Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

She didn't need to tell me my weight.

215 replies

NorthRock · 02/06/2023 08:29

Just to vent as I can't share my frustration anywhere else...

I went for my NHS health check yesterday, and specifically asked not to be told my weight. I said to the nurse that I've been obsessional about it in the past and it's better for me not to know, as it sets me off... In the other questions she saw that I do cardio exercise 6 days a week, and she could see from my measurements that I'm small. I didn't want to state outright that I have a long history of eating disorders. I thought she would gauge that from everything else I'd said.

At the end of the appointment, on the card where she'd noted my BP, pulse, cholesterol etc she also wrote on my weight and BMI. She said "Oh, I know you said you didn't want to know that, but..." <tinkly laugh>

Aibu to think this was not ok? Surely she would have some awareness of EDs? I'm trying so hard not to go back to the trap of weighing and feeling compelled to lose weight, but already I'm wondering if I might buy some scales just to shave off half a stone. I've fought this for 30 years and wish she had have listened to what I was telling her.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SweetBirdsong · 03/06/2023 12:24

NorthRock · 03/06/2023 09:49

Just checking back in and have seen so many more very helpful and thoughtful posts. Thank you all.

I will send an email with a "recommendation", not castigating the nurse in any way but flagging that listening to a patient's request is important due to the reasons we've gone into. I think it was a case of naïvety, but which has serious unintended consequences. I know in my field that we have to be vigilant for what a person is telling us, and to that's just ingrained in my practice, so I found it surprising that another person in a position of care for a client would be oblivious to this

Thank you again, to all, and I'm sorry that so many have either been parents of sufferers, or sufferers of these medical conditions. Strength to you all.

😘

Sandylanes69 · 03/06/2023 11:10

NorthRock · 03/06/2023 09:49

Just checking back in and have seen so many more very helpful and thoughtful posts. Thank you all.

I will send an email with a "recommendation", not castigating the nurse in any way but flagging that listening to a patient's request is important due to the reasons we've gone into. I think it was a case of naïvety, but which has serious unintended consequences. I know in my field that we have to be vigilant for what a person is telling us, and to that's just ingrained in my practice, so I found it surprising that another person in a position of care for a client would be oblivious to this

Thank you again, to all, and I'm sorry that so many have either been parents of sufferers, or sufferers of these medical conditions. Strength to you all.

Perfect response, and all good wishes to you for your recovery and happiness 😊.

NorthRock · 03/06/2023 09:49

Just checking back in and have seen so many more very helpful and thoughtful posts. Thank you all.

I will send an email with a "recommendation", not castigating the nurse in any way but flagging that listening to a patient's request is important due to the reasons we've gone into. I think it was a case of naïvety, but which has serious unintended consequences. I know in my field that we have to be vigilant for what a person is telling us, and to that's just ingrained in my practice, so I found it surprising that another person in a position of care for a client would be oblivious to this

Thank you again, to all, and I'm sorry that so many have either been parents of sufferers, or sufferers of these medical conditions. Strength to you all.

OP posts:
lurchermummy · 02/06/2023 18:58

Complain - she KNEW you didn't want to be told your weight but still told you. And even wrote it down so you had to look at it. A tinkly laugh does not make that okay.

phoenixrosehere · 02/06/2023 18:30

phoenixrosehere · 02/06/2023 18:28

It's not fair really, but everybody is so overworked and busy they just forget sometimes. That's not great but it doesn't matter really, what matters is we're not triggered.

The nurse didn’t forget though.

She said "Oh, I know you said you didn't want to know that, but..." <tinkly laugh>

That isn’t someone forgetting or overworked. That is someone choosing to blatantly do something they were asked not to do due to their own belief about a stranger.

assumptions not belief

phoenixrosehere · 02/06/2023 18:28

PostOpOp · 02/06/2023 15:42

OP I have some things that can trigger my PTSD due to sexual assault in a clinical setting plus rapes outside that. I have it written on my notes as some kind of special note, so if they read them, they'll see. Some read them some don't. So I always now bite the bullet and literally tell everybody new I come into contact with that I am uncomfortable with doing X because of my past (I say what I've said above), if X is likely to be required. I don't want to talk about it to strangers, but I feel that it's the lesser of two evils: say it vs being triggered. I've had loads of good therapy and have made massive progress but in a medical setting I just can't get it totally out of my mind.

So I haven't had time to RTFT, but I think we need to help the people trying to help us (even if we don't think they always are!) by making sure they know. Then if they're a dick, we can and should very legitimately complain.

I think you should send a "recommendation" that any HCP taking people's weight should be aware of why people may not want to know, and also make sure you say upfront "I don't want to know my weight as it can trigger a past ED." It's not fair really, but everybody is so overworked and busy they just forget sometimes. That's not great but it doesn't matter really, what matters is we're not triggered.

It's not fair really, but everybody is so overworked and busy they just forget sometimes. That's not great but it doesn't matter really, what matters is we're not triggered.

The nurse didn’t forget though.

She said "Oh, I know you said you didn't want to know that, but..." <tinkly laugh>

That isn’t someone forgetting or overworked. That is someone choosing to blatantly do something they were asked not to do due to their own belief about a stranger.

Parkandpicnic · 02/06/2023 18:25

PostOpOp · 02/06/2023 15:42

OP I have some things that can trigger my PTSD due to sexual assault in a clinical setting plus rapes outside that. I have it written on my notes as some kind of special note, so if they read them, they'll see. Some read them some don't. So I always now bite the bullet and literally tell everybody new I come into contact with that I am uncomfortable with doing X because of my past (I say what I've said above), if X is likely to be required. I don't want to talk about it to strangers, but I feel that it's the lesser of two evils: say it vs being triggered. I've had loads of good therapy and have made massive progress but in a medical setting I just can't get it totally out of my mind.

So I haven't had time to RTFT, but I think we need to help the people trying to help us (even if we don't think they always are!) by making sure they know. Then if they're a dick, we can and should very legitimately complain.

I think you should send a "recommendation" that any HCP taking people's weight should be aware of why people may not want to know, and also make sure you say upfront "I don't want to know my weight as it can trigger a past ED." It's not fair really, but everybody is so overworked and busy they just forget sometimes. That's not great but it doesn't matter really, what matters is we're not triggered.

Great advice, HCPs generally go to work to do the best they can. They only know what they know and are just humans working in an often high pressure environment . Most love it when we get to go on training courses and learn how to do our jobs better and come away thinking well now I know that I’ll do things differently next time, e.g. becoming aware what is and isn’t helpful to say to a bereaved person, that certain things might be triggering for abuse survivors etc, there are countless things and we never stop learning. Sometimes it’s just a misunderstanding, particularly if there’s ambiguity and thought patient just jokingly meant don’t tell me my weight, although no doubt if they’ve been on an ED study day she’d know to clarify but she probably hasn’t. Obviously some nurses might have a background in mental health or family member so will be more aware. Some general feedback re how triggering the issue of weight is in those appointments would be useful for all the staff and hopefully fed back in a team meeting but definitely people being really specific if they have things that they would prefer done a certain way. Like anything if you tell people a reason for an instruction they are much more likely to remember it as it attaches a meaning to it in our brains, just how attention/psychology works

PostOpOp · 02/06/2023 15:42

OP I have some things that can trigger my PTSD due to sexual assault in a clinical setting plus rapes outside that. I have it written on my notes as some kind of special note, so if they read them, they'll see. Some read them some don't. So I always now bite the bullet and literally tell everybody new I come into contact with that I am uncomfortable with doing X because of my past (I say what I've said above), if X is likely to be required. I don't want to talk about it to strangers, but I feel that it's the lesser of two evils: say it vs being triggered. I've had loads of good therapy and have made massive progress but in a medical setting I just can't get it totally out of my mind.

So I haven't had time to RTFT, but I think we need to help the people trying to help us (even if we don't think they always are!) by making sure they know. Then if they're a dick, we can and should very legitimately complain.

I think you should send a "recommendation" that any HCP taking people's weight should be aware of why people may not want to know, and also make sure you say upfront "I don't want to know my weight as it can trigger a past ED." It's not fair really, but everybody is so overworked and busy they just forget sometimes. That's not great but it doesn't matter really, what matters is we're not triggered.

MMMarmite · 02/06/2023 15:21

Redbone · 02/06/2023 14:21

@phoenixrosehere Yes, I think that I agree with you. That would have been the best way to handle it. So much venom here for the nurse when what really is the issue is the OP’s eating disorder.

The issue is the nurse ignoring an explicit request from the patient.

Suppose I say "please don't use latex gloves", and the nurse uses latex gloves and then says "oh I know you said you don't want me to, haha". Would you say "don't criticise the nurse, the real issue is your latex allergy. You can't expect her read your mind"?

Patients make requests for a reason. The nurse should never ignore a specific request, they should either ask the reason, or just follow the request.

Arewehumanorarewecupboards · 02/06/2023 15:14

I work in mental health and often weigh people (mostly due to weight gain from certain medications but also annual health checks).

I always ask (no matter what size) if someone wants to know. I assume they don’t until told otherwise.

If someone needed support due to their weight I can address that without mentioning numbers.

I’m sorry that you experienced this @NorthRock x

rubydoobydoo · 02/06/2023 15:05

Redbone · 02/06/2023 13:50

I think that YABVU . The problem here is not the nurse, who I presume was not aware of your eating disorder, but your eating disorder. In my opinion, although I’m not not a HCP you should be aware of your dangerously low BMI.

But the OP doesn't have a "dangerously low" BMI. She has a healthy BMI! No need to mention it at all, as there are no concerns.

Princessconsuelabananahammock9 · 02/06/2023 14:52

mynameiscalypso · 02/06/2023 10:10

To illustrate what it means to someone with a history of ED, just seeing the OP's card is hard for me. My immediate thought is that the OP is a little shorter but not that much shorter than me and my weight is more than hers and therefore I shouldn't eat today because I'm so gross and disgusting.

(Just a note to the OP, that doesn't mean that you shouldn't have shared it - I'm aware this is my own reaction and have plenty of support to deal with my own thought patterns)

Yep. I'm another one who read her card and felt triggered because I'm a bit heavier. This is why Eating disorder recovery programs have a no numbers rule.

I was hospitalized for years. I feel like a failure in ways because I am no longer at the bare minimum for weight. I struggle a lot still with "missing" anorexia.

I am so sorry this happened to you. No means no. You don't have to explain yourself.

blueshoes · 02/06/2023 14:37

ferneytorro · 02/06/2023 14:33

I wonder if the nurse thought this was because the OP would obsess that she was overweight and she was telling her as if to say "oh don't worry you are really slim" . Horrifically unprofessional and ignorant but in line with the odd thing that most people have that it's fair game to comment on someone's weight if they are perceived as "slim".

I am a similar height and build to the OP and was weighed years ago at a medical appointment and got told I was too thin. I looked in amazement at the nurse as it was just bollocks, of course i wasn't. I have no idea what she was basing it on, other than in comparison to her which surely she can't have meant?

I have no idea what she was basing it on, other than in comparison to her which surely she can't have meant?

I think you hit the nail there. Some people need to learn how to keep their mouth shut and it is not about themselves.

ferneytorro · 02/06/2023 14:33

SweetBirdsong · 02/06/2023 13:08

@Kamia

She seems quite ignorant. However, she also may not have been aware of your eating disorder. When I'm overtired and overworked the penny doesn't click for me. I would need someone to be very specific.

But the OP TOLD this nurse very specifically not to tell her her weight, as she has issues with her weight and it may set off anxiety/worrying etc. The nurse still went and told her, and even said 'I know you told me not to tell you but there you are, you're 9 stone 2.' (haha tinkly laugh.) So the fact the nurse said this means she DID hear the OP say 'please don't tell me my weight!'

It seems to me like she did it out of spite - but I'm not sure why. Whilst lots of nurses are lovely, kind, sweet-natured people, some of them are NOT. Just because someone is a nurse, it doesn't follow that they are lovely, sweet-natured human beings.

I wonder if the nurse thought this was because the OP would obsess that she was overweight and she was telling her as if to say "oh don't worry you are really slim" . Horrifically unprofessional and ignorant but in line with the odd thing that most people have that it's fair game to comment on someone's weight if they are perceived as "slim".

I am a similar height and build to the OP and was weighed years ago at a medical appointment and got told I was too thin. I looked in amazement at the nurse as it was just bollocks, of course i wasn't. I have no idea what she was basing it on, other than in comparison to her which surely she can't have meant?

blueshoes · 02/06/2023 14:33

Redbone · 02/06/2023 14:21

@phoenixrosehere Yes, I think that I agree with you. That would have been the best way to handle it. So much venom here for the nurse when what really is the issue is the OP’s eating disorder.

That is not what phoenix said. Do re-read her posts.

This is absolutely not about OP's eating disorder. It is about the nurse's disregard of the OP's clearly stated request.

GeneHuntsCowboyBoots · 02/06/2023 14:27

MidnightMeltdown · 02/06/2023 14:09

She didn’t need to have a specialist knowledge, experience or training in anything. The OP asked her not to tell her her weight (and elaborated slightly about why, but even if she hadn’t it wouldn’t matter) and the nurse went against that basic request.

@GeneHuntsCowboyBoots

Yeah that's true, but presumably, for most people, the point of going for a health check is that you are provided with information about your health. If you are not going to give the patient information about their weight, then would there be any point in taking the weight reading at all? Surely the purpose of a general health check is that you give the patient information that they can act upon.

I expect that the nurse didn't understand about eating disorders and simply thought that OP was being coy.

Weight taking isn’t necessary in nearly all cases. Only in for medication doses or as a PP has said, as a contraindication to certain contraceptions is it necessary to weigh a patient. None of these scenarios were relevant for OP’s appointment. The only other potential would be if there was a real life threatening risk (and again, that is highly unlikely in most circumstances based on weight alone and definitely not relevant to OP). IF the weight was relevant to medical history, like another poster mentioned they had theirs done every 12 weeks, then it could be noted on the system for reference and still didn’t need to be mentioned to OP.

Whichever way you try to dress it up, the nurse disregarded OP’s clear instruction not to tell her. That really isn’t ok.

Redbone · 02/06/2023 14:21

@phoenixrosehere Yes, I think that I agree with you. That would have been the best way to handle it. So much venom here for the nurse when what really is the issue is the OP’s eating disorder.

Sandylanes69 · 02/06/2023 14:18

VDisappointing · 02/06/2023 09:54

sorry but WTF - a person can't ask to be treated a certain way in their medical appt? Yes she knows she has ED - she clearly struggles with it but its not through choice.
The nurse has behaved inappropriately and I would complain as she needs reeducating on how to deal with people with ED.

See my other responses to OP - I agree the nurse needs some honest feedback to enable her to do better next time.

MidnightMeltdown · 02/06/2023 14:09

She didn’t need to have a specialist knowledge, experience or training in anything. The OP asked her not to tell her her weight (and elaborated slightly about why, but even if she hadn’t it wouldn’t matter) and the nurse went against that basic request.

@GeneHuntsCowboyBoots

Yeah that's true, but presumably, for most people, the point of going for a health check is that you are provided with information about your health. If you are not going to give the patient information about their weight, then would there be any point in taking the weight reading at all? Surely the purpose of a general health check is that you give the patient information that they can act upon.

I expect that the nurse didn't understand about eating disorders and simply thought that OP was being coy.

phoenixrosehere · 02/06/2023 14:05

Redbone · 02/06/2023 13:50

I think that YABVU . The problem here is not the nurse, who I presume was not aware of your eating disorder, but your eating disorder. In my opinion, although I’m not not a HCP you should be aware of your dangerously low BMI.

If it was dangerously low, the nurse could have said “ Apologies, I know that you asked me not to tell your weight but there is concern about your BMI. Are you sure you do not want to know?

Easy as that.

Claricethecat45 · 02/06/2023 13:58

YANU .....Not unreasonable to make a simple request; The nurse could have recorded your weight for clinic notes and no need to tell you what it was; just simple respect aside from anything else. This happens to me as a clinic nurse, and we write on the notes ' Patient does not want to know her weight' when specifically asked not to inform, by the Patient themselves, from the outset. Definitely flag this to the GP or practice manager.

autienotnaughtym · 02/06/2023 13:56

If she had accidentally told you then I would feel more tolerant. You may not have been clear/everyone makes mistakes etc. but she deliberately told you knowing you didn't want to know. I would complain to prevent this from happening again

Redbone · 02/06/2023 13:50

I think that YABVU . The problem here is not the nurse, who I presume was not aware of your eating disorder, but your eating disorder. In my opinion, although I’m not not a HCP you should be aware of your dangerously low BMI.

GeneHuntsCowboyBoots · 02/06/2023 13:42

MidnightMeltdown · 02/06/2023 12:32

I think that respecting your request would have been the right thing to do, but at the same time, I'm not sure that you can necessarily expect that a standard nhs nurse will have knowledge, experience and training in specialist mental health conditions.

You would hope that most people would use their common sense and have some basic understanding of these things, but clearly not everyone does. You can argue that she should have known better, but this isn't a mental health nurse or an eating disorder specialist.

In future, I would be very explicit in explaining that you have an ED. Most people should be able to put 2 and 2 and together, but you'll still get the odd one who doesn't get it.

I think that respecting your request would have been the right thing to do, but at the same time, I'm not sure that you can necessarily expect that a standard nhs nurse will have knowledge, experience and training in specialist mental health conditions.

She didn’t need to have a specialist knowledge, experience or training in anything. The OP asked her not to tell her her weight (and elaborated slightly about why, but even if she hadn’t it wouldn’t matter) and the nurse went against that basic request.

SweetBirdsong · 02/06/2023 13:08

@Kamia

She seems quite ignorant. However, she also may not have been aware of your eating disorder. When I'm overtired and overworked the penny doesn't click for me. I would need someone to be very specific.

But the OP TOLD this nurse very specifically not to tell her her weight, as she has issues with her weight and it may set off anxiety/worrying etc. The nurse still went and told her, and even said 'I know you told me not to tell you but there you are, you're 9 stone 2.' (haha tinkly laugh.) So the fact the nurse said this means she DID hear the OP say 'please don't tell me my weight!'

It seems to me like she did it out of spite - but I'm not sure why. Whilst lots of nurses are lovely, kind, sweet-natured people, some of them are NOT. Just because someone is a nurse, it doesn't follow that they are lovely, sweet-natured human beings.

Swipe left for the next trending thread