Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The problem with Brexit is we didn't Brexit hard enough

421 replies

Middlelanehogger · 01/06/2023 07:55

The EU itself was just the start.

But there are still more institutions which still influence our laws and make it impossible to actually achieve "taking back control".

If anything, we've left the trading bloc (which had economic benefits) but stayed in many of the legal institutions (which retain control over us).

So which body do we leave next - the ECHR? The ECJ? Keenly awaiting responses 😘

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Florenz · 03/06/2023 16:38

Blair and Brown are responsible for the "everyone's on benefits" culture where people say "what's the point in working more hours/getting a promotion, they'll reduce my benefits".

RosaGallica · 03/06/2023 16:35

i also remember the targeting culture. With horror.

RosaGallica · 03/06/2023 16:33

In what possible way are todays problems linked to Blair?

Hmm, starters for ten… mass push of training on to newly privatised universities instead of previous training on job and then forcing youngsters to pay for them; expansion of privatisation of national assets, which are now making huge profits for foreigners at our expense; mass expansion of buy to let causing generational inequality; mass deregulation of finance industry, pushing us into globalisation and beginning the financial corruption in London with foreign money, which also pushed up the house prices; immense number of unaccountable quangos handing out public money and destruction of traditional, more accountable councils and finances. Even the flagship things that are now seen as ‘goods’, surestart and minimum wage, have caused issues. Minimum wage devalued the wages of the next few ranks up, devaluing the work of those who were trying to work up to climb the ladder, while surestart was all too often handing out of public money to those who had done nothing to work for it, either at the bottom or the top end. I was working in the council at the time, paying taxes to see them disappear into the pockets of the same people who were sucking g me dry in the newly arrived private rent sector. Those of us who were there from poor backgrounds but working up remember it as a time of betrayal and ever moving goalposts. His time brought back the need for an inheritance and the class system: he brought in the two-tier society, those given everything by mum and dad, those given everything by the state, and those of us who had to work for everything were turned into mugs and fools.

Howpo · 03/06/2023 13:00

RosaGallica · 03/06/2023 12:46

I totally agree with your points, but the U.K. electorate didn’t have much of a choice in who to vote for for many years. Blair’s New Labour was as Tory as they come, and his era ushered in most of the problems we see today. Corbyn’s era was the only real alternative we’ve seen in the last 30 years. I’m not sure what Starmer’s version of Labour will bring but the signs aren’t great.

Really?

Blair was far removed from Thatcher and Majors Tory party e.g SureStart, Spending on NHS and min wage for starters.

There are/were alternatives, in England - Greens, LD's Ukip.. even with FPTP, if enough people vote for them, they will get MPs and as we saw in 2010, minor parties can form a Govt.

In what possible way are todays problems linked to Blair? on issues in the ME yes he holds some responsibility, along with Bush.

Is Blair stopping the Tories from Governing for the many and not the few? Did he make Sunak hand out billions in CV relief business loans to fraudsters? Did he vote in Truss? or BJ or give us Brexit?

Austerity has wrecked almost every aspect of the UK social welfare safety net, not least in the NHS and esp MH, the lack of care and capacity is purely down to UK Govt and its decisions on funding.

RosaGallica · 03/06/2023 12:46

pointythings · 03/06/2023 10:05

@Howpo exactly. Brexiters love blaming the EU for everything that was wrong in the UK since 1972 without taking into account that the same things were not going wrong elsewhere in the UK because we had sovereignty and our governments took the decisions that they took. And the UK electorate voted for them.

I totally agree with your points, but the U.K. electorate didn’t have much of a choice in who to vote for for many years. Blair’s New Labour was as Tory as they come, and his era ushered in most of the problems we see today. Corbyn’s era was the only real alternative we’ve seen in the last 30 years. I’m not sure what Starmer’s version of Labour will bring but the signs aren’t great.

MrsSkylerWhite · 03/06/2023 11:35

CalistoNoSolo · 01/06/2023 08:54
Crikeyalmighty · 01/06/2023 08:27

Hmmm - having observed sewerage in the sea this weekend- south coast - I can only say bring back EU standards asap. UK is currently like the Wild West .

“Absolutely. The UK just doesn't work anymore”.

Agree, sailing dangerously close to becoming a failed state. Really fear for where we will be in 10/20 years.

Howpo · 03/06/2023 11:32

I came into the 2016 referendum, thinking i'd vote Leave but it very quickly became clear that Vote Leave was about Wishlists i.e Could do's, Maybe's and blaming EU for UK caused problems.

Our roads are shite because govt's make a decision not to maintain them, our health service is shit because UK Governments don't fund it correctly, nor prioritise the training of UK citizens to work in it, we have the lowest number of scanners and diag equipment because UK Govt choses not to buy enough of them.... SFA to do with the EU.

SerendipityJane · 03/06/2023 10:20

Lonelycrab · 03/06/2023 10:12

it's the time machine model of Brexit, isn't it?

Rose tinted spectacles. Put them on and suddenly it’s 1969 again. Yay.

You'd better shut your pipe hole

1969 Again

Provided to YouTube by Parlophone UK1969 Again · Adam AntWonderful℗ 1994 Parlophone Records Ltd, a Warner Music Group CompanyComposer: Adam AntComposer: Boz ...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XBHuRcAgULw

Lonelycrab · 03/06/2023 10:12

it's the time machine model of Brexit, isn't it?

Rose tinted spectacles. Put them on and suddenly it’s 1969 again. Yay.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 03/06/2023 10:08

Howpo · 03/06/2023 09:45

No it hasn't, income inequality in the UK has increased since 2016.

But this isn't down to brexit or being in the EU, its down to UK policies on taxation, investment in infrastructure, education and health etc.

this blame game is just another example of attributing UK specific problems to the EU and now Ukraine, Covid... immigration... when its us, the UK, that are responsible & when these are a distant memory, we'll find another reason to not take responsibility.

Also to add, while there was some wavering in the levels of wealth inequality between 2016 and now, this has mostly been attributed to the rich getting slighty poorer than the poor getting any richer (due to the impact of the fall in the value of the pound has had on their assets).

It also only relates to wealth inequality and not any other type of inequalities e.g., health, housing, education, etc.

pointythings · 03/06/2023 10:05

@Howpo exactly. Brexiters love blaming the EU for everything that was wrong in the UK since 1972 without taking into account that the same things were not going wrong elsewhere in the UK because we had sovereignty and our governments took the decisions that they took. And the UK electorate voted for them.

Howpo · 03/06/2023 09:45

Florenz · 02/06/2023 21:24

Inequality has decreased since Brexit.

No it hasn't, income inequality in the UK has increased since 2016.

But this isn't down to brexit or being in the EU, its down to UK policies on taxation, investment in infrastructure, education and health etc.

this blame game is just another example of attributing UK specific problems to the EU and now Ukraine, Covid... immigration... when its us, the UK, that are responsible & when these are a distant memory, we'll find another reason to not take responsibility.

pointythings · 03/06/2023 08:38

@Yolo12345 it's the time machine model of Brexit, isn't it? If only we roll everything back to 1972, all will be well. With no insight that the rest of the world isn't going to do that.

RafaistheKingofClay · 03/06/2023 01:27

pointythings · 02/06/2023 21:29

I'm going to want to see some evidence before I believe that.

Good luck waiting for that evidence.

Yolo12345 · 02/06/2023 23:41

People who do not understand the modern world think like this....and also people who think that the EU is only about trade or economics...

pointythings · 02/06/2023 22:24
  • *@Middlelanehogger I actually don't object to people getting really rich. I object to people getting really poor in one of the wealthiest countries in the world. If sorting that out means that the very rich have a little bit less then I'm fine with that. How we achieve that is something that requires thought, but looking at maximum pay multiples would be a start, as would looking at UBI. It's ridiculous that it's possible for a family to have two adults working and still not be able to afford safe, warm, good quality housing without eating up all their income. Many countries in the EU do better, so clearly this isn't about the EU promoting capitalism and inequality. It's about national governments promoting these things.
Middlelanehogger · 02/06/2023 22:15

Club revenues across the Premier League are circa £5B a year, I'm actually okay with footballers getting a cut of that instead of their private equity owners.

Carry on.

OP posts:
pointythings · 02/06/2023 21:29

Florenz · 02/06/2023 21:24

Inequality has decreased since Brexit.

I'm going to want to see some evidence before I believe that.

Florenz · 02/06/2023 21:24

Inequality has decreased since Brexit.

SunnyEgg · 02/06/2023 21:21

Florenz · 02/06/2023 21:00

Doctors couldn't rock up from Poland on a Friday and start work as a doctor in the UK on Monday. Bricklayers could.

If being in the EU helps fight against Globalisation and inequality, why didn't it work in the UK? What is the point of it if it doesn't work?

Inequality has been about the same since 2000s but you’re right it rose after 70s

It peaked in 2008 and down slightly since

ichundich · 02/06/2023 21:20

Florenz · 02/06/2023 21:00

Doctors couldn't rock up from Poland on a Friday and start work as a doctor in the UK on Monday. Bricklayers could.

If being in the EU helps fight against Globalisation and inequality, why didn't it work in the UK? What is the point of it if it doesn't work?

It's not the EU's fault that workers in the UK aren't better protected. Many EU countries don't allow zero-hour contracts, have higher sick pay, longer maternity leave, etc. The UK chose not to implement those rights. I personally still prefer tradespeople from the EU (even though their rates have gone up stupidly as well) because I've had a much better experience with them in terms of their reliability and quality of work. I'm sure I'm not the only one. With time more people will train to be qualified electricians, plumbers, bricklayers and prices will be more reflective of the skill and knowledge required.

MovinGroovinBarbie · 02/06/2023 21:10

I must be the only person who has benefitted from Brexit. As a truck driver the increase in demand/wages in the past few years has been staggering.

Caught up with an old workmate the other day and he's earning £65k driving the arctics and has a three day weekend every week. Another guy I know is earning a grand a week driving a small curtainsider delivering booze. This would've been a low end driving job in years past. I remember an agency offering me £10.50 an hour to do it about five years ago. No thanks!

I'm also seeing a lot more women driving trucks in the last year or two and I speculate it's the prospect of a half decent salary and also the fact that companies are desperate for any driver they can get their hands on lately, which has lowered the bar for entry. The driver who came to deliver sand to our plant the other day was a 20yo girl. Next time I thought it was her again but was another young woman. Apparently there are three that regularly visit from that company alone.

I know there are plenty of negatives but for me personally it's massively improved my life. I'm making at least £15k more a year and could make another £10k if I wanted to go and work for one of the big construction outfits. And I don't need to take shit from any employer because I guarantee I could get on the phone and find another job in a day or two.

pointythings · 02/06/2023 21:08

@Florenz doctors couldn't rock up from Scotland on Friday and start work on Monday in England either, not even as locums. Because some professions have tight HR requirements. Nothing to do with FOM, everything to do with different jobs having different HR requirements.

If being in the EU helps fight against Globalisation and inequality, why didn't it work in the UK?

It didn't work because for the majority of the time that the UK was in the EU, we had governments that didn't want to fight inequality. Because they were Conservative governments. And because the UK had sovereignty while in the EU, that could happen and did happen. So really, the people to blame are and were Tory voters. In the case of the working classes, turkeys voting for Christmas.

Florenz · 02/06/2023 21:00

Doctors couldn't rock up from Poland on a Friday and start work as a doctor in the UK on Monday. Bricklayers could.

If being in the EU helps fight against Globalisation and inequality, why didn't it work in the UK? What is the point of it if it doesn't work?

pointythings · 02/06/2023 20:48

Florenz · 02/06/2023 20:22

We were had far less inequality before we entered the EU before we did after we'd been in it for 40+ years. Free movement breeds inequality as employers can employ the cheapest workers on the continent whereas wealthy, highly skilled people can sell their services to the highest payers on the continent. Plus there's the issue of "the professions" not being open to EU workers with equivalent qualifications from their home country whereas "the trades" were.

Sigh.

Everyone had less inequality before anyone entered the EU. Pay multiples 40 years ago in the developed world were much, much smaller than they are now. The problem is not and was not the EU - it's globalisation. That's why you need brakes on untrammelled capitalism to mitigate that - in the way that many EU countries do, because they have sovereignty and are able to do this in the EU, and in the way that the UK is choosing not to do.

While we were in the EU, there absolutely was cross border recognition of professional qualifications. Where did you get the idea that there was not?