Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel like a fake Irish woman?

117 replies

bumbleebe · 02/06/2023 19:16

So I was born in Ireland. All my grand parents and great grand parents born in Ireland. But before that, only about 1/4 of them are from Irish families. Rest of them moved over from England to Dublin (as a huge number did). So ‘genetically’ I’m only 1/4 Irish.

My parents gave me a very very Irish name. Sent me to Gaelic school etc.

I now live in England. People always sort of view me as being Irish Irish. But I feel like a fraud, because compared to many Irish folk, I’m not. I didn’t know this out until I did my family tree, and now I just sort of feel deflated.

OP posts:
darjeelingrose · 02/06/2023 19:58

AhNowTed · 02/06/2023 19:56

You're questioning why a sense of belonging might be important?

As an emigrant, believe me it matters.

Folks like me (born and bred in one country, adult life in another) have a very strong sense of where we're from and "belonging" to something.

It's not to be laughed at.

No, that's not what it is at all. It's about the OP despite all her great grandparents being born in Ireland not considering herself Irish. It's not about being a recent immigrant or a sense of belonging. It does reflect really badly on Irish society and a sense of inclusiveness though.

Chickenkeev · 02/06/2023 19:57

I'm Irish and welcome anyone who wants to be Irish along with me.

Hannahsbananas · 02/06/2023 19:57

AhNowTed · 02/06/2023 19:52

@MaggieBsBoat

How is that offensive?

I understand precisely what the OP means.

If someone was born in Jamaica, but lived most of their life in Ireland, would you call them offensive for saying they don't feel fully either? Ridiculous.

Ridiculous analogy, when op is fourth generation Irish and grew up there.

NatureNurture85 · 02/06/2023 19:57

if I went to Nepal I’d be a foreigner to them.

NatureNurture85 · 02/06/2023 19:56

So I’m not English? My parents and grandparents were born in Nepal but my Grandfather came here in the 1950s. I’ve been to Nepal once in my life. I see myself as British and English.

AhNowTed · 02/06/2023 19:56

Shallistayorshalligo · 02/06/2023 19:51

Why is it so important and why does it bother you?
What is so great about being born “true” Irish, English or Chinese?
What is your personal contribution to it?
To be proud of what is your nationality is the same as to be proud you were born on Monday. Yes, why aren’t you upset you were born on Tuesday instead?

i can totally get people being interested in their history and ancestry. But I fail to understand pride in something they have never had saying.

You're questioning why a sense of belonging might be important?

As an emigrant, believe me it matters.

Folks like me (born and bred in one country, adult life in another) have a very strong sense of where we're from and "belonging" to something.

It's not to be laughed at.

darjeelingrose · 02/06/2023 19:55

AhNowTed · 02/06/2023 19:52

@MaggieBsBoat

How is that offensive?

I understand precisely what the OP means.

If someone was born in Jamaica, but lived most of their life in Ireland, would you call them offensive for saying they don't feel fully either? Ridiculous.

Really? I find it obvious. It's the implication that some people are more Irish than others, and the ridiculousness of having all your great grand parents born in Ireland and somehow being 1/4 Irish. I don't know if I'm not more offended by the appalling maths though.

eggandonion · 02/06/2023 19:52

More important than Tayto is the protestant tray bake discussion thread.

romdowa · 02/06/2023 19:52

I'm as irish as far back as I can go , my husband is just as English. Our son is Irish, he's born here , has an Irish name and will grow up here. There's more to being Irish than blood. If the Americans who's ancestors left during the famine can claim to be Irish, then you are definitely Irish

IWonderWhereThatDishDidGo · 02/06/2023 19:52

It could just be that you've moved around so much you've lost your identity a bit. I'm similar btw but don't think of myself as a fake

AhNowTed · 02/06/2023 19:52

@MaggieBsBoat

How is that offensive?

I understand precisely what the OP means.

If someone was born in Jamaica, but lived most of their life in Ireland, would you call them offensive for saying they don't feel fully either? Ridiculous.

Shallistayorshalligo · 02/06/2023 19:51

Why is it so important and why does it bother you?
What is so great about being born “true” Irish, English or Chinese?
What is your personal contribution to it?
To be proud of what is your nationality is the same as to be proud you were born on Monday. Yes, why aren’t you upset you were born on Tuesday instead?

i can totally get people being interested in their history and ancestry. But I fail to understand pride in something they have never had saying.

IbizaToTheNorfolkBroads · 02/06/2023 19:49

Where do you stand on Tayto crisps @bumbleebe ?

Dacadactyl · 02/06/2023 19:49

bumbleebe · 02/06/2023 19:29

I know I’m Irish! It’s more that I don’t feel as Irish as someone whose family have lived on The Arans since before records began… do you see what I mean? I think it’s because I was raised with the notion that I was Irish Irish, and now there’s something that challenges that.

There are PLENTY of people born and bred in the UK and elsewhere with the notion that they are Irish Irish.

If you are of Irish descent (or of ANY descent e.g. Pakistani or Ghanian or Jamaican or wherever) with parents who kept links to their country of birth and their traditions, you can feel part of that culture too.

Nothing odd about that. It's more odd that someone born and bred in Ireland doesn't feel Irish tbh.

pointonepercent · 02/06/2023 19:46

YANBU

Much moral panic on MN when it comes to subjective measures of identity.

I don’t think national identity or legal citizenship trumps ethnic heritage when describing who you are. If, for example, all four of your grandparents are Korean but you are born in Sri Lanka and educated in Australia am you not allowed to feel Korean?

Somethingsnappy · 02/06/2023 19:46

Well, I feel about as British as British can be, despite my ancestors (near and far) being from a wide variety of other places and cultures. As a PP has pointed out, aren't we all a bit of a mish-mash?

MaggieBsBoat · 02/06/2023 19:46

You are making a good point and I agree@TheMurderousGoose I‘m just infuriated by this speak of ‚not real‘ this and ‚not real that‘ . The fact is no one is real anything. And I’ve encountered enough racism based on borders to make this a bloody absurdity.

Chickenkeev · 02/06/2023 19:44

MaggieBsBoat · 02/06/2023 19:34

Wow. This is absurd and almost offensive. It almost seems like a humble brag. You are as Irish as 90% of people in England are English or 80% of Scotland born people are Scottish.
there is literally no such thing as a ‚pure bred‘ person. That is Nazi-speak. I am an Irish person living in Germany. This is beyond awful to think this way!!!!
For what it’s worth, I was born in Scotland and consider myself a Scot. I hold an Irish passport. If I bother getting a German passport I’ll be German and as authentic as anyone else. FFS.

Offensive? Chill the beans like.

SocksAndTheCity · 02/06/2023 19:44

If you were English with English grandparents but had found out some great grandparents were Irish and moved, would you be here kvetching about how you're not properly English?

I'm neither, btw.

TheMurderousGoose · 02/06/2023 19:41

MaggieBsBoat · 02/06/2023 19:34

Wow. This is absurd and almost offensive. It almost seems like a humble brag. You are as Irish as 90% of people in England are English or 80% of Scotland born people are Scottish.
there is literally no such thing as a ‚pure bred‘ person. That is Nazi-speak. I am an Irish person living in Germany. This is beyond awful to think this way!!!!
For what it’s worth, I was born in Scotland and consider myself a Scot. I hold an Irish passport. If I bother getting a German passport I’ll be German and as authentic as anyone else. FFS.

Hmmm, there are lots of people (esp. post-Brexit) who have never set foot in Ireland but have been able to obtain an Irish passport due to having an Irish grandparent. Legally they're certainly Irish. But I personally don't consider them as Irish as the 10 year old born in Ireland to non-Irish parents, who's spent their entire childhood in Ireland and yet, due to a stupid law, isn't legally entitled to an Irish passport. Passports aren't the full story is what I'm saying.

DappledThings · 02/06/2023 19:41

bumbleebe · 02/06/2023 19:36

Wtf. This is about identity and feelings. Nothing to do with physicality.

So how many generations do you think real Irishness would feel like? 10? 20? Do those have to be complete or is there an acceptable percentage of each generation being born in Ireland that would make you feel better? It gets daft very quickly quantifying like that.

BitOutOfPractice · 02/06/2023 19:39

Isn’t this the wrong way round? Doesn’t everyone with even a scintilla of Irishness claim it loudly? You’ve got the wrong end of the shillelagh! You’re Irish and proud!

I’m quarter Irish! You beat me!

Hannahsbananas · 02/06/2023 19:38

You’re fourth generation Irish…
Bizarre post, op.

Howiwonderwhat · 02/06/2023 19:37

MaggieBsBoat · 02/06/2023 19:34

Wow. This is absurd and almost offensive. It almost seems like a humble brag. You are as Irish as 90% of people in England are English or 80% of Scotland born people are Scottish.
there is literally no such thing as a ‚pure bred‘ person. That is Nazi-speak. I am an Irish person living in Germany. This is beyond awful to think this way!!!!
For what it’s worth, I was born in Scotland and consider myself a Scot. I hold an Irish passport. If I bother getting a German passport I’ll be German and as authentic as anyone else. FFS.

Well that got Nazi-ish very fast!

eggandonion · 02/06/2023 19:37

Remember when Barack Obama came to Moneygall to find his missing apostrophe?
Do you think Jedward should represent Ireland in Eurovision?