Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you think there is a stigma to being autistic?

40 replies

Tryingtofitinwiththecrowds · 01/06/2023 23:13

My autistic DD 15 has recently had some trouble with bullies at school 😭 and it has got me thinking (worrying) more about the future for her.

Those of you with experience either lived or observed do you think their is a stigma to being autistic? Does it effect how you are treated at work, access to healthcare, how you treated for example by drs, midwives this sort of thing. Or now people are more aware of autism than previously does it actually mean better understanding and support?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Olderandolder · 11/06/2023 15:32

At my work there is a new policy of sponsoring autism diagnoses.

Secrecy available but I chose to disclose because it helps people understand the cause of the traits they already noticed.

The three colleagues who commented all said “Brave”. Made me think of Yes Minister. Not being neurotypical I hadn’t realised it’s a brave decision! I suspect it isn’t though. Someone neurotypical on here will have to tell me what they meant by “brave”.

Apparently coming out is thought of as a positive to write on my appraisal. Again, dunno why. Incompatible with “brave” as far as I can see.

Coming out to family can help them. My son was worried about his interviews and cheered to hear that feedback from my first interview was “you are terrible at interviews but you have got the job”.

caringcarer · 06/06/2023 13:41

@carbonarya and it's not my cricket team it's a county disability cricket team.

caringcarer · 06/06/2023 13:39

@carbonarya he seems very happy. His Mum says he doesn't talk hardly at home or school either. He is virtually mute.

carbonarya · 06/06/2023 13:02

Florissante · 06/06/2023 11:08

So it's fine to be autistic, as long as you're quiet and well behaved and act "normal".

Precisely. Don't exhibit any behaviours that fall outside the realm of 'acceptable'. In other words - mask, mask, mask - no matter what the cost to you emotionally or cognitively, to avoid making the the NTs uncomfortable.

Yeah, I wonder what life is actually like for the quiet well behaved boy on @caringcarers cricket team.

Florissante · 06/06/2023 11:08

So it's fine to be autistic, as long as you're quiet and well behaved and act "normal".

Precisely. Don't exhibit any behaviours that fall outside the realm of 'acceptable'. In other words - mask, mask, mask - no matter what the cost to you emotionally or cognitively, to avoid making the the NTs uncomfortable.

caringcarer · 03/06/2023 23:02

@lysozyme, I'm just stating I think people aren't put off by a person having autism per say but some of the associated behaviours. There are obviously a wide range of behaviours associated with autism and I think some people find some behaviours more off-putting than others. I find spitting and biting very off putting but can tolerate many other autistic characteristics, a person making lots of noises or not really saying anything, rigid behaviours and struggling with communication. I've taught in a special school and have had to deal with lots of behaviours from various different children some autistic and some not but many have other challenging conditions. I just personally find spitting and biting particularly unpleasant.

lysozyme · 03/06/2023 15:58

caringcarer · 02/06/2023 01:06

I agree with @forgetmenot as well. Some people will be put off by some behaviours. I took my DGS who is 5 to a soft play area over Easter and there was a child having a melt down as we arrived. He looked about 8. He was screaming and throwing all the things around. When the mother tried to calm him down he started spitting at her and swearing. She said to the lady near her that her son was autistic. All of the other children seemed a bit shocked and scared and later I noticed this child went over to some children and they all ran away from him. That seemed to make him angry and he was shouting nasty things to them, swearing again. The other children all gave him a wide birth. I think it can be the behaviour that puts some off. Some people will be more affected than others. I wouldn't tell dgs to keep away from a child because they had autism but I did say keep away because he was swearing and spitting at others and I didn't want dgs getting hurt as he was younger and smaller. It's the behaviour not the tag. I know an autistic boy in my foster son's cricket team. His behaviour is fine, he just hardly speaks. He doesn't upset anyone and gets treated the same as the others.

So it's fine to be autistic, as long as you're quiet and well behaved and act "normal".

Tryingtofitinwiththecrowds · 02/06/2023 08:17

Thanks for all the replies and 💐 for those who have had difficult experiences. But good to hear some positives too where sharing diagnosis has brought more understanding.

I think now she is getting older I'm worrying more about how she would manage services going forward. Like going to the gp or if she does have a child at some point will she get treated well listened to properly with things like maternity care. I'm not sure if she will be able to advocate for herself or be listened to if she does. There's also boyfriends etc on the horizon - I don't want to limit her but she does seem very vulnerable compared to her peers.

I guess as always we need to take one step at a time and try not to worry too much about the future.

OP posts:
Fairislefandango · 02/06/2023 08:14

Yes, especially amongst kids, but also lots of adults. They have spent their lives so far becoming very skilled at navigating human interactions and learning exactly how to fit in, act normal, not say the wrong thing etc, and they often find it threatening or very uncomfortable when another child (or adult) doesn't play by those rules. Kids will sometimes be openly hostile. Most adults have better awareness of autism these days and are less likely to treat autistic people differently. The increased awareness does mean that a lot of NT people have probably become very good at spotting autistic people.

50450750q · 02/06/2023 08:03

caringcarer · 02/06/2023 01:06

I agree with @forgetmenot as well. Some people will be put off by some behaviours. I took my DGS who is 5 to a soft play area over Easter and there was a child having a melt down as we arrived. He looked about 8. He was screaming and throwing all the things around. When the mother tried to calm him down he started spitting at her and swearing. She said to the lady near her that her son was autistic. All of the other children seemed a bit shocked and scared and later I noticed this child went over to some children and they all ran away from him. That seemed to make him angry and he was shouting nasty things to them, swearing again. The other children all gave him a wide birth. I think it can be the behaviour that puts some off. Some people will be more affected than others. I wouldn't tell dgs to keep away from a child because they had autism but I did say keep away because he was swearing and spitting at others and I didn't want dgs getting hurt as he was younger and smaller. It's the behaviour not the tag. I know an autistic boy in my foster son's cricket team. His behaviour is fine, he just hardly speaks. He doesn't upset anyone and gets treated the same as the others.

"Tag"? You mean diagnosis?

Florissante · 02/06/2023 07:28

Absolutely.

All you need to do is to read MN and one of the first comments about a person's odd or 'unacceptable' behaviour behaviour is always "sounds like autism".

BananaSpl1t · 02/06/2023 06:48

Definitely a stigma amongst teens. “ That’s so autistic” as an insult. My Dd still don’t accept her diagnosis because of the damage from school.

Mydcchangedmyusername · 02/06/2023 06:40

The thing is people do reject you based on autistic traits until they find out you have those traits because you're autistic. Then they're more understanding and accepting (not all but in general). It's why I don't hesitate to tell people that I'm autistic because it immediately removes that "what is wrong with this person" judgement and they accept you for who you are.

That said, I still think it has stigma especially when I see parents whose children have been diagnosed become so miserable and depressed over their children's diagnosis. Can make you, who's fine with being autistic and having autistic family and dc, feel like shit.

CurtainsForBea · 02/06/2023 06:34

I think there is. (ASD son here).

But what i dislike more than anything is how autism is used as an insult. get any person behaving like an arsehole and someone is sure to say 'He's probably autistic'. With a sneer. Not just on MN (but it's like MN bingo on threads here). But IRL as well.

I call it out now all the time. Like to my SIL who knows her nephew has autism and who was ranting about a shithead arrogant deceitful boss and said 'He's probably autistic' to me. I pointed out that he might just be an arsehole and oddly enough not all people with autism behave the way she was stereotyping.

BananaSpl1t · 02/06/2023 06:20

Yes there is, a big one. I have a diagnosis, as do my children. My Dd made her first suicide attempt because of the stigma. Both children have been bullied at school( seriously with catastrophic impact on mental health and another suicide attempt)as was I. Vulnerabilities have been abused. I’ve been patronised and not taken seriously throughout dealing with services. There has been no reasonable adjustment anywhere for any of us. None.

hattie43 · 02/06/2023 05:57

Yes , we have a colleague who has autism and he is not suited to the job he does . He is expected to go and visit clients on a daily basis and is given a list of who he needs to go to . It is absolutely in the lap of the gods as to whether he will turn up or not . He doesn't or can't follow set Rota's , takes forever to load his van , probably double the time of others and then he'll get to site and not have brought the right equipment. However he is the loveliest guy , he's never in trouble because we understand his needs and he gets away with things others don't . Would we employ him again , probably not in the job he does but there'd definitely be something he could do .

SparklyBlackKitten · 02/06/2023 05:56

Behaviour of the kids is what turns people away from them . Not their diagnoses.

I have dealt with quite a few "my son is autistic so he cant help it" mums over time.

They use autism as an excuse instead of an explanation.

Well im sorry not but i dont want my kid playing with your kid anymore because your kid bites and all you say is "he cant help it "

I am adhd and grew up being bullied for it
But not for having the label. Just because I was an oddball and all over the place.

But that being said
.. I also got bullied for having brown skin.

And other kids are bullied for being ginger
or not having cool NIKE'S or being poor

Kids bullying for ALL sorts of reasons
And no one is safe from them 🙁

But I DO feel like the stigma of autism is reduced for adults over the years. There has been more awareness. People understand them a bit better. I think ...

OneFrenchEgg · 02/06/2023 05:27

I agree with all the other posters. I find the current 'yay! I'm autistic! I'm so proud! It's a super power!' narrative amongst the younger generation so weird, my experience has been one of exclusion and struggle.
I wonder if the difference is in the work place and healthcare etc - awareness of the diagnosis and (even superficially) attempts at understanding.
But you can't make people like you, no matter how many campaigns and social media posts you sign up to.

Willyoujustbequiet · 02/06/2023 02:47

No. In the past yes but not now. In fact if anything its seen as a positive.

TomPinch · 02/06/2023 01:49

Lougle · 01/06/2023 23:27

Interestingly (for me) DD2 who has ASD was never bullied in secondary. My theory was that she was so aloof that there was just nothing for the mean kids to get a grip of. She literally didn't register people she wasn't interested in. DD3 (on the waitlist for ASD assessment) gets bullied quite a lot because she's aware she doesn't fit in but desperately wants to.

Your DD2 reminds me of my ASD DD. But I think my DD would love friends, but she knows it's a minefield. I worry about how she'll get on as an adult.

DW is also ASD, and tried much harder, and has had really shitty treatment again and again. She adores me because I'm safe.

caringcarer · 02/06/2023 01:06

I agree with @forgetmenot as well. Some people will be put off by some behaviours. I took my DGS who is 5 to a soft play area over Easter and there was a child having a melt down as we arrived. He looked about 8. He was screaming and throwing all the things around. When the mother tried to calm him down he started spitting at her and swearing. She said to the lady near her that her son was autistic. All of the other children seemed a bit shocked and scared and later I noticed this child went over to some children and they all ran away from him. That seemed to make him angry and he was shouting nasty things to them, swearing again. The other children all gave him a wide birth. I think it can be the behaviour that puts some off. Some people will be more affected than others. I wouldn't tell dgs to keep away from a child because they had autism but I did say keep away because he was swearing and spitting at others and I didn't want dgs getting hurt as he was younger and smaller. It's the behaviour not the tag. I know an autistic boy in my foster son's cricket team. His behaviour is fine, he just hardly speaks. He doesn't upset anyone and gets treated the same as the others.

Poyia · 02/06/2023 00:07

In my experience unfortunately yes, as others have said its the outward symptoms, I've had awful healthcare because of my autism, with actual issues being dismissed because of it and a real awful time getting employment.

MintJulia · 02/06/2023 00:04

Forgetmenott · 01/06/2023 23:22

I’m autistic. In my experience people don’t discriminate against you specifically because you have autism (they may not even know you have it). They discriminate against you because of the symptoms of autism - lack of eye contact and facial expression, speech differences, not wanting to shake hands or touch, defensive body language, awkward conversation and talking about topics they find odd or boring, etc. People don’t like that stuff. They will refuse to hire you or be friends with you because of it, even if they don’t know that the root cause is autism.

This.

But there are positives too. We have autism in the females in our family. They/ we are all known for being blunt, straight-talking, but also clear thinking and analytical. Not falling for marketing 'fluff', not wasting money on expensive fads, not putting up with manipulation from the men in their lives. Singlemindedness has allowed them to get further in their careers.

MumsPett · 02/06/2023 00:01

Yes of course . I've explained to people that dd is autistic and the reactions I've had have been vile to the point I now no longer tell people and and say she has LD instead (my mum's suggestion) to avoid negative comments. Even the gp I took dd about a physical problem and when I explained she was autistic the Dr decided it was just attention seeking. Doesn't help when any time a child is badly behaved people say they are probably autistic 🙄

Lemme · 01/06/2023 23:57

DD! Don’t want to get embroiled in the whole trans argument. She’s very clear she’s female :-)