Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Baby only wants DP. I'm so upset.

136 replies

alwaysthesame12 · 01/06/2023 08:32

We have an 11 month old baby.
Same sex couple. I gave birth but went back to work after a really short time. My wife has had the shared parental leave.
I work 3 days per week. So I'm with the baby 4 days per week. And in the mornings, evenings and then sometimes for an hour during my working day because I work from home.

Recently the baby hasn't really been wanting me that much. She holds her hands up to my wife so much more for her to pick her ip. She cries when my partner leaves the room sometimes. This morning, I went to get her from her cot and she didn't want me to pick her up. Then as soon as she sees my wife she smiles and her hands are straight in the air.

I feel awful. I already truly regret going back to work. I wish I'd had more time off. And now I'm just so upset that the baby doesn't feel as attached to me as my wife. I know my wife has obviously spent more time with her and the baby probably depends on her more than me. I just feel truly heartbroken.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Smelly28 · 05/06/2023 19:51

It’s like I’ve written this myself except I returned back to full time with my wife having the baby 3 days a week and going to childcare twice a week.

I have found when I get to spend 1-1 time with him and doing things he enjoys solely just the two of us it helps with the bonding, and I have spoken to my wife about it all as well - have you done the same?

You’re doing great just keep going it’ll get better :)

Mrscooper13 · 05/06/2023 10:37

It’s a phase

my husband was my youngest favourite for ages and now I am

she also does this strange thing if we are out with other adults and she’s hurt she only wants them to comfort her.

honestly they blow your mind

Elaina87 · 04/06/2023 11:09

It must be hard, especially as you're the one who gave birth. But it is just a phase I promise, she will likely switch at some point. You do spend lots of time of time with her so don't beat yourself up over that. Some babies and toddlers will switch to favouring the parent they see less off, and also I presume your wife will go back to work soon so it will become more equal. She loves you both Xx

Jah26 · 03/06/2023 10:52

It feels horrible when your kids openly prefer one parent to the other and can make you question your ability as a parent. I’ve experienced both sides of it. Its really hard, but try not to let it affect your relationships with your partner and baby, it will all change again soon, no doubt!

Cactusmad · 03/06/2023 10:28

children do have phases, I see it as priming us for the teenage years. They don’t want anything to do with you then. They also pop out of this . Parenting is such an assault on your emotions, good luck and this is totally normal.

xoomer · 03/06/2023 09:31

I only mentioned that as the OP's post is about her baby wanting her wife more.

I've never said the baby but lots on here seem to.

Carryonkeepinggoing · 03/06/2023 09:14

MrsSunshine2b · 02/06/2023 19:22

I feel like I should defend E Nesbit, a far superior writer to Enid Blyton, who actually wrote 5 Children and It, along with the sequel, The Phoenix and the Carpet, and The Railway Children. The youngest child is known throughout as "The Lamb" and the "It" is a very grumpy prehistoric wish-granting creature called a Sammead they find in a quarry and visit daily. The Sammead would be furious to be referred to as a pet.

Oh Gosh, you’re right, it was E Nesbit. I read the sequel and the railway children too. Probably fairly soon after Enid Blyton’s Faraway Tree series. With 5 Children and It, I do remember wondering at one point what the baby’s actual name was, because it was never used. I’d forgotten about the ´lamb’ nickname. And I distinctly remember finding the bit where the older sister gets sand out of the baby’s eye with her tongue gross and very unhygienic.
In my (poor and apologetic) defense I read the book about 25 years ago and haven’t come across it since.

Madwife123 · 03/06/2023 02:26

Also a lesbian couple and we had this so many times!

When I was off work and breastfeeding DD didn’t want anything to do with my wife which really upset her. When I went back to work however my wife became the favourite and I had typical mum guilt about going back to work.

Over the years it’s yo-yo’d a few times but now that she’s 11 she has amazing bonds with each of us so it didn’t affect anything. She is well aware of which mum she needs and when. If she hurts herself it’s always me she comes to. If she’s been falling out with a friend at school she goes to my wife for advice.

It’s rubbish at the time but switching from one parent to another is a perfectly normal stage of attachment and it has no bearing on how much she loves you.

JFDIYOLO · 03/06/2023 01:10

FYI there are lots more reassuring responses to your post over on the Mumsnet Facebook Page, where it's been copied

Mamanyt · 03/06/2023 00:45

Since you have her most of the time, at least some of it is the fact that you are routine, and DP is the shiny toy we don't see as much. This will pass. AND, LOL, you can play it to your advantage. This is what my mother did when I went through that with my father. What is your baby going to call you, and what will she call your DP? If DP is going to be, for instance, "Mama," then patiently teach her, "MAMA! Say MAMA!" That way, when she wants something, you can (as my own mother did) say, "Oh, listen, Darlin', she wants YOU!" When it was the only word I knew. Hungry? DADA! Wet/dirty? DADA! Bored? DADA! Mom was no fool.

Abouttimemum · 02/06/2023 22:15

It’s just a phase. I spent every waking second with our son for 15 month, yet he preferred my husband whenever he had a choice, who worked full time. Totally fine now at age 4.

What I will say is don’t fall into the trap of your wife doing everything just because your son prefers it, it’s a slippery slope and long term will make it worse.

We did things like alternate bedtime and if DS wasn’t happy that it was me it was tough, he soon realised that was the way it was and he’d have to suck it up!

ladyluck13 · 02/06/2023 19:56

Totally normal...my 18 month old has done this since day 1...I'm flavour of the day until she sees her Aunties, then I'm not interesting to her lol..babies have phases of who's their favourite...and totally normal to feel a bit put out too...

Missingpop · 02/06/2023 19:51

Oh dear it’s nothing to worry about babies go through this stage, it will change soon enough; make the time she’s with you fun; play daft games to make her laugh; the more she sees you as the entertainer the more she will look to you for cheering her up; if she’s on the move play hide & peel with her; make daft noises, honestly the more she’s laughs the less you’ll feel as you do now x

snowydays10 · 02/06/2023 19:22

xoomer · 01/06/2023 08:39

It's strange you say "the baby" a lot. Do you feel attached to her. Do you think it's you and not her? What does your wife think? Has she noticed what you see?

We very affectionately call our DS “the baby” because he was the first grandchild, great grandchild, nephew etc so he will always be the baby.. I guess until another little one comes along.

and OP if it makes you feel any better, DS always wants my husband not me. I’m a SAHM and he WFH mostly but does have to travel a lot so I don’t think it matters who does most the childcare. Sometimes it’s because they feel more secure with you and know you are always there for them

MrsSunshine2b · 02/06/2023 19:22

Carryonkeepinggoing · 01/06/2023 09:35

I’ve never heard anyone say ´the daughter’.
But ´the baby’ is very common. I think I said ´is the baby asleep’ to my husband last night. Our child is four and I still call him ´the baby’ sometimes, mixed with his actual name and all the cute nicknames.
Have you ever read Enid Blighton’s Five children and it? The youngest child of the five is called ´The baby’ by her siblings all the way through. ´It’ is some kind of magical pet monster.
In the Large Family series of children’s books the youngest Elephant is always ´the baby’ too - and it actually changes when a new baby elephant is born. The previous ´baby’ starts being called Luke.
The youngest child in the family being called ´the baby’ can be a term of endearment. Choosing ´the baby’ rather than ´DD’ on mumsnet really does not indicate a lack of bond or a failure to see the child as a person. If you’re going to analyse people’s choice of language over the internet then you have to be familiar with the huge variety in language use and accept that just because it’s not something you hear, doesn’t mean in another place or amongst other people it can’t be used differently.

I feel like I should defend E Nesbit, a far superior writer to Enid Blyton, who actually wrote 5 Children and It, along with the sequel, The Phoenix and the Carpet, and The Railway Children. The youngest child is known throughout as "The Lamb" and the "It" is a very grumpy prehistoric wish-granting creature called a Sammead they find in a quarry and visit daily. The Sammead would be furious to be referred to as a pet.

pollymere · 02/06/2023 19:18

Don't let it ruin your relationship long-term. My Mum was ill after I was born and my Dad did much of the caring. I didn't find this out until my late teens and worse, it was only then that I developed a close bond to my Mum. She was scared of rejection so withdrew and I just felt rejected. But actually, she adored me and I adored her.

Babies are fickle things. Work on your relationship now and suddenly it will be you they reach for just as much x

CM1897 · 02/06/2023 10:11

alwaysthesame12 · 01/06/2023 08:32

We have an 11 month old baby.
Same sex couple. I gave birth but went back to work after a really short time. My wife has had the shared parental leave.
I work 3 days per week. So I'm with the baby 4 days per week. And in the mornings, evenings and then sometimes for an hour during my working day because I work from home.

Recently the baby hasn't really been wanting me that much. She holds her hands up to my wife so much more for her to pick her ip. She cries when my partner leaves the room sometimes. This morning, I went to get her from her cot and she didn't want me to pick her up. Then as soon as she sees my wife she smiles and her hands are straight in the air.

I feel awful. I already truly regret going back to work. I wish I'd had more time off. And now I'm just so upset that the baby doesn't feel as attached to me as my wife. I know my wife has obviously spent more time with her and the baby probably depends on her more than me. I just feel truly heartbroken.

This won’t last. My daughter was all for me when she was a baby, never wanted her dad. Now she loves her dad just as much and wants him just as much. I know it’s not nice, but it’s temporary, I think babies always prefer one parent over the other, so don’t take it to heart

Bex2003 · 02/06/2023 00:03

I don’t normally reply on here, but my mum heart just went out to you 💜 I have two grown up children, and like in your situation childcare was pretty much shared. I gave myself a hard time for not breastfeeding (medical issues) and then for going back to college to complete my course - the list of mum guilt is endless! My kids are grown up now, and I wish I’d had more confidence in myself when they were little. I look back and can see how loved they were, and how cared for. They are lovely teenagers now! And really proud that I managed to get a degree while they were growing up. They didn’t feel abandoned by me still doing the things I loved and being their mum at the same time. You clearly love your daughter very much. They do go through periods of attaching to one parent over another. My daughter at the same age would only go to sleep with her dad. I used to cry sometimes because it upset me that I couldn’t settle her! But I grew to love the bond they had and I still have a special bond with her too. Go easy on yourself - kids change constantly. It’s like there no such thing as a “phase” it’s just always changing as they grown and learn. You got this mama xxx

FoggyDew · 01/06/2023 23:41

SarahAndQuack · 01/06/2023 23:29

Grin Oh dear, we are both falling over ourselves to apologise! I was also worrying I expressed myself so badly.

Your poor wife! Being listed as 'father' could be funny, but I imagine it could also really cut, too. We were very lucky with that side of things - the registrar couldn't have been more lovely.

With my DP it was utter madness. She isn't very butch and I am not very femme, but put us together and people only every see a male/female couple. You can only laugh at it, but actually it was horrible at the time - they didn't remember to give her a meal because they hadn't properly registered who was there; when I went to try to get her a breakfast on the postnatal ward they got cross with me because they thought I was trying to fetch a meal for my male, non-birthing partner. I was a size 10/12 back then; I didn't look vaguely plausible pregnant or postpartum. She wasn't properly checked for blood loss post-birth because we think they just didn't register who she was - someone glanced in and saw a woman-shaped person up and about with a baby, and they just looked past the very white woman lying down in bed bleeding. It's possible to play it for laughs and you have to try to, but honestly, it isn't very funny and DP had a horrible time.

On that note of black humour, I must borrow 'why keep a dog and bark yoursel!' Grin Someone on here, ages ago, suggested 'I keep track of the incomings and she does the outgoings,' which also made me smile.

God that’s awful, your poor wife (and you too!). That shouldn’t be possible but sadly I can absolutely see how it would happen.

. We were ok when I was in labour- I’m ‘the femme one’ so it didn’t seem to cause confusion, but when I had some complications while on holiday in Europe early in the pregnancy, the nurses refused to let my wife into the room with me and just kept grilling me on where my husband was. She was left in a corridor with no clue what was happening.

SarahAndQuack · 01/06/2023 23:29

FoggyDew · 01/06/2023 23:20

@SarahAndQuack dont apologise! I was trying to say thank you for understanding I wasn’t being insensitive with my first post, I was just saying it how it is for lesbian couples. I don’t think I explained myself very well, sorry!

How the fuck did they not notice she was mum while she was in labour?! That is beyond odd and into the valley of total madness.

We ended up with a birth certificate that listed me as mum and my (very obviously a woman with a woman’s name) wife was listed as ‘father’ 😂.

People are daft, and then they get flustered and that makes them more daft. Do you get questioned about when it will be ‘your turn’ to have a baby, and if you want one of your own? My wife has taken to replying “why keep a dog and bark yourself?!” because she has got so bored with it.

Grin Oh dear, we are both falling over ourselves to apologise! I was also worrying I expressed myself so badly.

Your poor wife! Being listed as 'father' could be funny, but I imagine it could also really cut, too. We were very lucky with that side of things - the registrar couldn't have been more lovely.

With my DP it was utter madness. She isn't very butch and I am not very femme, but put us together and people only every see a male/female couple. You can only laugh at it, but actually it was horrible at the time - they didn't remember to give her a meal because they hadn't properly registered who was there; when I went to try to get her a breakfast on the postnatal ward they got cross with me because they thought I was trying to fetch a meal for my male, non-birthing partner. I was a size 10/12 back then; I didn't look vaguely plausible pregnant or postpartum. She wasn't properly checked for blood loss post-birth because we think they just didn't register who she was - someone glanced in and saw a woman-shaped person up and about with a baby, and they just looked past the very white woman lying down in bed bleeding. It's possible to play it for laughs and you have to try to, but honestly, it isn't very funny and DP had a horrible time.

On that note of black humour, I must borrow 'why keep a dog and bark yoursel!' Grin Someone on here, ages ago, suggested 'I keep track of the incomings and she does the outgoings,' which also made me smile.

ADHDMummy2023 · 01/06/2023 23:29

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

FoggyDew · 01/06/2023 23:20

SarahAndQuack · 01/06/2023 23:04

Oh, sorry - I wasn't trying to suggest you weren't saying how it was for you. Just wanting to add another perspective.

My DP is the birth mum, but she certainly had her share of horrible questions. I'm honestly not sure who had more. She had someone call her 'dad' when she was actively breastfeeding (!), and when she was literally in labour people weren't sure she was the mum.

I guess for me the bottom line is that people can be really hurtful, and unaware, in all sorts of ways, just because they try so hard to map same-sex parents onto opposite-sex couples. Sometimes it works and it's so reassuring to know your baby is doing what everyone else's baby is doing. And other times, it's not, and you'll end up feeling confused or alienated. If you're in the latter situation, it is ok to be upset and to take time to work out why everyone else's 'normal' isn't quite descriptive of your experience.

@SarahAndQuack dont apologise! I was trying to say thank you for understanding I wasn’t being insensitive with my first post, I was just saying it how it is for lesbian couples. I don’t think I explained myself very well, sorry!

How the fuck did they not notice she was mum while she was in labour?! That is beyond odd and into the valley of total madness.

We ended up with a birth certificate that listed me as mum and my (very obviously a woman with a woman’s name) wife was listed as ‘father’ 😂.

People are daft, and then they get flustered and that makes them more daft. Do you get questioned about when it will be ‘your turn’ to have a baby, and if you want one of your own? My wife has taken to replying “why keep a dog and bark yourself?!” because she has got so bored with it.

meeeeeeshel · 01/06/2023 23:15

Totally just a phase. And also different personalities, too. My eldest has always been a daddies girl, and she would do this to daddy when I'd been with her all day on mat leave! She'd be awful to me and daddy would come in and be all smiles! 🙄
My second however could not be more of a mummies girl.
It's honestly just a phase and going back to work hasn't done this. Try not to be so hard on yourself. The baby is so very lucky to have two such loving parents 😍

SarahAndQuack · 01/06/2023 23:04

FoggyDew · 01/06/2023 22:43

@SarahAndQuack thank you… I thought I was just saying it how it is!

We do both get the awkward questions but I think because I’m birth mum it’s easier for me usually. No one questions my position in that way. My wife comes in for a lot more awkward and rude questions than I do.

Oh, sorry - I wasn't trying to suggest you weren't saying how it was for you. Just wanting to add another perspective.

My DP is the birth mum, but she certainly had her share of horrible questions. I'm honestly not sure who had more. She had someone call her 'dad' when she was actively breastfeeding (!), and when she was literally in labour people weren't sure she was the mum.

I guess for me the bottom line is that people can be really hurtful, and unaware, in all sorts of ways, just because they try so hard to map same-sex parents onto opposite-sex couples. Sometimes it works and it's so reassuring to know your baby is doing what everyone else's baby is doing. And other times, it's not, and you'll end up feeling confused or alienated. If you're in the latter situation, it is ok to be upset and to take time to work out why everyone else's 'normal' isn't quite descriptive of your experience.

AliceMcK · 01/06/2023 22:59

It’s normal, my eldest would cry when my DH went anywhere near her, god forbid I went to the toilet. When #2 came along, complete opposite only wanted DH, has never ever settled for me only DH. Number 3 was back to me but now her and DH are like 🤞

Swipe left for the next trending thread