Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is she demanding or am I a pushover?

59 replies

Egyptcalling · 02/06/2023 10:44

I need to vent and get this off my chest. I’ve always been a bit of a people pleaser and am happy to go with the flow. I tend to avoid conflict. I struggle to say no to people at times.

I’m getting increasingly annoyed with my DSis. She moved 1hr40 mins away with her DH and my niece who is 2. There is always an expectation that we will go to them to visit, they have never been to me and DH’s new house which we have lived in for over a year. Their reasoning is their DD’s schedule, it doesn’t fit in with her naps, too long in the car etc.

A few times they have given in and went to my parents house which is around 1 hour away from them, 40 minutes away from me. Whenever my niece is staying with my parents, I go over to visit her.

DSis seems to be becoming more and more selfish and demanding. For example, expecting me and DH to babysit our niece for 4 days next month while they go to Italy for their anniversary (having to both use 2 days AL). They booked the trip without having childcare arranged first. Not only that, she is insisting it has to be at her flat rather than niece coming here. We are more than happy to spend time with our niece but it just feels like there is no appreciation for the fact we are using AL, spending a fortune on petrol to travel there and during the 4 days.

My DDads 70th is coming up and she has said that his family birthday meal needs to be in their town, to make it easier for them. My parents have agreed to this.

DSis her DH and DD are going away to Spain in October and have asked us to look after their cat and dog. This really annoyed me as me and DH are spending hundreds for our dog to be looked after when we go on a cruise this month.

I think I get so annoyed because I hate to put people to any trouble so I just can’t comprehend why DSis has this expectation that everyone will do what suits her and has a complete lack of appreciation when they do. I worry that if I start to say no then I will be accused of not wanting to see my niece or spend time with her

OP posts:
determinedtomakethiswork · 02/06/2023 12:27

Why would you take annual leave to look after her child?

LiesDoNotBecomeUs · 02/06/2023 12:21

:) you are right OP; using 'the word that is not yes' is a skill to be learned !
Get rehearsing for your new strong role.

First line of defence:
No - I can't do that.
No- that isn't convenient for us.
No- we are not available.

Think of those cross-examination scenes in court-room dramas. Say little - stick to the facts. As soon as you start offering extra material (excuses/reasons) - you are lost.

If you are further cross-examined by your sis try things like:

She: ' Why are you not available?'
Strong You: 'I don't want to go into that now.' (Followed by swift change of subject) 'Isn't it infuriating that Philip Scofield...' or 'Have you heard about Mum and the...? or 'Do you remember when we all...' or 'Are you watching Y...'

She: 'Why isn't it convenient?
Strong You'It is just one of those things. (Followed by compelling subject change and distraction.)

(Try and pick a favourite irritation of hers or a subject she has strong feelings about. Have it ready!)

coeurnoir · 02/06/2023 12:20

Is your sister the only one with children? Was she like this before she had a child?

I very much doubt that she will withhold contact with your niece, but it does sound like she enjoys making the threat. If it wasn't your niece, it would be something else. She's selfish and self absorbed to the point where she doesn't care about inconveniencing your parents around your fathers birthday.

You have two choices, carry on and her demands will continue and get more and more ridiculous. Or put a stop to it now.

You are not her default childcare for when she wants a holiday. Say no now and she will either have to take her child with her, or cancel.

Same with her pets. Say no.

And visiting her all the time. And everything else.

Good luck.

Blobblobblob · 02/06/2023 12:19

There is no try, there is only do.

Your key mistake is engaging in debate or giving reasons that she can argue with.

"No, it's too far. That doesn't work for me. I won't be doing that."

Ok this next bit is going to sound harsh, but I'm saying it with the genuine intention to help you...

"people pleaser" is just a fancy way of saying weak and avoidant. It's a form of self indulgence and not a positive or attractive character trait at all.

She doesn't respect you because let's be honest, you don't act like you deserve it.

Make the decision that you matter too, and stop giving reasons!

Hankunamatata · 02/06/2023 12:02

Stop giving reasons. If you want to babysit dn fine but tell sis it's at your house or nothing and yes they will have to drop her off and pick her up.

And nope cant have their pets as your working

thecatsthecats · 02/06/2023 11:59

My sister was like this, in fact both were.

Thing is, I'm happy to take the lion's share of travelling. I get that it's easier for me. But it's not 100% easier, and certainly not cost or time free.

With that sort of distance, I think a 50% you, 25% them, 25% grandparents balance would be more realistic.

KingOfThieves · 02/06/2023 11:56

you need to put boundaries in place OP. It sounds like you want to help your sister but you want to be appreciated and not taken advantage of which is basic respect.

did you ask for help with your pets? What would she say? It needs to be give and take

i wouldn’t have took annual leave for example but would have stated I could help at the weekend at my own home (if that suited)

And as other PP say, if she takes the piss it will just have to be a flat no. Some people just take take take

Mummyoflittledragon · 02/06/2023 11:49

The more you just agree, the more she will put on you. It becomes defacto, an expectation rather than a request. If you then stand up to her, she will become affronted as you’ve always just done it so why not this time.

Thepeopleversuswork · 02/06/2023 11:49

She's taking the piss because she knows you won't push back.

It's outrageous that she is expecting you to come to her to babysit her child while she goes on a holiday which she hadn't bothered asking you about first. No sensible person would expect that.

Use this to assert some boundaries.

AbbieLexie · 02/06/2023 11:46

I've learnt many valuable things on Mumsnet - No. is a complete sentence. No discussion - just repeat. At first I found it very difficult but with practise it has become much easier.

TwoShades1 · 02/06/2023 11:43

I don’t think any of those things are particularly unreasonable to ask of close family members. I think the problem is you agreeing to do it even if you don’t want do. Where your dad has his birthday meal is really none of your business, it’s his choice. If it’s too far for you to attend that’s fine too. If you generally come across as agreeable and happy to help then people will keep asking for things as you seem to be happy about it to them!

BanditsOnTheHorizon · 02/06/2023 11:40

Just say 'no, this doesn't work for me' you don't have to give a reason, if she asks 'why' just respond with 'it's not convenient'

Well we've already booked the holiday
I'm sore you'll sort something

Don't you want to see dn
Of course we do, it's not convenient at this time

It'll cost us a fortune to put the pets in kennels
I know, kennels are expensive these days

Why won't you look after dm at our house
It's not convenient

And just keep going. It's her issue to solve, not yours

Isthisasillyquestion · 02/06/2023 11:38

Do it back! Don't pay for your dog to be looked after when you go away - cancel that and send the dog to your sisters. If she says no then you can say ok fine you'll have to put yours in the cattery/kennels too.

EliflurtleTripanInfinite · 02/06/2023 11:35

DSis seems to be becoming more and more selfish and demanding. For example, expecting me and DH to babysit our niece for 4 days next month while they go to Italy for their anniversary (having to both use 2 days AL). They booked the trip without having childcare arranged first. Not only that, she is insisting it has to be at her flat rather than niece coming here.
Start with this tell her DN will be babysat at your house and they will drop her off or they can find someone else to do it. Tell her she needs organise a pet sitter for the other holding. I don't know anyone who would think it was reasonable to ask someone with a full time job to pet sit or baby sit when they live that far away. She is being completely unreasonable, but if only works if you give in You and your DSis are very different people, she feels entitled to whatever she wants from you, this is working for her, she's not going to stop until you set strong boundaries and say no.

RoachFish · 02/06/2023 11:22

She has no authority to be demanding these favours of you so yes, you are being a pushover. It is perfectly fine saying no things you don’t want to do. The fact that you are taking AL for something you don’t want to do is absurd. How did you get your DH to agree to that?

Wishimaywishimight · 02/06/2023 11:17

Or "Tempting but no thanks!"

Stop being a pushover. Saying "no" is life changing, you will gain a whole new respect for yourself.

MarinatemysoulinSprite · 02/06/2023 11:16

I’ve always been a bit of a people pleaser

But you are a person too! So is your DH.

Are you "pleased" with how things are?

Tell her no (and enjoy being pleased).

Wishimaywishimight · 02/06/2023 11:16

Stop giving reasons! I find "Eh no thanks" followed by a laugh can put off the asker - if they think you think (or are pretending to think) they are joking it makes it a little more difficult for them to push it.

itsgettingweird · 02/06/2023 11:16

I think this is where the Mn phrase "that doesn't work for me" comes in!

She wants you have to have niece. It's at your house. Being at hers doesn't work for you.

Rubychews · 02/06/2023 11:13

While you continue to say yes to these absurd requests they will continue to ask.

OrigamiOwls · 02/06/2023 11:12

You don't need to try harder, you need to learn to say no. Start by declining pet sitting in October.

littleripper · 02/06/2023 11:06

Have you asked her to look after your dog?

MinnieGirl · 02/06/2023 11:04

Your sister is getting away with this because you are letting her….

She booked a holiday without asking if you could provide childcare, and then demands you stay in her flat, and have to take AL…
Sorry all leave is booked for that time, we can’t do it. Do wish you’d asked before you booked it. And staying at your flat wouldn’t work for us anyway.
It’s really too late to say no to this one but be in your guard for next time! She may cry and tell you she can’t cancel but that’s her problem. And I would be asking for a contribution towards petrol…

Dog and Cat in October? Sorry our dog won’t like that and it would be too stressful. You will need to book kennels or a pet sitter. You’ve got plenty of time…..

You can still visit them but start pushing back. Who the hell books a holiday without childcare? Stand up for yourself.

KnackeredBack · 02/06/2023 11:03

I've found that 'no, I don't want to' is a difficult phrase for the other person to overcome. No excuse there - blunt truth, but works well. If they then ask why you don't want to, you can then be utterly truthful (expensive, putting you out of your house, time consuming, using your precious AL etc.) You may need to practice saying those things beforehand and take a big breath before you do so, but hopefully it revolutionises your ongoing relationship.

WhineWhineWhineWINE · 02/06/2023 11:02

"I just can’t comprehend why DSis has this expectation that everyone will do what suits her"

Because nobody ever tells her no by the sounds of it. Be the first!