Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel like a fake Irish woman?

117 replies

bumbleebe · 02/06/2023 19:16

So I was born in Ireland. All my grand parents and great grand parents born in Ireland. But before that, only about 1/4 of them are from Irish families. Rest of them moved over from England to Dublin (as a huge number did). So ‘genetically’ I’m only 1/4 Irish.

My parents gave me a very very Irish name. Sent me to Gaelic school etc.

I now live in England. People always sort of view me as being Irish Irish. But I feel like a fraud, because compared to many Irish folk, I’m not. I didn’t know this out until I did my family tree, and now I just sort of feel deflated.

OP posts:
MissyB1 · 02/06/2023 21:54

Chickenkeev · 02/06/2023 21:52

Everybody looks the fucking same! It varies between cities and countries but everyone looks the same.

I don’t care whether they do or don’t but you can’t have it both ways! How people look varies between Countries and Cities but they all look the same??! 😂

TheMurderousGoose · 02/06/2023 21:54

Chickenkeev · 02/06/2023 21:52

Everybody looks the fucking same! It varies between cities and countries but everyone looks the same.

Everyone looks the same except when they don't? Exactly. People from Clare don't generally look like people from Sardinia.

Hannahsbananas · 02/06/2023 21:52

TheMurderousGoose · 02/06/2023 21:49

Yes.

To clarify; it’s just you.

Not an actual “thing” at all.

Chickenkeev · 02/06/2023 21:52

TheMurderousGoose · 02/06/2023 21:48

You think French and Irish people look the same? Some of them sure, but in general, nope.

Everybody looks the fucking same! It varies between cities and countries but everyone looks the same.

TheMurderousGoose · 02/06/2023 21:49

Hannahsbananas · 02/06/2023 21:47

No.

Yes.

TheMurderousGoose · 02/06/2023 21:48

Chickenkeev · 02/06/2023 21:44

It's incredibly irritating. We don't look anything, we're not a homogenous group. We're people no more than the brits or the yanks or the french.we're just normal, boring, bog standard people! breathes out

You think French and Irish people look the same? Some of them sure, but in general, nope.

Chickenkeev · 02/06/2023 21:47

TheMurderousGoose · 02/06/2023 21:44

I dunno, I think you can sometimes spot an Irish face.

Gabriel Byrne to me looks very Irish. Or if I was in NYC and saw someone who looked like, say Hector Ó hEochagáin, walking towards me I'd think 'this fella's deffo Irish'.

That's an absolute load of bollox. Confirmation bias or whatever there is absolutely no way you can tell an irish person that way. Rubbish.

Hannahsbananas · 02/06/2023 21:47

TheMurderousGoose · 02/06/2023 21:44

I dunno, I think you can sometimes spot an Irish face.

Gabriel Byrne to me looks very Irish. Or if I was in NYC and saw someone who looked like, say Hector Ó hEochagáin, walking towards me I'd think 'this fella's deffo Irish'.

No.

Chickenkeev · 02/06/2023 21:44

Hannahsbananas · 02/06/2023 21:39

Such a bizarre claim 🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️

It's incredibly irritating. We don't look anything, we're not a homogenous group. We're people no more than the brits or the yanks or the french.we're just normal, boring, bog standard people! breathes out

TheMurderousGoose · 02/06/2023 21:44

I dunno, I think you can sometimes spot an Irish face.

Gabriel Byrne to me looks very Irish. Or if I was in NYC and saw someone who looked like, say Hector Ó hEochagáin, walking towards me I'd think 'this fella's deffo Irish'.

Hannahsbananas · 02/06/2023 21:39

Chickenkeev · 02/06/2023 21:38

Snap!

Such a bizarre claim 🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️

Chickenkeev · 02/06/2023 21:38

Hannahsbananas · 02/06/2023 21:37

My youngest DS actually looks very Irish facially
??
What does “very Irish” look like, exactly?

Snap!

Chickenkeev · 02/06/2023 21:38

We'll take anyone tbf. But 'looks irish facially'? Wtaf is that?

Hannahsbananas · 02/06/2023 21:37

My youngest DS actually looks very Irish facially
??
What does “very Irish” look like, exactly?

TwoFluffyDogsOnMyBed · 02/06/2023 21:33

It’s understandable because I would love to be more Irish…I’m not sure why… I’m only 1 eighth.

My sons are 1 quarter Irish (from dad) plus 1 sixteenth (from me) and they’re considered Irish citizens even though they’ve never been to Ireland. My youngest DS actually looks very Irish facially.

Freeballing · 02/06/2023 21:00

I suppose I can see why you feel weird about it if you had some kind of pride in being Irish going back to the time of St Patrick. Most people don't think like that though and I can see why some people would find it offensive though that you would separate people out into Irish and Irish Irish.

Namechangeed · 02/06/2023 20:52

You never know, the English side could have migrated from Ireland to England years before, many did and then migrated back years down the line. You'll never truly know as a lot of records go missing, but you're definitely Irish.

My family are Irish and have lived there to the point we can't trace it back any further. I however, moved to the UK as a child and have an English accent now, everyone I know just sees me as English.

So, I feel a little lost with my identity also but it's out of my control and I enjoy telling people my nationality when I can.

Shallistayorshalligo · 02/06/2023 20:51

AhNowTed · 02/06/2023 19:56

You're questioning why a sense of belonging might be important?

As an emigrant, believe me it matters.

Folks like me (born and bred in one country, adult life in another) have a very strong sense of where we're from and "belonging" to something.

It's not to be laughed at.

One immigrant talking to another one.

i am an immigrant too and many many years ago I used to have similar feelings, that’s why there is no laugh in my post. As I sort of understand.

But I stand by what I have said previously. To be proud of your own nationality is the same as to be proud that you were born on Monday, in both cases there is no any of your personal contribution to it.

if all of a sudden you find you are not 100 percent Irish, why would you feel lesser?? If you find out you have English, French, Ukrainian blood, why would you be upset? What is wrong with the “other” blood? Why is it not good?

continentallentil · 02/06/2023 20:49

Of course you are Irish!

It’s not like the Irish and British are two different species, it’s just culture.

wineschmine · 02/06/2023 20:44

bumbleebe · 02/06/2023 19:29

I know I’m Irish! It’s more that I don’t feel as Irish as someone whose family have lived on The Arans since before records began… do you see what I mean? I think it’s because I was raised with the notion that I was Irish Irish, and now there’s something that challenges that.

I'm Scottish. Born in Scotland, live in Scotland. Grandparents were all Scottish.

Prior to that, the vast majority of my ancestors on both sides came from Ireland.

I don't consider myself to be Irish at all.

So, no, I see it completely differently to you. I think it would be farcical if I were to claim Irish heritage. I'm not, I'm Scottish.

Urban769 · 02/06/2023 20:40

I'm Irish, I was born in Ireland. My mother is American my father was a Dub. His father was a Dub his mother was from Armagh.

I was raised as an atheist in the 80s. Going to school I felt totally alienated as I was the only one who didn't participate in religion. I didn't really identify with being Irish. I do now, it's a big part of who I am. Ireland is where I am from regardless of my parental heritage.

Our opinions of ourselves change over time. If you perceive yourself as being less Irish because of where you're great great grandparents were from then perhaps you should reevaluate your definitions of Irishness, and how you evaluate yourself and others within that...

eggandonion · 02/06/2023 20:40

I assume the Gaelic school description is either auto correct or for a uk based readership...as this isnt in craicnet.

Greentree1 · 02/06/2023 20:40

bumbleebe · 02/06/2023 19:16

So I was born in Ireland. All my grand parents and great grand parents born in Ireland. But before that, only about 1/4 of them are from Irish families. Rest of them moved over from England to Dublin (as a huge number did). So ‘genetically’ I’m only 1/4 Irish.

My parents gave me a very very Irish name. Sent me to Gaelic school etc.

I now live in England. People always sort of view me as being Irish Irish. But I feel like a fraud, because compared to many Irish folk, I’m not. I didn’t know this out until I did my family tree, and now I just sort of feel deflated.

I always thought I was Scottish, Scottish on one side, I now find I am Irish, Irish on that side (a bit passing through Scotland). Enjoy what you are, nobody will care if you are less Irish than you thought. My other side is Yorkshire forever.

Hannahsbananas · 02/06/2023 20:40

darjeelingrose · 02/06/2023 20:34

Really? Because I feel like on the contrary, if you feel not legitimate in a country that considers that you are Irish even if you were not born in Ireland, with, I think, one grandparent who is Irish, when you have four, and you were born there, then it's really odd. In the UK, if you have one British grandparent you are not considered British and have loads of hoops to jump through even if you were born in the country. So not to feel Irish with all those generations going back, to feel like a fraud in those circumstances, just seems very odd.

I agree, in the sense that it’s op who’s being very odd. Not feeling legitimate in her circumstances can’t be blamed on anyone else.

StephanieSuperpowers · 02/06/2023 20:35

Gaelic school, eh?

Swipe left for the next trending thread