Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have refused to talk to this parent/give them my number?

333 replies

NotMyResponsibility · 02/06/2023 21:44

Nc as pretty outing.

We have a field/campsite that is open to the public July-Aug but that family/youth groups etc use outside of this time, it has toilets, showers, large open barn and picnic tables but that's about it, very rural so noise isn't an issue. None of this is relevant but I know if it don't provide all information I will get posts asking for it.

Tonight my older children are having a camp out party as a joint birthday. Youngest being my DD who will be 18 later this month. Everyone else 18-21. I can't see the field from my home ( I can hear the music)

New friend (NF) who is 19 nearly 20, not met before. My DC has said that NF can only stay if I speak to NFs parents and confirm that it is OK and where NF is/what NF will be doing/when NF will be home.

I have refused. Firstly I don't think pandering to such a request is helpful for anyone- this NF is an adult, it is up to NF to communicate/deal with it. But mainly I have no idea what is happening. Copious alcohol and vapes I should imagine (they know if I find out drugs are used I would stop all future camps- I don't condone copious alcohol or vapes but they are not illegal for 18+) but I'm not responsible for adults.

AIBU to refuse?

OP posts:
shouldisay · 03/06/2023 09:16

Poor NF!! My 19yo is at the other side of the bloody country at Uni, she would tell me to fuck off if I said I wanted to speak to the parents of wherever she was going. She knows she can call if she is ever in trouble but I trust that she will make good choices.

sawandnotseen · 03/06/2023 09:15

Very sad for NF. I'd been in Australia for 6mths and India for 6mth by 19! My daughter was in Thailand for a few months too....my son is 18 just and I don't know where he is most of the time but I know that he is street wise (we are in outer London) and that he'd call me or his dad if he needed us.
However, to enable NF to join the party, I would message / talk to the mum just so he/she can have some fun. It will only take minutes and will probably mean a lot to NF

TimesRwo · 03/06/2023 09:15

NotMyResponsibility · 03/06/2023 08:29

But parents can't check up on adults forever, they have to arm their children with means to look after themselves. NF had told the parents where they were and who they were with.

I don't know why or if a text would have been more acceptable, I don't know if it was just a reason to refuse. DH is at work now so I can't ask him anymore.

About to walk the dogs and will loop by the field and see if anyone is still up.

NF is not the diabetic, NF has been friendly for a while with my DC and haven't said anything.

I get that parents worry. I worry I still worry about my much older dc it never stops. But how you deal with it has to change once they are adults.

Yes, in an ideal world you should accept your children become adults who make their own choices. But not everyone is like that. Many parents are unreasonably controlling. And that’s not NF’s fault. NF was probably mortified at having to ask, but they knew they had no choice.

adviceneeded1990 · 03/06/2023 09:14

Meeting · 03/06/2023 09:11

Yes I am absolutely fine with it. I love my culture but if I wanted to live differently (as many of my family members do) I absolutely could. I'm not looking to derail the thread but OP seems to think that all people in the UK are also of the opinion that you are no longer a concern to your parents the minute you turn 18, when that's not the case.

I’m glad you’re comfortable with it. I think you are mixing up concern and control though. Your children are a concern to you for life. That doesn’t mean you treat them like a toddler having a play date at 19.

Barbie222 · 03/06/2023 09:13

A PP has brought up the fact that NF might come from another culture, where drinking and staying overnight without a family member present is not the norm. The parents of NF definitely aren't handling this well but the bottom line is that occasions for 19 year olds with 'copious amounts of alcohol and vapes' are by their nature going to exclude some members of a friendship group in a lot of communities, and the 'just get on board with it as it's perfectly normal' attitude shown here definitely centres your own culture.

Meeting · 03/06/2023 09:11

adviceneeded1990 · 03/06/2023 09:01

Out of interest, do you feel that this is ok? That parents control adults until marriage then hand them over to a husband to control? Are sons controlled until marriage or just daughters? Can you choose not to be married? I’m sorry but this sounds like abuse to me. No adult is answerable to another adult, parent or not.

Yes I am absolutely fine with it. I love my culture but if I wanted to live differently (as many of my family members do) I absolutely could. I'm not looking to derail the thread but OP seems to think that all people in the UK are also of the opinion that you are no longer a concern to your parents the minute you turn 18, when that's not the case.

TallerThanAverage · 03/06/2023 09:11

It’s not something that I would do but as so many people track husbands, adult children and younger children by their phones I’m surprised that they don’t just do that.

Rainbowsandbutterflies1990 · 03/06/2023 09:10

Meeting · 03/06/2023 08:47

YABU it's not for you to decide how other parents choose to parent their DC. You are being difficult for no reason.

There are many different cultures in the UK and in mine your parents are responsible for you until you're married. I would have been excluded from this because you feel that the way you parent is superior and everyone must be the same as you.

Just because something is culture doesnt make it acceptable and right. Child marriage is/was in some cultures !

ohtowinthelottery · 03/06/2023 09:09

My DS has ASD and I would never embarrass him like NFs parents have. I rely on DS to tell me where he's going/what he's doing, just as a courtesy, and if he doesn't choose to tell me then he won't!
If he needs my help he'll ring/message. I worry about him, of course, as he doesn't always make sensible choices when alcohol is involved, but I can't control his life.

At 19, I was driving to an airport 50 miles away, getting on a plane only knowing which airport I was going to at the other end and waiting for the travel rep to tell me and a friend which resort and accommodation we'd be staying at for the next week. This was pre mobile phones so my parents didn't know where I was or what I was doing and the dutifully sent postcard usually arrived weeks after I'd returned home.

BusMumsHoliday · 03/06/2023 09:09

Absolutely agree that you were right not to get involved. To me, it's a similar situation to a group of young adults meeting to party in a nightclub, or have a party at one of their own homes - both of which are absolutely ok because they are all adults. NF's parents either accept that their adult child will be meeting other adults of a similar age "unsupervised" (because supervision would be utterly inappropriate!!), or they shut them in their home and alienate them. They can't loop other older adults into this. I actually think you're doing NF a favour by showing her that other parents think hers are unreasonable.

Hope they had a fab party - sounds like an amazing set up!

Beamur · 03/06/2023 09:07

I think you were right.
Whatever their justifications, this level of interference in an adult child's life is not ok.
A bit of pushback might be useful for them to see that other parents don't do this.

Maireas · 03/06/2023 09:07

@Heronwatcher - they're not kids.
OP - just ignore.
Don't give any details, they'll try to hold you responsible.

ShoesoftheWorld · 03/06/2023 09:04

(I do understand, very well indeed, the above views about helping the adult child by supporting the parents' 'need' for control. But in the end it simply reinforces the parents' worldview that their actions are reasonable. A robust 'this is nonsense and you don't have to put up with it, you know' can also be of immense (longer-term) benefit. It sounds as if NF got to stay at the party, so certainly in that case I would be communicating to this adult child (in a way that doesn't make them feel bad or responsible for it) how outrageous the parents' request is and that it's not OK for them to try and co-opt others into their regime)

Clymene · 03/06/2023 09:02

But this person isn't a teenager. They're an adult. Surely if you have controlling parents, you just leave home? Confused

adviceneeded1990 · 03/06/2023 09:01

Meeting · 03/06/2023 08:47

YABU it's not for you to decide how other parents choose to parent their DC. You are being difficult for no reason.

There are many different cultures in the UK and in mine your parents are responsible for you until you're married. I would have been excluded from this because you feel that the way you parent is superior and everyone must be the same as you.

Out of interest, do you feel that this is ok? That parents control adults until marriage then hand them over to a husband to control? Are sons controlled until marriage or just daughters? Can you choose not to be married? I’m sorry but this sounds like abuse to me. No adult is answerable to another adult, parent or not.

ShoesoftheWorld · 03/06/2023 09:00

I had a parent very like NF's and I'm with you, OP. There is no excuse for it whatsoever. 'Worry' of a parent's doesn't trump the adult child's legal and moral autonomy.

Not the same thing as a party, obv, but my eldest turned 18 two weeks ago and promptly went into active service with our local volunteer fire brigade (not UK), that he's been training with for just over a year. He spent over 5 hours at a major fire last night, Was I worried? Hell yes. Do I get to dump that on him and restrict his life? Hell no.

Jantlet · 03/06/2023 08:58

TimesRwo · 03/06/2023 00:30

No, you’re not being unreasonable at all, but it wouldn’t have caused any harm if you did.

Very conscious I’m projecting here but I had very controlling parents growing up. This is the sort of thing they would have done (except by that age I had almost no friends as I lost them all by my parents not letting me go anywhere or do anything). It’s not the child’s fault their parents are so strict and unreasonable, but as it would have allowed them to have a taste of freedom for one night, it would have been nice for you to have been supportive of that.

Same for me. That was in the days before mobiles and I often think how much worse it would be now. My abusive controlling parents would have insisted on full access to my mobile and contents, with find my phone fully activated, that’s for sure.

My friendships were generally short lived as they quickly became forbidden, but I have never forgotten the few good parents of friends who did their best to make things easier for me.

A one off weekend at a friend’s house, when I was a teenager, remains a life long happy memory of two wonderful days. Her parents were so kind.

Please be generous to NF, you can’t imagine what could be going on at home, and she will be powerless.

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 03/06/2023 08:56

JMSA · 02/06/2023 22:42

Just message so that NF can come. Honestly, what's the big deal.

This!

LorraineInSpain · 03/06/2023 08:54

Meeting · 03/06/2023 08:47

YABU it's not for you to decide how other parents choose to parent their DC. You are being difficult for no reason.

There are many different cultures in the UK and in mine your parents are responsible for you until you're married. I would have been excluded from this because you feel that the way you parent is superior and everyone must be the same as you.

But the legal situation is that NF is an adult (assuming OP is in the UK)

OP doesn’t have to pander to people who want to control other adults. Cultural or not.

philautia · 03/06/2023 08:52

That's really weird and sad for the adult in question. You can't really call the adult parents of an adult human and let them know it's okay to stay - it's bonkers. I'd feel exactly the same way as you.

Meeting · 03/06/2023 08:47

YABU it's not for you to decide how other parents choose to parent their DC. You are being difficult for no reason.

There are many different cultures in the UK and in mine your parents are responsible for you until you're married. I would have been excluded from this because you feel that the way you parent is superior and everyone must be the same as you.

Stripedbag101 · 03/06/2023 08:42

Heronwatcher · 02/06/2023 21:56

I think if your friends want the NF to come I’d just send a quick text saying, “Of course fine for NF to come, my kids are looking forward to seeing them and I will be around if there’s an emergency but to be clear I am planning on leaving the kids to themselves and having an early night (with earplugs) so I won’t be at the party/ supervising closely.” I agree it’s a bit OTT but they could just be a bit anxious because they don’t know you (or NF could be massively vague with their parents so they actually want to check they’re invited at all!).

Unless this man/woman has special needs then the parents sound unhinged. A nearly twenty year old should be able to go to a party without their parents having to check they are invited!

it sounds deeply troubling. The man/woman is giving their parent too much information and should probably move out. Their development is being stunted

poorbuthappy · 03/06/2023 08:42

I sort of understood it until the you could be anyone comment to your DH. well yes. But anyone could be anyone! Bonkers. Hope they've all had a fab night.

theyarereallytakingthepissnow · 03/06/2023 08:35

100% agree with your stance and thoughts.

Clymene · 03/06/2023 08:34

No way would I give them your number. They will take that as assuming responsibility for NF which you're categorically not