Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

School reunion, everyone’s life is just the same

156 replies

Schooldinners1 · 01/06/2023 19:01

Was wondering how others found seeing their old classmates and going back to your old town.

The majority of people have stayed living in the same area, not far from their parents and haven’t really ventured anywhere outside of it.

I am wondering how it’ll go. I’m one of the few people who went to uni in a totally new city hundreds of miles away and never moved back!

It will be interesting. It’s going to be at the community hall I had my primary school discos in 😄

OP posts:
IAAL · 03/06/2023 20:27

@Schooldinners1 I had a friend at university who was the first member of her family to go to university. She went to a rubbish school in a dismal nowhere place. Her family were mystified by her going to university - the expectation was that she would stay at home, get a local job, and help out with her younger siblings. She just happened to be clever and motivated and saw a way out. She is now a consultant radiologist and lives in (surprise surprise) London.

IAAL · 03/06/2023 20:22

@Stripedbag101 Don't be silly. I'm not sneering at anyone. I would feel hemmed in and miserable if I had to live in my home town (which was the absolute reverse of remote or miserable - it's a very prosperous and desirable place, so much so that most of the people who live there now are not 'natives', but choose to live there because it's so desirable. While everyone who grew up there now lives in London...)

But if you like your home town and it offers you plenty of interest and newness and so on, then that's great. It just wouldn't be for me, or for any of the girls (now 50 yr old women) I went to school with.

Schooldinners1 · 03/06/2023 20:07

Stripedbag101 · 03/06/2023 19:54

@Schooldinners1 that has been my point. So many people here have made sweeping statements stereotyping people who live in their home towns, without seeming to understand that not every home town and not every person is the same.

therefore while these boasting about how broad minded and cosmopolitan they are they are actually demonstrating a lack of worldliness and imagination.

living in your hometown absolutely does not automatically mean a low skilled job and a holiday in Benidorm. It’s ‘parochial’ o assume that (if @IAAL allows mentions I use that word outside a context of sneering at people living in their home town😂)

I guess what I can say to this is because my upbringing was so drastically different I had no understanding or concept of someone growing up in a safe and positive environment.

I just never saw it. I never met anyone with professional parents or people who even worked in an office until I left and went to University and I was totally shocked by how much everyone else had and that’s only when I realised how little we had.

OP posts:
Stripedbag101 · 03/06/2023 19:54

@Schooldinners1 that has been my point. So many people here have made sweeping statements stereotyping people who live in their home towns, without seeming to understand that not every home town and not every person is the same.

therefore while these boasting about how broad minded and cosmopolitan they are they are actually demonstrating a lack of worldliness and imagination.

living in your hometown absolutely does not automatically mean a low skilled job and a holiday in Benidorm. It’s ‘parochial’ o assume that (if @IAAL allows mentions I use that word outside a context of sneering at people living in their home town😂)

Schooldinners1 · 03/06/2023 19:47

Stripedbag101 · 03/06/2023 19:30

And living in your hometown doesn’t mean a low skilled job!!! My fiends who live in our hometown include a barrister, a surgeon, a pharmacist and a few teachers. One is a tattoo artist - to her mother’s horror!!!!

I think this is the point I guess. All of you were from decent places I wasn’t.

50% of them were probably inbred.

OP posts:
Schooldinners1 · 03/06/2023 19:43

IAAL · 03/06/2023 19:27

@Schooldinners1 I went to an academically selective independent girls' school, and the expectation was that we would all go to Oxbridge (or a redbrick if desperate) and become lawyers/doctors/dentists/engineers etc. If you have those kinds of jobs, you mostly have to go to where the work takes you - you can't turn down a fantastic job because it's 200 miles from "home". So I'm coming at it from a very different angle, but the end result is the same!

Well yes exactly. It’s all about aspirations really. If you’ve been raised not to expect much of yourself or others I suppose you wouldn’t even bother.

Some folks have only worked in their local supermarket and holidayed in Benidorm for example. I suppose if that’s all you know and normal for everyone around you… it takes a strong person to break away from the cycle of poverty!

In many areas it’s like generational deprivation. However once you know/see what’s possible and people expect more from you, your life can totally change.

OP posts:
Stripedbag101 · 03/06/2023 19:30

And living in your hometown doesn’t mean a low skilled job!!! My fiends who live in our hometown include a barrister, a surgeon, a pharmacist and a few teachers. One is a tattoo artist - to her mother’s horror!!!!

Stripedbag101 · 03/06/2023 19:28

Parochial means having a limited or narrow outlook.

you can of course meet new and different people if you stay in your home town - you will likely commute to work and meet lots of new people there, you might marry into a new family and meet lots of new people, you will likely travel and met people on holiday.

you can read extensively, research different cultures, enrich your life however you see fit.

my hometown is a medium sized , pretty, expensive seaside town within thirty minutes distance of a largish city - the majority of my friends who still live there work in the city, and often socialise in the city. Airlinks are good and they travel frequently - with work and for pleasure. When i socialise with them they bring new and different friends. They are not parochial - or perhaps you have a different dictionary to me.

perhaps your hometown was remote and miserable. Perhaps new people never move there and no one commutes outside the town limits - I am imagining one of those movies with the bubble dropped over a small remote town😂.

but not everyone’s experience is yours - some people have amazing cultured happy adventurous lives while still living in their home town.

that’s all I am arguing - not everyone is the same as you

IAAL · 03/06/2023 19:27

@Schooldinners1 I went to an academically selective independent girls' school, and the expectation was that we would all go to Oxbridge (or a redbrick if desperate) and become lawyers/doctors/dentists/engineers etc. If you have those kinds of jobs, you mostly have to go to where the work takes you - you can't turn down a fantastic job because it's 200 miles from "home". So I'm coming at it from a very different angle, but the end result is the same!

Schooldinners1 · 03/06/2023 19:23

IAAL · 03/06/2023 19:16

Again - you honestly think that someone’s outlook on life is narrow becomes they choose to live in their hometown? Wow

Yes, I honestly do. And I'm not sure it merits a "wow".

I just can't get my mind round someone not wanting to live in different places, see different things, meet different people. Which doesn't mean there's anything wrong with staying in touch with school friends or whatever, or going 'home' to visit/see family etc. I like going to see my family, but they and I have never felt the need to live in one another's pockets. One of my adult DC is currently living in America and obviously I miss them, but I'm mostly delighted that they're experiencing something different from our (lovely) part of the world, and meeting new friends rather than only their bubble of school/university friends.

I can only assume that you don't know what parochial actually means.

I understand people going off and seeing the world and experiencing new things THEN coming back once they decide to have children - if you’re fortunate enough to come from somewhere nice (I was from a shithole) 😂

However what I suppose I find incredibly boring is living in the same house/two streets away. Getting a low skilled job and basically giving up on attempting to achieve or experience anything new outside of that.

Each to their own but I would rather be old with stories to tell.

We moved to the UK whilst I was primary school age and it’s always been drilled into us that education matters and even if we started off poor our families had high aspirations for us.

OP posts:
IAAL · 03/06/2023 19:16

Again - you honestly think that someone’s outlook on life is narrow becomes they choose to live in their hometown? Wow

Yes, I honestly do. And I'm not sure it merits a "wow".

I just can't get my mind round someone not wanting to live in different places, see different things, meet different people. Which doesn't mean there's anything wrong with staying in touch with school friends or whatever, or going 'home' to visit/see family etc. I like going to see my family, but they and I have never felt the need to live in one another's pockets. One of my adult DC is currently living in America and obviously I miss them, but I'm mostly delighted that they're experiencing something different from our (lovely) part of the world, and meeting new friends rather than only their bubble of school/university friends.

I can only assume that you don't know what parochial actually means.

Ruthdpl · 03/06/2023 17:42

Depends how you feel about your time there. Wild horses wouldn’t tempt me to my Grammar School reunion - there’s another one this summer🙄 It’s always the same former ‘It girls’ showboating. However I do meet up with some ‘girls’ from primary school and we always have a lovely time.

Tiredmama53 · 03/06/2023 08:30

I moved back to live in the same village after uni and a couple of years living away after but I wouldn't say my life is just the same. I'm married, have two kids, have done a degree and masters and have a successful career in an area I always wanted to work in. My husband owns his own business and we're alot better off financially than the way I grew up. I don't think our lives would be significantly different if we'd stayed living the other side of the country except to have less time with family and less help with my kids.

You sound like you're already gearing up to think and act as though your life is better than the rest of your classmates.

MALJA · 03/06/2023 02:03

I doubt everyone’s Lives are just the same as when they were in school just because they live in the same area - if this was the case for me I’d still be getting pissed in the local park!

you don’t have to go, it’s your choice and if you went to school pre social media and don’t keep in touch with your old schoolmates then your absence will likely go unnoticed by most. But who know’s you might enjoy yourself if you go and if not you can very easily leave

Stripedbag101 · 02/06/2023 23:43

IAAL · 02/06/2023 23:08

I avoid school reunions like the proverbial plague, but I can only think of a couple of girls I was at school with who still live in the city where we all grew up. Everyone else is scattered far and wide. We all went to university away from home, and most people have ended up in London (which is a long way from where I grew up). It never crossed my mind to go back 'home' after I went to university, despite having been very happy at home. I had just moved on, along with everyone else.

I'm always surprised by how many people on MN live close to their parents/siblings/cousins/grandparents etc. It does always strike me as a bit parochial.

Again - you honestly think that someone’s outlook on life is narrow becomes they choose to live in their hometown? Wow

to be honest I would argue that whoever makes such sweeping assumptions is actually the parochial one.

and I say this as someone who doesn’t live i their hometown. I left 25 years ago, and no longer have any family living there so rarely go back!!

IAAL · 02/06/2023 23:08

I avoid school reunions like the proverbial plague, but I can only think of a couple of girls I was at school with who still live in the city where we all grew up. Everyone else is scattered far and wide. We all went to university away from home, and most people have ended up in London (which is a long way from where I grew up). It never crossed my mind to go back 'home' after I went to university, despite having been very happy at home. I had just moved on, along with everyone else.

I'm always surprised by how many people on MN live close to their parents/siblings/cousins/grandparents etc. It does always strike me as a bit parochial.

Stripedbag101 · 02/06/2023 23:01

i think OP is getting a hard time because she is looking down on people.

I did grow up in quite an affluent area - but I lived in the poorer part. I chose not to stay there because I felt people looked down in me. The majority of people at school went to university - it was just expected. But is was an all girl grammar school. You were expected to be a doctor / or if you didn’t get very high grades you were pushed into teaching! It was also expected that you would marry well.

I could go back and live in the ‘posh’ area now but I don’t want to.

Its not a lifestyle I want but I don’t judge those who chose to stay.

i am old enough now to understand people are wildly different - in every part of the world:

BillyNoM8s · 02/06/2023 23:01

I don't know why people are uppity about staying in their "home town". Surely if you've moved, you've moved to someone else's home town?

I've lived in other countries and can't actually afford to live in my home town. Perhaps I should've stayed put Confused

Some people I went to school with are definitely a very specific "type" of degenerate, but I don't think they would've improved if they'd moved to Leeds or spent a year in New Zealand.

Hocuspocusnonsense · 02/06/2023 22:59

You might be surprised. Just because they’ve never left the area doesn’t mean you have achieved or experienced more than they have.

Highfivemum · 02/06/2023 22:51

my DH and I went along to our school reunion last year. It was awful , the same clicky girls in the corner, still sniggering like they used to. The boys still trying to be crude and thinking they were funny. My DH and I met at primary and went through schools together. ( didn’t date till 14) of course the ones who took the p**s out of us all those years ago still did like they were 14 again. We both left early and will never go to one again

Frozzie1 · 02/06/2023 22:46

I went back to my home town after 25ish years a few years. The town was much nicer than I remembered, lots more trees and houses seemed smarter. I met up with a large group of old school friends/year group, most of whom were still living in the surrounding area/county. I live overseas now. It was lovely to catch up. Some hadn’t changed at all, others quite spectacularly. I found the bond with my close school friends was the same as ever, others we had grown completely apart. We all had a laugh and remembered the old times.

Go with a completely open mind, life takes us all in different paths whether locally or far.

But overall I’m not a fan of going ‘back’. It can bring out bad as well as good memories. For instance, I find going back to my uni city tough.

Rewis · 02/06/2023 22:38

Moat people wake up, take the kids to school, go to work, make dinner, go to gym, take kids to football etc. Regardless if you live in your small home village or moved away to a bigger city.

HotSince82 · 02/06/2023 22:33

You'd live me OP!

I still live in my childhood home which I inherited from my parents!

Literally been here since I was eighteen months old in 1984.

Shame on me!

MXVIT · 02/06/2023 22:32

I moved abroad at 18 then dotted around the UK until moving back to my home city at 28, never been happier than I am to be back and im never leaving again.

Moving away does not make you special, or mean you're winning. Soz.

Happyhappyeveryday · 02/06/2023 22:29

I moved away, lived abroad, had a child, moved three times, to different towns/cities, then moved back ‘home’ when my parents became elderly. I’ve changed and my life has evolved. No reason why classmates won’t have too.