Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

She didn't need to tell me my weight.

215 replies

NorthRock · 02/06/2023 08:29

Just to vent as I can't share my frustration anywhere else...

I went for my NHS health check yesterday, and specifically asked not to be told my weight. I said to the nurse that I've been obsessional about it in the past and it's better for me not to know, as it sets me off... In the other questions she saw that I do cardio exercise 6 days a week, and she could see from my measurements that I'm small. I didn't want to state outright that I have a long history of eating disorders. I thought she would gauge that from everything else I'd said.

At the end of the appointment, on the card where she'd noted my BP, pulse, cholesterol etc she also wrote on my weight and BMI. She said "Oh, I know you said you didn't want to know that, but..." <tinkly laugh>

Aibu to think this was not ok? Surely she would have some awareness of EDs? I'm trying so hard not to go back to the trap of weighing and feeling compelled to lose weight, but already I'm wondering if I might buy some scales just to shave off half a stone. I've fought this for 30 years and wish she had have listened to what I was telling her.

OP posts:
Azerothi · 02/06/2023 09:44

It isn't ok to tell a patient anything they do not want to know. Those who think it is ok because OP is a healthy weight now are spectacularly missing the point.

I have a low BMI but I have never had an ED, I do however have malignant hypertension. I never want to be told my blood pressure and they have respected that after a talking to in a calm way.

Comfortablechairs · 02/06/2023 09:44

Perhaps the nurse should give up doing her professional and valuable job and get a cosy WFH job where she isn't judged for having a 'tinkly' laugh.

dudsville · 02/06/2023 09:43

I understand the angst, but it is yours to manage, not hers. Just because she told you doesn't mean you now have to re-engage a dormant unhealthy coping mechanism. You can't be safe so long as others can't hold that kind of power over your wellbeing.

Toenailz · 02/06/2023 09:43

Blancmangemouse · 02/06/2023 09:39

Yes, this.

You were expecting her to read between the lines that you had an ED and would be triggered by the information. But perhaps she read between the lines differently, without knowing about the ED she probably just saw a healthily slim woman worried about putting on weight, so as your bmi is fine presumed that letting you know would be a relief. As you are presumably neither under or overweight, she would have no prompt to consider that an ED could be an issue.

Perhaps in future you could let it be known in advance when booking the appointment, so you do not have to disclose on the spot, but also are not relying on people reading between the lines accurately.

Has the op stated she is slim? I may have missed this. Quite a lot of overweight people are eating disordered. And coming from someone who was one of those, I was absolutely ashamed to ever say it, because if you're fat, people do pull that face if you say you struggle with ED.

NorthRock · 02/06/2023 09:43

Toenailz · 02/06/2023 09:39

I had this once. I've never forgotten it. I have PCOS, and in my teens, suddenly ballooned with a combination of the onset of the condition, and side effects of the contraceptive implant (which I never wanted but was heavily pressured into by a parent). I had tried to explain to the nurse I had gained a lot of weight quickly, after having the implant fitted, and had no lifestyle or eating habits change. At all.

The nurse refused to believe it (funnily enough, when the implant ran its course, I dropped 5 stone very quickly, again without any change of eating habits or lifestyle changes).

When she told me she was going to weigh me, I told her I was ok with her recording it, but I did NOT want to be told what it was, as it would effect my mental health as I was feeling terrible about all of this, and explained to her I was well aware of my size and that I was an unhealthy weight.

She took my weight. Out loud. Just spoke it out whilst reading my weight. I was at this point, already struggling with having gained such a large amount of weight so quickly, and having intrusive thoughts about 'dieting' (and visiting pro-ana websites obsessively). I stopped eating completely for weeks after this, and my only income of calories was from some fizzy drinks (I had done a couple of much shorter stints prior to this). I obviously dropped a good amount of weight, but I ended up very unwell. Not as unwell as someone who wasn't obese when they started would be, thankfully.

Unfortunately, obviously, as soon as I started eating again, I gained it all back plus more. And my body was fucked from it. It took a good couple of years to get the binge eating and starving cycles under control, along with my mental health. Mind back then, help for people who had starve/binge cycles but were obese was not a common thing, my family tried.

The nurse didn't cause my ED, but she certainly did not fucking help, and triggered a massive downhill spiral. As I say, after getting things under control over the next couple of years, and returning to my usual diet, when the implant ran its course, I dropped the weight with no effort (or even attempt) at all.

The nurse took advantage of a young girl/teenager, and abused her position in my case and yours OP. Contrary to what many people believe, fat people are well aware they're fat and not in denial. They see themselves in the mirror every day. A nurse doesn't need to confirm it for them by reading a weight out. They can confirm it in other ways, in a supportive and helpful manner, offering solutions and listening to the patient.

Please complain, if you feel able, OP. The next time it might be another vulnerable young girl who doesn't realise they can complain about this or doesn't feel like she has a say. It's bad enough it happened to you. And I hope the nurse who saw me about 15 years ago ish is reading this. You're a horrible cunt.

I'm so sorry this happened to you, Toenailz. Like you mention, these events live long in the memory of someone with these struggles. You learn not to mention anything about it as the response from someone who doesn't understand can be so damaging. EDs are like a horrible, hidden battle that stops life being in any way enjoyable. I can't imagine what life might have been like if it hadn't accompanied me throughout.

OP posts:
MasterBeth · 02/06/2023 09:42

People don't like complaining.

So you don't need to frame your comment as a complaint if you'd rather not. Frame it as a suggestion, but absolutely write to the practice manager.

LaBellina · 02/06/2023 09:42

You don’t need to share with her that you have an eating disorder as it’s absolutely none of her business unless you decide that it is is. You don’t owe her an explanation on why you don’t want to know your weight, you stated a simple boundary that required more effort to ignore then to simply respect. She definitely should know better in her position and I would complain in your position.

Cherryblossoms85 · 02/06/2023 09:41

I wouldn't ever say I had an ED, because in theory I didn't. But I did a medical study as a volunteer once, and I was supposed to be in the control group. They rejected me based on my weight history (I know exactly how much I weighed when I was 17)and said that put me in the ED group (they didn't need more people in it), and asked my GP to contact me. Which of course he didn't.
I can't handle medical weighing either, to a lesser extent, but what could I possibly say, other than please don't tell me the number? I don't "officially" have a problem. The OP shouldn't have to justify herself.

OpenDoors72 · 02/06/2023 09:41

You didn't tell her you have an eating disorder. She's not telepathic.

Telepathickitty · 02/06/2023 09:40

NorthRock · 02/06/2023 08:43

That is something that if I didn't have an ED, I would definitely thought sensible to have done. But EDs come with a weight of shame, and actually if you are now normal/low normal BMI you risk someone saying that they wouldn't have guessed because you look normal. That's happened to me in the past, and other people with EDs will know how triggering it is. It's difficult to explain to someone without the condition, but it's like standing on the edge of a cliff not wanting to fall in again.

I've experience this especially as I now have a very high BMI. I explain history of ED and I get grimaces/screwed up face or eyerolls "really" and "well it wouldn't hurt you to lose some weight" as a reaction. I now just don't consent to being weighed (without explanation) unless it is critical eg medication calculations/surgery.

I'm sorry OP. You should be able to expect a HCP to have respected your wishes.

Blancmangemouse · 02/06/2023 09:39

Nordicrain · 02/06/2023 08:46

I think you ought to have said why you don't want to know. Like PPs say lots of people are sensitive or in denial about their weight and really ought to be told for their health rather that HCPs contributiung to the head in the sand approach.

All that said, perhaps you could feed back (rather than complain) to the practice as to why this was an issue for you and ask them to take this into account in the future.

Yes, this.

You were expecting her to read between the lines that you had an ED and would be triggered by the information. But perhaps she read between the lines differently, without knowing about the ED she probably just saw a healthily slim woman worried about putting on weight, so as your bmi is fine presumed that letting you know would be a relief. As you are presumably neither under or overweight, she would have no prompt to consider that an ED could be an issue.

Perhaps in future you could let it be known in advance when booking the appointment, so you do not have to disclose on the spot, but also are not relying on people reading between the lines accurately.

WomblingTree86 · 02/06/2023 09:39

It's weird that she told you when you said you didn't want to know. Whenever I've been weighed, they generally don't say anything, if I don't ask. Next time I would mention why you don't want to know and if asked for feedback mention it there too. I'm not sure it's worth a complaint though.

Toenailz · 02/06/2023 09:39

I had this once. I've never forgotten it. I have PCOS, and in my teens, suddenly ballooned with a combination of the onset of the condition, and side effects of the contraceptive implant (which I never wanted but was heavily pressured into by a parent). I had tried to explain to the nurse I had gained a lot of weight quickly, after having the implant fitted, and had no lifestyle or eating habits change. At all.

The nurse refused to believe it (funnily enough, when the implant ran its course, I dropped 5 stone very quickly, again without any change of eating habits or lifestyle changes).

When she told me she was going to weigh me, I told her I was ok with her recording it, but I did NOT want to be told what it was, as it would effect my mental health as I was feeling terrible about all of this, and explained to her I was well aware of my size and that I was an unhealthy weight.

She took my weight. Out loud. Just spoke it out whilst reading my weight. I was at this point, already struggling with having gained such a large amount of weight so quickly, and having intrusive thoughts about 'dieting' (and visiting pro-ana websites obsessively). I stopped eating completely for weeks after this, and my only income of calories was from some fizzy drinks (I had done a couple of much shorter stints prior to this). I obviously dropped a good amount of weight, but I ended up very unwell. Not as unwell as someone who wasn't obese when they started would be, thankfully.

Unfortunately, obviously, as soon as I started eating again, I gained it all back plus more. And my body was fucked from it. It took a good couple of years to get the binge eating and starving cycles under control, along with my mental health. Mind back then, help for people who had starve/binge cycles but were obese was not a common thing, my family tried.

The nurse didn't cause my ED, but she certainly did not fucking help, and triggered a massive downhill spiral. As I say, after getting things under control over the next couple of years, and returning to my usual diet, when the implant ran its course, I dropped the weight with no effort (or even attempt) at all.

The nurse took advantage of a young girl/teenager, and abused her position in my case and yours OP. Contrary to what many people believe, fat people are well aware they're fat and not in denial. They see themselves in the mirror every day. A nurse doesn't need to confirm it for them by reading a weight out. They can confirm it in other ways, in a supportive and helpful manner, offering solutions and listening to the patient.

Please complain, if you feel able, OP. The next time it might be another vulnerable young girl who doesn't realise they can complain about this or doesn't feel like she has a say. It's bad enough it happened to you. And I hope the nurse who saw me about 15 years ago ish is reading this. You're a horrible cunt.

Simonjt · 02/06/2023 09:38

It shows that she either doesn’t actually listen to her patients, or she listens and chooses to ignore their needs, neither are suitable for medical staff, especially for patients who are alone with her.

I’ve had similar, I complained and requested that I wasn’t treated by the member of staff again.

NorthRock · 02/06/2023 09:37

Yes- I'm anonymous on here, I presume, and I've faced this weight now - it is inscribed in my mind and I'm not going to stick my head in the sand about it now. It's a stone and a bit heavier than when I last weighed myself (mid therapy - before realising that it is not healthy for me to do and know).
I posted it as some people had queried the context/manner in which it was shared.

OP posts:
Shhhquirrel · 02/06/2023 09:36

RandomMess · 02/06/2023 08:36

Give it as feedback and why it was so damaging for your request to be ignored.

Absolutely this

ZekeZeke · 02/06/2023 09:36

It's probably needed for the file. If you were required to go on medication, to get the dosage right they would need your weight information.

The root cause as mentioned previously is your ED not the nurse.

LumpySpaceCow · 02/06/2023 09:34

Late to the thread but did you really need to be weighed? I have a health check each year for a chronic condition but just decline to be weighed - my weight has no impact on my medication, I'm active, have a good diet and know that I'm not overweight so what value does the number have to my appointment apart from statistics and then causing me unnecessary anxiety?

NotTodaySatanIHavePMS · 02/06/2023 09:31

You didn't want to know your weight, yet you've posted your weight and other personal medical stats on a public internet forum? Okay...

Anyway, YANBU about the nurse's ignorance of your request. Healthcare professionals need to sort it out. I was picking up a prescription yesterday and the pharmacist shouted across to the other pharmacist the name of the medication, which is well-known. Everyone in the queue heard and I was mortified.

User1367349 · 02/06/2023 09:30

Please give feedback. You don’t need to make it a formal complaint. People, even nurses, make mistakes and need to be given the opportunity to learn from them. As you said, it was a simple thing, it only required her to listen, and the consequences for you are quite significant.

I hope you are ok. Please ignore all the “she was busy, this isn’t a big deal” comments. I agree it’s not necessarily sensible to make this into a huge thing, but please do give feedback because in a half hour appointment that was meant to be promoting your health, there should be some consideration of you as a person.

Ladybowes · 02/06/2023 09:27

This has really made me cross - so sorry for you OP she should not have behaved like this.. many people don't go for these health checks and this is the kind of thing that puts people off. If there was a clinical reason for to you know that's different and I am sure it could be handled in a more sensitive manner.

NorthRock · 02/06/2023 09:27

Yep I'll go to there, nahwhale.

Thanks so much to everyone for your responses and support.

OP posts:
nahwhale · 02/06/2023 09:26

Maybe also feed back to that bit that says feedback

willWillSmithsmith · 02/06/2023 09:25

notanicepersonapparently · 02/06/2023 08:42

I’m sorry but I think the onus was on you to disclose why you didn’t want to know given it was a medical situation. I can imagine that an awful lot of women say they don’t want to know in a half joking way and so she wasn’t alert to your distress.

If the nurse hears the words please don’t tell me my weight then I don’t see it matters how many times she hears it. It’s not a difficult request to follow and it doesn’t need a detailed explanation to justify.

Summerfun54321 · 02/06/2023 09:25

Contact the GP and say you would like to provide some feedback on your appointment and explain what happened. Speak to the practice manager if you can. You made a basic request that wasn't followed, totally reasonable to provide feedback on this. If patients don't let management know then services can't be improved.