doesn't matter what you paid.