Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The problem with Brexit is we didn't Brexit hard enough

421 replies

Middlelanehogger · 01/06/2023 07:55

The EU itself was just the start.

But there are still more institutions which still influence our laws and make it impossible to actually achieve "taking back control".

If anything, we've left the trading bloc (which had economic benefits) but stayed in many of the legal institutions (which retain control over us).

So which body do we leave next - the ECHR? The ECJ? Keenly awaiting responses 😘

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Howpo · 04/06/2023 17:56

GP problems?

That goes back to not paying for more medical places at University to produce more GPs and Brexit

Yes i agree, the short-sightedness of UK Govt, esp over the last 10 years or so, is criminal.
Brexit has destroyed the UK.

Howpo · 04/06/2023 17:49

TheThinkingGoblin · 04/06/2023 16:22

None of those issues have anything to do with house building.

Those issues arise due to a lack of a nationally coordinated industrial strategy.

Sewage problems?

That goes back to a lack of investment going back 10+ years.

GP problems?

That goes back to not paying for more medical places at University to produce more GPs and Brexit.

Noticing a trend here?

Absolutely NONE of those things will be fixed in even 5 years. It will take at least 10 years to get improvements with a lot of investment.

The only real solution is housing DENSITY. That means you build UP. This then has less effects on the infrastructure.

But once again, the older NIMBYs block that too (and yes, they do tend to be older so the pearl clutching about ageism is getting a bit tiresome).

At a certain point, you basically have to ignore these people and get on with it. Thats were the UK is now.

What? nothing to do with House Building????

Whether you build up down or on a diagonal, you need infrastructure and a new sewage station for 200 houses doesn't take 5, let alone 10 years.... it could be built alongside the houses.... if there is no infrastructure and it really does take 10 years, then, i'm afraid houses cannot be built, unless you want to go back to the 1820s and open sewers.

As i also said, the planning system is completely pro the developer.

TheThinkingGoblin · 04/06/2023 16:22

Howpo · 04/06/2023 15:17

Well, that’s ageism right there. I object to more and more housing in my village and am twenty years away from 60. Why do i object? Because there is never an improvement in infrastructure or services

Yes we've had 100s of houses forced onto a rural community, now the local sewage plant cannot deal with the waste and it gets pumped into a river and/or tankered out, the 'station cannot be upgraded due to the fact it gets flooded!!!

The local health centre has less GPs than it was pre housing estate.

Oh and the developer got planning with 30% affordable/to rent, they got that removed post planning, so 100% market sale.

Planning is a developers wet dream in the UK, no wonder builders make billions in profit.

None of those issues have anything to do with house building.

Those issues arise due to a lack of a nationally coordinated industrial strategy.

Sewage problems?

That goes back to a lack of investment going back 10+ years.

GP problems?

That goes back to not paying for more medical places at University to produce more GPs and Brexit.

Noticing a trend here?

Absolutely NONE of those things will be fixed in even 5 years. It will take at least 10 years to get improvements with a lot of investment.

The only real solution is housing DENSITY. That means you build UP. This then has less effects on the infrastructure.

But once again, the older NIMBYs block that too (and yes, they do tend to be older so the pearl clutching about ageism is getting a bit tiresome).

At a certain point, you basically have to ignore these people and get on with it. Thats were the UK is now.

Howpo · 04/06/2023 15:17

Well, that’s ageism right there. I object to more and more housing in my village and am twenty years away from 60. Why do i object? Because there is never an improvement in infrastructure or services

Yes we've had 100s of houses forced onto a rural community, now the local sewage plant cannot deal with the waste and it gets pumped into a river and/or tankered out, the 'station cannot be upgraded due to the fact it gets flooded!!!

The local health centre has less GPs than it was pre housing estate.

Oh and the developer got planning with 30% affordable/to rent, they got that removed post planning, so 100% market sale.

Planning is a developers wet dream in the UK, no wonder builders make billions in profit.

Howpo · 04/06/2023 14:59

RosaGallica · 04/06/2023 08:48

Try to understand, I’m not interested in party politics. Clearly this thread is about that and I was wrong to butt in.

History and historical trends continue and yes we have had some cultural and economic trends continue since the 80s, some since the 90s, some since the 00s; many should not have happened, some were unavoidable. All have contributed to where we are now, to a country unrecognisable to those of us born a while ago. It is a country in severe trouble, a country that is pretty disgusting quite honestly to those of us raised in the post-war solutions of freedom of information and democracy. If all you are interested in is playing party politics and other power games those trends will continue until we are living in a dystopian nightmare. We are half way there already: I see very little difference between a 1-party state and a 2-party state, or even a 3-party state with our population levels and an attitude of command-and-control.

Party Politics is everything, politics is everything, from pot holes to swimming pool closures to housing... etc.

Parties get voted in and make choices that in the main have wrecked the UK over the last few decades, that wrecking has just accelerated over the last 10 years.

PaigeMatthews · 04/06/2023 13:47

TheThinkingGoblin · 04/06/2023 12:30

The problem has always been right to buy in the UK.

It is an abomination cooked up by Thatcher and her cronies which had created a massive supply-side problem in the social housing sector, which had then mushroomed from there to the private rental sector.

Until you get rid of it and allow local councils to build social housing with no intereference from the NIMBYs, nothing much will change in the UK.

Local people should get zero input on house building. We have far too many 60+ year olds delaying housing construction for years because they object to their "view" or the "village is too big" or "the pub is too loud" or "insert ridiculous reason here".

We need a national master plan for house bullding with an actual long-term industrial strategy. Right now we have neither. Its all short term hodge podge decision making depending on who happens to be in power.

Well, that’s ageism right there. I object to more and more housing in my village and am twenty years away from 60. Why do i object? Because there is never an improvement in infrastructure or services.

Crikeyalmighty · 04/06/2023 13:31

@Howpo Yes I think HA should have far more controls enforced. Personally I think labour should have stopped right to buy - unless you had been there for more than 15 years and paid 80% plus of the rent without any recourse to benefits and only at 25% discount from value. I know a good few that had paid little rent and somehow wangled it and got family to effectively buy for them and then flog it on very quickly which really wasn't the point.

TheThinkingGoblin · 04/06/2023 12:30

Howpo · 04/06/2023 06:45

No they didn't and they should of, as well as bringing in more secure private tenancies.
I'm not convinced HA properties are a good substitute either, enforcement of standards is shocking, helped along of course by council budgets slashed... didn't the Tories vote against min standards for rented properties?

How many council houses have the Cons built in the last 13 years?

However, the housing situation in the UK in the 2000s wasn't anything like as bad as it is now, 25% of private LL's have left the sector, house prices have trebled since Labour were in, so tenants cannot afford to buy properties that come onto the market and tenants still get just 2 months notice and no fault evictions will continue after the the new renters reform bill, just under a different name i.e LL wants to sell or move in, who will police that?

The problem has always been right to buy in the UK.

It is an abomination cooked up by Thatcher and her cronies which had created a massive supply-side problem in the social housing sector, which had then mushroomed from there to the private rental sector.

Until you get rid of it and allow local councils to build social housing with no intereference from the NIMBYs, nothing much will change in the UK.

Local people should get zero input on house building. We have far too many 60+ year olds delaying housing construction for years because they object to their "view" or the "village is too big" or "the pub is too loud" or "insert ridiculous reason here".

We need a national master plan for house bullding with an actual long-term industrial strategy. Right now we have neither. Its all short term hodge podge decision making depending on who happens to be in power.

LadyGrinningSoul85 · 04/06/2023 08:51

Jesus Christ...

Yes. That's what the problem is, we didn't do it hard enough.

Not that it was a shit decision made by selfish, and primarily racist, arseholes.
Nope, not at all.

RosaGallica · 04/06/2023 08:48

Crikeyalmighty · 03/06/2023 19:51

@Howpo exactly right. It's a bit rich of @Florenz to blame Blair and brown for the benefits culture- who has been in power for the past13 years??

However if we are into that scenario may I give you Thatcher and selling off the utilities and social housing. We are still feeling the repercussions

Try to understand, I’m not interested in party politics. Clearly this thread is about that and I was wrong to butt in.

History and historical trends continue and yes we have had some cultural and economic trends continue since the 80s, some since the 90s, some since the 00s; many should not have happened, some were unavoidable. All have contributed to where we are now, to a country unrecognisable to those of us born a while ago. It is a country in severe trouble, a country that is pretty disgusting quite honestly to those of us raised in the post-war solutions of freedom of information and democracy. If all you are interested in is playing party politics and other power games those trends will continue until we are living in a dystopian nightmare. We are half way there already: I see very little difference between a 1-party state and a 2-party state, or even a 3-party state with our population levels and an attitude of command-and-control.

Howpo · 04/06/2023 06:45

Florenz · 03/06/2023 20:19

There was nothing stopping Labour building social housing, but they didn't.

No they didn't and they should of, as well as bringing in more secure private tenancies.
I'm not convinced HA properties are a good substitute either, enforcement of standards is shocking, helped along of course by council budgets slashed... didn't the Tories vote against min standards for rented properties?

How many council houses have the Cons built in the last 13 years?

However, the housing situation in the UK in the 2000s wasn't anything like as bad as it is now, 25% of private LL's have left the sector, house prices have trebled since Labour were in, so tenants cannot afford to buy properties that come onto the market and tenants still get just 2 months notice and no fault evictions will continue after the the new renters reform bill, just under a different name i.e LL wants to sell or move in, who will police that?

Crikeyalmighty · 03/06/2023 21:28

@Florenz they built 350,000 Housing association homes between 98 and 2010 - that's a fair old few.

pointythings · 03/06/2023 20:48

@Florenz this is true (except for NIMBY locals), but the Tories have now been in power for 13 years, so that excuse is wearing a little bit thin.

Florenz · 03/06/2023 20:19

There was nothing stopping Labour building social housing, but they didn't.

Crikeyalmighty · 03/06/2023 19:51

@Howpo exactly right. It's a bit rich of @Florenz to blame Blair and brown for the benefits culture- who has been in power for the past13 years??

However if we are into that scenario may I give you Thatcher and selling off the utilities and social housing. We are still feeling the repercussions

SerendipityJane · 03/06/2023 19:22

Relying on international students is fine, their fees are much higher and subsidise domestic students.

Now tell that to the people who don't like foreign and see what they say ...

Oh we did. And they voted for a government (who lied they were going) to stop it

SunnyEgg · 03/06/2023 18:11

On high tuition fees Martin Lewis did a great session which I watched for Ds, they showed it at school

The majority will not pay back their university loans. He split the room by it and got to the near end of a semi circle before hitting students that would pay

His advice always take the loan you’ll likely not pay

SunnyEgg · 03/06/2023 18:07

TheThinkingGoblin · 03/06/2023 17:51

That has always been the case since they hiked tuition rates to £9k/year and cut Govt funding.

The UK is very dependent on international students.

Tertiary education is also one of the few world class "exports" the UK still has.

Trying to placate the mouth breathers from the red wall and the south will just damage the sector and make the UK poorer.

‘Mouth breathers’ isn’t a great term.

Relying on international students is fine, their fees are much higher and subsidise domestic students. Other countries do the same.

I do think plans to disrupt the education sector will damage our standing - which does feed into tertiary reputation

SerendipityJane · 03/06/2023 18:03

TheThinkingGoblin · 03/06/2023 17:51

That has always been the case since they hiked tuition rates to £9k/year and cut Govt funding.

The UK is very dependent on international students.

Tertiary education is also one of the few world class "exports" the UK still has.

Trying to placate the mouth breathers from the red wall and the south will just damage the sector and make the UK poorer.

Oh I know - my Uni was at it in the 80s when education became a product rather than a process.

Just I hadn't really thought about it until it was mentioned explicitly.

Worth remembering that Brexiteers are still quite happy to tank the entire UK economy, so I'm not sure why Universities think they will prevail where manufacturers haven't.

TheThinkingGoblin · 03/06/2023 17:51

SerendipityJane · 03/06/2023 17:31

I also note with interest that for all Big Bollocks Bravermans rhetoric, their limit on international students has been watered down as it turns out they subsidize domestic students.

A reason for immigration I hadn't really thought of till now. Nor, I suspect the voting public.

That has always been the case since they hiked tuition rates to £9k/year and cut Govt funding.

The UK is very dependent on international students.

Tertiary education is also one of the few world class "exports" the UK still has.

Trying to placate the mouth breathers from the red wall and the south will just damage the sector and make the UK poorer.

SerendipityJane · 03/06/2023 17:31

I also note with interest that for all Big Bollocks Bravermans rhetoric, their limit on international students has been watered down as it turns out they subsidize domestic students.

A reason for immigration I hadn't really thought of till now. Nor, I suspect the voting public.

SerendipityJane · 03/06/2023 17:28

Florenz · 03/06/2023 16:38

Blair and Brown are responsible for the "everyone's on benefits" culture where people say "what's the point in working more hours/getting a promotion, they'll reduce my benefits".

There is a lot of sense in ensuring as many people as possible are dependent on the government. It makes them easier to control.

Hence the growing hysteria of people who aren't dependent on handouts because they have paid their mortgage and retired.

(You will of course notice how pensions are never, ever described as benefits or handouts. And even if you haven't, I have.)

Howpo · 03/06/2023 17:25

... i'll just add that the UK having the worlds highest tuition fee's helps no one and who trebled those? at the same time removing the mtce grant and added it to student debt.. oh and withdrew the Nurse bursary?

I wonder if thats helped with NHS staff recruitment..

Howpo · 03/06/2023 17:16

@RosaGallica The Tories privatised almost all public utils and state owned enterprises.
Expansion of Uni's? Even now, only around 37% of young people go to Uni, slightly higher than EU comparable countries.
The world has moved on from on the job training for hi tech industries, you want to work for Airbus, you need a degree, same with nursing/AHP in most developed countries, its a degree course.

I take it you are referring to PFI ? well, what was the alternative? say TB had put education and nhs investment on the national balance sheet, then where would the ability to borrow come from in 2008 and again in 2020?
Or he didn't spend on the NHS? its already a disaster zone, in many areas, its simply not functioning.
Now you can complain about targets but what was access to MH services or elective treatments like in the 2000's ? whatever the individual problems, the NHS worked.

Lab left debt to gdp at approx 65%, it is now 100% and markets are losing confidence in our abilities to pay it back, Gilt Yields are rocketing, costing us a fortune in debt repayment interest.

@Florenz On Benefits & Taxation, the UK has long had an issue with DHSS and now DWP/HMRC penalising people who work over certain hours, Blair didn't do much about it and neither have the Tories after over 13 years in power, longer than Blair was in for.
Income support has been about in the UK for over 50 years, funnily enough Edward Heath expanded it the most.

Bottom line is, after 2 terms in power, any Govt has to be held account for what their achieved, 10 years is plenty of time to put right things the previous lot messed up, the Tories have spent most of the last 13years cutting services and arguing about Brexit/EU, that in itself was caused by Austerity & the cuts to regional funding.

RosaGallica · 03/06/2023 16:57

I dont disagree that austerity was a problem, or was carried too far. I do disagree with the idea that it was purely down to the Tories. Money was running out before the credit crunch, it was 2006 when many public sectors started to find themselves having serious issues due to ongoing ‘efficiency savings’, while public money was pulled out of the system both directly by handouts and by impoverishing working people, thereby reducing tax takes. Blair was an attempt, always obviously fundamentally misguided, to marry up private sector funding while destroying traditional public sector funding: he was a neoliberalist through and through.

Swipe left for the next trending thread