Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Phillip schofield scandal is homophobia?

913 replies

ivfregret · 01/06/2023 00:00

Have I missed something in that the guy Philip had the affair with was not a minor?

He was a minor when they met, as was Cheryl Cole and Liam Payne for example and no one has anything bad to say about that relationship.

I'm not sticking up for Philip and really dislike him, and also think even if the runner was above the age of consent is most definitely questionable behaviour but I can't help think of it was a heterosexual affair it would not be treated in the same way?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
Namechangenoidea · 01/06/2023 07:12

Is it normal a 17 year old boy with a 50 year old man? Do you think the 17 year old boy would have had the affair with a different 50 year old man? Or was it because he was famous it seemed more appealing? Would you not be furious if you had a 17 year old son that was dating a 50 year old! I think it’s an absolutely disgusting and I honestly think he should be arrested.

YellowAndGreenToBeSeen · 01/06/2023 07:11

Oh - and fellow main presenter pulling away to due to all above and saying ‘him or me’ publicly. That was the catalyst. Plus the fact that everyone in the industry knew.

YellowAndGreenToBeSeen · 01/06/2023 07:09

If being gay was an issue in the entertainment world, there’d be no telly, newspapers, theatre, films or music. This is a big story due to a number of factors reaching boiling point:

Abuse of a position of power

Possible grooming at worst / distasteful at best

Portraying a ‘family man’ image whilst clearly not

Using a show to stop a story breaking (I’m gay’)

Brothers crimes

Queue Gate

Alleged imperious and arrogant attitude on set

Allegedly dismissive of and rude to fellow presenters

Management allowing Talent to become bigger than the show

Fellow presenters being sick of all the above

A Talent agency cutting all ties to protect rest of stable

TeaYarn · 01/06/2023 07:09

I don’t think calling out PS is homophobic. He deserves all that he’s getting.

But I know there hasn’t been any sort of witch-hunt against straight men who have done very similar, if not worse things.

MN wouldn’t see the same posts if PS was a woman.

I guess it’s just a happy coincidence for a lot of people that PS is a gay man.

ProfessorXtra · 01/06/2023 07:04

People did make a big deal about Cheryl and Liam at the time. However, when they started dating it was many years after the X factor. If someone comes forward and says she was actually mentoring him from being young, getting him jobs on shows she worked on and holding his career in her hand and lying then it fair enough it’s the same. They didn’t have an affair and Liam Payne didn’t lose his job when it was over. By all accounts they didn’t have much contact between the X factor and getting together almost 7 years later when they were both adults. I find it odd, as she had met him as a child, but I don’t think it’s the same scale.

The PS thing isn’t homophobia. In fact PS used his sexuality to try an avoid the truth coming out at allZ The only reason he came out was because of this rumour. By coming out he switched the focus and no one could critique him. He was portrayed as brave and vulnerable. It was ‘oh poor Philip having to hide he is sexuality his entire life’. It was a huge distraction technique.

PS, by some accounts, had close contact with the person in question from being young. Not only got him a job on this morning, but managed to get him on screen and involved in all sorts…..because he was sleeping with him. Not sure there’s any evidence Cheryl was doing that for Liam. It means the older person is in a position of power.

He then lied about it. announced he was gay when it might be coming out. Then had the young man moved from TM when they split. Apparently, told everyone (and convinced them) this young man was lying about the affair, which negatively impacted his career.

Did Cheryl tell everyone Liam was a liar and ruin his career? Did Cheryl damage Liam to hide their relationship?

In my early 30s I couldn’t have dated someone I had known at 14. I would it find it odd. There’s definite differences between the 2 and it’s not the sexuality of the people involved.

I am in my 40s now. But if I got an 18 year old a job at my employer, pushed to give them opportunities others didn’t get because I was sleeping with them, then destroyed their career when it was in danger of coming out, even if I met them when they were 18, I would expect to be sacked and have my professional reputation destroyed. If my job involved media and I made alot of money using my ‘nice woman persona’ to present to the public and was a public figure, I would expect huge backlash.

Bintymcbintface · 01/06/2023 07:04

No, the sexuality of the people involved has nothing to do with it. It's more the fact that Schofe "mentored" the guy when he was a kid and later entered into a secret relationship with him, it very much seems like a dodgy grooming situation and the reaction to that isn't at all homophobic but rather being rightfully outraged at disgusting predatory behavior

crunchingupeyeballshohohoho · 01/06/2023 07:01

I think the idea that teens are children and not 'fair game' is quite a recent one. The Beatles and the stones, not to mention Elvis, all had sex with teenagers. They even wrote songs about it. Suddenly we've switched to (rightly so) condemning it as child abuse, which it mostly definitely is. That doesn't mean people like PS saw it as such. There are other famous couples who met when one was a teen, such as Aaron Johnson and that predator director woman.

GeorginaBell · 01/06/2023 06:59

nancy75 · 01/06/2023 00:20

I actually think he’s been let off for a long time because he’s gay.

When he first came out he was all over the place being ‘brave and strong’.
If he’d been married & having an affair with a (much younger) woman he would have been called out as a lying, cheating ratbag. Because he’d been unfaithful with men he was brave 🙄

He was seen as brave because unknown to others he felt he was. No mention of other men in his life at the time. Now we know he had to come out because this story was going to. Not fair on the gay community to have this tarnished but there is good and bad in everything.

Soontobe60 · 01/06/2023 06:55

ivfregret · 01/06/2023 00:06

I think it would be less of a scandal yes

That’s misogyny for you 🙄

GeorginaBell · 01/06/2023 06:52

MegaManic · 01/06/2023 02:21

If anything his declaration of being gay protected him.

Are you seriously suggesting that - if PS had an affair with a 19 girl he had met whilst she was a teenager (possibly younger) and that she worked in the show as a runner whilst he was the shows star and when they split up she was moved on - it would be less of a scandal? Not to mention the fact he was married at the time. It would have been a far bigger story.

He tried to get away with it by coming out as gay and even submitted legal complaints about newspapers who threatened to expose it assuming the young man would continue to lie for him.

The only real homophobia I can see is that for a very long time people clearly didn't care that the young man involved was clearly exploited. If it was a teenage girl it would have been exposed long ago.

It’s obvious that also this young man was and still is vulnerable in some way and that is heartbreaking. I doubt when it comes to his and Holly's rudeness that everyone who has spoken out is wrong either. He was my idol growing up on tv when my father was aggressive and awful I often would wish PS was my dad because he looked kinder. The irony.

Hellenabe · 01/06/2023 06:48

When this came out a while back (when PS actually came out), I mentioned the rumours to my gay friend and he said it was all homophbic and a witch hunt. I wonder if gay men think this is a non issue.

I've been at parties where the man is in his 70s and the partner in their early 20s. No one bats an eyelid.

I'd add that I'm straight and I think this all feels like grooming and bullying.

Willmafrockfit · 01/06/2023 06:33

interesting
how would people react if it was a female runner that he groomed?
better/worse?
probably still appalled

Freefall212 · 01/06/2023 06:32

The runner was born in March of 1996.

The date of the pictures of the visit at the theatre company are known and verifiable.

I don’t know why people keep making up ages. Some facts are well facts and he was a certain age (15) in the picture no matter if you think he looks 9 or 10 or 12 or 15 or 18.

I have not seen any evidence of contact between them before 2011 and the only evidence of contact between 2011 and 2014 (when he turned 18) is the photo of the visit and online Twitter interactions.

I have no idea what did or didn’t happen between them, I am just saying that most of it is speculation.

TheFairyCaravan · 01/06/2023 06:28

There’s no homophobia.

PS is a predator. We’ve known this since he came out, but ITV etc tried to convince us he was “stunning and brave.” PS abused his power and groomed a young boy, just because he allegedly waited until he was of legal age to have sex with him doesn’t make it ok.

I think this is the tip of a very large iceberg and won’t be shocked if a whole can of worms is opened very soon tbh.

SequinsandStilettos · 01/06/2023 06:28

If it had been a girl she would have been reported as having had far more agency in the whole thing.
Yes. Look at Virginia Giuffre.
Had the runner been female then Patriarchy dictates the reframing of the mentee as a Lolita/money grabber/sleeping her way to the top/bitter/kiss n tell blackmailer/Fatal Attraction psycho bunny. Have I missed any out?
Whereas I have only seen one paparazzo account that is disparaging to the runner, along the lines of how very dare he threaten to expose the affair?

I think the 34 year age gap, the work experience/patronage, the NDA/pay off and the orchestrated coming out have all played their part in sceptical people condemning the affair. That the couple are gay is by the by except for self-imposed reporting restrictions no longer doxxing/outing people.

Had the press publicly outed Phil, there may have been an outcry (see Rebel Wilson).
Had the co-workers done anything other than applaud Phil's coming out, then they would have been deemed homophobic.
Even co-presenters who were openly gay at the time - Ranj, Rylan, Dan - were put into a tricky situation. Do you call him out, understanding that twink/cub-bear/gerontophilia are not uncommon sub-cultures?
Do you call him out, knowing the history of homophobia that gay = predatory/pederast? Do you really want to add to that?

Phil's coming out itself was deeply cynical - note that it did not work for Kevin Spacey - Holly could have refused to go along with it.

Add to that a work-culture of playing hard, the runner not necessarily perceiving themselves as gay when they joined TM and the abuse of power in sleeping with a protégé you're mentoring: it's little wonder that it has become a scandal.

Timing is everything. Three years ago, # be kind and lockdowns played into ITV's hands. They had successfully taken the heat off Phil and made the story go away.
Three years later - and Phil's brother being a convicted paedophile - the writing was on the wall. Holly's PR recognised that weeks ago hence the desperate bid to extricate her.

PTSDBarbiegirl · 01/06/2023 06:23

PopcorningPancakingWheeking · 01/06/2023 00:06

It's because he cheated on his wife. Understandably people are upset about that. He isn't a victim. He didn't have to marry.

Sorry but how do you know his wife is not also gay? Marriages of convenience with children are not that uncommon in some circles! It's incredibly naive to say 'his poor wife didn't know'. Of course his wife and daughters knew. They didn't live together but PS is a lowlife, grooming deviant who targets very young males who will be desperate to impress and uses them. He's a massive narcissist.

YouJustDoYou · 01/06/2023 06:22

lemonchiffonpie · 01/06/2023 02:50

He came out as gay to hide the fact he was a pederast. It is not homophobic to object to the way he used and discarded a vulnerable teenage boy.

This

JingsMahBucket · 01/06/2023 06:21

Lovingitallnow · 01/06/2023 03:53

I agree if it had been a girl the scandal wouldn't have been as big and wouldn't have been reported the same way. If it was a girl I think there would have been an awful lot more discussion about the affair aspect, and also the various ways that she manipulated him into giving her a career and cheating on his wife and making her the temptress. Whether the reaction is different because of homophobia, misogyny or patriarchy I don't know. But I do agree if it had been a girl she would have been reported as having had far more agency in the whole thing.

The Liam and Cheryl comparison is ridiculous.

Definitely agree.

Mykingdomforanap · 01/06/2023 06:21

I agree with Mrs terry pratchet. It would have been less of a scandal if it was a girl - not due to homophobia but due to misogyny.

User18538754 · 01/06/2023 06:21

CrazyArmadilloLady · 01/06/2023 02:57

Are you coming back to your thread @ivfregret?

There’s no shame in admitting you were wrong.

They will be in bed I guess at this time.

JingsMahBucket · 01/06/2023 06:20

@ivfregret YANBU. There’s definitely a homophobia vibe going around. Like “See, we knew we couldn’t trust them” even though most grooming is done by heterosexual men.

StandingMyGround888 · 01/06/2023 06:16

I can't believe people are drawing comparisons with Savile.

Chchchchchangesss · 01/06/2023 06:14

ivfregret · 01/06/2023 00:00

Have I missed something in that the guy Philip had the affair with was not a minor?

He was a minor when they met, as was Cheryl Cole and Liam Payne for example and no one has anything bad to say about that relationship.

I'm not sticking up for Philip and really dislike him, and also think even if the runner was above the age of consent is most definitely questionable behaviour but I can't help think of it was a heterosexual affair it would not be treated in the same way?

The child was 10 years old when they first met for fucks sake. Phil was in a position of massive power, which he used to get this child into his grasp.

Why are some people so keen to shut down concerns of grooming by shouting homophobia?

He groomed a child. Just because he appears to have waited until that child was an adult before having sex with him it doesn't make it ok.

If phil the plumber from down your road took an unhealthy interest in your child from your child being 10-14 years old, and then started a relationship with your child, with a 34 year age gap, you wouldn't be concerned at this?

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 01/06/2023 06:12

nancy75 · 01/06/2023 00:20

I actually think he’s been let off for a long time because he’s gay.

When he first came out he was all over the place being ‘brave and strong’.
If he’d been married & having an affair with a (much younger) woman he would have been called out as a lying, cheating ratbag. Because he’d been unfaithful with men he was brave 🙄

Exactly. Fuck off with the 'homophobia'. He was let off easy for his behaviour before. There's a massive power imbalance. PS deserves every bad piece of press from this.

EggDaisy · 01/06/2023 06:01

He had to declare "the relationship was not illegal."

The fact he thought this was a good thing to say tells you everything.

I've personally never had to explain any of my relationships as "not illegal"!!!

He's a predator, pure and simple.