Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think it matters whether Phillip Schofield met the runner when he was 12 or 15.

258 replies

couldanyoneexplain · 02/06/2023 14:14

I've seen and heard both.
Obviously getting someone a job at 18 or 19 with exploitative intentions is sleazy in the extreme. 15 is underage and deeply concerning, but 12 is deep into paedo territory.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Clunged · 14/07/2023 18:08

He groomed that young supple choir boy with promises of fame and glory. He's always had that Jimmy Saville look about him.
Sick, sick man

AllOfThemWitches · 05/06/2023 20:41

In all seriousness though, having a sexual relationship with someone you've known since they were in secondary school (if you're an adult) is weird and unsettling. If they had regular contact it's like he was 'waiting' for the kid.

AllOfThemWitches · 05/06/2023 20:39

I bet you wouldn't be saying 'Oh well, he's only a nonce...'

This made me laugh, I'm going to hell

MysteryBelle · 05/06/2023 20:36

.

MysteryBelle · 05/06/2023 20:36

halfsiesonapotnoodle · 05/06/2023 20:13

Wanging on all the time in the press about it is not protecting children. Of course protecting children is essential but this daily shit being churned out isn't doing that. Also, he was an adult when they actually had a relationship and consented to it.

I’m not ok with children being groomed. No one should be,

AlwaysGinPlease · 05/06/2023 20:18

Just seen a compilation video of MM, PS, HW in this morning. MM is incredibly young. It's sickening.

halfsiesonapotnoodle · 05/06/2023 20:13

MysteryBelle · 02/06/2023 15:10

It’s difficult to think of anything better to do with one’s time than protecting children from predators, and raising awareness as op is doing falls into that category.

Wanging on all the time in the press about it is not protecting children. Of course protecting children is essential but this daily shit being churned out isn't doing that. Also, he was an adult when they actually had a relationship and consented to it.

dessyh · 05/06/2023 00:05

“Theyre salacious gossips with nothing better to do .”
Anya. You’re on the same thread.

“A lot being made up for the narrative”
“The problem I have with this now is people making their own shit up . There is simply no reason to believe there is more to it .”
then consider only what PS told the beeb and Sun newspaper. And him having to leave This morning....

“on the face of what they both said - there is No Grooming, no abuse, and I don't actually even think this was a full blown affair”
“Groomer” says no grooming, ok then. Young worker denies ANY relationship at all to employer of both of him and his lover/groomer/mate/boss.

“he said “something happened ” - that could be a kiss , a bj , a fumble , a wank , not necessarily full sex”
That’s ok then** Confused

“This is going to do a lot of damage because people who are in a position to help are going to stop having any contact at all with anyone who wants to work in that industry for fear of this type of accusation.”
Let’s not point out problems with this gross imbalance of power in case it affects the “it’s not what you know…” favours system.

If you keep mentioning your job in safeguarding in the police and asking if people have been abused yes you probably will get pushback on how appropriate that is.

AnyaMarx · 04/06/2023 23:41

Do you have experience of grooming cases ?

Or abuse ?

If not - you cannot pass aspersions on my professional credibility. I'm good at my job and I get huge satisfaction from bringing abusers to account .

What I'm not prepared to do is hang a man based on gossip.

Canthave2manycats · 04/06/2023 23:10

AnyaMarx · 04/06/2023 22:47

This is what I have issue with

There is no
Evidence of pay offs or gagging orders , o an ongoing online relationship

There is a lot being made up to for the narrative and for me - that's wrong

Let the investigation happen and let's review when that's happened but on the face of what they both said - there is No Grooming, no abuse, and I don't actually even think this was a full blown affair

You talk of shagging

Again - he said "something happened " - that could be a kiss , a bj , a fumble , a wank , not necessarily full sex

The problem I have with this now is people making their own shit up . There is simply no reason to believe there is more to it .
I'd like PS to turn around now tell people to
Fuck off instead of constantly apologising because he's making it sound like there is more to apologise for than the facts dictate .

Where is there grooming? pS did not take the boy under his wing as 15 and have a close connection to him - and tv is insular and it's who you know not what you know - he had minimal contact via Twitter until they worked together. This is going to do a lot of damage because people who are in a position to help are going to stop having any contact at all with anyone who wants to work in that industry for fear of this type of accusation.

My sister worked in theatre /tv and trust me if PS has acted in appropriately then there's gonna be some other big names squirming in their seats - and for much worse .

I do not believe PS groomed anyone .
He gave advice , helped then went on to have a legal, consensual fumble in a dressing room - he needs to answer this for his wife and no one else

There is a lot of hysteria around this

I have been involved in grooming cases - grooming to me is something different here and I have experience working in the area and also as I said - I think people commenting have no experience of actual abuse - the outrage does t match the facts .
The man hadn't been in constant communication with PS . There is no suggestion he did him a favour for sexual gratification, or blackmail,.
They got to know each other in later life and a fling a consensual fling - as adults - occurred - why does the public need to know anything that's a private matter between these two ?
We don't .
This is ridiculous and disproportionate. Peoples lives are being destroyed. Leave them all alone . Let the review be undertaken . Let the findings be known .

You see, my difficulty with this is that we only have PS's word for this. A 'word' that has been totally discredited by his own admission that he lied in 2020. Bared his soul on national TV, saying that he hadn't acted on his gay inclination and that his wife knew everything when he did. How can anyone trust this man? You have no idea what happened and what didn't happen, but PS does not come out of this looking good.

We now know this isn't true. He has used photos of him 'confessing' to his elderly mother, and he has given interviews that are all 'poor me'.

I have no idea what is going to come out of any inquiry and I'm not convinced that it will be impartial.

I'm concerned that you are involved in cases of grooming and you are so easily convinced by a proven liar.

AnyaMarx · 04/06/2023 22:50

Greenpin · 04/06/2023 22:41

Pay offs? How do you know that?

I would suggest they don't.

Theyre salacious gossips with nothing better to do .

AnyaMarx · 04/06/2023 22:47

This is what I have issue with

There is no
Evidence of pay offs or gagging orders , o an ongoing online relationship

There is a lot being made up to for the narrative and for me - that's wrong

Let the investigation happen and let's review when that's happened but on the face of what they both said - there is No Grooming, no abuse, and I don't actually even think this was a full blown affair

You talk of shagging

Again - he said "something happened " - that could be a kiss , a bj , a fumble , a wank , not necessarily full sex

The problem I have with this now is people making their own shit up . There is simply no reason to believe there is more to it .
I'd like PS to turn around now tell people to
Fuck off instead of constantly apologising because he's making it sound like there is more to apologise for than the facts dictate .

Where is there grooming? pS did not take the boy under his wing as 15 and have a close connection to him - and tv is insular and it's who you know not what you know - he had minimal contact via Twitter until they worked together. This is going to do a lot of damage because people who are in a position to help are going to stop having any contact at all with anyone who wants to work in that industry for fear of this type of accusation.

My sister worked in theatre /tv and trust me if PS has acted in appropriately then there's gonna be some other big names squirming in their seats - and for much worse .

I do not believe PS groomed anyone .
He gave advice , helped then went on to have a legal, consensual fumble in a dressing room - he needs to answer this for his wife and no one else

There is a lot of hysteria around this

I have been involved in grooming cases - grooming to me is something different here and I have experience working in the area and also as I said - I think people commenting have no experience of actual abuse - the outrage does t match the facts .
The man hadn't been in constant communication with PS . There is no suggestion he did him a favour for sexual gratification, or blackmail,.
They got to know each other in later life and a fling a consensual fling - as adults - occurred - why does the public need to know anything that's a private matter between these two ?
We don't .
This is ridiculous and disproportionate. Peoples lives are being destroyed. Leave them all alone . Let the review be undertaken . Let the findings be known .

Greenpin · 04/06/2023 22:41

Pay offs? How do you know that?

dessyh · 04/06/2023 22:19

Different parameters when it comes to views of grooming then Misschief.

A powerful 60 year old got an 18/19 year old first jobber a showbiz role that involved them working closely together after meeting him as a child and maintaining an online relationship with the boy from childhood until the job. Then had sex with this workplace subordinate just out of his teens. Payoffs to keep it all quiet. What DO you view as grooming. PS was never going to need to pursue young men via online video games was he. These opportunities present themselves to influential people - who are willing to exploit them as such.

And again this idea of only official “evidence” (when there isn’t a criminal case) or PS runner speaking out being the measure of what it takes to call grooming is interesting.

To suggest PS ‘just’ knew the runner as a child then kind of happened to sleep with him as an adult glosses over the whole sequence of events that led to that relationship and the reason PS is in the shit.

No one has claimed the runner was underage on the boozy dates with PS. No one said all workplace relationships are considered abuse.

MisschiefMaker · 04/06/2023 17:03

I can't see the grooming evidence either if I'm totally honest. I don't think he was underage in those pictures of them going for dinner was he? I don't want to let someone off the hook if they are abusive but just knowing someone when they are underage and then sleeping with them as an adult isn't enough to say grooming occurred.
If he had been 16 when they hooked up then yes of course that would look very much like grooming had happened but at 20 he was several years away from being underage.

And workplace relationships aren't always considered abuse either even if there's an age gap.

Will absolutely reassess if the young man comes forward with details of grooming but I just haven't seen anything like that.

dessyh · 04/06/2023 16:05

That’s a couple of mentions of “evidence” bella. PS has admitted he knew the runner as a child, got him a job working closely with him, began an intimate relationship with him in the workplace, arranged lawyers for him - had to leave itv, Itv facing investigation, up before MPs. The pics and videos of him with the runner... It’s not a criminal case so unsure what you can mean by other “evidence”.

You basically seem to be saying there’s nothing to see here unless the runner goes on record. A big step beyond refusing to lie for PS lawyers, a move that would see him forever officially publicly linked to PS by telling his story, however he sees it, to the world. That is v problematic territory.

Not dissimilar to the view PS took when his brother told him he was abusing the vulnerable child. If the brother had told PS it wasn’t ‘consensual’ would PS have actually acted to save the child from it. Indeed if the brother had, for example, admitted to the same offences but on boys unknown to him, targeted in the street or outside a school say, and PS had simply told him ‘don’t do it again’ a letter to court and return to This Morning would be unthinkable. PS took the view it was behind closed doors and could be ‘contained’ and therefore certainly didn’t put the abused youngster first.

LolaSmiles · 04/06/2023 14:05

The willingness of some posters to ignore the age difference, age of the runner when contact was established, and the power/status difference in this relationship is concerning.

bellac11 · 04/06/2023 10:36

dessyh · 04/06/2023 09:38

Exactly Alexandria. I said similar at 2:46. Can't imagine why bella is claiming that she knows this isn't grooming and no one is explaining how it is

I didnt say I 'knew' it wasnt grooming. I simply said there isnt evidence it is. And no, there hasnt been any explanation in this specific case of the elements that make it so.

The boyfriend may well come to say later and give details and it be established but that hasnt happened as yet.

This is the problem with these types of threads, posters making things up,, putting words into peoples mouths, not working with the evidence as its known.

FedUpWithEverything123 · 04/06/2023 09:47

Well said in all your posts @dessyh

@AnyaMarx you work in policing & safeguarding - yet you entirely fail to see the glaring safeguarding issues at play here - this certainly helps explain the regular safeguarding failures in the police

dessyh · 04/06/2023 09:38

Exactly Alexandria. I said similar at 2:46. Can't imagine why bella is claiming that she knows this isn't grooming and no one is explaining how it is

bellac11 · 04/06/2023 09:35

I do know what grooming is, I work in safeguarding! And there hasnt been any evidence thus far that this person was groomed. If you have it, then provide it.

I asked about vulnerabilities, because on this or another thread (I cant remember where) someone said he was vulnerable. I asked in what way.

AlexandriasWindmill · 04/06/2023 09:24

bellac11 · 04/06/2023 09:05

I think most people on this thread, or other threads about this really dont know what grooming means or what it entails. There is no evidence of grooming based on what is in the media at present.

Ive asked on a number of threads, including this one in response to posters making statements - what vulnerabilities did the boyfriend have, what 'concerns around safeguarding of a young person' were there, what is the evidence of grooming - and no one ever answers.

You don't seem to understand what grooming is. A young person doesn't need 'particular vulnerabilities'. Their age and lack of power are their vulnerabilities.

Here's a basic definition of grooming (from the NSPCC) in case anyone else is confused. Grooming can be a mentor who uses a DC's special interest to create a personal bond and build a relationship. They often use social media messaging to grow the relationship. They give advice, take the person on trips/buy treats/give experiences. The groomer will put themself in a position of power, influence or control over the younger person. A child or young person may not understand they've been groomed.

MilitantMommyBFArmy4Life · 04/06/2023 09:10

It's the exact same reason why female teachers having sex with boys aren't seen as bad as male teachers girls.

Because boys are seen as more mature and that they must have enjoyed it, while girls are seen as how they're supposed to, as people who couldn't consent.

In this case there is still outrage. But no doubt it would be perceived as worse with a girl.

bellac11 · 04/06/2023 09:05

I think most people on this thread, or other threads about this really dont know what grooming means or what it entails. There is no evidence of grooming based on what is in the media at present.

Ive asked on a number of threads, including this one in response to posters making statements - what vulnerabilities did the boyfriend have, what 'concerns around safeguarding of a young person' were there, what is the evidence of grooming - and no one ever answers.

MilitantMommyBFArmy4Life · 04/06/2023 09:04

LifeIsPainHighness · 04/06/2023 00:02

Yes I’m unsure what he ‘got off’ with considering he didn’t do anything terrible to anyone except his wife.

The outrage would be even worse if he has been grooming a young girl so he got off lighter. He'd still lose his job, but it would be a bigger story.