Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think it matters whether Phillip Schofield met the runner when he was 12 or 15.

258 replies

couldanyoneexplain · 02/06/2023 14:14

I've seen and heard both.
Obviously getting someone a job at 18 or 19 with exploitative intentions is sleazy in the extreme. 15 is underage and deeply concerning, but 12 is deep into paedo territory.

OP posts:
dessyh · 04/06/2023 08:30

Anya again - didn’t see it was same poster - I don’t know much about Caroline Flack - remember Sun mocking DV and her when she was facing a DV trial before she killed herself but unsure what that has to do with PS specifics?

Don’t think people don’t understand that you can’t “cross paths” later in life and it not be grooming - that just absolutely isn’t the case with PS and runner though!

If PS had bumped into the runner in a bar at 25 and runner was like oh I met you 10 years ago when I was a kid ha ha and they went on to have a relationship that would be very different.

Don’t know about you and your husband three decades ago, sounds completely different to timeline of a powerful 60 year old meeting a theatre kid then using his influence on him and his career as he turned into a man before dumping him, shifting him round and paying him off when the runner was unsurprisingly indiscreet.

ohdelay · 04/06/2023 07:48

The media outrage over this is overblown unless they really they have Saville levels of dirt on him and ITV. Or maybe they just hate him like his colleagues do and are savouring his downfall.

It's very disingenuous to squeal homophobia when threads like this have been cooking for 3 years
https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/_chat/4059338-Phillip-Schofield?page=1
without any biters even though this site is regularly swept for daily mail content.

Page 13 | Phillip Schofield | Mumsnet

He's on R4 this morning, Saturday Live, talking about coming out and of course his new book. I think this is tasteless - he talks about the upset and...

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/_chat/4059338-Phillip-Schofield?page=13

dessyh · 04/06/2023 07:32

Anya, as PS has been at pains to point out, it was consensual. No one has mentioned ‘criminal’ wrongdoing - working in policing, you know that no criminal case is active therefore “evidence” isn’t official.

The only official evidence in relation to PS and CSA is that he turned a blind eye to his brother’s abuse of a vulnerable boy.

You are ok with all the points already mentioned that led to PS and runner’s consensual relationship, you do you but don’t be surprised other people aren’t keen.

Bill Wyman ‘consensually’ had sex with a 14 year old and Peter Thatchell in campaigning to lower the age of consent cited knowing nine year olds who were unharmed by their 'consensual’ sex with adults. No evidence of grooming or criminal wrongdoing for either man. Doesn’t make it right to most.

In terms of evidence that takes PS beyond “speculation and titillation”, those would be the pictures, videos, screenshots, payoffs and resignations that led to PS’s own admissions and ITV being brought up before MPs. A fairly big deal.

AnyaMarx · 04/06/2023 04:09

Des - what do you make of the fact Caroline flak met her future relationship (s) as children?

She's dead so tragically can't answer

But I do believe you can cross paths with a person you at later go in to have an association or relationship with without it being grooming - that appears to be something people here can't understand? Why ?

If I'd crossed paths at some point with my husband (who was older than me ) would that automatically mean grooming?

I was actually 15 when I met my husband and he was 21 and was by far the most stable , kind and supportive influence in my life back then as it happens . He didn't groom me . He saved me actually. From homelessness and drug abuse and whatever comes with that life - he was a kind , loving influence and we were married 27 years, had two
Amazing kids and a good life . If anyone suggested he groomed me I'd suggest I actually groomed him . I needed a place to live and money - I saw a kind and gentle man and I clung to that because the alternative was a shared house with drug addicts .

I would suggest most people here screaming abuse don't actually have any experience of abuse .

AnyaMarx · 04/06/2023 04:01

There is no
Evidence of grooming. That's the problem I have . I work in safeguarding and policing and understand grooming- but this is speculation and titillation. Nothing more .

And that's why I'm uncomfortable with it . If there is evidence of criminal
Wrong doing why aren't police investigating?

There is none is why . Armchair detectives over reacting and causing an issue . It's such an over reaction. Man has affair at work - that's the story . Big deal .

dessyh · 04/06/2023 02:46

Seeing people suddenly defending PS who don’t seem to know or care what grooming is and why it’s a problem.

The issue is the abuse of power by an influential high profile man held up as a national treasure, given prime time access to prime ministers etc all the while espousing a particular image. He met the runner as a child. Obviously a huge moment in that child’s life. He stayed in some kind of contact with the child on social media. A few years later when the child only just legally becomes an adult he organises him a sought after role working for him in London, away from the teen’s family.

Runner roles are fairly entry level in tv but are still not easy to come by and certainly not usually offered to out of town teenagers for their first job. Then there’s the boozy lunches and dinners as caught on video/pics with the - let’s face it - childish or unworldly seeming runner when he was 18/19. Again, just doesn’t happen with runners and show hosts.

Then there’s the runner’s appearances on the show, studio access for filming his show reels, selfies with PS and Holly, being invited to go on stage at NTAs! The crew involved on a show like that is huge, these things are not usual for runners. Then of course during all this came kissing/ shagging or whatever the runner in the dressing room at work as PS declared in his story about it to the sun newspaper (and wasn’t that decent of him).

If PS had come out because he really wanted to (not 10 days after The young drunk runner made a public scene at NTAs) like if he’d wanted to go public with a long term boyfriend or simply not to live a lie and THEN had naturally met a 20-year-old brickie/banker/first year uni student outside of work that would be different. Eyebrows would be raised at any 60 year old setting out his stall as being “that kind of bloke” who goes for much younger people but it would ultimately be like, oh well.

Bollocks to all this ‘he was a grown 20, people are being homophobic’. The teen years contact and workplace power imbalance is the issue.

Imagine Holly (who’s 20 years younger than PS) visiting youth groups, repeatedly messaging a baby faced boy from one then getting him a job, taking him out on the town drinking and sorting him perks, then having her hand forced to admit she was living a lie as a married mother and had actually been getting off with young one in the work dressing rooms because they were friends who 'got excited’.

The awful thing with the brother and PS not alerting the authorities or helping save the boy from his brother’s child abuse fits with PS previous actions of looking after his own situation above all else.

The thing you know as well if this was Rishi Sunak, PS would be putting these points across to him in an interview but while he himself is ever so sorry for something - not quite clear what - he’s maintaining this wasn’t grooming and trying to give the impression to whichever public are willing to still give him time that it was an equal relationship. Just with pay offs and lawyers. And 60 year olds nurturing intense friendships with 18-20 year olds is just normal, “mates”. Righto. The runner might not even feel groomed but doesn’t mean he wasn’t!

Canthave2manycats · 04/06/2023 01:38

PrivateMolecule0 · 03/06/2023 23:48

We'd all be interested to see what evidence you have personally been presented with and it's source and standing in this issue.

I'll wait.

Wait as long as you want. You are just twisting things now. Do come off your high horse! Nobody knows what actually happened and that is what I have said - wise up!

I just choose not to take PS's word for it. It's hardly been reliable now has it? Why would you believe what someone says when they have just admitted lying comprehensively?

Or was it just a teensy weensy accidental little lie and all should be forgiven because he's upset now?

Personally I will wait. I will do what everyone one of us with a modicum of intelligence is doing and await the outcome of what we can only hope will be a thorough, unbiased investigation.

LifeIsPainHighness · 04/06/2023 00:05

The happiest couple o know left their spouses for one another. I’d find it weird if anyone was still raging about it years later.

Infidelity is quite a sensitive topic on MN from what I’ve seen. People say they’d go fully NC with their siblings if they had an affair - I find it utterly bizarre

AnyaMarx · 04/06/2023 00:02

Or because he's gay

One of my colleagues married his former kids babysitter! Totally successful relationship on every front - lovely couple , totally sorted .

This thread is batshit .

LifeIsPainHighness · 04/06/2023 00:02

Yes I’m unsure what he ‘got off’ with considering he didn’t do anything terrible to anyone except his wife.

AnyaMarx · 03/06/2023 23:59

He got off
Lighter ?

How ?

He's lost his job , reputation, entire career and actually for nothing illegal !

Jesus we've had politicians do
Worse and come back .

He had a fling . Like millions do and the relationship board on this forum is full of the same - my husband is having an affair with his colleague whose 25 years his junior- do those men get hauled over the coals publicly, hounded , trolled and lose everything? No . Because that's life . Morally it might be shot but legally it's not . Why should this one man be treated differently because of the job he does ?

Boobe · 03/06/2023 23:55

LifeIsPainHighness · 03/06/2023 23:31

It also feeds the homos-are-paedos poundshop Alpha fantasy.

100000% this.

Its a shame gay men are STILL tolerating this level of homophobia

Where? He got off lighter than if he were sleeping with a young woman.

One gay man doing wrong and being criticised is not homophobia. It just males people roll their eyes when this is used to excuse what happened.

Had it been a big story? Yes. Had it for anything to do with his sexuality, no.

PrivateMolecule0 · 03/06/2023 23:48

Canthave2manycats · 03/06/2023 15:49

OMG how naive are you?!

After the blatant lies he has ADMITTED to telling literally the world and its wife, with total impunity - and you want to believe him now?

I don't believe a word that comes out of his mouth. Not with his track record.

It's your prerogative if you wish to believe a self-confessed inveterate liar.

We'd all be interested to see what evidence you have personally been presented with and it's source and standing in this issue.

I'll wait.

LifeIsPainHighness · 03/06/2023 23:31

It also feeds the homos-are-paedos poundshop Alpha fantasy.

100000% this.

Its a shame gay men are STILL tolerating this level of homophobia

Yellowdays · 03/06/2023 23:26

Yep.

PrivateMolecule0 · 03/06/2023 23:18

The ponification over this topic is nosy white-entitled Brexit-failure Britain with f*ck-all-to-do-except-watch-TV-in-the-daytime at it's worse.

It also feeds the homos-are-paedos poundshop Alpha fantasy.

If it was Boris Johnson doing it to a girl he'd just be 'a bit of a lad'.

AnyaMarx · 03/06/2023 21:09

😂. If that's the best counter argument anyone can come up with I'll stick to my reasoned opinion and wait for the evidence of any investigation.

Gothambutnotahamster · 03/06/2023 19:42

Yes yes @AnyaMarx - nothing to see here, move along people. We can't have powerful and influential men held to account for their misdeeds and wrongdoings, that's not how our mysoginistic society works and you little women should know your place!

AnyaMarx · 03/06/2023 19:26

I dont think PS has groomed the young man .

Other celebs have met their future flings when they were younger - it doesn't appear PS had much contact with the man in question until he was well above the age of consent and helped him get a job

There is also no evidence that he had him removed from his job - he allegedly applied for a promotion and got it

The comparisons to CF meeting LP are valid - he was 16 , but there is no suggestion she groomed him before their legitimately legal relationship.

This is a witch hunt . The facts are when they worked closely a relationship developed and a fling happened . It ended . The young man moved jobs .

I think the timing of this is unfortunate because of schofields brother being jailed but nor do I think the timing is coincidence.

There is no evidence he groomed anyone. There was minimal contact between them - the man asked him to follow him and asked his advice re getting from a drama school into television. I'm sure any one with any investigative skill could very easily and quickly look at what the actual contact between them online was prior to the pair meeting and working together- when both were adults .

It's mass hysteria and hypocrisy at its finest . And it's time to leave the men involved alone , let the enquiry take place and then judge based on the evidence .

Wiccan · 03/06/2023 19:08

LifeIsPainHighness · 03/06/2023 18:45

I imagine the runner needs legal representation to protect his privacy, as he isn’t issuing statements. If so it’s entirely appropriate PS pay for it

Of course he does , but definatly not paid for by the man who is accused of grooming him . It's just more control over the runner by PS . It could not be more inappropriate !

LifeIsPainHighness · 03/06/2023 18:45

Wiccan · 03/06/2023 16:12

Agree. It's classic grooming. PS really needs to look up the term grooming . And by paying for the runners legal representative PS is still using his power over him !

I imagine the runner needs legal representation to protect his privacy, as he isn’t issuing statements. If so it’s entirely appropriate PS pay for it

Gothambutnotahamster · 03/06/2023 18:42

@Nat6999 so because they didn't have their careers ended, PS shouldn't?

That's crazy! I was a teenager when Bill Wyman was with Mandy Smith and remember being disgusted by it and also remember my mum and dad being angry about it too and not understanding how her parents were accepting of it.

We should learn from the past and be better, not accept abhorrent things today just because they were accepted 30 plus years ago.

Nat6999 · 03/06/2023 18:36

Canthave2manycats · 03/06/2023 15:39

They happened 40/50 years ago?

Yes Johnny cash & Elvis,. It doesn't matter when they were, none of them had their careers ended because of it. but Bill Wyman was in 1993

Wiccan · 03/06/2023 16:12

FedUpWithEverything123 · 03/06/2023 08:37

@AnyaMarx you're completely ignoring the issue particular to this case: grooming a child. You presumably met the 21yo you dated as adults; and perhaps you didn't have the huge power imbalance that PS had. In PS's case, he met the boy when the boy was 12/15yo, followed him on Twitter when the boy was 15, kept in touch with "career advice", seemingly helped the boy get a job at itv, then began a sexual relationship with him when he was of legal age. PS was very rich & powerful, the boy was not. When things broke down, the young man was removed from his job and moved to another programme.

Agree. It's classic grooming. PS really needs to look up the term grooming . And by paying for the runners legal representative PS is still using his power over him !

Wiccan · 03/06/2023 15:59

I think any adult who knew someone as a child should never enter into a relationship with them once they become an adult . It's just bloody wrong on every level !

Swipe left for the next trending thread