Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Phillip schofield scandal is homophobia?

913 replies

ivfregret · 01/06/2023 00:00

Have I missed something in that the guy Philip had the affair with was not a minor?

He was a minor when they met, as was Cheryl Cole and Liam Payne for example and no one has anything bad to say about that relationship.

I'm not sticking up for Philip and really dislike him, and also think even if the runner was above the age of consent is most definitely questionable behaviour but I can't help think of it was a heterosexual affair it would not be treated in the same way?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
LifeIsPainHighness · 02/06/2023 11:20

Haven’t RTFT but I was actually coming in to make the exact same post OP.

There is NO evidence that Philip Schofield groomed the man in question. We have to accept that not all age gap relationships are a result of grooming - it’s not that black and white.

It’s definitely gross but if Schofield had never come out and had been having an affair with an 18yo girl he’d get slapped on the back and congratulated while she would be called a gold digging slag.

Yet because it’s 2 men people are outraged and are calling for an inquiry!! An inquiry over a workplace affair FFS - they happen ALL the time. It’s 100% homophobia. The disproportionate anger is weird. Schofield could literally cut his hand off live on TV to say sorry and people still wouldn’t be happy.

Also while we’re at why do celebrities issue apologies when they have affairs?! I’m not Schofield wife, he hasn’t cheated on me or anyone here - it’s weird and people who aren’t his wife who expect an apology are weird too.

Newnamenewname109870 · 02/06/2023 11:20

Idontpostmuch · 02/06/2023 11:00

I don't think PA is a true comparison. First, we don't know for certain that he had sex with the girl. Secondly, assuming he did, she doesn't seem to be a victim in the way that that poor boy is. She's calculating and it's all about money with her.

There is as much evidence for him abusing that girl as there is for PS! He’s PA for god’s sake, if that’s a not abusive then I don’t know what is! And here is the misogyny and homophobia where apparently PS is somehow worse.

Newnamenewname109870 · 02/06/2023 11:19

Idontpostmuch · 02/06/2023 11:00

I don't think PA is a true comparison. First, we don't know for certain that he had sex with the girl. Secondly, assuming he did, she doesn't seem to be a victim in the way that that poor boy is. She's calculating and it's all about money with her.

Wtf?
that poor girl! Now that was 100% grim and tbh I’m sickened PA is doing better than PS over this.

DeliciouslyDecadent · 02/06/2023 11:17

I've watched the whole interview and I'm on the fence over this.

PS says there was no grooming. It is hard to prove that supporting someone through Twitter to try to get them an introduction into a career, is grooming. The timeline from meeting this young man (at a drama club/school) and him working in TV is 5 years.

Would someone who was gay (and having other gay encounters) really spend 5 years 'grooming' someone for casual sex when he was having it anyway?

This is another way to look at it.

There was /is no suggestion that the man had to have sex with PS to get a job in TV because he was already working in TV before the encounter is PS's dressing room took place. (According to the interview.)

I'm playing devil's advocate here by the way.

The risk to PS was not that he'd be outed as gay but that the other man would out him and say he was groomed/ abused.

SaltedButty · 02/06/2023 11:11

*thing

SaltedButty · 02/06/2023 11:11

He begged a TikTok influencer not to post a video of PS eating with his young lover. He told him it would end his career. He knew what he was doing. He's not a young man he is in his 60's

I wouldn't believe a think Jack Jones says. A lot of what he has posted is incorrect.

OCarumba · 02/06/2023 11:07

headstone · 02/06/2023 10:54

I’ve seen bits of the interview. I think Phil would have gotten away with this affair if his brother had not been charged and his questionable judgement. I think that was the trigger really rather than due to homophobia. However I would not like anything to happen to Phil and he doesn’t seem to be in a good place at all at the moment.

Agree it would not have blown up in the way it has if it wasn’t for his brother

OCarumba · 02/06/2023 11:06

Idontpostmuch · 02/06/2023 11:00

I don't think PA is a true comparison. First, we don't know for certain that he had sex with the girl. Secondly, assuming he did, she doesn't seem to be a victim in the way that that poor boy is. She's calculating and it's all about money with her.

Eww are you serious. She says she was trafficked and assaulted.

Idontpostmuch · 02/06/2023 11:00

Startyabastard · 01/06/2023 22:45

Yes crazy analogy. I hate it when people 'compare apples and pears'.

I don't think PA is a true comparison. First, we don't know for certain that he had sex with the girl. Secondly, assuming he did, she doesn't seem to be a victim in the way that that poor boy is. She's calculating and it's all about money with her.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 02/06/2023 10:59

I don’t think so - it would be the same if it was a girl.

But I am very tired of it dominating the news, when there’s so much else we should be discussing, like the hugely corrupt government.

Elior · 02/06/2023 10:57

With his background in TV over forty years and compulsive lies, he is a lot more media savvy than the people defending him on this thread. Their concerns for PS may come from a good place but there are always those who cannot accept that they are easy to manipulate or anybody else is easy to manipulate either.

Summerfun2023 · 02/06/2023 10:54

lemonchiffonpie · 02/06/2023 10:26

I'm baffled how it keeps moving in status to now just 6-7 times of "mates" having a sexual encounter, from "an on-off relationship", and prior "an affair"; none of his timelines of it match what others have witnessed, either.

He makes it sound as if it was his one dalliance, when others say he is notorious for these sorts of much younger man/boy scenarios and into the scene.

But frankly, I don't want anyone killing themselves over this. I hope MM has good support, and I hope PS does as well.

I think this is about intimidating MM to stay quiet.

That is an interesting and rather chilling thought.

He knew what the consequences would be. He begged a TikTok influencer not to post a video of PS eating with his young lover. He told him it would end his career. He knew what he was doing. He's not a young man he is in his 60's.

I read on another thread that it's very difficult to get into the entertainment industry because of all the Glitz and glamour. He threw it away and he ruined his reputation. You can feel sorry for him but that's how the industry is and I doubt he will get a second chance.

headstone · 02/06/2023 10:54

I’ve seen bits of the interview. I think Phil would have gotten away with this affair if his brother had not been charged and his questionable judgement. I think that was the trigger really rather than due to homophobia. However I would not like anything to happen to Phil and he doesn’t seem to be in a good place at all at the moment.

Elior · 02/06/2023 10:48

Tweedy and Payne was definitely not a healthy situation but fundamentally different. They were both wealthy and successful when the 'relationship' began. Sam Taylor Wood and Aaron Johnson would be more concerning even if they went the distance.
Tweedy never came out in a better position. She went from being viewed as young and gorgeous to being seen as the sleazy older woman who had ensnared a teenage heartthrob. He has not been positive about her and damaged her image even further through his silly comments.

Summerfun2023 · 02/06/2023 10:46

Raquelos · 01/06/2023 20:00

Oh dear, far too many baseless assumptions and too much drama there for me I am afraid.

"find it within yourself"

shakes head and backs away

I think they are talking about the #MeToo movement and it is a very important conversation to have. Too many men and women have been abused in the entertainment industry and I doubt it will stop any time soon.

WheelsUp · 02/06/2023 10:39

If Cheryl was texting 15 year old Liam then that is dodgy but nobody has suggested that she was in contact between first meeting and when they started dating.

donquixotedelamancha · 02/06/2023 10:39

Fair enough but did PS actually do all that’s been claimed?

Nobody knows except him and his victim. The problem for PS is that he did enough to classify him as a creepy and then he lied incessantly.

It makes his threats to commit suicide and his requests not to speak to his victim seem manipulative.

Elior · 02/06/2023 10:37

Of course you cannot know who is tasked with defending him online and on what terms. However, those parents doing so should ask themselves whether they would find it normal for their underage teenager to become "mates" with a man in their fifties and keep it going for five years leading to a job with perks. The work experience advice could not have lasted more than a few days on and off. The rest is probably unrecoverable and deleted.

As for being "mates", that is not the right word for it once you hit the sack, in any context. You become a FWB or a boyfriend, affair partner, fling, whatever... just not a "mate" anymore (not that I think it was the right description in the first place).

Newnamenewname109870 · 02/06/2023 10:33

bigbabycooker · 02/06/2023 08:23

@Newnamenewname109870

I don't think that there was really a power imbalance for Cheryl and Louis when they got together - both were stars. There's no evidence that they kept in touch, with Cheryl biding her time and showering him with gifts until he was "legal", whereas that is exactly what PS seems to have done. I also don't really think that Cheryl was really a proper mentor - she did a bit of encouragement for a TV show, but she never really had power over his career, which was in the power of others. The age gap is also miles better - I mean, Blake lively and Ryan Reynolds have a bigger age gap. It's plausible. So the two relationships are really not comparable.

Fair enough but did PS actually do all that’s been claimed?

Personally I still find CC and Liam a bit off and if Cheryl was a man I’m sure it would have been viewed as a scandal.

lemonchiffonpie · 02/06/2023 10:26

I'm baffled how it keeps moving in status to now just 6-7 times of "mates" having a sexual encounter, from "an on-off relationship", and prior "an affair"; none of his timelines of it match what others have witnessed, either.

He makes it sound as if it was his one dalliance, when others say he is notorious for these sorts of much younger man/boy scenarios and into the scene.

But frankly, I don't want anyone killing themselves over this. I hope MM has good support, and I hope PS does as well.

I think this is about intimidating MM to stay quiet.

That is an interesting and rather chilling thought.

SaxSick · 02/06/2023 09:59

This latest interview by PS turns my stomach. The reference to Caroline Flack, his daughters keeping him safe, flashing his marriage ring at the cameras. I think he has done a "Prince Andrew Car Crash" interview. Saying he had sex with this young man in the changing rooms and it was never an affair - my goodness.

TheFeistyFeminist · 02/06/2023 09:53

Older man in position of authority.

Met a child and offered that child opportunities that would not otherwise have been available.

Stayed in touch with that child (details as to how much contact I'm not sure)

Despite age gap and work circumstances, engaged in a physical relationship once that child was legally old enough, regardless of emotional maturity.

Did all of this while married to someone.

Potentially allowed wife to live decades in a lie of his making.

Used "ok I'm gay" as a cover to hide the rest of the issues.

Shows no remorse for serious lapses in judgement and potentially abuse behaviour.

I couldn't care less about whether anyone is gay or not. I object to the abuse of power, and the lying.

Plus, if I was gay, I think I'd be livid that yet again there's someone using their sexuality as a defence against some really serious accusations.

donquixotedelamancha · 02/06/2023 09:39

I think this is about intimidating MM to stay quiet. Getting his story out, trying to turn it into a pity party for him.

MM has already decided to be quiet or he'd have spoken sooner. That seems a very odd choice if Phil treated him well, as claimed, and he's not been paid or subject to an NDA.

donquixotedelamancha · 02/06/2023 09:36

He seems to completely ignore that, even if the young man was an adult when he got him the job, that there was a huge imbalance of power. He seems to ignore that even though the young man was an adult, someone in PS position did have power. He even used that power when it was over and is still denying he had that power.

This. He thinks his only sin was being unprofessional. Even if every word he's now saying is true he's a creepy old man who took advantage.

The problem is that it's really hard to credit his version of events.

The idea that he just happened to come out to the sun a while after the guy got moved away and as form evidence had surfaced seems unlikely.

Why was the kid moved show if no-one else knew? Why did his career get tanked? How did this kid get all these opportunities which all seem to connect to Phil?

If his version is true then he's been spectacularly unlucky in terms of events validating the rumours and spectacularly stupid in lying when telling the truth would have evaporated the rumours.

Wheresthebeach · 02/06/2023 09:24

I think this is about intimidating MM to stay quiet. Getting his story out, trying to turn it into a pity party for him. The 'one mistake' in 41 years is a very telling statement. Ignoring lying to everyone, the power imbalance, the damage he has done to this boys life, the continual pressure on MM to lie, and deny what happened. Then apparently chucking him out when he declared his love. The decision to help this one boy, for no apparent reason, into a career in TV like it's normal for someone of his power and influence to propel a young man into such an intimate relationship and to dangle a career in TV in front of their eyes (rather than the normal hiring via HR which is one big question ITV have to answer). It must have been a whirlwind for MM and PS see's it as one mistake?