Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

She didn't need to tell me my weight.

215 replies

NorthRock · 02/06/2023 08:29

Just to vent as I can't share my frustration anywhere else...

I went for my NHS health check yesterday, and specifically asked not to be told my weight. I said to the nurse that I've been obsessional about it in the past and it's better for me not to know, as it sets me off... In the other questions she saw that I do cardio exercise 6 days a week, and she could see from my measurements that I'm small. I didn't want to state outright that I have a long history of eating disorders. I thought she would gauge that from everything else I'd said.

At the end of the appointment, on the card where she'd noted my BP, pulse, cholesterol etc she also wrote on my weight and BMI. She said "Oh, I know you said you didn't want to know that, but..." <tinkly laugh>

Aibu to think this was not ok? Surely she would have some awareness of EDs? I'm trying so hard not to go back to the trap of weighing and feeling compelled to lose weight, but already I'm wondering if I might buy some scales just to shave off half a stone. I've fought this for 30 years and wish she had have listened to what I was telling her.

OP posts:
NorthRock · 02/06/2023 09:03

I'm sorry for the so many others have been through this journey too. 🌷and 💪to keep on track

OP posts:
NorthRock · 02/06/2023 09:00

MissBPotter · 02/06/2023 08:54

You didn’t disclose your reason for not wanting to know. Therefore it is I’m on you. People saying that’s terrible and you should complain should think about how much pressure the NHS is under these days! They offer you a health check which you voluntarily attend and then you kick off because she told you actual information about yourself?! Sorry I think you’re being unfair.

I hope it's clear that I'm not "kicking off". In my OP I said that I'm venting here because I can't mention it in real life. I have no desire to kick off. People with EDs are typically people who internalise their upset/self-harm rather than risk harming others.

OP posts:
Dinosauratemydaffodils · 02/06/2023 09:00

I’m sorry but I think the onus was on you to disclose why you didn’t want to know given it was a medical situation. I can imagine that an awful lot of women say they don’t want to know in a half joking way and so she wasn’t alert to your distress.

She said she didn't want to know. That should be enough.

I would have found it hard too. Dh threw my scales away after a helpful midwife told me my weight mid pregnancy with dc1 and it kicked off a spiral of obsessive weighing/living off 2 ryvita with a slivers of cheese and apple a day. Ds ended up being such a thin baby (90th something percentile for length, 18th for weight) and I still feel guilty years later.

NorthRock · 02/06/2023 08:58

mynameiscalypso · 02/06/2023 08:49

I think there's a lot of misconceptions about eating disorders on this thread. Like the OP, I feel ashamed at disclosing that I have/had an ED to medical professionals because I'm currently just pushing into overweight territory and I worry that they won't believe me or think that I'm just 'really bad' at having and ED.

Yes- this is exactly it, myname. It is a huge hurdle to mention EDs. I can count on one hand the number of people in my life I've said it outright to, despite it affecting every day of my life since I was 10, now that I'm 42.

I would love to be in the category of people who don't understand why telling someone you have an eating disorder and risking them responding that you don't look like it is enough to trigger a relapse.

OP posts:
ScottishBeth · 02/06/2023 08:57

And I completely disagree with several posters that you needed to disclose your ED. I am sure for some people that's not easy to do at all and not something you want to get into in this situation.

MissBPotter · 02/06/2023 08:54

You didn’t disclose your reason for not wanting to know. Therefore it is I’m on you. People saying that’s terrible and you should complain should think about how much pressure the NHS is under these days! They offer you a health check which you voluntarily attend and then you kick off because she told you actual information about yourself?! Sorry I think you’re being unfair.

MisschiefMaker · 02/06/2023 08:53

Sounds like she forgot and then remembered at the last minute. Why couldn't you tell her to remove it from the card when she remembered? Had you already seen it by that point? I would have said "yes can you please not include BMI" so she'd have to rewrite it or, passive aggressively in a disappointed tone "Oh if it has my weight on there I won't take it".

Anyway regardless I think you can feed it back politely to ask them to be more considerate in future. But you should be reasonable in your wording because it sounds like an innocent slip up and she acknowledged that on the spot, albeit awkwardly.

NorthRock · 02/06/2023 08:53

WetBandits · 02/06/2023 08:51

If their BMI is >35 there are certain types of contraception I can’t issue so we’d have to have that conversation then, but if they are clearly of a normal weight and don’t want to know their weight, me telling them isn’t going to make a difference to the outcome of supplying their contraception, but it might 1) trigger an ED relapse if they’ve previously struggled with one and 2) break their trust in me so they don’t come back.

I do tell people if their BP is high, they can’t see it for themselves, whereas someone of ‘a dangerous weight’ tends to have a rough idea of that.

‘Doing my job’ includes listening to the patient and respecting their wishes.

You sound like an excellent, sensitive and thoughtful practitioner, WetBandits.

OP posts:
SparklyBlackKitten · 02/06/2023 08:53

She was in the wrong
But so were you for not mentioning your eating disorder.

You wouldn't go to a restaurant with and say 'no nuts please' when you have anaphylaxis either
You'd make 1000% to mention that having peanuts could have you end up in hospital or worse.

A nurse is busy. And overworked. And dealing with 663838 issues. When you simply mention "I dont want to know my weight please" it doesn't register. Or at least it wouldn't register as a must avoid at all cost.

Time to refocus yourself and not going down a mumsnet AIBU rabbit hole! it is time to see a mental health professional about this. You need mental help. What you dont need is comments from random strangers agreeing or disagreeing with you

Changeforachange · 02/06/2023 08:53

notanicepersonapparently · 02/06/2023 08:42

I’m sorry but I think the onus was on you to disclose why you didn’t want to know given it was a medical situation. I can imagine that an awful lot of women say they don’t want to know in a half joking way and so she wasn’t alert to your distress.

I hadn't considered that a nurse probably hears 'oh don't tell me what I weigh!' at 50% of these types of appointment.

I don't think you're unreasonable to be upset that she didn't follow a specific, easy request, but with that as context, the situation could have been avoided if you'd clarified you have a history of ED; or if you're uncomfortable with that, reiterating seriously 'I know you must hear it a lot, but can I stress, I really don't want to know my weight. It's not helpful for me'.

It's certainly worth sending an email for awareness rather than criticism.

I hope you're okay OP.

NorthRock · 02/06/2023 08:52

Thank you for all of your replies and for the understanding so many have shown.

It was an NHS health check carried out at a local government building, so not within my GP practice. I'll look at the letter to see where I could give feedback.

I don't want to 'complain' as such, and she seemed like a nice woman, but I'm frustrated that this happened and that she lacked awareness and didn't take notice of what I was saying.

Re. Counselling - I had some excellent therapy about five years ago which saved my life, but I can't afford it again. I wouldn't qualify for NHS support as I'm not thin enough (the great conflict that many families with anorexic children have- physical recovery precludes support).

OP posts:
ilovesushi · 02/06/2023 08:51

I'm sorry that happened to you. You made a completely reasonable request which could easily have been followed. There was no need for you to give explanations. Anyone with half a brain would understand that it might be triggering or upsetting for you in some way. I would let the surgery know what happened.

WetBandits · 02/06/2023 08:51

Soontobe60 · 02/06/2023 08:44

Would you not consider that they should know if they are of a dangerous weight?
Would you not tell someone if they had very high blood pressure? Or low iron, or high cholesterol?

This HCP wrote the weight on a card. The OP had the choice whether to take the card or not. The HCP has to do their job. Imagine if the protocol says she must give the patient a complete record of the appointment, but doesn’t, and something happens to the patient linked to the findings?

If their BMI is >35 there are certain types of contraception I can’t issue so we’d have to have that conversation then, but if they are clearly of a normal weight and don’t want to know their weight, me telling them isn’t going to make a difference to the outcome of supplying their contraception, but it might 1) trigger an ED relapse if they’ve previously struggled with one and 2) break their trust in me so they don’t come back.

I do tell people if their BP is high, they can’t see it for themselves, whereas someone of ‘a dangerous weight’ tends to have a rough idea of that.

‘Doing my job’ includes listening to the patient and respecting their wishes.

Remaker · 02/06/2023 08:51

I think she was wrong to ignore your direct request.

I also think that it is important to disclose relevant medical information to medical professionals. You should have told her the reason you didn’t want to know.

Parkandpicnic · 02/06/2023 08:50

Please cut her some slack, if she was a health care support worker she might not have had any knowledge of ED and for most other healthcare professionals their knowledge of ED is still going to be limited as they have so many other things they have to know. Please do mention your history of ED and how this triggers it when asking next time. Staff work in a very fast paced environment, never enough time and trying to make multiple simultaneous assessments on a person. As other posters have said it may have been something she had to write down and without being aware of the ins and outs of your eating disorder and how triggering this is for you she wouldn’t have prioritised using precious time to go and speak to another busy senior to find out how the administrative issue could be got round

mynameiscalypso · 02/06/2023 08:49

I think there's a lot of misconceptions about eating disorders on this thread. Like the OP, I feel ashamed at disclosing that I have/had an ED to medical professionals because I'm currently just pushing into overweight territory and I worry that they won't believe me or think that I'm just 'really bad' at having and ED.

Nordicrain · 02/06/2023 08:46

I think you ought to have said why you don't want to know. Like PPs say lots of people are sensitive or in denial about their weight and really ought to be told for their health rather that HCPs contributiung to the head in the sand approach.

All that said, perhaps you could feed back (rather than complain) to the practice as to why this was an issue for you and ask them to take this into account in the future.

notanicepersonapparently · 02/06/2023 08:45

I meant to add that I would contact your GP to make sure it doesn’t happen to you again and to help you if you are concerned about your ED resurfacing. 💐

ScottishBeth · 02/06/2023 08:44

I agree with you - she shouldn't have told you. If you feel able I would also feed it back to the practice. With as much detail as you feel able. Hopefully she'll reflect on it and realise how important it might be. It might also make you feel better about the situation.

I'm sorry you're in this situation. 💐

Fallowandbar · 02/06/2023 08:44

I work in healthcare and I would definitely feed that back. The fact that she said 'i know you didn't want to know' before saying it shows that it wasn't just a slip up.
And you shouldn't have to say that you've had an ED before- common sense would tell you that a lot of women are sensitive about their weight, and basic manners would say that if someone asks you not to tell them something, you don't tell them!

mynameiscalypso · 02/06/2023 08:44

She didn't, you're right. And it's pretty shit that you ignored your explicit instructions. For what it's worth, I refuse to be weighed in those sort of circumstances and no HCP has ever been anything but supportive.

Soontobe60 · 02/06/2023 08:44

WetBandits · 02/06/2023 08:39

That’s not on ☹️

I weigh people every day for contraception and if they don’t want to know their weight, I don’t tell them!

Would you not consider that they should know if they are of a dangerous weight?
Would you not tell someone if they had very high blood pressure? Or low iron, or high cholesterol?

This HCP wrote the weight on a card. The OP had the choice whether to take the card or not. The HCP has to do their job. Imagine if the protocol says she must give the patient a complete record of the appointment, but doesn’t, and something happens to the patient linked to the findings?

NorthRock · 02/06/2023 08:43

LittleDonkeyKong · 02/06/2023 08:37

I think you should have out right said I don't want to know my weight as I have ED

That is something that if I didn't have an ED, I would definitely thought sensible to have done. But EDs come with a weight of shame, and actually if you are now normal/low normal BMI you risk someone saying that they wouldn't have guessed because you look normal. That's happened to me in the past, and other people with EDs will know how triggering it is. It's difficult to explain to someone without the condition, but it's like standing on the edge of a cliff not wanting to fall in again.

OP posts:
notanicepersonapparently · 02/06/2023 08:42

I’m sorry but I think the onus was on you to disclose why you didn’t want to know given it was a medical situation. I can imagine that an awful lot of women say they don’t want to know in a half joking way and so she wasn’t alert to your distress.

Sandylanes69 · 02/06/2023 08:40

NorthRock · 02/06/2023 08:38

Yes of course, but it was a half hour appointment, so more than a fleeting, rushed set of notes.

I would not recommend that people with EDs attend these appointments if they should expect this to happen even when they ask for it not to. Which is not great, as a heart health check is pretty useful for someone with a history of EDs.

I definitely think she would benefit from some constructively worded feedback from you, to raise her awareness. A good healthcare professional should want to keep learning and doing better.

Swipe left for the next trending thread