Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The problem with Brexit is we didn't Brexit hard enough

421 replies

Middlelanehogger · 01/06/2023 07:55

The EU itself was just the start.

But there are still more institutions which still influence our laws and make it impossible to actually achieve "taking back control".

If anything, we've left the trading bloc (which had economic benefits) but stayed in many of the legal institutions (which retain control over us).

So which body do we leave next - the ECHR? The ECJ? Keenly awaiting responses 😘

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
SunnyEgg · 01/06/2023 16:55

I also see people like you trying to argue that we should not return to CU/SM

I’m not sure that’s the case, nor see who this is aimed at. Personally I would have liked to see it as an issue to vote on at the GE. Unfortunately it’s been ruled out.

I don’t recall it as an explicit part of the Leave campaign though, happy to be proved wrong with examples

There’s been a fair bit of research into why people voted for Brexit, if you look it up you’ll see voters felt strongly about a couple of topics

FrippEnos · 01/06/2023 16:52

PaigeMatthews · 01/06/2023 11:22

wouldnt even have progressed if it was a trade union vote to strike.

I wonder whose fault it was that no safety measures where put in place?

TheThinkingGoblin · 01/06/2023 16:51

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

TheThinkingGoblin · 01/06/2023 16:49

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

FergalforPM · 01/06/2023 16:47

But not one single person in the country, not one, voted to leave the Single Market or the Customs Union
Of course this is true in the sense that those options were not on the ballot. However, it would be madness to imagine that there were not significant numbers who voted leave in the hope of also leaving those arrangements, as well as significant numbers of leave voters who expected us to remain in the SM and CU.

Dreamstate · 01/06/2023 16:42

And there we have it, now even remain voters start being nasty to other remain votes.

Dreamstate · 01/06/2023 16:38

CalistoNoSolo · 01/06/2023 16:35

Typical non-reply of a leave voter who is pretending they didn't vote leave, whilst defending the idiocy of their own actions by proxy. I gave up asking leavers for reasons a long time ago because their reasons just cemented in my mind the kinds of people they were, I certainly wasn't expecting any answers from you, or anything other than continued drivel tbh.

Just because I won't be nasty about people who did or be spewing some level of hatred about the vote, doesn't make me someone who is pretending.

I voted remain and that's a fact. If you refuse to believe me, well its pretty sad that you can't.

SunnyEgg · 01/06/2023 16:38

Daftasabroom · 01/06/2023 13:56

But not one single person in the country, not one, voted to leave the Single Market or the Customs Union. Zero, zilch, nada. Anyone who thinks they did is truly ignorant.

But not one single person in the country, not one, voted to leave the Single Market or the Customs Union

Where was this communicated to voters? Do you mean the Leave campaign explicitly outlined that we would not leave the SM and CU

One of top reasons for vote was immigration did they still define Brexit as including FOM in pamphlets / press etc

I’m not saying definitely not the case I just can’t recall the specifics being raised

Leave campaign was focussed on a couple of things which got the attention but maybe it was there too, are there any examples?

FergalforPM · 01/06/2023 16:38

LlynTegid · 01/06/2023 16:34

I see there are not 52% agreeing with the OP.

It isn't very clear what the voting options mean though.

Lily0719 · 01/06/2023 16:37

FixTheBone · 01/06/2023 08:10

I'll humour you.....

Please tell us how you think 'leaving the ECHR or ECJ' benefits the average, or indeed any UK citizen...

The fact sunak is in Moldova today, begging the EU to help with the 'immigration problem' that even having 'taken back control' we can't control is somewhere between hilarious and depressingly pathetic.

Posts like this

'this isn't the brexit we voted for' from brexiteers are a pathetic lack of ownership of their own ill-informed decision making and lack of insight, as, every remainer will tell you, this is exactly the brexit we voted against.

This!

FergalforPM · 01/06/2023 16:36

CalistoNoSolo · 01/06/2023 16:35

Typical non-reply of a leave voter who is pretending they didn't vote leave, whilst defending the idiocy of their own actions by proxy. I gave up asking leavers for reasons a long time ago because their reasons just cemented in my mind the kinds of people they were, I certainly wasn't expecting any answers from you, or anything other than continued drivel tbh.

Please can we stop this level of hatred?

CalistoNoSolo · 01/06/2023 16:35

Dreamstate · 01/06/2023 14:13

I never said I voted Leave I don't need to spend my time convincing you of reasons other people did. I don't though, brand other people stupid for decisions the made for their reasons.

Typical non-reply of a leave voter who is pretending they didn't vote leave, whilst defending the idiocy of their own actions by proxy. I gave up asking leavers for reasons a long time ago because their reasons just cemented in my mind the kinds of people they were, I certainly wasn't expecting any answers from you, or anything other than continued drivel tbh.

FergalforPM · 01/06/2023 16:35

RedToothBrush · 01/06/2023 16:09

They voted to leave the EU.

What they didn't vote for was HOW that should look.

The Vote Leave campaign very cleverly dodged this in order to appeal to as many people as possible. They deliberately framed it so Brexit looked like something different to every single leave voter.

And that's where the problems started. No one could agree on whether the result meant leaving the common market, the customer union or hard brexit. That's why it went round and round in circles in parliament.

There was and still isn't popular support for any individual form of Brexit.

People who voted for Leave did not vote for the Brexit we got. They voted for the Brexit they thought in their heads.

It was a vote AGAINST the status quo not a vote FOR the form of Brexit we have had.

Ultimately what happened was the hard right of the Tory Party highjacked this in various ways.

'Taking back control' ultimately wasn't about the UK taking back control - it was about the Tory Party and Elites taking back power from the people which the EU helped to protect. The ECHR story here is more of that.

We had a referendum that established we didn't want to remain in the EU but that vote DID NOT establish what we wanted instead.

This is an important distinction for CURRENT and FUTURE politics.

That's all true. It's pretty hard to see how the wishes of leavers (and for that matter remainers) about the type of Brexit we wanted could be enacted though since they are so divergent. This is one of the big problems with referenda when we have a representative democracy. In fact, contrary to some revisionist historians, we were not given an option on joining what was then the EEC, because we elected a Tory government and they had a mandate to sign us up, which they did.
The 1975 referendum was leave/remain, just like the 2016 one - but of course remain won.

LlynTegid · 01/06/2023 16:34

I see there are not 52% agreeing with the OP.

Onthechaiselongue · 01/06/2023 16:33

Anyone passionately advocating in either direction knows very little about EU membership, IMHO. EU membership is actually a mixed bag, and staying in the EU would have presented unique issues not faced had we not left. I think there are many hardline Brexiteers and remainders who don’t have a particularly strong knowledge of the other side of the argument. I appreciate the arguments in favour of remaining from studying the EU in my master’s degree, but equally appreciate the arguments in favour of leaving.
From what I’ve seen of the discussions of Brexit on Mumsnet, there tends to be a lack of fundamental understanding of EU law within a lot of the discussions. There is an awful lot of tribalism going on, and a lot of more-remainer-than-thou attitudes in a remainer echo chamber which fuels the toxicity.
The Tories may have been in power when Brexit was enacted but new rules and negotiations will inevitably take place once successive governments take hold, so the UK-EU relationship will evolve over time.

RedToothBrush · 01/06/2023 16:09

Howpo · 01/06/2023 13:53

An old argument but the fact remains that just 17.2m voted not to remain in the EU.... out of an electorate of 46m.

Now you can argue the numbers all you like but the cry that the UK voted to leave the EU is frankly bollox.

We didn't, a minority did, a rather small minority of utter idiots but there you go.

They voted to leave the EU.

What they didn't vote for was HOW that should look.

The Vote Leave campaign very cleverly dodged this in order to appeal to as many people as possible. They deliberately framed it so Brexit looked like something different to every single leave voter.

And that's where the problems started. No one could agree on whether the result meant leaving the common market, the customer union or hard brexit. That's why it went round and round in circles in parliament.

There was and still isn't popular support for any individual form of Brexit.

People who voted for Leave did not vote for the Brexit we got. They voted for the Brexit they thought in their heads.

It was a vote AGAINST the status quo not a vote FOR the form of Brexit we have had.

Ultimately what happened was the hard right of the Tory Party highjacked this in various ways.

'Taking back control' ultimately wasn't about the UK taking back control - it was about the Tory Party and Elites taking back power from the people which the EU helped to protect. The ECHR story here is more of that.

We had a referendum that established we didn't want to remain in the EU but that vote DID NOT establish what we wanted instead.

This is an important distinction for CURRENT and FUTURE politics.

Dreamstate · 01/06/2023 16:02

pointythings · 01/06/2023 15:47

@Dreamstate the old 'they're all as bad as each other' argument really doesn't hold water with this current government. If you think they're no worse, you haven't been paying attention.

And how can you say with certainty that other governments haven't been as corrupt or even more so than this one..they just hid it better. You can't really

MovinGroovinBarbie · 01/06/2023 16:02

It's easy to feel lost after leaving a controlling relationship but things usually get better with time. 😂

pointythings · 01/06/2023 15:47

@Dreamstate the old 'they're all as bad as each other' argument really doesn't hold water with this current government. If you think they're no worse, you haven't been paying attention.

FergalforPM · 01/06/2023 15:45

Howpo · 01/06/2023 15:16

My point is on the off trotted out "The UK voted for Brexit" nope, a minority did and an ever smaller one support it too, as older voters die off, younger ones become of age & we see the idiocy of our choice.

Its also a rather undemocratic too, as there is no means to have another vote to change ones mind, as we do with a GE.

We are tied to this vote, regardless of its consequences, probably for the next 15 to 20 years as a minimum.

Everyone had the opportunity to vote and turnout was relatively high. In terms of a representation of the voting intentions, it actually reflected the votes cast more accurately than most elections due to our shit electoral system.
In fact, I reckon we'd never have had the referendum if we had a better electoral system. It really only happened because David Cameron was trying to face down the UKIP infiltrators in the Tory party.

Absolem76 · 01/06/2023 15:33

The 'morons' you refer to would be most of the people in the UK. Perhaps your GP, your neighbours, even family and friends.
Most of the people in the UK didn't vote for Brexit (and I know for certain that my GP didn't nor my friends!)
Of those who voted a small majority voted leave but it's wasn't the majority of people in the UK, many people didn't vote, and some weren't eligible for a variety of reasons.

Absolem76 · 01/06/2023 15:26

No, the problem is that some people seem to think that a small Island like the UK doesn't need to have close economic and political ties with its nearest neighbours.
The UK had a very privileged position within the EU with a veto on any regulations. We have lost that forever just because some people wanted to go back to a 1950s paradise that never existed anyway. There was a very good reason that the UK fought so hard to get into the EU in the first place!

Dreamstate · 01/06/2023 15:19

pointythings · 01/06/2023 15:04

It's ironic and sad that people going on about EU corruption have landed us with the most corrupt government since probably time immemorial.

The EU acted when they found out about the Qatar bribes. Our government just carries on and does nothing. And yes, I consider people who still support them to be stupid. Because if they aren't, they are immoral.

Name one government that isn't corrupt? Doesn't matter how corrupt they are, they all are. Doesn't matter what party gets voted in the UK, they have all been corrupt.

Dreamstate · 01/06/2023 15:17

Izzabird · 01/06/2023 14:53

But nobody is questioning their 'right'. On the other hand, it seems quite strange to be unable to acknowledge that some decisions are stupid, and made for demonstrably stupid reasons.

Stupid to whom? To you - you think tis stupid. To person making it, it isn't.

Howpo · 01/06/2023 15:16

FergalforPM · 01/06/2023 14:08

The leave vote was not a minority in the same way general elections mostly are.

Only just over 16million people voted to remain - an actual minority of those voting, and a smaller proportion of the 46million electorate than the 17 million who voted to leave.

In general elections the majority of people who vote usually vote for parties other than the one that gains power. In the most recent election, only a little over 43% of those voting voted Tory, the remaining 57% voted for other parties.

My point is on the off trotted out "The UK voted for Brexit" nope, a minority did and an ever smaller one support it too, as older voters die off, younger ones become of age & we see the idiocy of our choice.

Its also a rather undemocratic too, as there is no means to have another vote to change ones mind, as we do with a GE.

We are tied to this vote, regardless of its consequences, probably for the next 15 to 20 years as a minimum.