Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think using children with SN for a school award is distasteful

28 replies

IsThatReallyNecessary · 01/06/2023 12:45

NC as this is based on a Facebook post and on the off chance I'm recognised (my DC doesn't want his ASD and learning delay public knowledge). I don't know if IABU and over sensitive. Have a friend who has super high achieving children, academically, sportingly and musically. Her posts are full of their achievements which is nice to see. Usually like, well done and carry on.

The last achievement left me a bit speechless. It was an award for being kind to, helping and making an effort to include children who are in the special education program. WTF? So they are using children with SN as the basis of a reward for children without SN, who probably find everything to do with school about 10,000 times easier than said children with SN? A little pat on the back, complete with certificate and award ceremony in front of parents for deigning to notice and be decent to another child. They're all human. All credit to her child for being kind, but why specify the special education? Doesn't really say a lot about the school or their expectations of the pupils does it? Is it a US/UK culture difference?

YABU and over sensitive.
YANBU - a group of children should not be used for an award like this

OP posts:
Lovetheplace · 01/06/2023 12:48

They did this when I was at secondary in the 90s, every pupil had to go in groups for a set amount of weeks to assist with swimming at the SEN school and then had a certificate and photo for their record of achievement

I totally refused and was massively told off and told I had no choice and I would be going - I had my form tutor scream in my face about it that I wasn’t allowed the choice that everyone had to do it !

ThisJenistheInternet · 01/06/2023 12:48

I hope the children with SEN can have an award for being nice to the ones without SEN.

Saucery · 01/06/2023 12:47

YANBU. An award for being a kind, inclusive person to everyone in school is fine. Singling out the SEN cohort is not.