Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Phillip schofield scandal is homophobia?

913 replies

ivfregret · 01/06/2023 00:00

Have I missed something in that the guy Philip had the affair with was not a minor?

He was a minor when they met, as was Cheryl Cole and Liam Payne for example and no one has anything bad to say about that relationship.

I'm not sticking up for Philip and really dislike him, and also think even if the runner was above the age of consent is most definitely questionable behaviour but I can't help think of it was a heterosexual affair it would not be treated in the same way?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
BeachBlondey · 01/06/2023 09:59

It's the Casting Couch, isn't it? Thoroughly wrong, but rife in the entertainment industry.

Gcsunnyside23 · 01/06/2023 09:57

I definitely thought it was really weird about Cheryl and liam too but he was definitely an adult when things happened and hadn't much interaction in between or even at the time they met. With Philip there is suggestion of grooming, he met him as a young minor, because a mentor and got him a job, kept him close and they got involved while he was married when the boy was still a questionable age. At the end of the day he was a married man carrying on with a young lad, if it was a young girl the reaction would be the same. Also he didn't go to the police about his brother sexually interacting with a young boy which makes him complicit. None of this is homophobic, it's about him being a sleazeball and being protected and allowed to be in a position which facilitated it

WakeMeUpWhenGoodOmensIsBack · 01/06/2023 09:49

PerfectYear321 · 01/06/2023 01:30

Does anyone actually believe this?

His wife knew he was gay. It was obviously an open marriage

And this is why I think it might actually have been worse for PS in some ways if this young person was a girl.

Most people give him a pass on the adultery because they assume (rightly or wrongly) that his wife was well aware that he was gay and they had some kind of arrangement. If he'd been having an affair with a much younger woman then he'd obviously have been cheating on her.

Quitelikeit · 01/06/2023 09:44

PosseGalore · 01/06/2023 09:05

Okay…I am going to get a lot of flak for this, but why do people say he “groomed” the boy? It is a very loaded word which in my mind we use conventionally to discuss the way that paedophiles lure children (and those around them) into their control so that they can abuse the child.

Schofield is a very famous man. He can have a relationship with almost anyone he chosen - young or old. I would guess that before his downfall most people he met were dazzled by his fame - no need to “groom” them.

People using the idea of grooming in the Schofield case are giving out a dog whistle to say that he likes underage boys but his relationship with McGreevy - strictly speaking - doesn’t demonstrate that, although it doesn’t make their relationship any less inappropriate, which it would be in any professional setting.

I would contend that the use of the word “groomed” in Schofield’s case is actually homophobic, that in casting the relationship as paedophilic we are displaying our unconscious biases towards gay sexuality.

TRIGGER WARNING
(I would like to add that I am a survivor of child sexual abuse and my experience of grooming was that the paedophile convinced those around him that he was a fine upstanding man who could be trusted with children. I was seven when it happened and he lost interest when I was 12. That is paedophilia)

You are correct in that the definition of a paedophile is someone with an interest in children under 13

but what about 13/14 & 15 year olds or just an interest in young teens

I don’t know if the law needs revisiting

I am so sorry about what happened to you. I hope you are well and that the perpetrator suffers and was punished with the full might of the law.

hugs to you

Blancmangemouse · 01/06/2023 09:44

I get what you mean OP, but I think what has blown it up has been all the lying and denials before now. If it was just ‘weird but ok’ why would PS be so secretive about it?
That has made it all seem much, much more seedy.

Cherry2010 · 01/06/2023 09:43

Freefall212 · 01/06/2023 09:19

Yes, this has been known for years as some of the boys have posted screenshots of their snap conversations on social media. They were all pretty mundane conversations.

But with the context of his involvement with this young lad, at best it’s showing an interest in young boys. The boys he was sending Snapchat messages to in my sons school were year 9 :aged 14/15.
if you don’t find that unsavoury I think you will find an excuse for anything and we will just have to disagree.

DollyParkin · 01/06/2023 09:42

The young man was NOT of age when Schofield first started a “mentoring” relationship. It’s worth listening to The Newsagents podcast on this. By journalists who know this sort of stuff.

Quitelikeit · 01/06/2023 09:40

Freefall212 · 01/06/2023 09:03

Philip was known to have many dalliances and trysts with men ever since the 1990s. It wasn't really a secret at all that he was gay. The gay world knew he was gay but he hadn't come out publicly so they respected that.

He had his own apartment. I am sure his wife knew as well, long before he came out publicly.

This Spitting Image clip was made in 1992 I think (could be wrong year in the 1990s). There was already a lot of speculation about him being gay then.

Yikes!! So do you think Jason Donovan is too

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 01/06/2023 09:40

LostFrog · 01/06/2023 08:33

I don’t know if it’s homophobia, but I agree that the public reaction is bigger than I would expect. Maybe people just didn’t like him and were waiting for a concrete reason not to. He always seemed nice to me, but I didn’t want watch This Morning so I’m basing that off CBBC about 35 years ago! Maybe it is also the context of his brother.

You have to take into account the fact that many people bought into the ‘charm’ and nice boy/ man next door appeal that has comprised PS career (nothing to do with me, I’ve never seen his programmes and I didn’t know who he was until Waitrose started to plaster him all over their wine list for no apparent reason). So I think there is an element of personal disappointment and disillusion which adds to the condemnation. His ‘fans’ feel let down by him, and maybe by the much too late repudiation by his costar who was like an onscreen ‘wife’ .Mr and Mrs Clean are now Mr and Mrs Tawdry.

The rest of the soi disant celebs ( KK!) who are piling on are just desperate for a bit of exposure, and maybe don’t understand that their behaviour is probably only highlighting their own lack of dignity and judgement.

QueenieMe · 01/06/2023 09:40

PosseGalore · 01/06/2023 09:05

Okay…I am going to get a lot of flak for this, but why do people say he “groomed” the boy? It is a very loaded word which in my mind we use conventionally to discuss the way that paedophiles lure children (and those around them) into their control so that they can abuse the child.

Schofield is a very famous man. He can have a relationship with almost anyone he chosen - young or old. I would guess that before his downfall most people he met were dazzled by his fame - no need to “groom” them.

People using the idea of grooming in the Schofield case are giving out a dog whistle to say that he likes underage boys but his relationship with McGreevy - strictly speaking - doesn’t demonstrate that, although it doesn’t make their relationship any less inappropriate, which it would be in any professional setting.

I would contend that the use of the word “groomed” in Schofield’s case is actually homophobic, that in casting the relationship as paedophilic we are displaying our unconscious biases towards gay sexuality.

TRIGGER WARNING
(I would like to add that I am a survivor of child sexual abuse and my experience of grooming was that the paedophile convinced those around him that he was a fine upstanding man who could be trusted with children. I was seven when it happened and he lost interest when I was 12. That is paedophilia)

PS actually met him first when the boy was 10-12 at a theatre school (there are pix of that meeting) and reconnected at 15 when the boy followed on him on Twitter. Over the course of the next two years they remained in contact with PS saying he could get the boy his TV break, which he did at 17/18 with work experience at This Morning. That mean the boy, already in his thrall, owed him. PS then abused his power by entering into a relationship with him. That's how he groomed him.

Jellybebe · 01/06/2023 09:38

This is not about homophobia. PS actually used coming out as gay as a way to deflect away from this story coming out.

I personally found Cheryl and Liam icky due to the age gap but there are some very important differences between their relationship and PS with the runner. Whilst Cheryl met Liam when he was 14, she did not take on any mentor type role and his position on the X factor was not contingent on her. He was eliminated and returned to xfactor several years later when Cheryl was no longer a judge. Their romantic relationship did not begin until he was 22, a successful "musician" in his own right with his own wealth. There was no power imbalance.

In comparison, the runner got the job through PS and was given certain privileges by PS that other people in his junior role would not have been given (attending awards ceremonies and filming a showreel for example). PS was very much in a position of power at TM and the runners job was very much contingent on PS as demonstrated when the relationship came to an end and the runner was "promoted" over to Loose Women.

skyeisthelimit · 01/06/2023 09:37

Mentoring a young boy from the age of 15 , getting him a job on his show, dumping him when he declares his love, getting him kicked off the show and basically ruining the boys life, gagging the press... nobody knows when the sexual relationship started, but PS does not come off well here.

When he came out as gay, it was all over the internet about the young man. His name was everywhere along with photos, but none of it was in the papers until now. It was all hushed up by PS/ITV.

He was in a position of power and influence and he abused that position.

His "coming out" on live tv was cringeworthy and so fake, his hug with Holly where his face is in front of hers. and it was all done to cover up the true story about the young man.

ejbaxa · 01/06/2023 09:35

It's definitely not homophobia. Quite the opposite - media had the opportunity to break this story years ago and the reason they didn't is that they didn't want to be seen to be shaming someone for their sexuality. The overwhelming desire not to be homophobic allowed some very unsavory actions to be covered up.

The problems are quite clearly: grooming during the boy's teenage years, exploitation of a huge power imbalance (a teen "nobody" vs a very famous 50-60yo), the management of ITV turning a blind eye to and facilitating this predatory relationship. It seems none of it is illegal - that doesn't make it ok. I have 2 teens b/g. If either of them began shagging someone of any gender/sex who was in their 50s/60s, I would be disgusted.

Bluebells1970 · 01/06/2023 09:33

Given that the runner is now believed to be around 21-22 it doesn't take a genius to work out that this relationship was highly inappropriate 6 - 8 years ago, possibly even longer.

He was groomed. And ITV/his management/friends/family were complicit in this. He was taking this lad to work and socialising with him. I hope that they are all held accountable.

Linkstolondon · 01/06/2023 09:29

Check out the video that shows him sat at a table in a cafe with the young lad and I can guarantee you’ll be shocked at how young he is.

He met Schofield as a vulnerable teenage lad and was offered unbelievable opportunities in a field he wanted to work in. He no doubt will have been sexually inexperienced and possibly still get used to his own sexuality at that age.

The balance of power in that relationship was miles apart, even if nothing happened between them until the lad was 18. As a mother of a young gay lad I feel Schofield’s behaviour was nothing sort of extremely predatory and highly inappropriate.

The fact that the media has responded so strongly to it all suggests to me that the situation is way worse than we actually know. He’s a disgusting human being who deserves no sympathy from anyone.

Bunnycat101 · 01/06/2023 09:27

Taking away the issue of age, there are big issues about seniors being in a relationship with their junior staff. I found out that one of my (in a relationship) colleagues was sleeping with his grad trainee and I was disgusted. My team only told me after they’d both left otherwise I would have reported it. Both were consenting adults but the power dynamics made it wrong and inappropriate. With PS you then have the questions about age, prior contact as a minor, all of the super injunctions, his brother and it becomes a very messy picture.

SaxSick · 01/06/2023 09:26

Boomboom22 · 01/06/2023 00:03

If the runner was female the reaction would be the same.

If not worse!

Seasideresidentslovechips · 01/06/2023 09:26

Nothing to do with the fact that he's gay. I couldn't give a hoot about that, being gay is perfectly normal/usual/absolutely fine. Better not to have cheated on his wife or have lied about it for years, but whatever.

It's because he's taken advantage of a vulnerable young person, allegedly grooming them. He was in a position of power and trust, and given that he met/befriended the young man when he was (very!) underage, there are serious questions about the appropriateness of their 'relationship' prior to the young man being a consenting adult. Even as a young 'consenting' adult, the power imbalance is sickening.

I'd liken it to a teacher/pupil 'relationship' tbh. And no one would call that a relationship in 2023. Rightly, it'd be recognised for what it is. Abuse.

willWillSmithsmith · 01/06/2023 09:25

Quitelikeit · 01/06/2023 08:27

if you knew someone when they were a minor and then developed a relationship with them when you are 40 years older it is enough to question the type of person that would do such a thing?!

And it is made more complex by his brother being gay and interested in children

Yes it’s extremely unsavoury whichever way you look at it. Imagine at the school gates knowing the little kids and then once they’re no longer a minor forming a physical relationship with them even though you’re old enough to be their mum. That is never going to feel right in my eyes.

Freefall212 · 01/06/2023 09:25

Shakirasma · 01/06/2023 09:19

Nothing whatsoever to do with sexuality, it's about;
Grooming
Predation
Sexual exploitation
Abuse of power
Lies and cover ups
An huge institution's complicity and their failure to show any duty of care to junior staff.

As the parent of young adult children I am heartbroken at what this poor young man has been through, and am relieved he seems to have got through it in one piece. Just because someone is over the age of 18 it doesnt mean they are suddenly worldly wise and not at risk from predators with an unsavoury agenda, particularly if they've been groomed and manipulated since their youth.

The abuse of power and lies and institutional cover-up / ignoring are certainly supported but there isn't any evidence so far that he had groomed him since he was a child. We don't know what the relationship between them was or wasn't.

newnamethanks · 01/06/2023 09:20

Meanwhile, Bill Wyman lives out a comfy old age with no comeback at all. Poor Mandy Smith, used by all who she met.

Shakirasma · 01/06/2023 09:19

Nothing whatsoever to do with sexuality, it's about;
Grooming
Predation
Sexual exploitation
Abuse of power
Lies and cover ups
An huge institution's complicity and their failure to show any duty of care to junior staff.

As the parent of young adult children I am heartbroken at what this poor young man has been through, and am relieved he seems to have got through it in one piece. Just because someone is over the age of 18 it doesnt mean they are suddenly worldly wise and not at risk from predators with an unsavoury agenda, particularly if they've been groomed and manipulated since their youth.

Freefall212 · 01/06/2023 09:19

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 01/06/2023 09:16

Yep, my ds said the same.

Yes, this has been known for years as some of the boys have posted screenshots of their snap conversations on social media. They were all pretty mundane conversations.

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 01/06/2023 09:16

Cherry2010 · 01/06/2023 09:06

My son has since said Philip Schofield used to Snapchat boys in his year (year 9) because he was well known for responding to “young fans” It was a well known thing (all boys school) I never knew about this at the time, and my son didn’t personally do it, but knew boys who did. To me, that’s predatory behaviour even if that was girls.

Yep, my ds said the same.

Lambstails · 01/06/2023 09:13

To the contrary, IMO if the runner had been female, I think this would have come to light a LOT sooner than it did