Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

She didn't need to tell me my weight.

215 replies

NorthRock · 02/06/2023 08:29

Just to vent as I can't share my frustration anywhere else...

I went for my NHS health check yesterday, and specifically asked not to be told my weight. I said to the nurse that I've been obsessional about it in the past and it's better for me not to know, as it sets me off... In the other questions she saw that I do cardio exercise 6 days a week, and she could see from my measurements that I'm small. I didn't want to state outright that I have a long history of eating disorders. I thought she would gauge that from everything else I'd said.

At the end of the appointment, on the card where she'd noted my BP, pulse, cholesterol etc she also wrote on my weight and BMI. She said "Oh, I know you said you didn't want to know that, but..." <tinkly laugh>

Aibu to think this was not ok? Surely she would have some awareness of EDs? I'm trying so hard not to go back to the trap of weighing and feeling compelled to lose weight, but already I'm wondering if I might buy some scales just to shave off half a stone. I've fought this for 30 years and wish she had have listened to what I was telling her.

OP posts:
Rosscameasdoody · 02/06/2023 11:20

notanicepersonapparently · 02/06/2023 08:42

I’m sorry but I think the onus was on you to disclose why you didn’t want to know given it was a medical situation. I can imagine that an awful lot of women say they don’t want to know in a half joking way and so she wasn’t alert to your distress.

This. I can’t imagine that her ‘whoops’ type comment would have been made, and accompanied with a ‘tinkly laugh’ if she had been aware that she was dealing with someone with an eating disorder - she obviously thought it was light hearted and you have to take some responsibility for not alerting her to the fact that you do have a history of eating disorder.

PizzaPizza56 · 02/06/2023 11:20

There are people answering who clearly have no idea how triggering this can be. I also ask not to know my weight and have been respected, even all the way through my pregnancy.

If this happened to me I would send an email to the Practice Manager. Not an email complaining but an email from an education/feedback point of view. I wouldn't expect anything back but I'd want to know it had been said so that potentially you can prevent it from happening to someone else.

Dixiechickonhols · 02/06/2023 11:05

Even slimmingworld so no professional qualifications at all will not share your weight with you if you ask to ‘blind weigh’ and they never publicly say or share your weight as they realise it’s such a sensitive issue. A nurse is qualified and should be more aware.

Dixiechickonhols · 02/06/2023 11:03

I’d definitely feedback. If it’s essential the patient is given their weight/bmi not just recorded on system then surely it could be in an envelope etc. They should also make patients aware that weight/bmi will be discussed so patients can choose not to book on.
When you said I don’t want to know that was point she should have said I’m obligated to give you this information and you could have said I’ll leave now or can you put it in a sealed envelope.
I had a check recently (they invited me - it takes about 30 mins not a rushed appointment I assume they get funding for it) and don’t think I was told my weight or bmi. Just told I was low risk.

Buffypaws · 02/06/2023 10:46

she didn’t forget she literally said she knew you didn’t want it on the card and she did it anyway. so you should certainly complain. What a shit nurse. She deliberately ignored a simple request. No need for it at all. Unless she wanted to wind you up.

LadyMacbethWasMisunderstood · 02/06/2023 10:43

I should add that the tinkly laugh when she gave you the card, of itself, underlines how unreasonable she was. If you decide to complain make sure you highlight that. I really do feel so cross on your behalf.

LadyMacbethWasMisunderstood · 02/06/2023 10:40

As the Mother of a beloved, now 22 year old, who I have supported through anorexia which, literally, nearly killed her, every word you have written OP resonates with me so much.

Of course you are not unreasonable. Of course your patient choice should have been heeded. Of course the nurse should have had a bit more of a clue. Those saying otherwise are frankly, bafflingly wrong.

I have practiced with my daughter phrases that she can use in such situations. Her anorexia was so severe that she had some clinical complications which required ongoing intervention. Sometimes from people whose specialism was not eating disorders. She has found saying “I very much do not want to be told my weight or BMI” kind of does the trick.

Whether or not you complain really depends on how further discussion about it will make you feel. You would not be unreasonable to do so. But if complaining is an unhelpful focus for you, don’t feel pressured to do so in the expectation that you owe it to someone else who may be similarly affected. Though that would be altruistic, in these particular circumstances your responsibility is to safeguard and protect your own well-being as best you can.

I really feel for you. Much solidarity from me.

SleepingStandingUp · 02/06/2023 10:39

NorthRock · 02/06/2023 08:35

Yes- she was writing notes to send to the GP and I consented to that. But this was written on a colourful pocket-sized card specifically for me to take home.

She said the "Oh I know you didn't want to know that" bit as though she was saying "whoops 😂" It just seemed slack and showed no awareness of how triggering this is to people recovering from EDs.

Yeah this is why I'd complain.

She heard you. You asked her not to do it. She did it despite knowing yo u didn't want her to and there was no need to do it. She didn't it whilst acknowledging you didn't want to do it. She did it whilst laughing at the fact she was doing it even though you asked her not to.

This isn't you accidentally seeing it on your notes or you asking her previously and her not remembering.

EggInANest · 02/06/2023 10:34

OP, I have not had an ED and have no specialist knowledge, but want to say Well Done You for the progress you have made. I hope that you can maintain your sense of autonomy and control by giving feedback to the practice rather than allowing the nurse’s mistake / unprofessional behaviour to undermine your progress.

Ongoing strength to you.

ladymaiasura · 02/06/2023 10:31

I’m a nurse. I work in research and clinical trials generally require me to document a patient’s height and weight. I have had a few patients ask me not to tell them their weight. So I don’t. I don’t need them to give me a reason. If they don’t want to know I don’t tell them. I can still document it without showing them or saying the figures out loud. I actually tend not to tell people unless they specifically ask because it can be triggering for so many.

This nurse was wrong to tell you. The fact that the wrote it down and acknowledged that you didn’t want to know while showing you is shocking. This wasn’t an accidental slip, this was blatant disregard for your wishes and goes against NMC core values. I would be appalled if one of my colleagues did this. You are absolutely justified in putting in a complaint.

SweetBirdsong · 02/06/2023 10:31

Nah, YANBU, she shouldn't have done it. You specifically said 'please don't tell me my weight' and she purposely said it!

I reckon if you hadn't have asked her she wouldn't have told you. How mean. Hmm

Worth a complaint to the practice manager? I'm not sure. It may be worth mentioning though, how much it upset you, and how you don't understand why the nurse told you your weight when you asked her - specifically asked her - NOT to.

Hope you're OK @NorthRock

AllotmentTime · 02/06/2023 10:31

Definitely complain.

Those saying "oh the nurse may not have thought of it" - well that's the point. Training/behaviour from HCPs around EDs can be shocking. The nurse should immediately think of that as a possible reason (I mean it's a fairly obvious one), but whether she does or not, should be respectful of the patient's wishes unless there's a sensible/medical reason otherwise. Not just oh I'm going to remember that you didn't want this but I'll do it anyway lol.

Bloatstoat · 02/06/2023 10:30

Absolutely not OK OP, you should give feedback to the practice. It's not uncommon to be asked this and I always make sure people don't have to know if they don't want to, it's their voice and like you most have very good reasons for it. It's an easy thing to do, it sounds like she forgot and wrote it on the card automatically and then tried to laugh it off but she could have written another card or crossed it out so you didn't see it.

To the person who suggested most people who ask this are 'playacting' - firstly I don't think this is true, and secondly it's easy enough to check, both if you aren't sure what someone has said or if you think they really do want to know - I would just say something like "Did you want me to write your weight on your card?" or "Are you sure you don't want to know your weight" - the patient may feel annoyed to be asked twice but better than telling them something they specifically don't want to know.

1offnamechange · 02/06/2023 10:25

SparklyBlackKitten · 02/06/2023 08:53

She was in the wrong
But so were you for not mentioning your eating disorder.

You wouldn't go to a restaurant with and say 'no nuts please' when you have anaphylaxis either
You'd make 1000% to mention that having peanuts could have you end up in hospital or worse.

A nurse is busy. And overworked. And dealing with 663838 issues. When you simply mention "I dont want to know my weight please" it doesn't register. Or at least it wouldn't register as a must avoid at all cost.

Time to refocus yourself and not going down a mumsnet AIBU rabbit hole! it is time to see a mental health professional about this. You need mental help. What you dont need is comments from random strangers agreeing or disagreeing with you

But it clearly did register because the nurse said "oh you didn't want to know your weight!" And then write it anyway
So she was fully aware but just chose to disregard it. If she'd said "oh I'm so sorry I completely forgot you'd said about your weight" then presumably OP wouldn't have an issue.

It doesn't matter if to her (or you) it's a minor thing -patient has made a reasonable request that does not inconvenience you in anyway nor impact on your work - you should follow it!

It's the same as addressing someone as "mrs" when they've said "no its ms" -
they could have been recently widowed, separated after abuse or just sick of assumptions.

Or mispronouncing a name, being corrected and then saying it wrong again - vaguely annoying, or, if it's a "foreign sounding" name actually a racial microaggression when it happens again and again?

Are they huge issues? No! But equally so because they arent huge they are very easy to get right and doing so is the bare minimum of courtest and respect.

Nobody is suggesting that op complains and asks for the nurse to be publicly flogged - just raises it as a learning point.

FarmGirl78 · 02/06/2023 10:24

drpet49 · 02/06/2023 08:38

This.

I work in the NHS and I totally disagree. Yes, staff are very busy and I can totally understanding her forgetting and accidentally writing it in the Patient's card as part of her routine, which she no doubt does several million times a day on autopilot. But to knowingly go against a Patients wishes, and the laugh about it is just unprofessional. Yes it would have been a pain, but she should have written out another card.

This isn't a case of 'the customer is always right' as sometimes we do have to go against Patient's wishes if it's on their best interests and safety. But this nurse couldn't have made that decision without knowing WHY the Patient didn't want to know, and weighing up the risks of triggering an ED relapse against the Patient being unaware of their potentially unhealthy weight.

OP, I wouldn't necessarily complain, but as a first step I'd give official feedback or a "Patient experience letter" as we call them. Depending on much she realises she was out of order I'd then consider an official complaint.

Verbena17 · 02/06/2023 10:23

She didn’t listen and went against what you consented to. She knew she wasn’t supposed to be doing it, but still write it down and said verbally she knew you didn’t want the information. I have found many health professionals who don’t specialise in EDs to be like this - as though they think they can ‘cure’ you.
I would feedback what happens to the practice.

I have a DS with a serious ED and whilst our surgery is generally ok and understanding of his quite unknown ED, some nurses have less training than the GP’s and just say stuff like “oh you need to just eat more” 😩. When he was under the paediatric ED team, even some of their nurses (because his ED is a relatively new term in the DSMV manual) still didn’t understand completely and tried to treat him as though he had a more common ED.

So I think you would need to be quite explicit and overt in your requests to them in future.

Judystilldreamsofhorses · 02/06/2023 10:23

I get it, OP. I don't ever get weighed at the GP/nurse - also previous ED. I am booked in for a smear next month and will simply say no, I would prefer not to be weighed. I'm clearly not over weight and "normal" range and my other stats (BP, heart rate etc) are all fine. If it came to it that having the smear test depended on being weighed at the same time I am not sure I would go.

Namechangeed · 02/06/2023 10:20

Namechangeed · 02/06/2023 10:20

Agreed.

I do sympathize with you OP.

However, you need to be more vocal. I wouldn't have added up that you have an ED by the limited information you gave the nurse.

Had* and ED

Haywirecity · 02/06/2023 10:20

Begsthequestion · 02/06/2023 10:17

How do you know this? That everyone else is "playacting"??

I didn't say "everyone else". I said it's common for people to do that. Not that everyone does that.

Namechangeed · 02/06/2023 10:20

Sandylanes69 · 02/06/2023 08:32

She's also very busy, and it wasn't an ED clinic - I'm sorry for your problems, but the root cause here is your ED not that nurse.

Agreed.

I do sympathize with you OP.

However, you need to be more vocal. I wouldn't have added up that you have an ED by the limited information you gave the nurse.

unkownone · 02/06/2023 10:18

I think you said enough when you said you don’t want to know. One dr made my teen read out loud her weight when I even said it was for eating disorder and she then didn’t eat for a week. She was wrong to write for you when you said not to.

Begsthequestion · 02/06/2023 10:17

Haywirecity · 02/06/2023 10:10

Usually when people say they don't want to know, it means they're worried they're overweight and they'll be embarrassed. It's a bit of a playact. If you didn't state clearly that this was serious because of your history, she might have thought that you were being like that and she was doing you a favour to say that actually your weight was fine.
People make mistakes. We're all human.

How do you know this? That everyone else is "playacting"??

Begsthequestion · 02/06/2023 10:16

caringcarer · 02/06/2023 10:14

But you said you didn't tell her you are recovering from an ED. The nurse can't read your mind. She was probably told to fill it in for all patients to take home. If she'd left it off she might have been in trouble for not doing her job.

She made a very clear request which was ignored. She didn't need to be a mind reader. She just had to listen to the patient.

Glad you're not a nurse!

RedHelenB · 02/06/2023 10:15

LittleDonkeyKong · 02/06/2023 08:37

I think you should have out right said I don't want to know my weight as I have ED

This.

OpenDoors72 · 02/06/2023 10:14

ThreeCoursesForMe · 02/06/2023 09:56

Op please don't complain, I'm not sure why others are telling you to. Yes it's a silly thing to overlook - struggled with ED's myself and so so get where you're coming from, for a while last year I didn't even want to acknowledge my clothes size when shopping but its nobody else's fault. All a complaint will do is hurt the nurse who sounds like she was unaware but not malicious. Also, I had to learn as will you over time that other people are not fuelled by ED thoughts and views - they're not trying to hurt you and aren't as sensitive about it but they're also not the problem for not thinking in such a distorted way. The last thing a busy NHS nurse needs is a complaint over something she definitely wouldn't have intended to cause upset. If you ever want to talk to someone who has had an ED my inbox is always open, it is possible to move past fears of knowing things like your weight etc - really hard at the time but liberating when the ED no longer controls you. Best of luck OP

Exactly - lots of people without eating disorders do cardio six times a week. I don't think it jumps out to most people.

OP is hyper aware of it, though most people wouldn't automatically think it was 'obvious.'