Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

We need to start talking about population decline

792 replies

user4567890754 · 02/06/2023 22:15

The first signs of it are starting to show in the UK, with primary school closures. Secondary school closures will follow.

https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/11158f12-0133-11ee-a364-04e704863f75?shareToken=5ef47b2b4776be376153089146c8bacf

Italy is a few years ahead of us.

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2023/may/01/plunging-birthrate-threatens-italian-schools

Japan shows where every country is headed - towards a crisis where they are on the brink of being unable to maintain social functions.

https://edition.cnn.com/2023/04/13/asia/japan-population-decline-record-drop-intl-hnk/index.html

And yet there are still people who think that we have a problem with overpopulation. It’s the opposite.

The school with one pupil: how falling birthrates are killing village primaries

Four generations of Ruby Booker’s family have been educated at Skelton Newby Hall, an idyllic village primary school in North Yorkshire.It was the autumn of 194

https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/11158f12-0133-11ee-a364-04e704863f75?shareToken=5ef47b2b4776be376153089146c8bacf

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
hyggeb · 03/06/2023 16:44

Question for all the posters that think humans are a scrounge on the planet and we aren't dying quick enough... why are you still alive?

Bet many have had dc too but it's because others should die not them!

Successstory82 · 03/06/2023 16:43

@GCalltheway out of interest how many children do you have?

hyggeb · 03/06/2023 16:43

Too many people on a tiny island is the issue. I can’t share your laughter - it isn’t funny.

It's a bit funny that you think other people are the reason you are stuck in traffic & that fewer babies will have any impact on said traffic in your lifetime.

GCalltheway · 03/06/2023 16:23

hyggeb · 03/06/2023 15:09

Well thank god for that because we infrastructure can not cope as it is. It took me 5 hours to drive a few miles on the M25 this week not because of an accident but sheer weight of traffic. We need to slow down the birth rate everywhere if we are to have any quality of life whatsoever and AI can assist us greatly.

It's not the babies driving the cars though. You are the traffic 😆

Too many people on a tiny island is the issue. I can’t share your laughter - it isn’t funny.

inamarina · 03/06/2023 16:23

AngryGreasedSantaCatcus · 03/06/2023 11:57

Question for all the posters that think humans are a scrounge on the planet and we aren't dying quick enough... why are you still alive?

It’s such a weird and grim outlook on life, isn’t it?

GCalltheway · 03/06/2023 16:22

pointythings · 03/06/2023 15:11

You should have been living like that anyway!! Goodness me that is surely a benefit of brexit right there, personal responsibility and not constantly relying on the nanny state/others to wipe your arse.

You do know that it is possible to live the healthiest of lifestyles and still end up disabled and unable to care for oneself, don't you? Hmm

People generally need to step up and help themselves so there are carers available for those that are disabled not through obesity and bad life style choices but through unavoidable situations. Too many people do not take care of themselves, and expect the NHS and the state to pick up the multi billion pound bill.

inamarina · 03/06/2023 16:05

user4567890754 · 03/06/2023 09:58

In terms of demographic change I think the short-term solution is for us to continue working in some fashion as long as we are physically able.

Increase rights to WFH and part-time to retain more older people for longer.
Investigate ideas like the 4 day week so that people aren’t burned out by 65.
Facilitate and encourage retraining and reskilling in middle age.
Get rid of the expectation of a long healthy retirement, start trying to achieve a work-life balance now.
If people have more leisure time they will have more time to serve their family and the community in other ways, caring for children and the elderly etc.
I think we’re going to need to be more community-minded and less individualistic in general.

I agree with all your points, OP 🙂

WakeMeUpWhenGoodOmensIsBack · 03/06/2023 15:57

jane1956 · 03/06/2023 15:46

the amount of small boats coming here we hardly need more immigration, and certainly not in a population decline. Not the elderly costing the young but the £150 a night hotels to keep these folk descending here

I'm not sure that getting the small boats demographic to staff care homes would be either feasible or desirable. Even without the fact that the government doesn't let asylum seekers work for at least a year.

Oliotya · 03/06/2023 15:55

jane1956 · 03/06/2023 15:46

the amount of small boats coming here we hardly need more immigration, and certainly not in a population decline. Not the elderly costing the young but the £150 a night hotels to keep these folk descending here

State pension alone costs over £100bn a year. We spend something like £3 or 4bn on asylum seekers. I'm no mathematician but I think you might be wrong there.

inamarina · 03/06/2023 15:53

User135644 · 03/06/2023 08:56

Covid was there to facilitate that but we locked down for 2 years to make sure we didn't. Not saying we shouldn't have took loads of precautions over that virus but that was the irony. Western nations are fucked because of ageing populations and working age populations are fucked, yet all had to lock down for 2 years to protect the elderly because we all must live eternally.

That is a good point. Lots of people going about how there are too many of us, how the world would be better off without us, how we need to reduce the world’s population drastically.
I wonder what those people thought about lockdowns and other safety measures during Covid.
It could have been such a great opportunity to drastically reduce world population, right? (And no, that’s not what I would be advocating for.)

jane1956 · 03/06/2023 15:46

the amount of small boats coming here we hardly need more immigration, and certainly not in a population decline. Not the elderly costing the young but the £150 a night hotels to keep these folk descending here

woodhill · 03/06/2023 15:20

luvvverly · 03/06/2023 13:41

We are constantly being told that humans are causing catastrophic climate change and that we have to reduce our carbon footprint. At the same time, we are being told there aren't enough people to support the elderly. And everyone gets old eventually so this becomes a population ponzi when countries need an ever bigger amount of people at the bottom to support the top (who currently own all the wealth and housing).

What will happen is that the people at the bottom will demand better wages and living conditions and the elderly will have to compete for scarce helpers by paying them more and allowing housing to adjust to be affordable. At the moment the older generation don't want to pay more for carers and also don't want cheap housing "my house is my pension" yet complain when there are no carers. If you make living unaffordable then young people will adjust by not bothering with things like having families.

So very true

Stalkedbyzombies · 03/06/2023 15:13

We also know that plenty of people do not live like that, despite knowing that they should. I think people deserve credit for doing the obvious. Brexit was meant to give a massive boost to the NHS' ability to serve all. Remember that advert on the side of the bus?

pointythings · 03/06/2023 15:11

You should have been living like that anyway!! Goodness me that is surely a benefit of brexit right there, personal responsibility and not constantly relying on the nanny state/others to wipe your arse.

You do know that it is possible to live the healthiest of lifestyles and still end up disabled and unable to care for oneself, don't you? Hmm

hyggeb · 03/06/2023 15:09

Well thank god for that because we infrastructure can not cope as it is. It took me 5 hours to drive a few miles on the M25 this week not because of an accident but sheer weight of traffic. We need to slow down the birth rate everywhere if we are to have any quality of life whatsoever and AI can assist us greatly.

It's not the babies driving the cars though. You are the traffic 😆

GCalltheway · 03/06/2023 14:56

MrsSkylerWhite · 03/06/2023 12:05

Stalkedbyzombies · Today 11:26
Finding carers for the elderly is already a crisis situation and getting worse. That is why there is attention drawn to elderly not being discharged from hospitals for months because even though care packages are drawn up, there are not enough staff to implement them”.

Quite. Brexit.

Shall be 60 next spring. I’m doing everything I possibly can to stay healthy. Eating right, exercising, cutting back/out the alcohol, learning new things etc. because I dread to think what a godawful state social care will be in in 10/20 years, if it exists at all.

You should have been living like that anyway!! Goodness me that is surely a benefit of brexit right there, personal responsibility and not constantly relying on the nanny state/others to wipe your arse.

GCalltheway · 03/06/2023 14:54

Well thank god for that because we infrastructure can not cope as it is. It took me 5 hours to drive a few miles on the M25 this week not because of an accident but sheer weight of traffic. We need to slow down the birth rate everywhere if we are to have any quality of life whatsoever and AI can assist us greatly.

Endlesssummer2022 · 03/06/2023 14:24

It’s going to get much more difficult for working people very quickly. We must welcome immigration of working aged people until we can find feasible long term solutions.

‘10 million people in the UK are over 65 years old. The latest projections are for 5½ million more elderly people in 20 years time and the number will have nearly doubled to around 19 million by 2050.

Within this total, the number of very old people grows even faster. There are currently three million people aged more than 80 years and this is projected to almost double by 2030 and reach eight million by 2050. While one-in-six of the UK population is currently aged 65 and over, by 2050 one in-four will be.

The pensioner population is expected to rise despite the increase in the women's state pension age to 65 between 2010 and 2020 and the increase for both men and women from 65 to 68 between 2024 and 2046. In 2008 there were 3.2 people of working age for every person of pensionable age. This ratio is projected to fall to 2.8 by 2033.
Public spending and older peopleMuch of today's public spending on benefits is focussed on elderly people. 65% of Department for Work and Pensions benefit expenditure goes to those over working age, equivalent to £100 billion in 2010/11 or one-seventh of public expenditure. Continuing to provide state benefits and pensions at today's average would mean additional spending of £10 billion a year for every additional one million people over working age.

Growing numbers of elderly people also have an impact on the NHS, where average spending for retired households is nearly double that for non-retired households: in 2007/08 the average value of NHS services for retired households was £5,200 compared with £2,800 for non-retired. These averages conceal variation across older age groups, with the cost of service provision for the most elderly likely to be much greater than for younger retired people. The Department of Health estimates that the average cost of providing hospital and community health services for a person aged 85 years or more is around three times greater than for a person aged 65 to 74 years.

State benefits and the NHS accounted for just under half of government expenditure in 2009/10. With much of this spending directed at elderly people, their growing number will present challenges for providers of these particular services as well as for the public finances as a whole.’

https://www.parliament.uk/business/publications/research/key-issues-for-the-new-parliament/value-for-money-in-public-services/the-ageing-population/#:~:text=While%20one%2Din%2Dsix%20of,68%20between%202024%20and%202046.

DemiColon · 03/06/2023 14:14

Puzzledandpissedoff · 03/06/2023 12:33

It’s not a particularly attractive topic for politicians to tackle though

And that's precisely why all that will be done is tinkering at the edges - because it's not really something which people want to think about, and if they do the possible answers are likely to be unpalatable

I also think that when it gets right down to it, they don't really know what to do either.

As much as they might like to control how the global economy works, they don't. And globalism has made what politicians can do about that stuff even less effective than it was in the past. No national government has the power to change the way banking works, to do away with the concept of the constantly expanding economy, or profit as the goal of productivity.

Immigration is a stop gap, but it creates local problems in terms of absorbing new people and integrating them, even under the best circumstances. For some reason the left prefers to pretend that isn't a thing, while the right talks about it but has no real solutions. Plus there are all the ethical issues of what is essentially harvesting the best labour from other countries for our own purposes, the modern capitalist version of importing colonial labour.

And the population is unlikely to accept the answers. IN some cases for good ethical reasons, killing off the elderly is rightly something most will back away from. But we also are unwilling to accept a world where consumer goods are much more scarce, where cars are an unusual luxury, where people seldom travel abroad, and where we need to rely on our own workforce for things like agricultural production or caring for our elderly and children.

How many young people now looking at going to university and working in what is undoubtedly a bloated civil service, or academia, or as some kind of edi consultant or advertising position or whatever, would be willing to consider that where they are really needed is agricultural production? The vast majority would consider that work to be too hard and beneath them, though obviously it is ok for migrant workers or immigrants.

SalviaDivinorum · 03/06/2023 13:58

There's an interesting article by Dr Ezekiel J. Emanuel who sets out the problem with an increasingly old and infirm population. "Health care hasn’t slowed the ageing process so much as it has slowed the dying process"

https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2014/10/why-i-hope-to-die-at-75/379329/

Why I Hope to Die at 75

An argument that society and families—and you—will be better off if nature takes its course swiftly and promptly

https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2014/10/why-i-hope-to-die-at-75/379329

SunnyEgg · 03/06/2023 13:48

The reality is the only true solution is to remove things from the top (where the issues lie), be that support, services, funding, or people.

We’ve just spent a large fortune on keeping the last of your options from occurring. Lockdown was very popular on mn and amongst various posters so I’d assume they’re not the reduce people believers.

It doesn’t have to be the other solutions although we are less likely to look after our own elderly in the U.K. than many other countries, maybe that will change (probably reluctantly). It’ll be younger people who do this though.

luvvverly · 03/06/2023 13:41

We are constantly being told that humans are causing catastrophic climate change and that we have to reduce our carbon footprint. At the same time, we are being told there aren't enough people to support the elderly. And everyone gets old eventually so this becomes a population ponzi when countries need an ever bigger amount of people at the bottom to support the top (who currently own all the wealth and housing).

What will happen is that the people at the bottom will demand better wages and living conditions and the elderly will have to compete for scarce helpers by paying them more and allowing housing to adjust to be affordable. At the moment the older generation don't want to pay more for carers and also don't want cheap housing "my house is my pension" yet complain when there are no carers. If you make living unaffordable then young people will adjust by not bothering with things like having families.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 03/06/2023 13:33

Florenz · 03/06/2023 13:04

I don't think that many would find unacceptable. This is what most people want. The problem is that the few that would find it unacceptable have very loud voices and would go on and on about it.

That's the system we already have in place. If you don't have a job, family members who live here, enough money to support yourself / qualify for an investor visa or have any distinguishable talents you'll struggle to get a approval to move to the UK.

Many British people just don't like immigrants full stop (unless they're the right kind of white) and will be unhappy with any level of migration.

Either way, allowing more workers into the country wouldn't actually address the problems mentioned, it would just kick them further down the road.

The reality is the only true solution is to remove things from the top (where the issues lie), be that support, services, funding, or people. It wouldn't be pleasant whichever way it goes so obviously those most likely to be impacted by those sorts of changes will oppose it no matter what. Unfortunately, that means younger generations will just continue to be shat on and have even more opportunities removed from them.

Maddy70 · 03/06/2023 13:31

Nature always balances. COVID was probably nature culling the old and weaker but governments interference reduced the impact

SunnyEgg · 03/06/2023 13:30

CeciNestPasUnPipi · 03/06/2023 13:26

Another one in agreement here.

To those agreeing with this what’s your preference?

To keep increasing population size without ever decreasing. Although you’d see other issues mount up surely

What’s the reality if we don’t decrease?