Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The problem with Brexit is we didn't Brexit hard enough

421 replies

Middlelanehogger · 01/06/2023 07:55

The EU itself was just the start.

But there are still more institutions which still influence our laws and make it impossible to actually achieve "taking back control".

If anything, we've left the trading bloc (which had economic benefits) but stayed in many of the legal institutions (which retain control over us).

So which body do we leave next - the ECHR? The ECJ? Keenly awaiting responses 😘

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
RedToothBrush · 01/06/2023 20:24

You can believe in democracy and you can also believe that people didn't understand that voting against something is different to voting for something.

What was undemocratic was the lack of public vote on what should follow our exit from the EU.

Therein lies the issue.

Florenz · 01/06/2023 20:02

At the end of the day, more people didn't want to be in the EU than did. Which is why Brexit won the vote. If the EU was that good, people wouldn't have voted to leave it. You can't blame public ignorance. It's the same public that vote in every general election. You either believe in democracy, and accept that votes will sometimes go the way you don't want them to, or you don't believe in democracy.

Clavinova · 01/06/2023 20:01

On the question of the SM and CU : many leave campaigners were stating quite explicitly that the UK was not leaving these bodies.

22 February 2016
EU referendum: Ukip leader Nigel Farage says he doesn’t want to be part of the European Single Market

Leader of the UK Independence Party Nigel Farage has said that he doesn't want the United Kingdom to be a part of the the European Single Market, but instead wants the UK to "stand on its own two feet".
https://www.cityam.com/eu-referendum-ukip-leader-nigel-farage-says-he-doesnt-want-to-be-part-of-the-european-single-market/

12 April 2016
Michael Gove gambles as he rejects single market membership

Today, in a lengthy, cerebral and frequently humorous speech, Michael Gove ate his cake. He announced that the UK would not apply for membership of the single market but would instead seek a free trade agreement with the EU.
https://www.newstatesman.com/business/economics/2016/04/michael-gove-gambles-he-rejects-single-market-membership

13 June 2016
MailOnline looks at what the future could hold for the UK if we vote OUT on June 23

Vote Leave have repeatedly insisted during the campaign that we should exit the single market - a free trade area for goods and services - and establish a bespoke package of terms.

Full membership of the area could involve contributing to the Brussels budget and accepting the principle of freedom of movement, which would hamper the ability of UK ministers to bring immigration under control.
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3639242/Brexit-nightmare-brave-new-world-MailOnline-looks-future-hold-UK-vote-June-23.html

ichundich · 01/06/2023 19:59

khw666 · 01/06/2023 13:38

Also most people who live near me would not even know we'd had Brexit if you didnt tell them. Ask most of them and they've not got a clue.

This will obviously make some people sigh with relief and others be extremely frustrated depending on whether you are a remain or leaver.

Which begs the question what was the point?

It also begs another question: why should we rejoin (if the EU agreed to it - maybe our billions pumped in may help eh 😁) but what would we gain?

I'm talking about folk who live near me. Normal salt of the earth, not rich people who employ nannies at cheap rates. What would joining the EU do for normal everyday working class folk? Because we hear a lot of privileged people moan they cannot live in an EU country for over 90 days or their kids cant go skiing and work in the chalet and I know that is annoying, but your ordinary josephine like me could never do that anyway and there's loads of us in the UK.

Would it make lives better or worse or stay the same? I dont think I see much difference in my life either way.

So you haven't noticed the empty supermarket shelves a few weeks ago when no vegetables were delivered to the UK (whilst they pretty much continued to the EU) or the long queues at petrol stations because of the lack of lorry drivers? What about EU grants that used to benefit your community (cycling paths, Book Start) which have now stopped coming? Or the delay in being seen at your local hospital because EU workers went back home? Or the fact the Britain paid the highest energy prices in Europe last winter?

Clavinova · 01/06/2023 19:48

But not one single person in the country, not one, voted to leave the Single Market or the Customs Union

Hansard - House of Commons Wednesday 15 June 2016

[David Cameron] The Prime Minister

I am very happy to agree with my hon. Friend. “In” means we remain in a reformed EU; “out” means we come out. As the leave campaigners and others have said, “out” means out of the EU, out of the European single market, out of the Council of Minister - out of all those things -
https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2016-06-15/debates/517E6CB0-162A-461D-A907-CD10C3FA7382/Engagements?highlight=single%20market#contribution-2C1D076D-5F0E-4F7A-A16D-8E40A8BA4833

Abhannmor · 01/06/2023 19:47

*flaw not flag..

Abhannmor · 01/06/2023 19:44

On the question of the SM and CU : many leave campaigners were stating quite explicitly that the UK was not leaving these bodies. People saying otherwise were lumped in with Project Fear.

Johnson , Farage , Daniel Hannan all said trade would go on exactly as before. Then the Good Friday Agreement , of course they knew it would cause problems. But they decided to plunge on regardless.

One Brexiloon ( Hoey?) said it wasn't written in stone anyway. Gove said it was ' treason'. Boris Johnson said it was ' just a footnote in history' . So they could just ignore it and hang the consequences. And here we are.

Now...Will Ukraine join the EU in 15 years? Not a hope. The lads learnt a hard lesson with Greece joining the Euro. Not to mention Brexit. Rapid expansion was probably the EU's major flag in retrospect. Of which Britain was a great proponent lest we forget.

So , the EU is not perfect but it's the only game in town.

Clavinova · 01/06/2023 19:37

But not one single person in the country, not one, voted to leave the Single Market or the Customs Union

We quite clearly voted to leave the single market:

June 12 2016
David Cameron confirmed that he will pull Britain out of the single market if there is a vote to leave the European Union at the upcoming referendum...
The prime minister said: “What the British public will be voting for is to leave the EU and leave the single market.”
https://www.politico.eu/article/david-cameron-bbc-andrew-marr-ill-pull-uk-out-of-the-single-market-after-brexit-eu-referendum-vote-june-23-consequences-news/

June 3 2016
5 takeaways from David Cameron’s first Brexit TV ‘debate’

3. Single market, single market, single market
If Cameron had one job Thursday night, it was to bring the debate back to the economy.
The Remain campaign clearly believe Gove and Johnson have committed a major strategic error by calling for Britain to leave the single market, with Cameron returning to it again and again. “I keep going on about the single market, but it’s so important,” he said at one point, in a sentence that summed up his entire debate strategy.
https://www.politico.eu/blogs/on-media/2016/06/5-takeaways-from-david-camerons-first-brexit-tv-debate/

Clavinova · 01/06/2023 19:37

RedToothBrush
Remind me about the process of joining the EU, how long other nations have been in it and what the criteria are. And who has the power to veto.
Oh yes. Reality

The reality is that you are relying on the government of the day to exercise its veto - and vote in accordance with your wishes.

StaunchMomma · 01/06/2023 19:28

CalistoNoSolo · 01/06/2023 07:59

I guess this is probably how the morons who voted to leave would see things. It seems to me though, that the only thing standing in the way of the Tories stripping away all of my rights is EU legislation.

👏👏👏👏👏

RedToothBrush · 01/06/2023 19:04

Clavinova · 01/06/2023 19:00

Lonelycrab
Or Turkey joining the Eu?

Ukraine might join the EU in 10/15 years' time - population of over 40 million and the poorest country in Europe even before the war started.

Remind me about the process of joining the EU, how long other nations have been in it and what the criteria are. And who has the power to veto.

Oh yes. Reality.

Ukraine won't join within the next 20 years at the very least, despite talk. It won't be ready. It's more likely to be 30 before it's a realistic proposal.

RedToothBrush · 01/06/2023 19:00

IamSlave · 01/06/2023 18:54

Red during the time of the vote and after many very eloquent leave voters went into the great detail as to why they voted leave.
Unfortunately the response was immovable like a bricks wall no one could penetrate.

Yes. They did argue.

They argued that the Good Friday Agreement didn't matter and wasn't their problem. Til it was and even the US intervened.

They argued we could get trade deals with the rest of the world. Til they couldn't.

They argued that we could just decide on a deal and the EU would agree. Til the EU said 'uh no'.

They argued it was just remainers being difficult and pessimistic. Til red tape just stopped businesses trading backwards and forwards at all cos it wasn't worth the headache.

They argued that a hard brexit wasn't going to be a big deal and wouldn't affect the border. Til they had massive queues at all the ports and the tunnel.

They said no one would vote to be poorer. Til we were.

Yep. As I say. Fantasists. Utter fantasists.

I'm done with arguing. It's pointless.

Clavinova · 01/06/2023 19:00

Lonelycrab
Or Turkey joining the Eu?

Ukraine might join the EU in 10/15 years' time - population of over 40 million and the poorest country in Europe even before the war started.

Abhannmor · 01/06/2023 18:58

I'll just assume this is a wind up OP. Although , considering you've burnt all your boats perhaps you could leave the planet? Or even the solar system.

Who knows what sunlit uplands await in Alpha Centauri.

ElmTree22 · 01/06/2023 18:57

CalistoNoSolo · 01/06/2023 07:59

I guess this is probably how the morons who voted to leave would see things. It seems to me though, that the only thing standing in the way of the Tories stripping away all of my rights is EU legislation.

👏🏻

IamSlave · 01/06/2023 18:54

Red during the time of the vote and after many very eloquent leave voters went into the great detail as to why they voted leave.
Unfortunately the response was immovable like a bricks wall no one could penetrate.

RedToothBrush · 01/06/2023 18:54

Some people like to live in a simple fantasy world. Everyone else has to deal with reality of not living in a bubble or a time warp for them.

I spent five years arguing the point. And I'm wise enough to see that there's some people who are simply divorced from the concept of distance, supply chains and other people also doing the best for their own country.

RedToothBrush · 01/06/2023 18:51

Rolls eyes.

Ok.

Carry on.

Lonelycrab · 01/06/2023 18:51

Mission creep

Is that the same mission creep that said that the Eu are going to form an army that we would all be powerlessly conscripted into?

Or Turkey joining the Eu?

These things were said to be upon us if we remain, and yet they don’t look at all likely seven years on from the vote.

How can you claim mission creep if the things we were supposed to be creeping towards were infact untrue in the first place?

IamSlave · 01/06/2023 18:49

Red I wouldn't be able too explain much if you have no context to pin it too

overworkedovertaxed · 01/06/2023 18:49

KrisAkabusi · 01/06/2023 11:15

Never forget that 50% of the population is of below-average intelligence!

And yet 99.99% of the population have more than the average number of legs. Try harder.

RedToothBrush · 01/06/2023 18:46

IamSlave · 01/06/2023 18:36

Oh yes the tunnel.... Linked us to the eu.

Red in the nicest way that's the absolute weakest argument I've ever come across!

How so?

Please explain to me how changes in our supply chains which meant we increased the amount of trade we did with the EU and made us more reliant on it and how trade barriers and borders within the EU being removed made it harder for us to compete with the internal market. And how the EU regulations that we adhered to, as part of the EU which we still have to comply with if we want to trade suddenly disappeared. Or how the cost of shipping shit from the other side of the world compared to driving it from our neighbours suddenly was going to make everything cheaper with the decline in reserves of fossil fuels.

Seriously. You haven't a scooby do if you thought we could return the world in 1991 on leaving. You really are deluded and naive.

You can try and argue the case until you are blue in the face, but we simply would not have had all the upheaval and political instability if it were that easy.

If you think my argument is 'the weakest' I really think you need to go read seven years worth of Hansard records.

IamSlave · 01/06/2023 18:36

Oh yes the tunnel.... Linked us to the eu.

Red in the nicest way that's the absolute weakest argument I've ever come across!

RedToothBrush · 01/06/2023 18:33

IamSlave · 01/06/2023 18:25

I don't think it was that complicated. They're imply remembered that we had been independent.

The eu also started as a trading block and morphed into so many other things areas of life.

Mission creep.

Red it's extremely important however to remember history.

History will tell us that every single alliance in the past in Europe failed. History will also show us how the baddies took over in many guises.

Many people, historians among them simply didn't want another layer of government on top of our own. A government in the shadows no less who we don't really know.

Benn? Who are they, can we take their power away?

A government taking billions form eu countries and losing it downloaded the black hole of corruption.

Interesting that corbyn and his cronies we're on the same side as the tories.

You can only move forward taking into account change and history.

You can't separate the two.

In 1991 we didn't have the tunnel. Joining the EU and the opening of the tunnel changed our travel and transportation methods and our supply chains forever.

It meant we could import and export much more easily and became dependent on that relationship which relied on minimal border checks.

In forgetting all this in a nostalgic rose tinted view of the world, we were exposed to problems.

That's why it's staggeringly naive.

We couldn't return to 1991.

In voting against the EU without acknowledging these issues never mind addressing them before the referendum we doomed ourselves to a right mess.

That's before you even think about the implications of the Good Friday Agreement.

I stand by my point and triple down on it. And then times it by infinity.

No one knew what they were voting FOR when they voted leave. They could only possibly know what they were voting against.

IamSlave · 01/06/2023 18:29

@CuriouslyDifferent

Don't be cross with that poster.

People have been really afraid and don't know their names history. They may havr no context or perspective and they are really frightened.

Not everyone did a proper investigation and research into both sides pros and cons, casting the net wide to really make an informed descion