Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The problem with Brexit is we didn't Brexit hard enough

421 replies

Middlelanehogger · 01/06/2023 07:55

The EU itself was just the start.

But there are still more institutions which still influence our laws and make it impossible to actually achieve "taking back control".

If anything, we've left the trading bloc (which had economic benefits) but stayed in many of the legal institutions (which retain control over us).

So which body do we leave next - the ECHR? The ECJ? Keenly awaiting responses 😘

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Florenz · 02/06/2023 20:22

We were had far less inequality before we entered the EU before we did after we'd been in it for 40+ years. Free movement breeds inequality as employers can employ the cheapest workers on the continent whereas wealthy, highly skilled people can sell their services to the highest payers on the continent. Plus there's the issue of "the professions" not being open to EU workers with equivalent qualifications from their home country whereas "the trades" were.

pointythings · 02/06/2023 20:07

Florenz · 02/06/2023 19:57

The EU is all about unfettered free market capitalism. What other purpose does freedom of movement serve other than to allow the rich to get richer and the poor to get poorer?

If that were so, all EU countries would have levels of economic inequality greater than the UK. They don't - because countries in the EU have this thing called sovereignty, which means that they can set policies which prevent this from happening. The UK has one of the highest levels of inequality in Europe (note data is not just for the EU). Your argument doesn't hold water.

Florenz · 02/06/2023 19:57

pointythings · 02/06/2023 18:55

@Florenz unfettered free market capitalism tends to make the majority of working class people poorer.

The EU is all about unfettered free market capitalism. What other purpose does freedom of movement serve other than to allow the rich to get richer and the poor to get poorer?

pointythings · 02/06/2023 19:44

@SunnyEgg it's the NHS surcharge. It isn't new, but because of Brexit people from the EU would now have to pay it, whereas they didn't before. It's a lot of money for someone on low pay (and it was a very bad idea because it actually deterred skilled migrants that the UK needed from coming here, but Tories...)

I'm all in favour of people earning what they are worth (and footballers are paid far too much but that is a global issue) but these are entrenched problems. The UK has very many fields where there is a shortage of people, and that cannot be fixed immediately through higher pay - the people aren't there and the funding isn't there (thinking of care homes here, where pay comes out of council funding, and guess who has been starving councils of funding?).

As I said, there isn't an easy fix - but Brexit has not made anything better, and won't.

SunnyEgg · 02/06/2023 19:44

Although as I posted earlier my preference would be for SM / CU to be a GE issue

With polls as they are I’m not sure why not

SunnyEgg · 02/06/2023 19:35

pointythings · 02/06/2023 19:28

@SunnyEgg whether it's good or not depends on many things.

  • Owner's costs are likely to be very much higher - food and energy gone through the roof.
  • However, that also applies to owner's staff, so yes, they need a higher wage
  • Which will drive up the prices the owner can charge customers, who are also in a CoL crisis and will spend less, and do so less frequently than before

And you'd have to be a blinkered Brexiteer to deny that Brexit has been a contributing factor to all of the above - see previous post setting out total cost to the UK according to that well known lefty organisation, Bloomberg.

So basically there are no good options for anyone. I very much doubt that many people would now come here for a two year hospitality visa when that means they have to pay the NHS charge anyway.

What’s the NHS charge? Is it new post Brexit?

He had a compelling argument in terms of pre Brexit you’d get many young people coming from EU for a short time to brush up on English and often take casual jobs for something like two years

This was a way to emulate same conditions. I know other countries do it for young people

We do now for post graduates actually from top universities but maybe not reaching what he had before in terms of casual skills

I’m not sure either way, I could be convinced but it’s not looking likely for either party at GE, looking at their lines on immigration

pointythings · 02/06/2023 19:28

@SunnyEgg whether it's good or not depends on many things.

  • Owner's costs are likely to be very much higher - food and energy gone through the roof.
  • However, that also applies to owner's staff, so yes, they need a higher wage
  • Which will drive up the prices the owner can charge customers, who are also in a CoL crisis and will spend less, and do so less frequently than before

And you'd have to be a blinkered Brexiteer to deny that Brexit has been a contributing factor to all of the above - see previous post setting out total cost to the UK according to that well known lefty organisation, Bloomberg.

So basically there are no good options for anyone. I very much doubt that many people would now come here for a two year hospitality visa when that means they have to pay the NHS charge anyway.

SunnyEgg · 02/06/2023 19:24

pointythings · 02/06/2023 19:20

An owner was annoyed he had to lift hospitality staff wages the other day. Would prefer a two year visa to keep them lower

Well, that isn't so vague as to be meaningless at all.

🙄 just ask for more info if you don’t get it.

Itsu owner on R4 asking for two year visa to keep staff wages lower in hospitality.

Good idea or not?

pointythings · 02/06/2023 19:20

An owner was annoyed he had to lift hospitality staff wages the other day. Would prefer a two year visa to keep them lower

Well, that isn't so vague as to be meaningless at all.

SunnyEgg · 02/06/2023 19:12

More people will enter trades if lucrative.

An owner was annoyed he had to lift hospitality staff wages the other day. Would prefer a two year visa to keep them lower

Is that a good idea?

I’m not committed either way but I can’t see either party going with it for the GE

Abhannmor · 02/06/2023 19:07

Ah yeah ; the ould 'hidden hand of the market ' will fix everything shtick we've been hearing since the early 80s.

Yet the market is like electricity - a good servant but a bad master. There does have to be some regulation of course as @Florenz says you can't expect trades people to work for poverty wages.

On the other hand , you've just left the richest market in the world. And it does seem to many people that leaving was sold on a false prospectus. There was much talk about untold billions for the NHS. Surprisingly little about learning how to unblock drains and fit doors.

Not that there's anything wrong with such pursuits I hasten to add. Perhaps that's what Levelling Up meant. Boris was going to enrol everyone in vocational schemes to learn useful stuff. But then the ungrateful sods knifed him so we'll never find out! Unless he sobers up and writes the book....

pointythings · 02/06/2023 18:55

@Florenz unfettered free market capitalism tends to make the majority of working class people poorer.

Florenz · 02/06/2023 18:49

People are entitled to charge what they want for their skills and labour. Let the market sort itself out. If locksmithing is a lucrative trade, more people will train to be locksmiths and prices will come down.

What is the alternative? The government setting fixed rates that locksmiths can charge?

Crikeyalmighty · 02/06/2023 18:41

@Florenz absolutely not the case. I have paid out for various things over the last 10 years for trades and I can assure you none were for a pittance!!

pointythings · 02/06/2023 18:33

@Florenz a doubling in price over 4 years is price gouging. And in an economy where the majority of people aren't getting pay rises, and where any pay rises are being outstripped by massive inflation, this kind of behaviour is a recipe for economic crisis.

Are you OK with people on minimum wage not being able to afford to keep their houses secure?

And if we all did our own locksmithing, electricianing, building, carpentry, car maintenance - how many people would end up out of work and not earning at all?

There has to be a balance.

Florenz · 02/06/2023 18:18

Are doctors price gouging? Are architects price gouging? Are top footballers price gouging? Is anyone that doesn't work for minimum wage price gouging?

The problem is that people got used to tradespeople working for a pittance because of free movement, now they are charging the going rate, they feel ripped off. Maybe people should learn to fit their own locks.

pointythings · 02/06/2023 18:11

So basically the main benefit of Brexit is that rip-off Britain is now on steroids and 'the going rate' is price gouging. Nice.

Crikeyalmighty · 02/06/2023 18:08

@Florenz yes it may well be the going rate - but as I had something similar done in 2019 and the cost was £210 that's a hell of a lot of an 'uplift' for a similar priced part- and in my opinion a total rip off. Are we just expected to accept massive 'rip offs then' these days?? How do working class people (as you Tory's constantly mention them) who aren't in these trades afford to have any work done, ever!!

Florenz · 02/06/2023 17:55

If only 3 people could do it, and they all quoted the same price, surely that is the going rate?

Abhannmor · 02/06/2023 17:30

Crikeyalmighty · 02/06/2023 12:59

@Blossomtoes well that's genuinely good to hear as we were charged£415 to change a door lock. Took half an hour. The part was £115 - we checked. Problem was only 3 people could do it and all quoted roughly the same and it had to be done .

£300 profit for half an hours work- £250 if I'm being generous allowing for petrol and travel time (15 minutes away)

I feel for people who can't just pay sums like this when it's an essential job. It was quite a specialist lock and not one you could just do yourself without the right gear

Good grief. I paid €120 a few weeks ago for a lock to be changed , aluminium front door. I thought that was a bit steep tbh but it had to be done. But £415 is monstrous.

Crikeyalmighty · 02/06/2023 14:51

@TheThinkingGoblin you summed it up very well- it really isn't all about 'well we pay in xyz and then get xyz out of it for projects/rebates. ' it's about the fact that being part of it massively eases legitimate trade, particularly those business with exports in goods or/and services and encourages multi nationals to invest here in jobs and businesses for access to the EU market. The only UK market simply isn't large enough for certain businesses to make it pay to remain with all the hoops and additional costs they now have to jump through -

The Tesla factory was destined for the UK- they have now gone to Germany I believe. So not Romania or Poland etc-.it's a business that wanted to come here. The UK car manufacturers are very much still assessing the situation and others like Nissan no doubt are being incentivised (not for free) not to leave .

What we needed to do was play an active and dominant role something the Tory's did very well for a lot of years, as did Blair but sadly it went down the tubes since the rise of the very right wing ERG who had an agenda to appeal to UKIP voters to shore up the Tory's voting base .

At this rate we will end up with towns and cities with retail and hospitality and public service jobs - but remarkably few higher paid manufacturing jobs and these jobs do benefit the aforementioned working class, as well as others, plus industries servicing and supplying. The UK market on its own with export being a pain in the arse is not a tempting prospect anymore for those kinds of businesses.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 02/06/2023 14:25

I see the ultra amazing free trade deal with Australia is going down a storm over there, but probably not for the reason the brexiteers had hoped (from 5:18 in the link).

I also think Tory grandee Chris Patten gave a pretty good assessment of the situation on QT the other night which is worth sharing too.

https://twitter.com/Otto_English/status/1664365038935703552?s=20

Karl's dig at UK exports has guests in stitches 😂 | Today Show Australia

Subscribe 👉 http://9Soci.al/L72O50GjSJY | "There's black pudding, Cumberland sausages...that's about it isn't it?" Karl didn't hold back on UK exports follo...

https://youtu.be/gDjywEGjAcw

Blossomtoes · 02/06/2023 14:18

Dontevenstart · 02/06/2023 14:09

Not all exponents of Brexit are racist, but all racists are exponents of Brexit. Joint venture. Can only hope for a day of reckoning.

Not true. My sil and BiL are horrible racists and hate Brexit with a passion.

Dontevenstart · 02/06/2023 14:09

Not all exponents of Brexit are racist, but all racists are exponents of Brexit. Joint venture. Can only hope for a day of reckoning.

TheThinkingGoblin · 02/06/2023 13:56

YouAreEntitledToMyOpinion · 02/06/2023 13:30

£20bn over how long?

That was our contribution for 12 months in 2018. We handed over £20 billion in 2018 for that year and there was a rebate of £4 billion that they would give us back.

Then they earmark some spending money for us to projects they agree on.

You clearly have little idea of how the financing works.

That £16bn goes into a large pot.

And we then got things like Horizon (£2.5bn for UK scientists)

But more importantly, th EU (via SM/CU) it also drove our long-term economic growth rate to hover around 2.5%.

Do you know what that long-term growth rate is now?

Its hovering around 1%.

Thats £100bn in lost out put PER YEAR, and £40bn in less tax revenue PER YEAR.

So we are now massive net losers.

And thats not even the worst part. These losses will also compound over time as investment gets routed to the EU and US, and not the UK.

Car manufacturing and farming will be decimated.

No "if" about it. They will be shrunk accordingly because they will not be able to export as they will become totally uncompetitive.

And in terms of the old EU regeneration funds, those fund were earmarked for specific regions using actual metrics.

Why do you think Cornwall and Wales got so much EU regional funding?

Because they were poor and the UK Govt never lifted a finger to help them.

Now, post-Brexit, are those same regions receiving more money from the UK Govt?

The answer is no. They are getting materially less as the entire country (as predicted by rational experienced people) is poorer.

And that is also precisely the future that awaits the UK.

Becoming poorer relative to our European peers given the economic headwinda caused by Brexit in combination with a deteriorating demographic profile (which even massive non-EU migration will not "fix").

Swipe left for the next trending thread