Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

London buses - are we worse off?

82 replies

bushopper · 01/06/2023 23:30

NC for this as transport related issues seem to get everyone agitated these days.

Do you think we are worse off with all the redesign and rationalisation of the bus network in London?

For instance, one used to be able to use the 11 bus to get from Fulham Broadway to Liverpool Street on a single £1.75 ticket. No need to change.

Now, to cover the same route, you would most likely need to take 3 buses, and even if you tried to access the 'one-hour' hopper fare, it's unlikely you could as the traffic makes it virtually impossible to cover the whole route in one hour.

Also those with walking difficulties or unwell usually suffer as connecting bus stops can sometimes be 100 metres or more away

In winter, bad weather or when carrying shopping or luggage it can be a nightmare too.

What has been the point of it all?

OP posts:
Thisisabsolutelyfine · 02/06/2023 09:32

bushopper · 02/06/2023 08:42

I very rarely get on a bus that is empty. Most seem to be quite full during most ot the day

If certain parts of a route are underused then they’ll look at reshuffling it. As PP have said, this is because TfL budgets have been cut, but would be much worse if privatised (see pretty much anywhere outside of London for examples)

DorritLittle · 02/06/2023 09:29

Pottedpalm · 02/06/2023 08:25

I doubt this is do, but if it is, why not rally support and become ‘vocal’ workers/non pensioners.

It definitely is so. Vocal pensioners are usually happy to go out during the daytime when buses are cheaper to run. There is no amount of being a vocal non pensioner that will get more funding for peak routes in rural areas without more government subsidy.

BreathesOutSlowly · 02/06/2023 09:28

TheNestedIf · 02/06/2023 01:36

I know what you mean, bushopper. They've just changed a route that runs near where I live. Originally, it went to Oxford Street, then the route was truncated to Trafalgar Square, and then only as far as Whitehall. Now that bus has been rerouted to Victoria, which another bus service that is local to me already goes to, along with the train and the nearest tube. There have been other changes to local routes over the years, but that has been the most useless from a passenger point of view. The number of endpoints are shrinking. Now you have to make a number of changes to get where you want, so the journey time and sometimes the cost goes up.

The 3 was a wonderful route in its heyday.

Elior · 02/06/2023 09:11

I once took the 11 from Kings Road and it took an hour to get as far as Knightsbridge. This was about a year ago when the roadworks were taking place but it was the most exasperating bus journey of my life. Prior to that, I did the whole route to Liverpool Street and when it ran smoothly, It was amazing.

I'd have liked to see less passengers and higher fares. In particular, bus passes only given to teenagers in exceptional circumstances because a lot of secondary school pupils live close by and use the bus to go to the fried chicken shop and go back and forth to encounter other teenagers - not to get home from school. I think means testing for families with older children would make a lot more sense then giving them all free travel.

CatsOnTheChair · 02/06/2023 09:02

Pottedpalm · 02/06/2023 08:25

I doubt this is do, but if it is, why not rally support and become ‘vocal’ workers/non pensioners.

If you doubt the first bus of the day is at 9.30, you don't have a Scooby-Doo about public transport outside the major cities!

FWIW, DH's work decided they were going to ban all private cars from the site. Except they had to concede and hand out a load of parking passes when a number of people in one direction pointed out they would have to set out for work on Tuesday before they got home from work on Monday.....

bushopper · 02/06/2023 08:42

Thisisabsolutelyfine · 02/06/2023 07:53

its a nightmare in other parts of the country, we are SO lucky with the bus service we have. Services get cut due to cost effectiveness and efficiency don’t they, so that long route you describe was not be sufficiently well used to justify one bus route. Just look at the state of our train system and tell me that privatisation of public transport helps passengers.

I very rarely get on a bus that is empty. Most seem to be quite full during most ot the day

OP posts:
Seeline · 02/06/2023 08:42

Lockheart · 02/06/2023 08:15

Just get the tube. Problem solved.

There a vast swathes of South London that are no where near a tube station.
The buses don't link up properly - both my local routes (one of which isn't particularly close) go to the local town but neither go to the main train station. One stops on the very edge and doesn't even go to the bus station to link to other buses.
Most public transport funnels in to the centre of London. If you want to make your way around the edges it's pretty much impossible.
And yes, from August it will be £12.50 a day to use your car if it isn't compliant.

bushopper · 02/06/2023 08:40

DorritLittle · 02/06/2023 08:04

I think what gets to me is that there's so much emphasis in getting everyone to use public transport while it's being reduced and made more and more inconvenient

It doesn’t make sense at all and is a Tory funding issue.

I'm not sure whether you can blame the central government or the Labour mayor. It seems to be a compex issue.

For example, Business Rates, ULEZ and CC impact one another. If fewer people can access London businesses will suffer.

In any case, the bail out they are referring to seems to be due to the pandemic, and the routes started to be cut a couple of years before then.

https://tfl.gov.uk/corporate/about-tfl/how-we-work/how-we-are-funded

OP posts:
SocksAndTheCity · 02/06/2023 08:31

Lockheart · 02/06/2023 08:15

Just get the tube. Problem solved.

For the people who can and want to get the tube, yes. What about the rest?

I live near several underground stations and I'll use it if I have to although I prefer the bus. I don't have to go too far East (or South) before they dwindle to much farther and fewer between, and the buses are most people's main transport then.

bushopper · 02/06/2023 08:28

SocksAndTheCity · 02/06/2023 00:57

I used to get the 11 bus home if I'd been working in Victoria/Pimlico. I could do a decent shop in the big Sainsbury's and be back to the City in forty minutes or so - I haven't caught it since it rerouted to Waterloo.

The 73 used to be handy for getting to Victoria from Kings Cross before they cut it short, and the 521 to London Bridge got dumped altogether. I realise we're still very well served, but I don't particularly like getting the tube and I wish they'd leave the routes alone even if the buses had to be slightly less often.

Yes, what they've done to some routes like 521 or 8 is shocking. Depending where you are travelling from, you probably need to take 2 or 3 buses to get to Oxford Street and I'm not sure whether you still can (I believe you would need to get off and walk for at least 15 minutes to get there)

OP posts:
Pottedpalm · 02/06/2023 08:25

gogohmm · 02/06/2023 08:00

First bus from where I live to where I work goes at 9.30am, needless to say i drive. Here buses are only run for the benefit of vocal pensioners, useless for working people

I doubt this is do, but if it is, why not rally support and become ‘vocal’ workers/non pensioners.

CaroleSinger · 02/06/2023 08:20

You'd have an apoplexy at Essex bus prices. A fiver for one short one way journey on some routes. We really have got it good in London.

Sissynova · 02/06/2023 08:19

MindPalace · 02/06/2023 07:42

But surely people still need to get to work there?

We are lucky in London. Where I live, I have three tube stops within reasonable walking distance, and buses every 2-4 minutes (on the sign that shows the next ten buses, the tenth is never more than about 28 mins’ wait). Very fortunate.

I think they could cut half of our buses and give the money to the rest of the country.

They quite obviously couldn’t cut half the bus service. Busses particularly at rush hour are totally max packed. There are almost 9 millions of people living in london, you just can’t compare it to a town or city 5% of the size.

SpringNotSprung · 02/06/2023 08:17

@Larner, I was in London from 1980 and don't particularly remember much improvement in services under Red Ken except that the fares got much cheaper. Wasn't there then a huge furore because the rates levy was also applied to all the outer London Boroughs, Like Bromley, which didn't have the tube or London buses?

I used occasionally to take a 22, 11, 14 or 30. They went along the Old Brompton, Kings and Fulham Roads. I can't remember which now. They were handy for going into town at weekends.

For work I used the tube. DH couldn't stand it and bought himself a GWizz and a parking space. He used to leave at 6.30am and rationalised 20 minutes was better than 40 minutes.

The issue in London is that short distances can take such a long time.

When I first came to London, despite the frequency the lack of timings was frustrating. In the country, the bus came (unfailingly at a quarter to the hour from 7am until 10pm), the up train was 36 and 06, and the down train 10 past and 20 to. In 8 years of catching the train to school, (8-16) I can only remember it not running about twice - usually whatever the weather.

40 odd years ago, you could cross London, probably the country, and no-one would be able to track you. You'd pay in cash, there was little to no CCTV, you might pay for a big item with a cheque which would take days to process. No GPS signals. Looking back they were halcyon days.

Lockheart · 02/06/2023 08:15

Just get the tube. Problem solved.

DorritLittle · 02/06/2023 08:04

I think what gets to me is that there's so much emphasis in getting everyone to use public transport while it's being reduced and made more and more inconvenient

It doesn’t make sense at all and is a Tory funding issue.

gogohmm · 02/06/2023 08:00

First bus from where I live to where I work goes at 9.30am, needless to say i drive. Here buses are only run for the benefit of vocal pensioners, useless for working people

Thisisabsolutelyfine · 02/06/2023 07:53

its a nightmare in other parts of the country, we are SO lucky with the bus service we have. Services get cut due to cost effectiveness and efficiency don’t they, so that long route you describe was not be sufficiently well used to justify one bus route. Just look at the state of our train system and tell me that privatisation of public transport helps passengers.

MindPalace · 02/06/2023 07:43

Sorry meant to reply to @octoberafternoons

MindPalace · 02/06/2023 07:42

But surely people still need to get to work there?

We are lucky in London. Where I live, I have three tube stops within reasonable walking distance, and buses every 2-4 minutes (on the sign that shows the next ten buses, the tenth is never more than about 28 mins’ wait). Very fortunate.

I think they could cut half of our buses and give the money to the rest of the country.

Sissynova · 02/06/2023 07:42

I think you’re probably just in a minority OP. I would never get a bus for 2 hours if there was another choice and likely lots of other people feel the same.

Sissynova · 02/06/2023 07:41

ZenNudist · 02/06/2023 00:02

Chippy Northerner here. London buses are cheap and the public transport is good, unlike everywhere else where its both expensive and shit. Be glad for what you've got.

Campaign for what you want in your own area.

People in London are allowed to discuss transport in London without basically being told to shut up.

A massive capital city, with the population ten time over some of their other cities in the uk, has a large transport infrastructure? What a shock.

BarbaraofSeville · 02/06/2023 07:40

I think there's a rule that a 'local' bus route can't be over a certain distance/time.

Some years ago the bus route that circled the outskirts of our city was cut due to this. It was split into two halves and renumbered, I think. Can't remember the exact details as I don't use buses that often due to aforementioned unreliability, infrequency and expense outside the capital.

octoberafternoons · 02/06/2023 07:35

Imisspacers · 02/06/2023 00:32

Public transport in London is fantastic. I live in the northwest in a sizeable town but with poor facilities. To next town is eight miles away and is where the closest hospital is. If you want to get there by public transport you have to use the bus which runs every two hours and costs £3.50 for a return.

I'm in London and my workplace is 8 miles away and takes about an hour on public transport. That's an average commute here. With the huge numbers of people here, reliable public transport links are essential. It isn't really comparable to life in smaller towns and cities.

LlynTegid · 02/06/2023 07:22

Bus services in London are much better even after the changes than anywhere in the country. Especially the level of evening and weekend services. I'd say either Edinburgh, Oxford or Brighton of places I have experienced might come in second place.

The government probably has forced service cuts on the London Mayor and TfL, which I doubt would have happened if a Conservative Mayor was in place.