Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH says he 'cant deal' with our 4 year old

135 replies

Theprincessisblanketed · 02/06/2023 20:52

We have two children 6 and 4. DH was totally fine with our first child, did half the work, changed nappies, did bedtimes, took them out, etc. etc. Lovely family time and we were both excited to have a second.

However once we had our second child things changed. DH just keeps having excuses for not ever being able to take both of them, and talking about how it is too difficult to cope with both of them (but I have to, every day!). But he was doing stuff with one child if I was taking the other.

Now he's started saying he simply can't/won't deal with our youngest at all - because he's 'violent'.

He's 4. He gets upset and throws things/hits. I'm not pretending it's lovely behaviour, but I think it's normal at this age and we just have to teach him not to. DH however insists that he can't reason with a four year old, therefore there is nothing to do but refuse to parent him at all and have me deal with it all?

I'm honestly just completely floored that DH even thinks just saying he can't deal with his own 4 year old child is an option. I don't know what to say to him.

OP posts:
Garrard · 02/06/2023 22:56

cptartapp · 02/06/2023 21:20

Well he needs to be careful here. Because if your relationship fails and you split over this, he'll very quickly have to learn to 'deal' with both DC 24/7 all on his own half every week going forward.
Remind him of that.

This sort of comment is so silly.

Child arrangement orders are made which reflect the status quo - a man who has no track record at all for looking after both children together would in fact have them relatively infrequently. I hate the way people wheel out the "well, he'll be sorry when he has the DC half of the time" line, as if most mothers would actually welcome their children being away from them and in the care of someone inadequate, or as if looking after your own children is some kind of punishment. Most of us actually quite like having our children with us.

OP, my ex husband was similar with the "can't cope" thing. One of our DC had additional needs, so it was very, very hard. But what parents have to do is find ways to cope. Ex husband couldn't or wouldn't try, so we are now divorced.

Hearti · 02/06/2023 22:54

he basically needs to develop a much much stronger bond and positive interactions with the boy through doing nice things together 1:1. The poor boy will presently sense that his father feels negatively about him and play him up as a result.

Theprincessisblanketed · 02/06/2023 22:54

ToK1 · 02/06/2023 22:35

@Theprincessisblanketed

You can force him to parent.

Why, by age 4, has he never had to?

If you're seriously worried he'd harm his kids, why are you with him?

He has been taking each child separately. He has only very rarely had them both.

I can't make him do it against his will.

He's always just had reasons why he couldn't have them both and it's too hard. He kept saying it would be easier when they got a bit older.

I don't think he would harm them. If I 'just walk out the house' what's stopping him from walking out at the same time? We both know I would just have to back down and return.

OP posts:
Redshoeblueshoe · 02/06/2023 22:54

MargaretThursday that's a great post

AMuser · 02/06/2023 22:47

Hardbackwriter · 02/06/2023 21:18

I really think I'd find it hard to continue to share a house with DH if he said this. There's so many layers of how it's awful - the favouritism, the rejection of a four year old, the casual assumption that things that aren't reasonable for him to put up with are just fine for you, the contempt that underlies that assumption. Is this very recent? It's such a difficult situation - of course he shouldn't abdicate responsibility like this, but I also wouldn't want my 4 year old spending time with someone who thought of them like this. Four is old enough that he will know that he's disliked. I actually don't think it's entirely 'normal' for a four year old to routinely hit or throw things at people - or rather, it isn't abnormal but nor is it par for the course - but I think his dad's rejection and disengagement is more likely to be cause than consequence of him acting out like this.

This. This is all so toxic and damaging for your poor son. But I get how stuck you must feel with his “can’t “

How odd that you don’t have the luxury of “can’t”.

This is strong frank conversation time. He needs to know this is marriage ending stuff here. He needs to come to you with his solutions to help himself parent his own kids equally and lovingly and partner his wife.

Prick.

MargaretThursday · 02/06/2023 22:40

Dh tried something similar after dd2 was born.

He'd always done bath time for dd1, but when dd2 was tiny didn't feel he could handle them both. Fine, for a bit, but when dd2 was a little bit older I said how much I'd appreciated the time and could he start it again. He was at this time getting home just before bedtime, so often went straight into it from work, whereas for dd1 he'd been home for a couple of hours before bed time.

He said almost word for word: "No, I really don't feel I can handle two at once. But it would be nice if they were ready for bed when I get home, so if you could bath and dress them, then I can play with them before bedtime."

When I had finished laughing sarcastically, and pointing out that if he was expecting me to handle them both in the bath with no one else in the house, then he could jolly well manage them when in an emergency/difficult situation, he could call for me, he looked rather sheepish.
We agreed that he would start doing the bath and I would just be outside on the landing at first. After a couple of days he was happy for me to go downstairs, and within a couple of weeks didn't blink at doing it on his own.

So can you try something similar. Start by him taking them to the park, and you sit outside with a book or something, and he takes them in onto the equipment. You're there, but he has to deal with it unless it's an emergency.
Although it also sounds like maybe he's not wanting the 4yo at all, even on their own, so maybe the first step is for him to take the 4yo out on their own.

SouthLondonMum22 · 02/06/2023 22:39

Theprincessisblanketed · 02/06/2023 22:32

I can't force him to parent. I'm not going to play some kind of game of chicken with my children's well being.

If he refuses to parent then the marriage would be over for me.

Spendonsend · 02/06/2023 22:38

Before my husband could cope and I was having to cope whether i liked it or not, i found support from friends, relatives and paid childcare.

If he isnt prepared to do counselling or parenting classes you are rather stuck.

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 02/06/2023 22:38

It's hard as you don't want to leave him with 4 year old if they're going to upset each other it's not fair on the child.
Surely though you can say 'it's not normal to have a family where the dad and the son can't spend time together one to one. Without blame here, something is wrong that needs to be fixed or it will only get much much worse. We need to try family therapy to get help with this'

ToK1 · 02/06/2023 22:35

@Theprincessisblanketed

You can force him to parent.

Why, by age 4, has he never had to?

If you're seriously worried he'd harm his kids, why are you with him?

Theprincessisblanketed · 02/06/2023 22:32

ToK1 · 02/06/2023 22:12

@Theprincessisblanketed

Why haven't you left him alone with his children?

I can't force him to parent. I'm not going to play some kind of game of chicken with my children's well being.

OP posts:
ToK1 · 02/06/2023 22:32

@Theprincessisblanketed

Why are you shocked when you're enabling him to do it?

Theprincessisblanketed · 02/06/2023 22:30

no one, parent or not should be in charge of children if they can't cope!

Right, but back in the real world, I have to parent my children whether I can cope or not. If I don't do it it won't happen. I'm shocked DH sees this as something he can just stop doing.

OP posts:
SaulGoodman1 · 02/06/2023 22:24

TimeSlipMushroom · 02/06/2023 22:21

Says who?
There's no law requiring this. He can leave and see his children for 0 hours if he chooses. It's not right but he can

I know. Posters always say this. Men walk away all the time with 0 contact or very little. If he’s refusing to parent under the same roof then why do posters believe he’ll voluntarily take them both on his own 3/4 days every week.

TimeSlipMushroom · 02/06/2023 22:22

cptartapp · 02/06/2023 21:20

Well he needs to be careful here. Because if your relationship fails and you split over this, he'll very quickly have to learn to 'deal' with both DC 24/7 all on his own half every week going forward.
Remind him of that.

My post was in reply to this

TimeSlipMushroom · 02/06/2023 22:21

Says who?
There's no law requiring this. He can leave and see his children for 0 hours if he chooses. It's not right but he can

SaulGoodman1 · 02/06/2023 22:19

Theprincessisblanketed · 02/06/2023 22:04

I certainly don't see it as a joke but what exactly am I supposed to do?

I can't solo parent one child while joint parenting another while we all live in one household? That's clearly not fair to either child (the six year old would never get time with me alone), before we even get to how difficult it would be for me (but making it hard for me to cope is fine, I guess?).

of course it’s not fair on you at all. But what I’m saying is as he can’t cope, you need to take ‘making him cope’ off the table as other posts suggest. As in, please don’t just force him to look after the dc and just go out leaving him alone with them as others suggest.

Of course he needs to be actively looking at ways in which he can parent younger dc.

I would recommend he signs up to a parenting course and some therapy. Younger dc is obviously triggering him somehow. Whilst he is doing this, he can’t parent entirely solo until he gets some tools to cope.

I know that is unfair but what’s the alternative? Either you force his hand and he could snap or you leave him and your parenting solo anyway.

But then maybe I’m reading it wrong and him ‘not coping’ isn’t him walking away full of anger out instead him laying on the sofa and playing on his phone whilst leaving you to wrestle your child having a tantrum. If that’s the case then that’s not him ‘for coping’ but more he ‘can’t be arsed’. Which one is it?

Soproudoflionesses · 02/06/2023 22:17

cptartapp · 02/06/2023 21:20

Well he needs to be careful here. Because if your relationship fails and you split over this, he'll very quickly have to learn to 'deal' with both DC 24/7 all on his own half every week going forward.
Remind him of that.

This

beAsensible1 · 02/06/2023 22:13

SaulGoodman1 · 02/06/2023 21:55

I actually think you should take heed of this advice.

Parens have and do ‘snap’. Statistically it’s usually men that do it too.
All it takes is one tantrum/attack too far from your child and your husband could flip.

Even meek and mild parents have snapped when they can’t cope and they feel there is no escape.

I would never back someone into a corner with a child they say they can’t cope with because it’s their duty. People don’t think of their duties when they flip their shit. This isn’t a mum/dad debate. This is real life and shit does happen.

I would be working ways around until DH can cope. Whether that meant splitting up, living apart whilst DH does parenting courses/therapy, or taking the lead on youngest child whilst he works through it.

Anyway, parents not coping is no joke. I’d take it seriously.

yes yes yes. leaving him with the kids after he's admitted not coping and disapproving for a couple of hours isn't helpful or safe.

no one, parent or not should be in charge of children if they can't cope!

Rolloisthebestpony · 02/06/2023 22:13

So he just gets to opt out of childcare for his own child?
Did he not realise pre-kids you can’t just opt out?
If he’s serious, and not suffering from depression or something I couldn’t personally stay with him

ToK1 · 02/06/2023 22:12

@Theprincessisblanketed

Why haven't you left him alone with his children?

Theprincessisblanketed · 02/06/2023 22:11

To be clear the only person who thinks our child is violent is DH, he doesn't 'routinely' hit and has never thrown something AT someone.

A few times he has gotten upset whilst holding an object and thrown it away from him to the floor. Literally twice DH has picked him up to take him to bed when he didn't want to go and 4 year old has flailed around and hit out at him.

Its really not some major behavioural problem.

OP posts:
beAsensible1 · 02/06/2023 22:10

I honestly think if he isa assign he struggle to cope with dc then believe him! I don't think hats an easy thing to admit, but make it clear that means he needs to address the situation and get some help to deal with it.

go on a course, spend a weekend away from the children and come up with a clear parenting plan with expectations and consequences. agree on an united front and how to deal with the throwing and the hitting.

I don't think the best plan is to just condemn him for saying he is finding it extremely hard this time around, lots of parents feel this. But he can't refuse to solve the issue.

Maybe you both need a break and to reset.

SarahAndQuack · 02/06/2023 22:09

Theprincessisblanketed · 02/06/2023 21:14

I don't know. He seems to genuinely believe that he 'cant' so there's nothing to discuss, I'm asking him for an impossibility.

In that case, you accept he's absolutely right. He just can't.

So neither can you.

Choose a time - maybe Saturday morning? And then - you can't. Sorry, love. Off out the door now. I just can't any more.

If push came to shove, do you really feel he would be unable to step up?

nighthawk99 · 02/06/2023 22:07

at least he is recognising that the 4 yos behaviour is a problem and not normalising his violence as you seem to be doing

Swipe left for the next trending thread