Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

We need to start talking about population decline

792 replies

user4567890754 · 02/06/2023 22:15

The first signs of it are starting to show in the UK, with primary school closures. Secondary school closures will follow.

https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/11158f12-0133-11ee-a364-04e704863f75?shareToken=5ef47b2b4776be376153089146c8bacf

Italy is a few years ahead of us.

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2023/may/01/plunging-birthrate-threatens-italian-schools

Japan shows where every country is headed - towards a crisis where they are on the brink of being unable to maintain social functions.

https://edition.cnn.com/2023/04/13/asia/japan-population-decline-record-drop-intl-hnk/index.html

And yet there are still people who think that we have a problem with overpopulation. It’s the opposite.

The school with one pupil: how falling birthrates are killing village primaries

Four generations of Ruby Booker’s family have been educated at Skelton Newby Hall, an idyllic village primary school in North Yorkshire.It was the autumn of 194

https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/11158f12-0133-11ee-a364-04e704863f75?shareToken=5ef47b2b4776be376153089146c8bacf

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
Secondwindplease · 03/06/2023 08:23

WhimHoff · 02/06/2023 22:28

Surely more to do with house prices? Nothing available in most villages near me for less than half a million quid. People move to the countryside when they or their children are older so primary schools will suffer.

DH and I moved somewhere very rural 4 years ago. We got married here and are prime child bearing age. Yay for the village!

So let me tell you how it has gone. There is a minibus that comes once a day, three days a week for £9 return. You get around 2.5 hrs in the local town if you catch it. So I finally learned to drive and we are now a two car family, at significantly more expense than when we lived in a city.

I’ve had zero luck making friends - everyone with the time to be friendly is retired and invites me to nice (if slightly bland) activities that take place mid-morning or mid-afternoon, when I am clearly working. The few people our age are farmers and don’t really have the time or inclination to meet new people.

Going to the supermarket is an hour’s round trip. In winter the weather is miserable and we often get cut off from snow or floods. I get most things delivered which just means I rattle round the house even more. But don’t worry, I have Netflix when the internet isn’t too unstable.

We persevered and tried to buy a house for three years. Anything affordable gets snapped up for a holiday let. Anything nice doesn’t go in the market at all - it gets sold within extended families or handed down.

Meanwhile, everyone looks at me as a walking womb and makes unsubtle comments about how good it will be for the local school to have more children in it.

We have given up and made an offer on a house in a large town 45 minutes away. We expect to move in August and the relief is immense.

So yes, it’s easy to see why rural schools are closing. And even if it is a wider trend, I can’t get wound up about it. We don’t need to exponentially grow as a global population, it’s unsustainable. The human population on earth has historically been a tiny fraction of what it is now, and it was fine. They positives would be at least equal to the negatives in my view.

Jourdain11 · 03/06/2023 08:23

Florenz · 02/06/2023 22:30

All countries should be working on reducing their population and there should be embargoes on countries that refuse to do so. 8 billion is far too many people for a small planet like ours.

The Nazis had some good ideas about how to do that.
Also, "embargoes"? What do you actually mean? What form would these "embargoes" take? 🤔

Venndiagrammy · 03/06/2023 08:22

I don't think people should have more children just because the school funding model sucks, or because successive governments have not planned for the much known about sharp uptick in the elderly population.

This will be an unpopular view but I agree with a PP that a good start are serious discussions are around the decisions in healthcare which are invariably to just prolong life no matter what the person wants, what harm and pain the treatment causes, what quality of life someone has and other factors. It's actually very cruel sometimes and makes me ashamed to work in healthcare.

The workplace will look leagues different in a few decades anyway, the real issue will be how to entice anyone into working manual jobs we need doing.

I wouldn't underestimate the power of women rightly having more autonomy over their decisions and society now not demanding that the right thing to do is have children. Its very liberating.

I think the world will become more fluid, some parts are going to become even more inhospitable and uninhabitable and they will need somewhere to go, it makes sense to give them safe passage rather than promote people having more children just because we might not have enough of our own paying taxes.

I love Japan, been many times and its beautiful but also very regressive towards women and people of other races. Its not surprising not many people move there, perhaps if they addressed those embedded societal issues they'd have more luck than trying to persuade women they want more children?

hyggeb · 03/06/2023 08:21

True but only in eighty years time.

I think economically we are feeling it now. Look at the nhs currently, it won't exist in 80 years if things continue!

WakeMeUpWhenGoodOmensIsBack · 03/06/2023 08:20

Oliotya · 03/06/2023 08:13

Surely it's more like 10-20 years away?

Oh yes, you're right, there look to be slightly more people in the mid-50s bulge than the bulge below it because the children of the baby boom were more tightly packed in agw than the grandchildren.

We need to start talking about population decline
hyggeb · 03/06/2023 08:19

And isn’t child benefit only paid for two kids anyway?

It's reductive nonsense, who has a dc for child benefit? I think it should be universal personally as the equivalent was for my parents.

hyggeb · 03/06/2023 08:18

@BadLad there was probably an element of people praising their model because they didn't go down the usual route of immigration.

inamarina · 03/06/2023 08:18

Rowthe · 02/06/2023 22:43

I dont think they are encouraging people to 'breed'.

Child benefit isnt much and nursery fees are crippling.

Exactly. And isn’t child benefit only paid for two kids anyway? Not sure how that translates into “encouraging to breed”.

hyggeb · 03/06/2023 08:17

@BadLad I remember a teacher using it as a case study of "good management" in a geography module I did at uni or 6th form. If you google older articles there is definitely more positivity towards how they were managing the shift. The tide has turned though.

Florenz · 03/06/2023 08:16

Robots will be able to do a lot of the public sector work, cleaning the streets, mending the road, a lot of the caring for the elderly etc. We will probably end up with robots doing a lot of the emergency services work as well.

Endlesssummer2022 · 03/06/2023 08:15

user4567890754 · 02/06/2023 22:37

If you read the article you will see that "On the brink of being unable to maintain social functions” is the way the Prime Minister of Japan is describing the crisis his country is facing right now.

Japan is quite a racist country. They don’t welcome any type of immigration so it is what it is. You’ll probably see an uptick of emigration by young Japanese who refuse to pay 90% tax to support an elderly majority.

Oliotya · 03/06/2023 08:13

WakeMeUpWhenGoodOmensIsBack · 03/06/2023 08:11

True but only in eighty years time. In forty years time we will reach Peak Pensioner, and it will be very challenging.

Surely it's more like 10-20 years away?

fyn · 03/06/2023 08:13

The council in a city in the South West I work for has just asked a developer not to build a new school that was planned, the birth rate is falling so fast that they can’t fill the current schools. There would be no demand for another.

hyggeb · 03/06/2023 08:12

It's the great dichotomy though. Older generations don't want more immigration and will vote Brexit and Conservative and anyone else who pledge to stop it. However, because older people live longer - and the average age in the UK is so high - we need more working age people to look after the older generations.

Yes, a very difficult square to circle. I do think it's a really interesting conversation.

RedRosette2023 · 03/06/2023 08:12

There’s also a cost of living crisis and kids living in poverty. I have a professional job and still childcare for my two is half of my salary.

WakeMeUpWhenGoodOmensIsBack · 03/06/2023 08:11

Famzonhol · 03/06/2023 08:06

Fewer people means fewer elderly people going forward.

True but only in eighty years time. In forty years time we will reach Peak Pensioner, and it will be very challenging.

Oldnproud · 03/06/2023 08:11

Joey2323 · 03/06/2023 00:07

We are absolutely doomed OP. Our current economic system is based on infinite growth, on a finite planet with a falling population. It’s never going to work and no one seems to realise.

My thoughts exactly.

LlynTegid · 03/06/2023 08:11

There was a 'baby bulge' just after the second world war. Then another when those born then had children, then a third in the mid noughties. I don't expect fourth because of various factors.

The OP is right that population or more precisely birth rate decline needs to be talked about, not sure of the answers to the impacts.

CoalCraft · 03/06/2023 08:11

You're right, OP, but as this thread shows, people are in complete denial.

hyggeb · 03/06/2023 08:10

Fewer people means fewer elderly people going forward.

Of course, but that doesn't help with the here & now...

Vegetus · 03/06/2023 08:10

Mumsnet is a hive of anti natalism and mass hysteria over climate change.

Rather than concern the idea of population decline will have most crying with glee.

musixa · 03/06/2023 08:09

hyggeb · 03/06/2023 08:06

It wouldn't surprise me if I never see my state pension. The age I can claim it has risen three times since I started working.

It probably a reality as healthy life expectancy has stagnated.

Yes. And having to work until such a late age isn't going to improve anyone's wellbeing.

WakeMeUpWhenGoodOmensIsBack · 03/06/2023 08:09

One thing that's not being realised is that many countries' populations will keep growing due to the inertia of previous growth. The EU fertility rate is about 1.5 children per woman over her lifetime, which should in theory be a recipe for decline.

But because of previous population growth in the 1960s/70s/80s/90s there are far more women in their 20s and 30s having babies than there are women in their 40s-60s becoming grandparents, who are in turn a larger cohort than the great grandparent generation who make up most of the people dying. Every single country in the world has got this baked in population growth, so even South Korea, with a fertility rate of less than one, can still see organic population growth in the short term due to the cohort in their twenties and thirties being so large relative to the cohort born in the 1940s and 50s.

But once you get one generation further on the tide will turn and it will turn quite suddenly. Nobody has found a way of making well educated women with good access to contraception want to have more than 2 children on average. Not Sweden, not Denmark, not France (who give huge tax breaks).

And in the wider long term view that's a good thing, because the world can't take 8 billion people with the lifestyles that they all aspire to, but it will take a lot of management. We have decades of warning that this is coming - we need to use it wisely.

User135644 · 03/06/2023 08:07

WhyCantYourPartnerDoIt · 02/06/2023 22:27

We need more immigration. There's lots of young people who want to live and work here and would help to stabilize the population.

It's the great dichotomy though. Older generations don't want more immigration and will vote Brexit and Conservative and anyone else who pledge to stop it. However, because older people live longer - and the average age in the UK is so high - we need more working age people to look after the older generations.

pennypingletonpenny · 03/06/2023 08:07

The same is happening to schools near me and yet most people seem completely unaware. Even those with primary school children.

I think it’s because only a few years ago, catchments really were tiny and there were stories in the local news about kids being offered places at schools (with poor reputations) in other towns.

But now you really can get a place at pretty much any school you like. Even some of the supposedly most sought after schools haven’t filled their places for 2023 entry. The stats are all there for anyone to see on the county council website and yet whenever I’ve mentioned it to anyone who’s worrying about school places they look at me in disbelief. And the local FB page is full of posts about “shrinking catchments” and “all the schools are very popular and oversubscribed”. It’s just not true anymore but nobody seems to believe it! It’s weird.