Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have refused to talk to this parent/give them my number?

333 replies

NotMyResponsibility · 02/06/2023 21:44

Nc as pretty outing.

We have a field/campsite that is open to the public July-Aug but that family/youth groups etc use outside of this time, it has toilets, showers, large open barn and picnic tables but that's about it, very rural so noise isn't an issue. None of this is relevant but I know if it don't provide all information I will get posts asking for it.

Tonight my older children are having a camp out party as a joint birthday. Youngest being my DD who will be 18 later this month. Everyone else 18-21. I can't see the field from my home ( I can hear the music)

New friend (NF) who is 19 nearly 20, not met before. My DC has said that NF can only stay if I speak to NFs parents and confirm that it is OK and where NF is/what NF will be doing/when NF will be home.

I have refused. Firstly I don't think pandering to such a request is helpful for anyone- this NF is an adult, it is up to NF to communicate/deal with it. But mainly I have no idea what is happening. Copious alcohol and vapes I should imagine (they know if I find out drugs are used I would stop all future camps- I don't condone copious alcohol or vapes but they are not illegal for 18+) but I'm not responsible for adults.

AIBU to refuse?

OP posts:
DiscoBeat · 03/06/2023 08:30

Do they want you to supervise or do they just want to say hello? Maybe NF has issues that requires a little more involvement from his parents than the usual 19/20 year old? I would give the number but make it very clear when you speak to then that you're not actually going to be down there on the field with them.

NotMyResponsibility · 03/06/2023 08:29

But parents can't check up on adults forever, they have to arm their children with means to look after themselves. NF had told the parents where they were and who they were with.

I don't know why or if a text would have been more acceptable, I don't know if it was just a reason to refuse. DH is at work now so I can't ask him anymore.

About to walk the dogs and will loop by the field and see if anyone is still up.

NF is not the diabetic, NF has been friendly for a while with my DC and haven't said anything.

I get that parents worry. I worry I still worry about my much older dc it never stops. But how you deal with it has to change once they are adults.

OP posts:
Elfidela1980 · 03/06/2023 08:26

NotMyResponsibility · 02/06/2023 23:19

DH back from the field and has spoken to NF parent on NF phone. Apparently speaking to DH wasn't good enough as he could be anyone. He left it saying that NF was welcome, that they were staying with other adults and gave the what.three.words if they wanted to collect them.

Appreciate what others are saying about other issues but NF seems mortified/resigned. This isn't normal and it saddens me that some think it is.

hi OP

When I read your first post I wondered if it might be NF has abusive parents? Sometimes those parents make their kids jump through hoops to be allowed to have any sort of normal life, and part of that is making unreasonable or humiliating demands of them. Like getting you to text though NF is an adult.

Don’t ask me what the point is, it’s nuts. Control I suppose. They don’t even just say ‘no’ instead they put in suspensive conditions that make attendance uncertain and means their child has no sense of agency and can’t freely enjoy participating in their own life. Like the DHs on here who enjoy ruining their wives’ special occasions by picking fights. Parents of young adults often control the finances, the YA’s home is theirs, and like with spousal abuse, the only solution to move out and become financially independent. Which takes time, sometimes, and a lot of hoop-jumping. To all the people saying NF should just tell them where to get off, understandable, but abused people don’t do that.

It’s nice NF feels your family would understand about the need for the contact, DD must be a non-judgemental girl. I’m not sure I’d have asked a new friend, I’d have been too humiliated.

Hardbackwriter · 03/06/2023 08:08

It's clearly a moot point now - they are all probably finally asleep! - but for the PP saying that they just want reassurance that it's not illegal camping/where she is in case of emergency - that's not was asked for. The OP says she was asked to provide:
My DC has said that NF can only stay if I speak to NFs parents and confirm that it is OK and where NF is/what NF will be doing/when NF will be home.
OP doesn't know the answer to two of those questions.
It does feel quite clear that they wanted her to take responsibility and even supervise. Since the DH talking to them wasn't good enough I doubt anything else OP could have done would have been.

Newspeaker · 03/06/2023 08:05

Bloody hell! NF is nearly 20! Some of the replies on here are mind boggling to me. I had left home and was living in a little rented flat alone by the time I had my 20th birthday.

I hope they had a great time. 😀

TheoreticalRefusal · 03/06/2023 08:02

I wonder if NF is autistic and the parents want to check that they haven't misunderstood their invite. One definition of autism is that it's a social communication disorder, so it wouldn't be unreasonable to worry that they had maybe invited themselves where they weren't wanted.

DrMarciaFieldstone · 03/06/2023 07:56

I would wonder if the parents have maybe some trauma in their lives that leads them towards over protection or if NF has significant additional needs or health issues and they are just finding it a bit harder than you are to loosen the apron strings

But none of this needs feeding. It needs to stop, not for other people to conform to it. I think OP’s DH handled it perfectly.

AMuser · 03/06/2023 07:55

mondaytosunday · 03/06/2023 07:44

@TeenDivided @Ladybug14
Fascinating! What an amazing idea. I too had no clue about what 'what.three.Words' was and assumed it was just a nonsensical autocorrect.

It’s one of the best things ever if you’re at large crowded event or for hard to find fields full of hungover teenagers.

Some delivery cos even let you add it for your home address.

adviceneeded1990 · 03/06/2023 07:53

JMSA · 02/06/2023 22:42

Just message so that NF can come. Honestly, what's the big deal.

would you think this if it was an abusive partner asking you to confirm their whereabouts? Or is policing/stalking/controlling an adults movements only ok for a parent?

Peonyfun · 03/06/2023 07:52

I feel sorry for the young adult, that it’s overly controlling. I think as your husband has spoken to them that’s as much as can be done.

Aubree17 · 03/06/2023 07:49

I would speak to them and give them the facts.
Including that you are not responsible for their adult child.
Maybe they just want to check that you are happy with a bunch of teenagers camping out on your property,

BadSkiingMum · 03/06/2023 07:48

TimesRwo · 03/06/2023 00:30

No, you’re not being unreasonable at all, but it wouldn’t have caused any harm if you did.

Very conscious I’m projecting here but I had very controlling parents growing up. This is the sort of thing they would have done (except by that age I had almost no friends as I lost them all by my parents not letting me go anywhere or do anything). It’s not the child’s fault their parents are so strict and unreasonable, but as it would have allowed them to have a taste of freedom for one night, it would have been nice for you to have been supportive of that.

Agreed.

All the anecdotes of ‘I was off doing whatever at eighteen’ are no help or relevance to a young person who is severely restricted by their parents.

A controlling parent can wield a lot of social and economic power over a young person, even if they are legally an adult. It can arise from over-protectiveness; it can be out-and-out bullying, abuse or economic coercion.

Sometimes other kind adults who see what is going on and tactfully intervene to help things happen are that young person’s only chance of experiencing some normal activities.

SlippySarah · 03/06/2023 07:47

NotMyResponsibility · 02/06/2023 23:39

parents are overly protective for some reason you haven't considered

But it isn't for me to consider, if there is an issue they cant expect another adults parent to parent.

One of the friends is a T1, one has a nut allergy, my eldest has brittle asthma. They have to trust themselves and their friends because they are adults and parents can not be present always.

Yeah I'm not saying its your responsibility or you should get involved. Clearly it's up to you and YANBU to refuse.

I'm saying I'd do it personally because it's not a big deal to me and I try to see the perspectives of others. I don't assume everyone else is a nightmare control freak for no good reason like half of mumsnet. I would wonder if the parents have maybe some trauma in their lives that leads them towards over protection or if NF has significant additional needs or health issues and they are just finding it a bit harder than you are to loosen the apron strings.

YouJustDoYou · 03/06/2023 07:44

Adults aren't your responsibility. Ridiculous for them to expect you to babysit their adult child, whether they have "diabetes" or whatever or not as a pp said. Goodness sake.

mondaytosunday · 03/06/2023 07:44

@TeenDivided @Ladybug14
Fascinating! What an amazing idea. I too had no clue about what 'what.three.Words' was and assumed it was just a nonsensical autocorrect.

FarmGirl78 · 03/06/2023 07:37

NotMyResponsibility · 02/06/2023 22:47

Would you think the same if your parents asked the same about where you went.

In this instance I'd be mortified by my parents, but very grateful if friends parents could send a quick message saying "Fine for FarmGirl to come over but as they're adults and I'll be in bed I won't be supervising. They're a sensible lot and I'm sure they'll have a great time".

Because A) it would hint to my parents that not everyone is strict like them, B)if v paranoid it would reassure my parents I'm not lying to them and haven't 'made up' this story about being invited to a camp out in a field and C) sometimes when your parents are really strict its nice to know other parents will support you (well not 'support you', that's not the right phrase, but more sort of mentally 'have your back' and help a little when they can also see your parents are unreasonable). Its just nice to be nice and help others a little when chance arises.

HowcanIgetoutofthisalive · 03/06/2023 07:32

Thack · 03/06/2023 04:57

If speaking to DH on the phone isn't sufficient then why would a text be? Surely that's worse.

Just what I thought.

LAMPS1 · 03/06/2023 07:28

It’s puzzling that the NF’s parents set out these conditions.
And even more puzzling that NF adhered to them. Maybe her parents are the sort who tell her that while she’s under their roof, she must obey their rules. Maybe NF can’t afford to move out and set up her own home yet if she’s still in education. Let’s hope her new friendship with your dc help her become a bit more independent from them.
I think it was good your husband reached out to them and I hope he explained that while the invitation to the adult camp-out overnight party had the full permission of the landowners, he could take no responsibility for the events of the night as he wouldn’t be present.
I hope the birthday celebrations all went smoothly and they had fun.

Doingmybest12 · 03/06/2023 07:25

I guess there is more to this than meets the eye but they are not being reasonable wanting you to say what they'll be doing and when she will be home. Suggest NF tells parents where you are , where she will be and tells parents you have their phone number in case you need it. Other than coming to meet you how will she know anything about you from a phone call anyway. Hope NF gets to come to the party.

DrMarciaFieldstone · 03/06/2023 07:23

Poor NF, their parents are batshit. Agree it’s borderline abuse. They shouldn’t be dragging OP into it, to solve their own anxieties.

PoseyFlump · 03/06/2023 07:17

I'm presuming the NF is female and the parents assumed she was lying about where she was going and instead was off to a cocaine fuelled orgy.

The parents have massive trust issues (unless NF is an addict who has previously stolen all of Nans heirlooms)

Poor NF.

Batalax · 03/06/2023 07:15

I think your kids, or you if you get the opportunity, should encourage poor NF to stand up to her parents. She’s an adult and needs to act like one.

TallerThanAverage · 03/06/2023 07:04

I don’t think it’s normal but I would have begrudgingly called as NF is the one stuck in the middle here and if I didn’t call I’d think of them missing out. Hopefully if they go NF’s parents will lighten up a bit.

itsgettingweird · 03/06/2023 07:02

At that age I was working abroad in holiday camp type situations.

I'm so glad mobile phones weren't everywhere and certainly didn't have photos and SM!

My parents were grateful to be blissfully unaware of my antics Grin

Also no drugs involved - EVER - but certainly copious amounts of alcohol!

Best part of growing up is these experiences. Good on you for providing them. Hope your DD has a fab birthday

ZforZebra · 03/06/2023 06:54

My impression is they know NF might do something silly/dangerous/illegal and want you to somehow be responsible for it. If there was a genuine reason they were being extra cautious (e.g. NF had a health condition/allergy/injury etc) they would’ve let you know. Anyway, like others have said I would refuse to take responsibility for an adult, especially one I had never met and knew nothing about.